Dropped by the new Savor space Sister Bay this weekend and it's nice to have the extra seating, bigger menu and expanded craft beer menu. I did the ribs again and they were still awesome. Great some flavor and very moist. My wife had the Gaucho Sandwich and it was great. She did admit there might have been a touch too much cream cheese but the brisket was done perfectly. Still love the fact that the owners young daughter waits table and greets you when you enter. read more

SAVOR Barbeque & Taphouse - Gaucho Sandwich - Barbeque Near Me - Sister Bay, Wisconsin

See all

Went here for lunch hoping it was going to be as good as Grasse's used to be, and truthfully we were disappointed. The service is order at the counter. The woman taking our order was very off-putting and had a strange attitude before we really even interacted and ongoing, so we started with a bad taste in our mouth.. not to mention it's relatively expensive for bbq. Our food did not take long to come out, which was nice for a quick lunch. The food itself was underwhelming, nobody at the table was overly excited about their meal. The flavor and spices you could tell were created with care, but the meat was majority gristle and fat on the brisket sandwich and the wings were very dry as a whole. The quesadillas had a ton of cheese so it was heavy and disproportionate. Ambiance is great for a bbq restaurant and you really can't beat the location, lots of foot traffic. I believe they might have operated better on a smaller scale. However they are new to this location so maybe it needs some time to adjust? Overall we probably wouldn't go here if we had the option again. read more

See all

Unfortunately, our experience was disappointing from start to finish. When my husband and I walked in, we were told it was a fast-serve setup: grab a menu, decide what we wanted, and order at the bar. We did exactly that and waited at the bar for about 10 minutes. During that time, a young employee came to the register and instead of asking who was next or helping the customers who had already been waiting, she immediately assisted someone who had just walked up. It was frustrating and came across as very disorganized. When another employee finally approached us, she asked if we were ready to order. We said yes, only to be told that we needed to order somewhere else and "wait in line like everyone else." The problem was that we had been waiting where we were instructed to wait. Rather than helping us or acknowledging the confusion, the response felt dismissive and rude. As for the food, I paid $27 for brisket, half a chicken breast, and cornbread. The brisket was extremely fatty, with a large amount of unrendered fat and very little meat. For the price, I expected much better quality and portion value. I understand that every restaurant can have an off day, but between the poor customer service, confusing ordering process, and disappointing food quality, this visit fell far short of expectations. read more

SAVOR Barbeque & Taphouse - Very fatty Brisket - Barbeque Near Me - Sister Bay, Wisconsin

We went there yesterday, on they're unofficial first day of the season. Im so glad they were open!! Great staff!! Great tea!! Really good brisket! Really good fries!! Really good cornbread, almost cake-like, so moist and sweet! I had the Bronco sandwich. My husband had the brisket sandwich. It was all so good!!! We went to Casey's barbeque in Egg Harbor tge previous day. It was okay. If you want BBQ, you want Savor!! They have a side porch if you want to sit outside and enjoy a bit of the water view. We sat inside, in a booth that looked out to the road. We enjoyed watching the people pass by. read more

SAVOR Barbeque & Taphouse - Photo from a booth at their front windows - Barbeque Near Me - Sister Bay, Wisconsin

See all

All round the best food, service & location in Door County for meat! Love the new location. The ambiance is gorgeous! We could easily eat here a few times a week. read more

See all

Absolutely Awesome! We had a party of 4. Items ordered were The Maverick, Tex-Mex burrito, The Buckaroo with pulled chicken , and The Hog-tide. Everyone raved about the meal. I had a Tex-Mex burrito and really enjoyed the taste. It included rice, even though it did not say rice in the menu. I liked the rice addition. My husband had The Hogtide and he commented that the apple bacon jam was a nice touch. The owner's young daughter was a rock star. We enjoyed watching her interact with the customers. Very personable and will definitely go far in this world with a personality such as hers. She was proud and full of smiles when we gave her compliments. This is a place we will come back to when in Sister Bay. read more

Everything is overcooked. No color in the brisket, along with the ribs were over barked and not very enjoyable to eat. The only item that was partially a hit was the Mac and cheese flavoring. The noodles were also overcooked. Sausage had no decent flavor. Hoped for better BBQ, but we were not impressed. read more

