Cancel

Open app

Search

Sandy's Diner

4.7 (13 reviews)
InexpensiveSandwiches, Diners

Sandy's Diner Photos

You might also consider

Recommended Reviews - Sandy's Diner

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration

Reviews With Photos - Sandy's Diner

Just a taste of their awesome menu
Josiah Z.

This place is pretty awesome, but I wish the wait wasn't so long. It's also kind of annoying how huge groups of people always come from Wacholz funeral home to enjoy the "munchies" appetizer. I called in a Valentine's Day reservation like 6 weeks ago, and I got the last one! Still, the food was soooo worth it. We started off with some cheese nuggets for appetizers, then moved on to the Foie gras for the main course. Absolutely delightful experience. Can't wait to go back. PS the wait service will sing for you if it's your birthday. They say it's their favorite part about working there.

a man eating a hamburger and fries

See all

4 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

4 years ago

Very welcoming owners. The food is always fantastic!! Highly recommend this small town diner!

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

8 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

13 years ago

Helpful 2
Thanks 0
Love this 3
Oh no 0

4 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of Glenn J.
159
28
0

13 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0

7 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

11 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

8 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

7 years ago

Just walking in to Sandy's Diner is an add to my day . My family and I enjoy the good food and great service. Deb Mejchar

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

13 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

13 years ago

All you could want from a diner; friendly atmosphere, great service and good food.

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

12 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

Ask the Community - Sandy's Diner

Horseradish - Korean Nachos.  The best!! Recommend

Horseradish

4.8(50 reviews)
12.1 mi

Our first time in Princeton and very under the radar town in Wisconsin. Horseradish was dog…read morefriendly in the back area. They have a dog Benny who hangs out and my wife and I are dog people and had our dog Sauce hanging with us while we had an amazing lunch! Everything was super fresh and the bread the caprese sandwich was served on came from a local bakery which is also a must stop called Renards European Bakeshoo. Had the lavender lemonade, which I also recommend. Can't wait to be back in Princeton as it's a hidden Gem and go back to Horseradish!

We were visiting Green Lake, WI from the Chicago burbs over Memorial Day weekend, and needed a…read morequick lunch spot that was within walking distance of the flea market that had both vegetarian options, and kid friendly options. Horseradish was bustling at 12:30pm on a Saturday, but wasn't too overly packed when we came in. We were able to find a table for 4 and get our orders in quickly. That being said, it took over an hour of listening to terribly overstimulating music with bad vibes to actually get our food. Our kids were hangry, as were the children at a few other tables as well. I ordered the Vegan Witch (I LOVE kimchi) and my daughter ordered the Gus Special No. 1. We also all ordered various sodas/Olipops. The prices for the sodas were absurd, and the side salad that I ordered with my vegan witch was flavorless. I was kind of shocked at the kids' menu options and expected better ... my daughter of course ate it, as she's 4, and who doesn't love cheese on tortilla chips, but what an odd lunch option. I would have preferred more kid friendly veggie options for the side veggies, as radishes are a bit strange to plate for a child ... my sandwich was good, but just seemed to be lacking something. Staff were incredibly nice, but with how slow service was, I would not recommend going when you're actually hungry. I also don't recommend for kids. It was a fun experience and a nice find for in the middle of nowhere, but I guess I was just hoping for a bit more ... The bathrooms are nice, and my daughter and I loved the banana and lipstick lights on the bathroom walls that were also for sale. Cute place, slow service. I'll probably never be in Green Lake, Wisconsin again, so I can't say whether I'd return or not.

Photos
Horseradish - Front counter space where you order.

Front counter space where you order.

