Oh, sweet, sweet Sellas, how I miss you. Graduation from WSU was six years ago, yet I still fantasize about Sellas and the delicious, cheesy-goodness of the Coug Calzone...pepperoni, mushrooms, olives, and mass quanitities of cheese. Picture me now as Homer Simpson, drooling over doughnuts. Oooh, doughnuts. Wait, wrong review. Oh, and the salads. Just a green salad with croutons and shredded cheese, but it too is delish. And the bread twists. I seriously contemplate buying mass quantities of the calzones and breadtwists every time I go to Pullman, just so I can bring them back to Portland and freeze them to get me through the long, cold winter. Definitely a casual environment, but good service, good food, it's clean, and fun to go watch a ball game on the big screen. read more

Fun atmosphere DELICIOUS food highly recommend the cheesy bread and the calzones which are plenty big to share between 2 people. They will cut your calzone and serve on 2 different plates on request read more

The first time I went to Sella's I got the best calzone I've ever had, but unfortunately since then I've developed an inability to digest dairy due to chemo...so cheese was off the list this time. I ordered the kids' spaghetti with meat sauce but no cheese (I can't eat much), and an employee came to ask if the no cheese was due to a food allergy. I said yes, and she said there was dairy in the meatballs, so did I still want them? Not only did they change the meatball order, but they made sure to keep butter away from the breadstick without me even asking. It's hard to eat out these days, especially at a pizza joint, so I consider this a huge win. Thanks, Sella's. I'll be back the next time I visit my daughter in Pullman. read more

Excellent pizza!

When I lived in Stephenson, this was a fun place to go if you felt like 'eating out' but didn't really want to drop the cash for something extravagant, or, didn't have a car, like me! An easy walk (barring the ice on the street, at times!) from campus made this location an appealing meeting spot as well. One of my most treasured memories was visiting here with my Paraprofessional Staff. After we ordered our magnificant and gigantic (we're talking leftovers for a few days!), we passed the time, crayon-ing out our masterpieces on our placemats. Although I never won a calzone with my artistic endeavors, it was a built-in stress relief! read more

Sella's was the first place I ate in Pullman as a young Freshman back in 1994. It was always a place you could count on for a great Calzone and a cold beer when you had a taste for it, and back then, who didn't? Glad to see it's still around for the younger generation to enjoy. read more

the best zza on the palouse, and there is no argument. end of discussion. that is all. good day.

Love the calzone! I got the Coug calzone. It was delicious! Cooked just right with plenty of fillings. Usually there is a line when football games are going on but it's worth the wait! The customers do art work and it's posted all over the walls in the restaurant. Very creative, funny, and witty to say the least! read more

Sella's Calzone & Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Pullman, Washington

The calzones pretty good. Consistency is the biggest issue I've had. I've had great calzones with good flavor. Then, of course, the first time I took my wife there, our calzones were really dry. Now she wonders why I like the place :). Soda in a Mason jar is the ONLY way to do it! The place needs updating, but they figured out a way to have people pretty forgiving about the aesthetics, and that's to PURPOSEFULLY give it a run-down feel. read more

Amazing calzones and a must for anyone driving through Pullman or coming to WSU's campus. You ain't a coug until you've been here!

The service is okay. The place-mats are fun to color on. The cheese is too much pizza wise, but the salads and calzones are great. read more

Sella's Calzone & Pizza - Calzone - Pizza Near Me - Pullman, Washington

See all

Holy crap is it good!! This may be one of the best calzones I've had since I left NY 30 years ago and I've looked. Was in town for the day and took a chance. Really good. The Italian dressing on the salad was yummy too. They make it with a balsamic vinegar. Supreme calzone was awesome and as big as my head Had half for lunch and will have the other half for the travel home. read more

I haven't been back since I graduated in 2005 but I still regularly reminisce about Sella's salads! So good, and so big! My then girlfriend (now wife) will be planning a pilgrimage back to Sella's soon... and if there's time, we'll check out the WSU campus too. :) read more

If your looking for subpar calzones and pizza this is the place to go. Calzones are ultra watery and really don't have much flavor. The cheese pizza for the kids has so much cheese that it was difficult to eat without almost choking. Beer selection is very minimal as well. Go find something better. Not worth the price. read more

Sella's has always been a great place to visit for having amazing pizza and has decent vegetarian accommodations to their menu items. The place is wonderful for children who would probably take great joy in being able to draw pictures with chunky crayons. As a 20something year old woman, I know that I did to with friends I have come to this restaurant with. I don't really recommend their pastas...it is definitely not their niche. Do not stray away from the calzone and pizzas!!! read more