Incredible Experience!!! Food Awesome! Staff so friendly and Sweet Journey is a star in the making! Thanks Joleen for a wonderful yummy meal! love your chicago fans read more

I had a smash burger at the savor bbq old location that is now savor juicy burgers. It was a pretty solid burger and great feel and definitely juicy as the new business implies. Either the savor burger joint or the bbq restaurant, I would expect a good visit read more

SAVOR Barbeque & Taphouse - Savor smash burger - Barbeque Near Me - Sister Bay, Wisconsin

Yum! I ordered the two meat platter with chicken, brisket, cornbread, and the best potato salad I've ever had (don't tell my mom). I wish we lived closer! Service was fast and friendly, restaurant was clean and casual. Thank you! read more

My family went to lunch here over Fourth of July weekend and it was exceptional. I had a single meat platter with brisket, sides being: Mexican Corn and Charro Beans. I was so surprised to find true Charrro beans in the north! My wife had a half slab of ribs and they were awesome too! Highly recommend. Great atmosphere and service. read more

Excellent BBQ Options. There is dedicated parking on the north side of the building. If you have been to Sister Bay that is a big plus. It is casual dining where you order at the counter and they bring you your table. The place was busy but we had our food in less than 5 minutes. There is a kids menu for 10 and under. Serving were a good size. We had the Cubano and The Maverick. Will definitely be back!! read more

SAVOR Barbeque & Taphouse - Menu as of 5/30/26 - Barbeque Near Me - Sister Bay, Wisconsin

See all

Greeted upon entering by a very nice young lady. We took a menu to our table and then ordered at the counter. Our food came out quickly and very hot. First bites were amazing. My husband had the Maverick and I had the Mac & cheese. Both were fabulous. We ordered a triple chocolate cheesecake slice to share for dessert. Absolutely delicious food, great friendly service, and interestingly fun decorations. We loved it the whole Savor experience. We will be back!! I read more

SAVOR Barbeque & Taphouse - Mac & cheese - Barbeque Near Me - Sister Bay, Wisconsin

See all

I got the smoked pastrami rueben, and it was soooo good! They also had a great selection of draft beers. While it's a bit pricey, the food quality makes up for it. read more

My girlfriend and I have been coming up to Door County the last four summers for a weekend getaway. We cannot say enough about Savor - as we were pleasantly surprised to see their larger space this year just down the hill in Sister Bay from their fast food location. The staff for one, including the owner are absolutely wonderful to interact with. They are pleasant, friendly, and welcoming. We were greeted with smiles, warmth, and treated kindly from the moment we walked in. Throughout our delicious and well-valued meal, the staff checked on us and asked if there was anything else we needed. The pork belly burnt ends were one of our favorite items we ordered. Hats off to the staff and owner of Savor. We will definitely be back on future trips! read more

Barbecue had good flavor. Ordered the dinner for six people/Savor Sampler, it was over $100, the four sides were the smallest I've ever seen, each of the six of us maybe had a bite or two they were that tiny. Really not enough meat for all of us either, the two sausages were dried up. Mac & cheese had zero flavor. Would not order again. Owners have to amp up the quantity and quality. read more

Stopped in for lunch and got the meat platter with brisket, Mac n cheese and one of their baked beans options. Service was fast and friendly! I'll be honest I wasn't expecting to like everything as much as I did. The brisket was tender and fall apart, the beans were super flavorful and the Mac n cheese was delicious! My only little knit pick would be to add pickles to the meat tray for building a sandwich and to complement the meats. Overheard they are moving into a bigger space this week so excited to see the new location next time! read more

SAVOR Barbeque & Taphouse - 1meat tray with brisket - Barbeque Near Me - Sister Bay, Wisconsin

Visited Savor this evening, and was disappointed. I wish I would have read the reviews first, JD may be correct, in their assessment. We arrived to a half empty restaurant, which I attributed to the early hour. I ordered the quesadilla with pork, and the dish had very little meat, perhaps 1 or 2 ounces at most, but heavy on the fat and grissle. My husband thought his sandwich was ok. I mentioned this to the waitress that cleared my basket, and I don't believe she understood, so she had a young girl visit our table to discuss. The young girl said this was how the pork was supposed to be, I said ok, I'll just know not to visit again. She asked if there was anything they could get me, I said no. The young girl seemed very versed in handling these types of issues, I'm wondering if from much practice? I just ate the cheese quesadilla for my dinner. I very rarely send food back, probably because of an old story that I can't forget about a cook in another restaurant far from here, and additives to some food they prepared. read more

