We got takeout and I didn't pickup so I can't comment on the atmosphere, but it is cute from the outside and does have some parking. Its at the end, just off the main area so its easy to grab for takeout. There's easy online ordering and we got everything as ordered. There's even an option to make any pizza half and half which is great! We got the Supreme, the Margherita, and a half and half of the Thai chicken and the sausage/ mushroom pizza. I only tried the Thai and sausage ones and both were good but the Thai one is the real standout. Such a unique and delicious pizza, and good both hot and cold! read more

See all

Really a great spot for pizza while in Bisbee AZ Great choices and all is amazing! Can't go wrong with anything you order!!! This was within walking distance of the Castle Rock Casita that we stayed in. read more

Screaming Banshee Pizza - Stuffed red peppers were fantastic - Pizza Near Me - Bisbee, Arizona

See all

Waiter never came to greet us for over 5 minutes after being seated. Ordered a bowl of pasta. It was served semi-warmed. Luke warm at best . The waiter dropped off bowl & never came back. Never checked in with us until he dropped off check. Never asking if we wanted anything else . Terrible service & food was not prepared correctly. If you like over- priced food, little to none service then there are your place to eat at. read more

We stopped by and had a couple glasses of sangria. We sat outside as the weather was beautiful. Great service. The white sangria is dry and the red was semi- dry. Would love to come back and try some food. read more

See all

This is a nice quiet little pizza place. The menu was full of stuff that looked ok, but nothing that really jumped out at me. We ordered the supreme pizza and for 25 bucks, it was really just a small, pizza. Not bad, but definitely not good and darn sure not worth the price. We had some 10 or 11 dollar dip beforehand that came with some dried bread. The food and the prices were just disappointing. I will say the location was nice. The food was prepared in a timely manner. The servers were very attentive and nice. Just the size of the servings for the high prices charged was enough to say I can't see myself ever going back and wouldnt recommend it to anyone else. read more

See all

Delicious pizza option in downtown Bisbee! Prices are fair and the pizza was out quickly after we ordered. There's not a ton of indoor seating, so plan accordingly if you're going on a nice weekend evening. They also have a large drink menu with some unique cocktails. A bisbee must do in my opinion. read more

Screaming Banshee Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Bisbee, Arizona

Great Pizza! Amazing wings!!! Loved it!!! Fun atmosphere, loved the music! It was a very enjoyable Sunday lunch, I also liked the service with a smile, friendly hostesses, and skilled Pizza Tosser!!! read more

See all

We like the roasted veggie pizza, and the Thai Me Up, Thai Me Down pizza. The Piquillo pepper appetizer was my favorite part of our meal, and we liked the cheesey bread too. The staff was definitely short staffed and we felt it. read more

See all

First of all I am not one to give reviews and nonetheless a bad one but my wife and I had a very unpleasant experience this Saturday, May 2nd. To start off the waiter/manager insisted on speaking Spanish to us which is not wrong but made the ambiance rather uncomfortable. The service was decent but the pizza that we ordered wasn't the one they served but we decided to keep it without letting the waiter know. (Ordered with Diablo sauce served with regular sauce). My wife upon choosing her piece noticed a long brown hair cooked in the dough. Upon looking at the men making the pizza I noticed two men with long hair, one with a hair net the other with a hat on. When the waiter finally came passing by I showed him the hair and told him that we would be leaving for my wife had lost her appetite. I am not one for handouts but no solution to the problem was offered. We were charged $8.35 for 2 lemonades that were hardly touched. Not an apology or a solution was offered but a "that will be $8.35". Very poor customer service. read more

Pizza was excellent. The service was good. The atmosphere was really neat. Definitely recommend this place.

