Cancel

Open app

Search

Sam’s Square Pie

4.8 (133 reviews)
ModeratePizza
Updated 1 month ago

Sam’s Square Pie Photos

Business Info

SAM’S SQUARE PIE ATMOSPHERE

What's the vibe?
Casual
Trendy
Dogs allowed

You might also consider

Recommended Reviews - Sam’s Square Pie

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration

Reviews With Photos

Karla S.

Heard rave reviews so had to come check it out for myself! It's not obvious from the street where this place is but just trust that you are walking in to the right spot! Follow your nose :) I missed the sign but there is a small one outside. The owner, Sam is very nice and friendly. It's a small space inside but several tables. I imagine seating can be challenging during peak times. We went on a Wednesday evening and no issues with parking or seating. The meatballs are the best! 10/10 for me! I love the FLAVOR! You get 3 meatballs per order. They are nice size and I think the price is fair. The sauce is very good as well. I would definitely come back for these! I tried their most popular pizza the Jefe. It was just ok to me. To be fair, I don't like pepperonis but I picked them off as the person I went with loves pepperonis. I couldn't taste much of the sausage. The jalepeno ricotta sounds amazing but I couldn't really taste any jalepenos or spice to it. I did appreciate the pizza dough was airy and crisp and not chewy and "doughy". I wouldn't order this again but would like to try another pizza ; most likely a build my own. As far as drinks, there is a cooler with canned and bottled water. There is beer and wine available as well. There is free tap water.

Katherine C.

Went to Sam's Square Pie in Fountain Square for dinner with a friend and the food was absolutely incredible!! Parking is terrible to figure out, but that's FS for you. This pizza...holy crap. Best pizza in Indy! The crust was crunchy, soft and bounced back. Truly can tell by taste, looks and texture that's it's made in house. If you haven't been here yet--you're missing out.

Carryout - perfection
Brittany S.

It's all about the chewy and cheesy crust from Sam's Square Pie. It truly sets it apart from the pack. Not to mention the beautiful box design For Christmas this year, I gifted my husband a "diy weekly pizza pass" and we kicked things off with Sam's. The pie made its way home still hot and we loved the sweet salty dough, paired with the chewy cheese, honey glaze combination. It packed a punch and we'll definitely be coming back for more. They offer a small dine in space but we opted for carryout. It was faster than I expected for a deep dish style pizza. Highly recommend!

Just kissed my baby
Merry B.

From the outside, it's an unassuming spot on 10th street but it's totally worth a stop! The staff was so friendly and the owner was so warm and genuinely welcoming to everyone who came in. It seemed like there were a lot of first-timers in and I really appreciated him telling us where to order, etc. right away. We ordered garlic knots with vodka sauce and a "just kissed my baby" pizza. Each came out pretty quickly and both were incredible!! We could've eaten that vodka sauce with a spoon. Will definitely recommend and be back again! Lots of parking available in a lot behind the building and on the street off 10th.

The James
Theresa E.

Greeted by the owner when we walked in. That man doesn't know a stranger such a nice guy. Hugged me and thanked me for coming in. It's order at the counter service. We order two pizzas and garlic knots two canned sodas. The food was fresh delicious. If you want water it's free in a water cooler by the register. Also bottle water for purchase. Just go the vibes were good and buying local is always better . Keep in mind it's not Pizza Hut so the pizzas you get from those places aren't available here.

Just Kissed My Baby Pizza
Ariyanna M.

First let me start off by saying that the owner is wonderful! I feel like the atmosphere of the place just makes you feel like you're in for a good time. As for the food itself, one of the best pizzas I've had by far. I loved the crispy edges, the jalapeño ricotta cheese gives it a nice touch as well. A lot of flavors going on. They also have beef pepperoni for those who don't eat pork, a very nice substitute. Absolutely will be coming back.

Sticky Icky
Sydney T.

10/10 -- easily one of the best pizzas I've had in Indiana, hands down! We ordered the El Jefe and the Sticky Icky and both were absolutely incredible. The ricotta on the El Jefe truly takes it to the next level and seals the deal. I'm already looking forward to going back to try more of their menu. If you've been debating it -- just get the pizza. It's more than worth it. The service was impeccable and the vibes were fantastic from start to finish!

High Plains Drifter Pizza
Weil T.

High Plains Drifter pizza at Sam's Square Pizza is an award winning and I know why. First, the crust is a perfect crunch on the edges and a sponge dough in the center. The cheese blend pulls as you grab a slice. Who doesn't like a lot of cheese! The pesto and smoky maple syrup take it to the next level. Stop by and say hi to the owner. You won't regret it.

Christie N.

Good gluten free pizza is hard to come by, but Sam's Square Pie knocks it out of the park!! My expectations were exceeded with their GF Detroit style pizza and I cannot wait to order again! The crust, sauce, cheese, and toppings were perfection!

Sticky Icky
Andrea G.