What a great place!! The people are incredible. And the food. Omg. I had the Brit and sausage. Both done to perfection. We actually reordered to take some home with us. read more

This is by far the best old school BAR B Q around! Let's talk brisket: juicy - extremely well smoked and an unforgettable taste! We had the pulled pork as well and Wow, so good! Soft yummy buns and tangy sauce plus excellent sides. The Mexican corn was outstanding as was the corn bread. You will not be disappointed! read more

Food was fantastic and the setting is super casual and fun for families. We enjoyed the brisket, corn bread, and Mac and cheese. The service was good but note you have to order from the counter and your order will then be brought to your table. read more

Service friendly and very good. Food was very good, had the Cuban and it was tasty. Yes we'd go back again.

OUTSTANDING! Delicious food and more choices than most Barbecue places. Super friendly and fast service. read more

The brisket was decent but everything else was not good. It smelled so good going in but such a disappointment. Ribs were dry and overcooked. Some bites were like Jerry. The cornbread was the worst I have ever had so dry and crumbling. This place could be a goldmine with some improvements. They will probably make some money but they will have to depend on tourism alone. Not recommended read more

OUTSTANDING!!!! Everything from start to finish was just great...and exceeded our expectations! It was a busy night and we arrived at Happy Hour. We were warmly welcomed by an adorable young server and promptly provided with a menu and clear instructions on how to place an order. The options were all so mouthwatering that it was difficult to make a decision but after watching the many varied dishes coming out of the kitchen and smelling the amazing aroma of the smoked meat, we chose the pulled pork and ribs with sides of Cole Slaw and BBQ Baked Beans. The ribs were fall off the bone tender and the pulled pork was served with a choice of 3 BBQ sauces, one that was close to the best I've ever tasted. The ambiance was warm and inviting with an upbeat lively energy. The dining room tables and bar areas were comfortable, clean and the patrons seemed relaxed and genuinely enjoying themselves. The noise level was good and the room was filled with conversation and laughter. The staff were friendly, knowledgeable and professional.... and the quality, quantity and flavor of the food and drinks was outstanding. Despite the restaurant being extremely busy, the service was impressively prompt and efficient. Orders arrived quickly and follow up by our server made us feel well cared for. This was a great dining experience that struck a perfect balance between casual and energetic and we highly recommend it....TWO THUMBS UP! A great value for money!! read more

Love Savor Bbq, and tried the new location; Savor Juicy Burgers this evening. Wonderful burgers, I ordered a Dragon Smash Burger for myself and a kids Smash burger for my 94 yr old mom (who is very picky). We both loved the burgers, and the fries were delish - crispy & flavorful. Def will be coming back again!! Great service, quick turnaround for my carry out order - highly recommend! read more

2nd Update: This owner is completely unhinged. She's threatening to post video of us which I'd love her do since it will show exactly what I have described. I'm glad this review is anonymous. Holy shit. Update. Check out the owner's comments. Her entire story is a flat out lie. She's never seen us before and the only voice raised or bullying done was on her part. Disgusting. This sort of thing has no place in Door County. I'm frankly shocked. Stay away. Savor has become a flat out tourist trap. We paid $60 with tip for two brisket plates. We each got a single 1/4 thick piece of brisket. I counted, I ate mine in eight normal sized bites. I mentioned something to a staff member and she became instantly belligerent and claimed they weigh each serving. I think that's likely a lie but if they do they need to recalibrate their scale or buy a new one. I told her it was fine. Even so, she stomped off and got the manager who stood over our table and in a very confrontational manner said "I hear you want to order more food." I replied "No, we don't. I don't want an argument. Can you step back so we can leave?" She moved back six inches. As we were getting out of the booth she snarled "Don't come back." We're longstanding home owners up here and this isn't the Door County attitude. We will be warning our friends off. I'm sure they'll continue to rip off tourists but no one who lives or owns a vacation property around here will appreciate this behavior. It's much more like Brooklyn than Wisconsin. It's also clear from their instantly defensive and belligerent behavior that other people have called them out. Lots of great restaurants in Sister Bay with lots of lovely staff and owners. Choose somewhere else. read more