Screaming Banshee was recommended to us several times and I can see why. It's located at a very scenic intersection and has an outdoor dining area. They offer a nice selection of pizzas, appetizers and drinks. Our two pizzas were both pretty good. The service seemed a little disoriented and forgetful. Maybe there was a staffing issue, so not a big deal. I'd still go back next time I'm in Bisbee. read more

Easily the best pizza in the area. The wood fired pizza crust is fantastic. Great pizza, tasty appetizers (including the knotty knots), and a warm, comfortable ambiance makes this place a must visit if you're in the area. read more

Screaming Banshee Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Bisbee, Arizona

Spaghetti meatballs really needed a lot more sauce, this has great portions but it was only like 25% sauce coating the spaghettis. Service is a bit slow and relaxed. We were outside with a party of 10 or so with only one heater on. The food isn't anything special and a bit bland for me read more

See all

I've been wanting to try Screaming Banshee for years, but it's always been packed. I finally got the chance during our last trip to Bisbee and it was more than worth the wait. We started with an order of the Knotty But Nice, which were easily the best garlic knots I've had in my life. We also had a small garden salad, which was actually quite big, and shared the Screaming Banshee pizza. The house-made sausage was delicious and perfectly complimented the other toppings, and the pizza was just as good reheated the next day. I will definitely add this to my list of must-stop places the next time I'm in Bisbee. read more

Screaming Banshee Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Bisbee, Arizona

See all

Wanted a really casual place and stumbled into screaming banshee pizza. Loved the ambiance and decor. Service was great- prompted, through, nothing mind blowing. Wings were big and flavor was good. The meatball appetizer was a little small with only 3 small meatballs- hard to share 4 ways. Pizza was decent but not the best I ever had but did definitely satisfied our craving. read more

I would say this place is meh. I've had better pizza at other places. The past 2 times I've been there, it immediate flopped, not in a good way, it was because the dough was pretty raw, and the toppings slipped off basically immediately after you picked it up. The mozzarella sticks are pretty good but the redeemable part of this place regarding food here are the garlic knots. They're really good and the marinara sauce compliments it well. What's also nice about the food is you can tell it's more of a homemade style pizza. I like how it's presented to you. I big downside is that it's pretty overpriced for what you get. It's definitely a once in a while when you're out with friends place to eat at. The waiters/waitresses are kinda good at refilling your drinks. It depends on who you get. Sometimes they just leave you alone and you have to ask. The inside is kinda crowded and goodness if someone is remotely loud beside you, you will be hearing EVERYTHING they are saying and barely be able to carry on your own conversations because you're pretty close. There are some decent spots inside you may get but definitely try to get outside if you can. For what it is, I would recommend it as somewhere to eat if you're touring the area. Besides that, I wouldn't recommend it as a regular place to go to. read more

We had been here before and the food was great !! Well today I decided to try the screaming banshee pizza with sauce well it came back with No marinara sauce I was not happy !! The crust had no flavor I was really disappointed !! Also we had the spinach dip with 6 different cheeses there wasent enough bread to use all the dip , and it wasent that hot like they said it was !! Now I'm wondering if they used chef Mike ( the microwave ) to try to make it hot !! I'm not a fan of the microwave by the way !! Well it was over all a bad experience!! read more

Screaming Banshee Pizza - Screaming banshee pizza without sauce - Pizza Near Me - Bisbee, Arizona

First time out in Bisbee and we were hungry saw this cute building and decided to have lunch here Vibe was awesome loved the decor Waitress was super friendly Ordered our food Explained the speciality's and made suggestions Pizza was ok it was a veggie pizza definitely needed more flavor a little blah Wings were delicious and the drink I had was good Loved the whole vibe read more

See all

Up in Bisbee for Valentine's weekend. Walking through the town early to grab a coffee. By about 10-ish we were walking by this place and someone opened the door to come outside. A blast of scents hit us. It was the sauce. We decided to order a pizza that night. Went to the place, ambience was nice, servers were friendly, service was slow. The pizza is great when right out of the oven. Needs better service, but really not their fault, the place was packed. read more

