Scott's on Fifth is one of those rare restaurants that feels completely and unapologetically…read moreitself. Charming, eclectic, eccentric, glamorous, glittery and magical, there is something interesting to look at in every direction. The atmosphere has so much personality that simply walking through the door feels like the beginning of an experience.
Chef Scott is incredibly talented, creating dish after dish from a remarkably small kitchen with an always-evolving menu, and somehow everything that comes out feels thoughtful, beautiful and made with genuine love. There is an artistry to the food here. The flavors deliver just as much as the presentation.
We started with escargot, prepared two different ways, and both were absolutely delicious. From there came rich, comforting soups, fresh bread with seasoned butter, and a crisp salad before moving into the entrées. The seafood dishes were beautifully prepared, delicate where they needed to be, rich where they should be, and accompanied by simple but flavorful vegetables and sides.
Our server, Todd, only enhanced the experience. He was attentive, friendly and had such a wonderful personality. He knew the menu beautifully and was unbelievably helpful throughout the evening, answering questions, offering guidance and making us feel genuinely taken care of. Service can completely shape an evening, and Todd made an already special experience even better.
What I especially love about Scott's on Fifth is that it doesn't feel like a restaurant trying to duplicate anything else. From the décor to the plating to Scott himself, it has its own identity. It is quirky, intimate, elegant and just a little theatrical--and that is exactly its charm.
There are plenty of places where you can have a good dinner. Scott's feels like somewhere you go to have an evening.
Beautiful atmosphere, genuinely wonderful food, exceptional service and a chef whose talent is evident in every plate.
An easy 5 out of 5. Absolutely fabulous.