I've been going to Savor at all of their locations for years and I've never had a bad meal. Previously, this was my every Friday treat for lunch by the winery all summer long. Corey and Jolene put their heart and soul into their craft and it comes through in their finished product: the burnt ends, and brisket are always delicious and while it shouldn't have been a surprise to me, considering how well they've done with everything else, their smash burger is definitely in contention for the best burger I've ever had. Ignore the negative reviews here, some people can never be pleased. Keep up the amazing work guys, you are horrible for my waist line but fantastic for my taste buds! My only complaint is that it's a little too far away for me to just pop in whenever I get a craving from Sturgeon Bay! read more

SAVOR Barbeque & Taphouse - Brisket - Barbeque Near Me - Sister Bay, Wisconsin

Yikes. I actually felt bad for suggesting my friends and I try this place. I ordered 6 wings with a side of slaw and macaroni salad, a water, and a cider. The wings are the driest wings I've had in my life. Truly gross. I couldn't even eat them. The side sauces were unimpressive and the macaroni and cheese and macaroni salad were both bland. The slaw was the best thing I ate. What a waste of money. read more

Tried Savor in Sister Bay for the first time today. Pulled pork sandwich for me, chicken wings and brisket for my spouse. Everything was fantastic! Good portion sizes, several sauces to choose from, comfortable seating, well themed. Servers (and the sweet junior server) were friendly and helpful, checked on us several times to be sure we were happy with our meal. We will be back, and we will bring friends! read more

Todo está delicioso. El servicio es excelente, el menú tiene opciones para todos, recomiendo mucho la hamburguesa estaba super buena. La selección de draft beer es excelente. Totalmente recomendable. read more

SAVOR Barbeque & Taphouse - Barbeque Near Me - Sister Bay, Wisconsin

See all

Everything was perfect. Online ordering easy. Pick up was ready as I walked in. Right on time and freshly packed. Food was amazing. Baked beans with some brisket in them- wow! Terrific all around! read more

Food was nothing to write home about, rather mediocre. Ordered a plater that included brisket, ribs, sausage and two sides--the meat was meh, dry. Sandwich and platter was somewhat small for the price. Service and ambiance were fine. All together the experience was a near comical take on the 'new millennial restaurant.' read more

We visited their food trucks before they had their sister bay location, and are so excited to have them in sister bay at their store front!! Amazing meats and sides! Highly recommend. We have eaten inside before but it is a great place to order Togo and have a picnic by the water or at home to watch a game. read more

I've eaten here with my kids maybe 6 times since it's opened. I'm not sure there are awful reviews. Maybe they've had bad days. We love their breakfast burritos, smash burgers, and brisket and pork sandwiches. The baked beans are excellent. They have creative sandwiches and nice owners. Prices are a bit high on their sides for what they are. Commercial rent and cost of meat is expensive in our current economy so they're just passing on that cost. read more

Rude server at their food truck window. was one thing. Waiting 30 minutes for brisket that was drier than my grand-daddy's scalp was another

Great food and awesome owners! Can't wait to get back to their location this summer!

We were there for today for lunch and it was fantastic! I had the Maverick sandwich and my wife got the smash burger and they could not have been better. We will be back! read more

I was not expecting to exceptional, award winning barbecue in Sister Bay, Wisconsin. They are able to make almost everything on the menu gluten free. It has indoor seating, outdoor seating or take out. The potions are generous and fairly priced. Highly recommend. read more

SAVOR Barbeque & Taphouse - Nachos with japaleno peppers - Barbeque Near Me - Sister Bay, Wisconsin

See all

We went to Savor for the first time last Saturday and had to go back today for more! We loved the beef Barbacoa burrito, the quesadillas, and the pulled pork! Baked beans and cornbread were great sides. Highly recommend!! Online order was quick and easy, super convenient location. Will be back for sure!!! read more

SAVOR Barbeque & Taphouse - A generous 1 pound of delicious pulled pork with some tasty sweet bbq sauce. - Barbeque Near Me - Sister Bay, Wisconsin