This restaurant made their biggest mistake! They had the opportunity to create widespread positive reviews and instead they bombed!! They were hired to cater a small wedding and totally blew it. Half the order showed up over an hour late and the other half showed up an hour after that. That was almost expected, the communication from the start was unacceptable. The owner even went as far as to shut off his phone, couldn't be bothered. DO NOT PATRONIZE THIS ESTABLISHMENT, You'll only end up disappointed. Besides the pizza wasn't even tasty. read more

I visited today, first time since the pandemic. While my visit was.pleasant, the Banshee has lost some luster. The menu has been changed. Prices gave gone up. Gone is the spaghetti with meatballs dish. Focus is on the pizza. And the best part is watching the pizzas get tossed in the air.The kitchen crew tossed a few for me. these boys really hustled . Mexican folk music played in the background The pizza dough itself has no special flavor. The sauce and sweet tomatoes were the best part Service was fine. Server gave me water, took my order, gave me my veggie pizza, then wrapped the leftovers to go, and then gave me my check without asking what else I wanted. I wanted a second glass of water, but by now I felt more like somebody who should just leave. This is a small place that gets crowded and loud fast. There is outside dining where dogs can hang out,but I find the ambiance incompatible for a romantic night out. read more

See all

Had dinner here, got the Screaming Banshee pizza with red and a salad. Both were really good. Service was good along with good draft beers. They had Big Blue Van on draft, which is a favorite of mine. I definitely recommend this place. read more

Screaming Banshee Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Bisbee, Arizona

See all

Fantastic Pizza! Fantastic Service! A must go if you are in Bisbee. Don't worry about the walk...it is well worth it!

Just wanna thank the group that decided they couldn't wait for their table so lucky us! Our party of four had the most relaxing, fun time, good food with amazing service; but the best part.....The Aroma of open oven fire pizza... Yum. read more

Screaming Banshee Pizza - Drink menu - Pizza Near Me - Bisbee, Arizona

Great sides, great pizza, great service. Stop here everytime when in the area and worth the wait busy.

A day trip to Bisbee. I had to stop at the Banshee...the pizza was amazing and the staff was very friendly. I enjoyed the atmosphere..the vibe was chill read more

Screaming Banshee Pizza - The Big P w mushroom and jalapeños. Yummie. - Pizza Near Me - Bisbee, Arizona

See all

cool place! yes a bit pricey but you're paying for the location and great view of some of bisbee famous stairs. we got the screaming banshee and the bread board. make sure to add sauce to the screaming banshee, can't imagine what it would taste like without.... the bread board is a very basic starter, however cool plating read more

See all

Everything we.had was delish. The pizza, salad and bread. Top notch. The service was excellent too.

I'd mention quality of the food as a redeeming quality before I get into the issues but... We did not get seated! My boyfriend and I are visiting his family in Tucson and we went to Bisbee for sight seeing and to shop. It was already 5:45pm when we got to the Screaming Banshee and we were hungry after walking around all day. We enter and there was 7 of us, 5 adults and 2 tweens... We're standing around waiting and someone in our party asks if we seat ourselves to which the guy at the counter making the pizza responds, "no, someone will be with you in a sec." Completely normal response, so we just stand around listening to the loud music they have behind the bar. This (black haired) woman comes up and says "Oh look at this group of zombies who waltzed in expecting service!" and we brush it off and say there's 7 of us. She pushes past our group then another (blonde) woman comes by and the previous worker fills her in, saying "well these 7 people walked in here asking for our service!" in the most demeaning tone ever. The blonde lady says "oh well we can't sit that many right now.. we can put you on a waitlist and call you when we have an opening." We ask how long the wait is and she just says we'll have to wait. It's also freezing out, probably like 35F and it snowed a few hours earlier so we're saying how we can wait inside since its cold, to which the black haired lady says we have to wait for a call to get served, which we assumed was her kicking us out. They were also saying they can't promise to seat us inside due to our party size. After we left, a group of our size was waiting at the door and the blonde lady opens the door for them very politely and seats them immediately.... I'd also like to mention there was maybe 2 people sharing one table and that was all the business they had. No one at the bar, no one in any other tables, it just seemed like they did not want to do the work. We also were going to share 2 pizzas max, but even if we ALL ordered, we'd be paying them damn well. I really do not understand what the issue is here. Rude and unhelpful service. My boyfriend's cousins have brought their family and friends here and have LOVED the food, but this exchange is just such a bummer and they said they won't bring their service there again. read more