This is a small place with a ton of cool art inside. There is a parking lot in the back of the bldg. We were greeted by the owner, Sam, and he took our order. We got the Sticky Icky. The pizza was amazing. A small was very filling for two people. Would recommend stopping by if you're in the area!

Wall decor
John P.

First time here. I've seen a lot about this place and heard that it was one of the best pizza places in town. And it lived up to its billing. We started off with the garlic knots. They were really soft a great garlic flavor on them and had some cheese to dip them in. They were very hot and were really excellent. Not too heavy but still really good. Also, we had the El jefe pizza with sausage, three kinds of pepperoni, hot honey and ricotta cheese. It was incredible great cheesy crispy crust nice thick Detroit style crust. And the toppings were excellent with the sauce on top and then topped with a dollop of ricotta cheese. The honey gave it a really nice sweet flavor and some a little hot aftertaste. The pepperoni was great sausage was great overall it was one of the best pizzas I have had in town. We got drinks out of the refrigerator, canned and bottled. But they also have a bar, but we just chose to do cokes. The atmosphere is really cool lots of Indianapolis area memorabilia kinds of things and references. A really cool space very welcoming friendly. Small seating area, maybe six or eight tables. But plenty of space for us. The guy that helped us to get our order in talk to us through the entire menu and was very friendly welcome rest in and told us to have a nice week when we left. Highly recommend.

My husband and I with the owner. You can see the restaurant in the picture. We ate the food too fast to take a picture.
Ashley C.

We are in town for the Indy 500 and decided to try this local eatery. The pizza was beyond delicious! We ordered the El Jefe and my husband reports it is the best pizza he's ever eaten in his life. I don't disagree. The restaurant has an eclectic vibe and the owners are fabulous people. They're very welcoming and happy to give us recommendations on what to order. The whole place had an eclectic chill vibe with 80's music pumping at the perfect volume to enjoy and also be able to have a conversation with the people around you. We met locals and enjoyed the game on the TV in front of us at the bar. The restaurant probably seats 25 people with 7 to 8 tables and a bar that seats about eight people. They serve beer and wine spritzer's. I found them on Yelp and as always, Yelp did not disappoint!

Loving Cup (drool)-I liked the art in the box, too!
Lien K.

Stopped in for pizza to share with a friend while we planned a road trip. It's in my neighborhood so I did carry out and walked. Note prep time can take a while-plan ahead. So. As a native New Yorker, I prefer the East coast pizza style, but this pizza... I think it's called "Detroit" style, a saucy, thick crust but not like a deep dish. After much deliberation, I chose the Loving Cup-pepperoni, sausage & pesto + red sauce and cheese. I ordered online and left my house minutes ahead of the pickup. My order ready text arrived en route. The guy at the counter was very friendly and the interior had some tables and chairs and a few good beers on tap, in addition to some canned options and cider. The pizza had crispy, carmelized edges, generous toppings and the crust a nice crunchy exterior and soft interior. The pricing may seem high but this is a very filling pizza. I may have dreamed of my leftovers. I'm thrilled to have Sam's close to home. I heard this place gets busy during peak times. Plan ahead, it's worth it.

Irie Pie Pizza w/ pepperoni (cuppy). Notice the lines of the sauce -- just pure beauty. No 2 bites are the same!

See all

29 days ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 2
Oh no 0

2 months ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of Marci I.
81
29
10

4 months ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0

6 months ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 2
Oh no 0

8 months ago

Business owner information

Photo of Jeff M.

Jeff M.

Helpful 2
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of Brittany S.
4975
3187
23714

8 months ago

Helpful 4
Thanks 0
Love this 5
Oh no 0

8 months ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 1

6 months ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0

6 months ago

Helpful 2
Thanks 0
Love this 2
Oh no 0

7 months ago

Helpful 2
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0

8 months ago

Helpful 2
Thanks 0
Love this 2
Oh no 0
Photo of Weil T.
7
59
58

4 months ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 2
Oh no 0

9 months ago

Business owner information

Photo of Jeff M.

Jeff M.

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 2
Oh no 0

4 months ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

5 months ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0

5 months ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0

6 months ago

Business owner information

Photo of Jeff M.

Jeff M.

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

1 year ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 1

6 months ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

8 months ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 2
Oh no 0

2 years ago

Business owner information

Photo of Jeff M.

Jeff M.

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0

2 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0

1 year ago

Business owner information

Photo of Jeff M.

Jeff M.

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of Melody D.
105
9
11

8 months ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0

9 months ago

Business owner information

Photo of Jeff M.

Jeff M.

Thankyou for taking the time to spread the word! We appreciate you!

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0

1 year ago

Business owner information

Photo of Jeff M.

Jeff M.

Thankyou so much for coming by!!!

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

2 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 1
Love this 3
Oh no 0

2 months ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of Adam B.
17
55
5

6 months ago

Business owner information

Photo of Jeff M.

Jeff M.