Many years ago I lived in Pullman and at least once a week I would eat a Sella's calzone. I still believe they are the best I have had! The environment was always very fun and creative. I don't remember the service as being all that great but being able to draw on placemats hoping for your 'art' to get on the wall and viewing others creative works always helped the wait time. read more

I bring all of my Oregon duck friends here every two years for football Saturday. They love the calzones and pizzas and cheat on Eugene eats - Rennie's and Track Town 'zah. Best food by miles, and many dates when I was at WSU. read more

My wife, daughter, and I dined here on July 13--at least, my wife and daughter dined. My food never came. We all ordered at the same time, but only two meals were delivered to our table. After a few more minutes, I inquired about my sandwich. This process took an inordinate amount of time, after which I was told I had not placed an order. I insisted that the person running the register just had not listened well. At that point, I decided not to press the matter, since I had not been charged for the sandwich. A few minutes later, just as we were leaving, I at least got an apology. Stella's hires a lot of college students and does not train them well. I won't be back. If you like really good food, this isn't the place for it. If you like even adequate service, go somewhere else. read more

Very well made pizza. Not like any other pizza place in Pullman. It is made from fresh ingredients, creamy cheese and has a flavorful sauce. The crust is nice and crunchy and absorbs all the flavors from the toppings. My favorite is the Piesan pizza with a combination of meat and veggies. It is delicious! They top the pizza with some shaved parmesan to add a little extra touch to the already amazing pizza. They also have calzones that are always packed with lots of cheese and taste just as great as the pizzas. What I love about this place is the drawings that fill up all the wall space all around the restaurant. You are given a white disposable place mat when you sit down and a jar of crayons. You are free to draw whatever you would like, just for fun or to enter it into it being placed onto the wall for display. It ranges from little kids drawings to professional drawings. They also have great deals on beers as well as a porch to sit out on in the gorgeous Pullman sun. The pizza is a little pricey compared to the other fast food pizza places in Pullman but that is only because 1. it is worth it 2. they take the time to make the pizza there with fresh ingredients and 3. the pieces are so packed with goodies that one pizza can easily serve as 3 meals. read more

Sella's Calzone & Pizza - great deals on pitchers and pizza! - Pizza Near Me - Pullman, Washington

See all

Their Chicken Alfredo is to die for. It's so good! Better quality than Olive Garden honestly. I came out for my birthday and I was not disappointed. Calzones are nice and big. You can't finish one in a sitting! Expect some leftovers! Their Garlic bread is nice but not the best. I will be coming back! read more

Sella's Calzone & Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Pullman, Washington

See all

I've only been here once, but not because I was dissatisfied. Instead, I've only been here once because without a little restraint I would eat so many calzones as to turn into one! The dough was good and the cheese was plentiful...and so were the extras (spinach is what I remember, and probably mushrooms and olives -- it's what I usually order in a calzone and I'm sure I did here as well). Quite tasty. read more

This place is ALL HYPE. Don't bother coming. I went there once and I thought it was decent so when my whole family wanted me to order some for them I bought 5 (they are big). EVERY single one was still raw. As in the dough was still white, gooey, stretchy dough on the bottom! I was appalled because I ended up with raw dough in my mouth. Checked them all and threw them all away. At $25 (overpriced) a calzone that's $125 down the drain. I've never been so disappointed in a restaurant, especially one that's rated so high. Later on in the year, a friend of mine convinced me to give the place one more try and, get this, it happens again! The same exact thing. UGH. The only reason why this place is rated so high is because it's a popular hang out amoungst the cougs but the quality is shit. I also forgot to mention that it took literally an hour for us to get 3 calzones. Unacceptable. read more

Sella's has a piece of my cougar heart. The calzones are amazing, It'll be hard to find much better after i graduate. They are cheesy, and huge, and amazing. Very hard to finish one in one sitting. I always take home leftovers. The salads are pretty darn good as well. Other than the food, you have to stop in just to see the decoration. The walls are covered in colored placemats! It's amazing what a college kid will do with good food, a blank piece of paper and some crayons! read more

Simply put: Sella's is awesome. A great place to go if you want a calzone. The calzones are amazing and a pretty good price too. They always make a great greasy meal. It has a nice environment; usually with sports on the television and all the pictures of Sella's drawings all over the walls. The service is great too. The employees are nice and friendly. The parking can suck if it's a busy time. read more