A day trip to the Copper town of Bisbee. Server apologized for the delay in greeting us and told us he'd be right over. The Good: The pizza was delicious- but as the menu states- they only have one stove? Oven? Therefore, the wings that were ordered took longer to arrive.... It was a slow day and time, so I can't imagine how this works on busier evenings during peak hours?? Server was polite and friendly with steady refills on a hot day- kuddos! The Blah: Although the outside reflects a retro fun aesthetic- the inside is not what you would expect.. The name itself made us hesitate and wonder if we were actually at a biker bar, which is not what we were looking for....the inside reflects a dark vibe- portraits similar to Salvador Dalí mixed with the Conjuring. The menu has its logo that reminds me of a depressive emo teen going through the goth phase. In Summary: We were hoping to be wow'd- unfortunately the environment is what wow'd in the other direction... would we consider this a fun, family friendly place? Maybe for older teens hungry for pizza. Larger groups might be a tighter squeeze or opt to eat outside for more room! I would have liked to see more Bisbee theme for this place- we have enough Banshee type places everywhere else for those looking to fill their grunge cup. We were looking for unique to the town's history- expectations too high? read more

Screaming Banshee Pizza - Banshee Supreme pizza - Pizza Near Me - Bisbee, Arizona

See all

We stopped by here because they had a dog friendly patio and seemed to be the only place in Bisbee open on a Sunday night. We ordered the 'No Besos para ti' to start which I was excited about because I LOVE roasted garlic, however they give you like 5 tiny crostini and half of them were burnt to a crisp, so that was very disappointing.. We also ordered the Banshee pizza and the Cadillac Margherita. The waitress brought us the wrong pizza, stating that she thought that's what we ordered. We did not. we decided to just take to go because it DID look good, and we had her bring us the Margherita that we had originally ordered.....the pizza came super fast and was wrong, so I know they threw that together. There was no fresh mozzarella or feta on this pizza which was stated on the menu and why we wanted it in the first place. Unfortunate. My wine glass was taken without an offer of another glass or anything else to drink. I asked for extra napkins and they never came. We also didn't receive any knives with our appetizer so I had to go inside to ask for them myself. The pizza was actually delicious. Great flavor and fresh tasting ingredients. The service, however, left something to be desired. I do understand that it's a Sunday and not busy and everyone wants to go home, but I'm a server and these are very basic things . We were offered a discount on the mistake pizza, but only because we said something. Overall I would probably return because the pizza was great, but I would avoid the garlic appetizer and probably return on a day when it is busier and the service is more attentive. read more

See all

Pizza was well priced, served at a reasonable pace. Would recommend. Garlic bread was excellent. We did a split pizza (all mushroom, half pepperoni and half spinach). The cut had a price of pepperoni on the vegi side (only complaint). Would eat here again on my next trip through Bisbee: read more

Loved the selection of pizzas and really wish I could have been more adventurous in my choice but I was with friends and we decided on sharing a pizza. We got half Spicy mutha chicken and half Screaming Banshee. Both sides were delicious, however, that chicken half was amazing! If my head wasn't pounding from the heat, I would have ordered another to-go. The service was okay, we were there mid-day and there were very few people in the restaurant. We sat inside but they did have patio seating. The restaurant appears to be a converted gas station with the hostess out front outside. On the side, you can see the employees making the dough which is pretty cool. Service with our waiter was pretty average. read more

Screaming Banshee Pizza - Menu - Pizza Near Me - Bisbee, Arizona

See all

Absolutely love this place. Pizza is amazing, staff is super friendly, and the price is perfect. I would definitely go again.

Doesn't disappoint. Service was amazing, love all the art. The garlic knots are definitely worth ordering every time. read more

See all

Me gustó la Margarita y la pasta con camarones. La atención muy buena. Me sentí muy a gusto!!

