Cute little place just outside cruise terminal shops. Pizza available by whole pie or by the slice. Slices are huge and they definitely don't skimp on toppings. Lots of locals coming and going and Jonny the owner seems to know everyone. Highly recommend. read more

See all

Fantastic slice of pie. Had a slice called the works. It was so good, Hot, and a lot of ingredients, it was a great experience. First time to St John. Met John the owner. Great guy. Liked the sayings on the cups. read more

Pizza Amore - Pizza Near Me - St Thomas, Virgin Islands

Pizza was so delicious! We loved all 3 kinds! Highly recommend! The service was good and a relaxed atmosphere.

Who says you can't get a good pie on a island? Have no fear, a good pie is here! In St.Thomas, known as the islands best pizza is Pizza Amore. We got a large pizza, half pepperoni/half cheese. They are not shy on the cheese. The pizza was amazing! read more

Pizza Amore - Pizza Near Me - St Thomas, Virgin Islands

You can never go wrong with a big cheesy pizza. Decor is compared to an old school pizza joint, Quick service, friendly waitstaff, the pizza was huge and cheesy and you can't beat the price point. Had a little arcade game for my kid to play too. read more

Pizza Amore - Awesome bar decor - Pizza Near Me - St Thomas, Virgin Islands

See all

I drive past Pizza Amore all the time on the way to work, so I decided to stop by for lunch one day. I got a piece of cheese pizza and a piece of Hawaiian, and a can of coke. It ran be about $13, which isn't too bad. The slices are quiet big. The pizza is warmed up in a big flat-top oven, giving the pizza a nice tasty, toasty bottom. There are also plenty of seats inside, and there are some tables outside as well. I was very disappointed with the cheese. Overall it was bland and tasteless. The sauce was way too hot, and it tasted like the slice had been sitting out for awhile. I did get the piece of Hawaiian, which is now the only thing that I do get. It is DECKED in cheese and toppings and is SO good. I literally cannot get enough of this Hawaiian slice. The cheese is different than the cheese pizza, which is weird. The pineapple and ham are big chunks that don't hold back. It can be hard to get to the pizza place because parking is limited. A lot of the time, I park across the street at Havensight mall and walk across. The crosswalk can be treacherous, so I would warn caution. There is the same older gentleman who takes orders. He seems like he is bored and is a bit rough around the edges. He is nice but a little rough -- don't be alarmed. The other staff is so nice and welcoming. read more

Pizza Amore - Pizza Near Me - St Thomas, Virgin Islands

See all

Pizza w a view is pricey but it's in line w island prices . We ordered the Hawaiian pizza and a pepperoni pizza . The pepperoni was definitively better . The Hawaiian was bland as the sauce is pretty tasteless . Not one of the better I've had , very pedestrian. The pepperoni though was spicy and flavorful . The sauce here needs a punch up and maybe a better cheese blend to give it some flavor . read more

Pizza was a soggy mess. Sign out front stated "Worlds greatest pizza" so I thought ok, this must be good. Ordered the combination pizza and 2 sodas, ram about $44. Little overpriced for an 18" pie, but boldly was advertised as great. Came out 30 min later and was steaming hot, little burnt on the crust. Had to let it cool for 10 minutes to even take a bite. They gave us paper plates which in no way shape or form could have supported the weight of a single slice. The veggies were cooked under the cheese which is a big no no as it cause the entire pizza to be too wet and greasy thus allowing the toppings to slide off as you picked it up and tried to take a bite. Way too much veggies, sauce had little flavor, crust was crunchy and just felt like I was eating a lasagna versus a flavorful pizza. Owner needs to remove the sign out front and work to improve the quality of what's being put out. Also wanted $1.00 for refill on a soda. Like it's $.17 cents cost and all profit, so you could at least do free refills to wash this mess down. A Costco $10 pizza is more scrumptious than this pie. Save your self the disappointment and try something else. I do not recommend. Will not be back! read more

See all

We struck out looking for a place to dine our last night on the island, mainly because it was late and we were there mid-pandemic, so restaurants were either out of business or limiting hours. I called Amore and they had a lone x-large pizza for grabs, so we popped over right at closing to snag it and a couple of salads. Everything was tasty. The pizza was huge, so the x-large is easily enough for a group of 5 - 6. We just had the cheese, but there was ample cheese and the crust was tasty. OK, I am not a New Yorker, so I can't say if it holds up against NY standards, but comparing it to pies you get outside of there, it is just fine. The side salads were small-ish and basic, but good. As a side, two people could easily split a salad. The pie and salads ran about $50 wit tip, so it was a little pricey, but considering how many people it could have few, it was not a bad deal. If you have a big crew, this is a decent way to make everyone happy. read more

Pretty good pizza, and this is coming from someone from the nyc area! The largest are large. very friendly staff.