Horseradish
Horseradish - So cozy, lots of atmosphere, color and fun! Can't wait to try the food

See all

So cozy, lots of atmosphere, color and fun! Can't wait to try the food

Green Lake Sub - Thick turkey cuts on "the hook"

Green Lake Sub

2.8(12 reviews)
9.6 mi
•$$

Don't go here. The service is so bad. The wait is consistently so long...For a 15$ sandwhich these…read moreguys could be a little more friendly or appreciative to the community and patrons that are keeping them in business. Workers- 3 strikes you're out based on how unbelievably rude you are. Came here to write this review after having a discussion at a party with many people about all of our wild experiences being spoken to rudely by these people LOL love the other reviews about the same topic.

On my most recent visit to Green Lake, I had a salad at Subco. The owners were oddly rude, but…read moresince I like to eat greens, I thought I would try it again anyway next time. Big MISTAKE! Just as bad as the first time, with even worse attitudes to me and the two customers behind me, as well! Being open-minded, I decided maybe 3rd time was the charm. Huh. I was wrong : 3 strikes and you're out! Today, after getting coffee , baked goods (try Sassafras' homemade cookies!!!) and pleasant service at my fav coffee place, I couldn't believe what I saw on Subco's window: these people actually posted a tacky, childish, window sign that read: "closed for the winter- enjoy your hot dog, or at least pretend to." What kind of person attacks a fellow business owner so rudely and publicly - especially in a small town!? Well, I thought to myself, with a recommendation like that, I better try that hotdog place! Thanks for that fantastic suggestion guys -- I will be going to Walk The Dog from now on! Being a business owner myself, this is horrible community etiquette from subco. I often bring my employees to GL for a little R & R and will never go to this sub place again. I support small businesses, but not rude small businesses.

Photos
Green Lake Sub - Shanghai

Shanghai

Green Lake Sub - Chief John sub with sour cream and chive chips. The drink is an Autumn from Sassafras.

Chief John sub with sour cream and chive chips. The drink is an Autumn from Sassafras.

Green Lake Sub - Zaco

See all

Zaco

Alimentari - Spicy Sopressata Sandwich

Alimentari

4.8(93 reviews)
50.0 mi•Dudgeon-Monroe

While popping between nearby Colectivo and the adjacent park, we popped into Alimentari out of…read morecuriosity, and somehow left with a pre-made frozen dinner for the evening and a Spicy Soppressata sammy to enjoy alongside the lake mere feet away! While they seem to be known for their sandwiches, and for good reason, they have a lot of great artisanal items rooted in Italian cooking. This includes oils, wines, sauces, spices, treats and more. The "more" also includes fresh-made pasta, hand cut meats and cheeses, gelato and a few other absolutely delish items! Back to that sandwich...we were not hungry, but could not pass up a good sandwich, especially one freshly made on locally sourced and baked bread! The bread was the absolutely star of each bite, I mean...sheesh! The sandwich in full was great, and definitely worth the stop in on its own. The store itself is small, but mighty, and well laid out, stocked with all the goods, flows well, clean and in great condition. Service was stellar as well. We were greeted upon entry, checked on while browsing and chatted up while being rang out. Overall, solid spot for a ready-made meal, a special ingredient, a tasty sandwich, fresh pasta, charcuterie or just to wander around in!

Holy smokes... I am going to have dreams about this sandwich. It is definitely top 3 sandwiches of…read moremy life and maybe the best ever. I had the prosciutto sandwich and my SO had the pastrami and both had nothing but good things to say as we ate. The prosciutto sandwich had balsamic that had just started to soak into the otherwise crunchy bread, with these big chunks of mozzarella and the freshest tomatoes and greens. Alimentari itself is this awesome little deli/grocer with both bagged pastas AND FRESH PASTA/antipasti available to buy, as well as all sorts of goods, breads, coffees, chocolates, beverages and a whole wine selection. Beware that there is no seating inside but definitely do not let this dissuade you from visiting.

Photos
Alimentari - What's a boat day without turkey sando

What's a boat day without turkey sando

Alimentari
Alimentari

See all

Sandy's Diner - sandwiches - Updated June 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...