Great pie and atmosphere! We had a one hour plus wait as they were packed as well as every other restaurant in Bisbee Labor Day weekend. Anyways, found out we could get a drink at the bar and ended up having our dinner at the bar as well. I enjoyed a couple of glasses of beer (Copper City Ale), my wife had a specialty drink, and a couple of glass of Chardonnay. We ordered a custom pizza, and the crust was the best I've had in a long while as it was a thin crust pizza, pepperoni, black olives, basil and extra mozzerela. Jennifer our bartender/waitress was engaging and entertaining with conversation. Great place to have a drink, or a bite to eat. Very family oriented and wonderful selection of beverages, seating inside is limited but lots of seating outside too. read more

Screaming Banshee Pizza - pepperoni, black olives, basil pie - Pizza Near Me - Bisbee, Arizona

We came to Bisbee for a day during a busy weekend. we sat outside and it was hot, but had good shade. we ordered the wings and some pizzas. the 3 flavors on the wings we tried all tasted the same- ginger pineapple, Caribbean jerk, and honey chipotle. The wings were nice sized, a bit soggy/ not crispy, and had good flavor, but definitely could not tell the difference between all 3 flavors. They also charge $1.50 for tiny cups of dressing. we got the meat lovers pizza, and the Thai pizza. Half of the Thai pizza we got with no cheese and thats what i ate, it was very good flavored, but dry. the meat lovers one i didn't eat, but it looked good. we got some beers on tap- delicious!! owner came out and talked to us, he was real friendly, and helpful; i do think because we were outside in the backyard area, we were got forgotten about, and didn't get beverage refills as needed in the hot weather. read more

See all

Second time at the Screaming Banshee Pizza. Great occupancy for a previous gas station. Enjoyed lunch under an outside canopy. Great wood fired pizza and salad. Service was also very good. Had the Cadillac Margherita Pizza with red sauce, mozzarella fresca, asadero, feta and parmesan cheeses with basil, oregano and red pepper. Also shared a small fancy salad with fresh greens. Put this one on your list. read more

See all

Bluf: been going here since they opened. Love them. They sort of lost their way with the dough after covid but they're back to that magical thin crust. Service has been horribly slow and almost a guarantee, but just depends on the night. Look, Screaming Banshee is a staple in the southern Arizona pizza scene since its inception. There have been points over the past 14-15 years that I would swing by monthly or a couple times a month with the fam or friends. It has set itself apart by providing amazing food, having beautiful mining town views, and exemplifying a culture of acceptance for all who enter its doors. I say all of this because I love this place and want them to have success for years to come, but the service situation has been in the gutter since 2020. You can expect to wait for your waiter/waitress a lot and you'll need to wave them down at times. Now, the food. You will never be disappointed. My go-to is the Cadillac Margarita with Pepperoni added and the Spicy Mutha Chicken. The fresh mozzarella, large pepperoni, cherry tomatoes, and incredible red sauce just makes an amazing pizza in a brick fired oven (caddy margarita). If you're in any way a fan of wings and ranch, you MUST try the spicy mutha chicken. The shredded chicken is marinated in hot sauce, they use a ranch for the base instead of red sauce, fresh mozzarella, and some celery. It's just incredible and my wife and I have, at times, gotten our own so we don't fight over the pieces! You really can't go wrong with these two pizzas. Honorable mentions that I have to mention, the Screaming Banshee pizza used to be my go-to, but my tastes have changed. It really is a filling pizza with some very flavorful fennel sausage. Paul's screaming dip is my favorite appetizer. It's a perfect intro to the fresh ingredients you're about to dive into. The wings, which get cooked in the brick oven, are to die for! Lastly, their bananas foster is so freakin good. They've done an apples fosters for me too, on request. This establishment has earned its place in the Arizona Pizza hall of fame. Our meal this evening just hit the spot and I'm so exited to see Banshee killing it in the kitchen. read more