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

11 months ago

Helpful 2
Thanks 0
Love this 2
Oh no 0

5 months ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

2 years ago

Helpful 9
Thanks 5
Love this 7
Oh no 0

6 months ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

6 months ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

2 years ago

Helpful 3
Thanks 1
Love this 1
Oh no 0

1 year ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

7 months ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of P M.
0
13
0

3 months ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

7 months ago

Business owner information

Photo of Jeff M.

Jeff M.

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of Greg W.
379
623
3061

3 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 1

Page 1 of 4

Ask the Community - Sam’s Square Pie

I am really interested to try the Sicilian style from here, as no other pizza spot in Indy has really made an effort to feature that particular style. Went to website to order but not seeing where I can specify which style pizza to order. Any help?

If you have instagram send me a direct message. We only make a few due to the amount of pans and time spent on the Detroit style. The Sicilian is twice the dough and 12 slices feeds 6-7.

View All 2 Questions

You might also consider

Ten Hands Social Bar & Eatery - Chocolate pudding.

Ten Hands Social Bar & Eatery

3.8(58 reviews)
2.8 mi•Wholesale District, Mile Square

Wow. Ten Hands is…read morelocated inside the Westin so you may not see it from the street. Walk inside the Westin and immediately turn to the right and walk towards the Ten Hands as we did today. Ryton was amazing. Her big bright smile was just what we four needed this morning as none of us slept well in the hotel. We did make a reservation but this morning was not necessary as there were plenty of tables. Let's start with the coffee - FANTASTIC. The coffee was on point. God bless. The menu is short but stacked. You can create your own omelette or order two eggs any style or be like my boss and order the Butter Pecan French Toast. My other boss ordered the Farmhouse croissant. Every dish was very eye appealing and believe it or not- there were ZERO COMPLAINTS. As I remarked to Ryton, having delicious coffee, great food, and zero compliants is a miracle and how we were blessed today. If you are in the area, don't overlook the Ten Hands and if you see Ryton and her beautiful smile, make sure to say hello!

We were attending a conference in the area and decided to pop over to The Westin to give Ten Hands…read morea shot! We ordered pizza, smoked swings, Brussels sprouts, and truffle fries to share. Honestly, the food was delish. The Brussels sprouts were AMAZING! Smoked wings were good too. We absolutely loved the pizza. The truffle fries were okay. They were out of the garlic aioli that comes with the fries, and I think that would have given them the kick they were missing. The ambiance is cool with the fire pit right at the entrance. Many TVs at the bar, so it's a great spot to catch a game. I also liked the layout of the room - particularly the booths, in relation to where the TVs are. Honestly much better food and ambiance than at one of the other nearby hotel restaurants we tried.

Photos
Ten Hands Social Bar & Eatery - Contemporary setting. Entrance to Ten Hands from inside the Westin.

Contemporary setting. Entrance to Ten Hands from inside the Westin.

Ten Hands Social Bar & Eatery
Ten Hands Social Bar & Eatery

See all

King Dough Indy - Weekend at Mortie's pizza

King Dough Indy

4.3(545 reviews)
1.3 mi•Holy Cross, Cottage Home
•$$

King Dough is one of those places that feels cool without trying too hard…read more The open kitchen lets you watch the crew work around the wood-fired oven while the smell of fresh pizza slowly convinces you that you made an excellent life decision. The space itself is bright, industrial, and relaxed, with large garage doors that let plenty of light in and communal tables that make it easy to settle in. Our pizza came out surprisingly fast, especially considering everything is made fresh. We ordered pepperoni, sausage, and red onion, and they absolutely loaded it with toppings. Crispy, blistered crust, gooey cheese, and enough pepperoni to make me stop counting after about bite three. It was honestly love at first bite. One tip: don't skip the restroom before you leave. I won't spoil it, but whoever decorated those walls and that door clearly had some fun. King Dough nails that balance between casual neighborhood pizza joint and destination-worthy meal. I'd happily come back...and next time, I might have to branch out from my beloved pepperoni.

Never have had a bad time at King Dough. Love the patio but on a warm day it is also nice to be…read moreable to sit inside with the AC while still enjoying fresh air because of the garage doors. The Greko salad is my ALL TIME favorite salad and will never not be ordered. Pizzas are always perfectly cooked. While some of the topping choices seem strange, the combos always work! Only request would be that they allow for halvsies on pizzas since it is hard to chose just one. Pizza favs: Fungi Ricky, Gabba Ghoul, & Stinky Pete Looking for a fun drink not on the menu? Ask for a snake bit (combo of sour beer and cider). Perfect for those who think sours are too sour and ciders are too sweet.

Photos
King Dough Indy - Something borrowed cocktail

Something borrowed cocktail

King Dough Indy - Non alcoholic mock tails

Non alcoholic mock tails

King Dough Indy - Cider from Normandy France

See all

Cider from Normandy France

Sam’s Square Pie - pizza - Updated October 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...