This is our 2nd year back to St Thomas. We missed this Restaurant on our first trip because it's tucked away in the corner of a strip of other busy businesses. We made it our mission this time to go!!! So glad we did. When they say extra cheese trust them. There crust is Amazing. It has a Superb Crunch and great chew. Toppings down to the sauce great quality ingredients. We where all so happy to get it and to have some leftovers was a bonus. The 20" was a true giant. We'll be spreading the word throughout Limetree resort and anyone else that will listen. Excellent Customer Service. Very hard to come by on the Island. They get a 110% on this along with their food. Great job Pizza Amore!!! Thank you again for a great meal and making us feel so welcome in your businesses. read more

Pizza Amore - Pepperoni,Ham and Pineapple/Pepperoni and Mushrooms - Pizza Near Me - St Thomas, Virgin Islands

Great pizza and location. The two ladies serving were so helpful. Not handicap acccesible, many stairs.

Definitely recommend this pizza joint. Ordered a 16 inch pepperoni pizza. The slices were huge!!! The staff was extremely nice. Thanks for the wonderful service. read more

We were pleasantly surprised by the cost, size, and friendly staff at Pizza Amore. It was a bit off the beaten path but certainly worth the effort. John was simply outstanding and VERY helpful. We highly recommend a visit to this place. Also - seems to be a favorite for the locals!! read more

Lunch for under $5 in St. Thomas? How cool is that? Especially in the land of bad and expensive food this place is an awesome find tucked away in the corner of the now very deserted Al Cohen plaza (post hurricane). You can't even really see this restaurant from the street, I didn't even know it was there. But be warned the local lunch crowd knows it's here because the rush promptly starts at noon. By 12:30pm on a week day all tables are gone so you'll have to snag a seat outside on a picnic table. If there are that many people inside pizza amore all parking spaces are gone and you should probably try to find something across the street My favorite pizza is the roasted garlic & artichoke heart pizza with spicy chili flakes! 2nd favorite is the veggie pizza! Yum! Slices are of the deep dish variety and are massive, so one slice may be filling enough. Service is actually pretty good, the cashiers are always helpful and they bring your order out to your table instead of you coming up to get it. Pizza Amore also has an old school arcade game table that you can play pac man or space invaders on. My hubby is more interested in the games than pizza here. I think that's the real reason of why we have lunches at this joint. If you're in the area of Havensight or need an affordable snack off of the cruise ship you're on stop by pizza amore! #St.Thomas #USVI read more

Pizza Amore - Pizza & Pac-Man! #St.Thomas #USVI - Pizza Near Me - St Thomas, Virgin Islands

I wish I could give 4.5 stars. This wasn't my first time here (and definitely won't be my last). The pizzas are huge, so come hungry. Their veggie pizza is so loaded you almost need a fork and knife to eat. Today was a simple cheese pizza, but like usual it didn't disappoint. They don't skimp on the cheese, and I love that the crust is tender and thin. They also serve brownies that are out of this world - beware you probably can't finish it all in one sitting. The prices are reasonable as well. What are you waiting for? Go get yourself some grub! read more

The food was fantastic, super large portion, the service was exceptional and really nice environment.

Looking for a great Italian Pizza in St Thomas? You can't go wrong here. Easy to find Havensite location and run by a kind and professional team. You're missing out if you don't have a slice of pizza from here. read more

Pizza was good. Wish there was more options for 1-2 people. The 16 inch pizza is pretty big.

Sort of looks like a hole in the wall, but it seems clean and the staff were pretty friendly. They offer 16", 18", and 20" pizzas. We got an 18" with two toppings and it cost us $29. The dough is really good, and they don't skimp on toppings. read more

Some of the best NY pizza going. Thanks John for great pizza, we will see you all in May. Your Chicago regulars!

If I could give this place 100 stars I would!!! The absolute BEST NY style pizza I've ever had and I've tried about 8 different places in NY and CA. My husband and I were getting coffee near by. He went to the restroom then came back with pizza because he passed by the place and heard a NY accent in the kitchen. So upset with him because I'll forever crave this place! read more

Very cute mom an pop type pizza place. The toppings were great! Quickly made and brought straight to the table. We got the supreme style pizza which was awesome! read more

See all

Great place!!! Best New York style Pizza. Reasonably priced. We ate here several times. Owner is a cool guy from the states. This is a must have. read more

Fell into this place as family was starving after a busy morning. Great pizza, good amount of toppings and quality ingredients. Should've taken a slice to have at the brewery next door but next time, eh? read more

Pizza, pizza! Listen this is a spot for some spectacular pizza whether it's by the slice or if you get a pie. The pies come in 16-18-20 inch and with my husband, myself and our toddler, we still couldn't finish the 16' - they are huge! It's just a classic pie, no frills, great dough just enough chewy and crunch. The toppings are pretty standard, they have calzones and sandwiches as well. Great thing is it's walking distance for cruise ships and there's parking both in the front and back of the strip it's in. There's a burrito spot directly next door as well as a coffee shop and chicken spot so if you are with a part wit mixed tastes you can all sit outside and eat. There's seating inside as well, nice wooden booths and tables and chairs, place is clean and has a restroom. And there is also and old school PAC-Man video game machine! read more

Pizza Amore - Pizza Near Me - St Thomas, Virgin Islands

See all

I LOVE THIS PLACE! Owner is from New York, you can purchase the pizza by the slize and it is a little thicker than a typical new york style pizza and the slices are big! Hospitalith was amazing and the food was great! read more