Every time I went here, I wondered why. The calzones are just not good. They are 75% bread with some cheap, lukewarm sauce and filling. If I had to pick the best one, it would be the pesto calzone. I'd rather go to Papa John's. read more

Sella's has huge calzones and you can draw with crayons while you wait for your food. One time I think they put frozen ingredients in my calzone because it wasn't hot in the middle, but other than that the food has always been good. Yum! read more

The upside is that the calzones are huge... big enough to share, but the pepperoni one I tried was super oily and the amount of cheese was borderline revolting... over an inch thick at it's thickest. I will give it another try because it was still good! Mine just needed to be more proportionate and other ingredients than cheese and bread. Service was also lacking. I ordered for carry out, and they seemed semi busy but it was pretty unorganized behind the counter. read more

If you find yourself hungry in Pullman, this is the place to go. It's not a fany place, you can go in your yoga pants and take your loud-mouthed friends or kids and not get any dirty looks. I love that this place hasn't changed since I was in college. Everything is the same, except for the local art hanging on the walls - feel free to contribute to it by drawing on your placemat. The salads are cheap and yummy, with a heavy handful of mozzarella on top. The calzones are where it's at! They are enormous, and full of cheesy, saucy goodness. I personally always pick The Coug which is tomato sauce, mozzarella, pepperoni, olives and mushrooms. read more

I was pretty excited about my calzone until I got a big mouthful of cold, raw dough. Shudder. I had to spit it out and pick the remaining crusty bits from the outside. read more

Sella's is a great place to go by yourself or with friends. As it's right down the hill from wsu, both staff and clientele are mostly students, which makes for a friendly environment. The food is good (only had their calzones) and service is always attentive. They serve a few local beers, too. They have enough ingredients to provide variety, or to fine tune your calzone. Poor Trisha must have paid with monopoly money, because I've never paid over $10 for any calzone. I make sure to hit Sella's every time I'm in town. It's a great alternative to the chains. read more

Great huge Calzones. More than most can eat. The atmosphere could use some work overall.

I really really love cheese but I actually found myself wanting to remove about half of the cheese from my calzone. Not because I didn't like the cheese, but because it was really hard to taste anything else because there was so much of it. I didn't find the cheese to be watery as some other reviewers mentioned. Oily/greasy yes, but that is the nature of cheese. I am looking forward to trying Sella's again but I think the next time I go I will ask them to go easy on the cheese and add extra sauce. The atmosphere is definitely small, college town hangout. It's probably a pretty fun place to hang out with a group on a game night. read more

If you visit Pullman, then you must visit Sella's. Be sure to come in hungry if you want a calzone...they are huge. The lunch special (mini calzone and salad) is a perfect lunch. The pizza looks pretty tasty, too. Definitely will not be my last visit. read more

It's a Pullman staple, so you have to eat there once. But that is all I would want to eat there. Their breadsticks are amazing, and I think it is really cool they display cool artwork of their customers. But any food other than their breadsticks isn't that great. I didn't know there was a thing as too much cheese, until I went to Sella's. read more

I've lived here for about 20 years, and until yesterday, only had the Sorority Girl Combo (Salad and Breadsticks). Their OK, but nothing spectacular. BUT, yesterday, I had a pizza! Bravo! In those 20 years, I've settled for the cheap paper thin tomato bread from the downtown joints, but no more! The Sella's pizza is the best in town! And not much more in price, and robust! Worth it! Enjoy! read more

By far the best pizza I have ever eaten! Dont care much for bbq sauce on pizza but their cowboy was off the hook, but my favorite was the piesan OHMYGEE is all I can say. Had the twist loved the sauce. read more

Absolutely amazing pizza. Haven't tasted the calzones yet but the pizza has amazing flavor and texture. Also has moderate prices considering portions and quality. read more

Great quiet homely place that also is exciting. Definetly worth a try. I recommend the Alfredo dish, but the calzone is definetly worth a try too. read more

Im not a big fan of the Calzones, they were WAY too salty from the cheese and meat. But everything else is exellent.

So maybe it's because I'm not the hugest fan of pizza as of late, but Sella's was pretty good, but not amazing. Their service was wonderful, very polite and the food came out in good time hot and fresh. The veggies on it were perfectly crisp and delicious, and the crust was pretty good too. I would say that you have to go there at least once!! read more