Fast service. Outstanding flavor! We had our pizza fast. It was fresh from the ovens. The staff offered us extra spices, plates and napkins. Exceptional service! Will go again! read more

Pizza is always great from this NY style pizzeria. We had a large cheese pie and meatball parmesan sandwich that hit the spot again. Pizza was perfectly cooked, with delicious melted cheese, slightly soft crust, and perfect consistency (not too chewy). Meatball parm loaded with beef, cheese and sauce in a delicious sub roll. Owner and staff very friendly and welcoming. Would be very good for NYC area but great for those longing for a great slice in St. Thomas. read more

Very good pizza. An owner who appreciates you business. Wish I had tried the Italian sub for lunch the next day. You'll find quality food on St Thomas at a reasonable price is rare. read more

Best pizza on St Thomas! 4 of us had pizza and 1 had a meatball sub. We devoured our food. The owner & workers were all friendly and the restaurant has a cool/old timey vibe. read more

Surprisingly great pizza on the island and I'm originally a Jersey girl! Turns out the gentleman who helped me hails from Queens. Very friendly and happy to see us. Sorry no pics as we are it up!! read more

We wanted pizza and every place we called was closed , this place was further away from us but I'm glad the other places were closed . Without a doubt it's the best pizza on the island , heck maybe even the best I've ate anywhere . read more

We basically ate pizza every night while on our 10 day vacation here in St Thomas USVI. Why? Because pizza. Also, no diets while on vacay!! We asked locals where the best pizza was and they all had different opinions. We tried Pizza Amore after shopping all day and were not disappointed. We ordered the large combo (everything) pizza and there we're 4 of us. It was HUMONGOUS!!! We almost had to move tables it was so big. The dough was perfection and the toppings were fresh, sausage so good it seemed homemade. We had 4 very hungry adults and we couldn't even finish it (which is rare!) If you are craving pizza, this is the place!! You won't be disappointed!!! read more

We've been in St. Thomas and St. John for about a week - we're sunburnt and have snorkeled more than I can ever remember. We're staying at the Marriott and the first thing our boys asked for was to never eat on property - local only. So, after eating mahi mahi for 5 straight days, we were ready for pizza. Pizza Amoré is about 5 min from Frenchman's reef and definitely in the tourist zone for the boat people. However - we were delightfully surprised! Nice authentic place - old metal signs on the walls, natural wood tables - plain and clean. Pizza prices were excellent - a slice for $3.25! We got a slice of cheese, a slice of veggie, and a 18" Hawaiian. Pizza was excellent - piping hot out of the oven, the Hawaiian was exceptional - plenty of cheese, nice chunks of pineapple and ham - the kids loved it. I ordered the cheese and veggie - the cheese slice is the standard by which pizza must be judged: excellent, lots of cheese, foldable, crust is a bit crispy (compared to the NYC standard) and perfectly sized. The veggie was amazing - I think I got several days worth of vegetable servings in that one slice. So - if you are staying around Charlotte Amalie and want a good slice, this is a good call. read more

I love love love Amores Pizza i love mom and pop kind of pizza joints i have been buying pizza here every Friday night for going on 3 years now...So apparently on Friday nights after 4 pm they have a new person making pizzas not the original owners John recipe...i ordered last Friday night and it was horrible the crust was weird and the cheese was i cant even describe how bad this person changed the Amore pizza i so dearly loved!!! Anyways i called to let the owner know and he said he would look into it...What he doesnt know is that alot of people ordered last Friday night and i heard theirs tasted like Dominos! someone even said Tostinos frozen pizza GROSS!!!! Hopefully John will go back to his original recipe! Darn why did they have to change a good thing! read more

This is my favorite pizza on St. Thomas. Sure I get a craving for other pies, but this is the one I always come back to and enjoy the most. Still has reasonably priced slices after all this time and they really pile on the toppings. They also make some great hot sandwiches. read more

Pizza Amore - Pizza Near Me - St Thomas, Virgin Islands

The original slice could have used more sauce - too much topping, comparatively. I was chewing on just cheese for a bit, felt like Chicago deep dish. Service is fast, and they take credit cards with no minimum so that was great. Island ale was great, and with the original slice and island ale it came up to something like $9.50 which was pricier than I expected (the slices are 5.50 each). But it was a good quick meal, in and out in less than 20 min. read more

Pizza Amore - Original slice. Huge! - Pizza Near Me - St Thomas, Virgin Islands

This is probably the best pizza on the island. My husband and I moved here a few months ago and have eaten lots of pizza but prefer Pizza Amore. The service has always been great. You can call in orders and pick up- parking can be tricky but if your just grabbing a pick up you can park on the sidewalk/ on the side of the road. Also, if it's after Havensight closes down, you can park there and walk across the street. We usually grab a 16 inch for the two of us which leaves a couple extra pieces for my breakfast :) they have beer, wine, and sodas. Also, they will provide paper plates and napkins (sometimes they ask if you want and other times they don't). If you're craving good pizza, you should stop in. read more

Pizza Amore - Pizza Near Me - St Thomas, Virgin Islands

Great Pie. Well worth the trip with limited options.