I've been a regular at Sally's since the other locations were around, so I was really excited to try the Erskine location and see if it was going to give me that same Sally's satisfaction. And honestly... it did not disappoint! We started with the happy hour appetizers: jerk shrimp tacos, escovitch wings, and salmon bites. Everything came out pretty quickly and was well seasoned. I didn't personally try the jerk tacos, but my brother LOVED them, so I'll take his word for it. The salmon bites were really good and came with sweet chili sauce, although they were flavorful enough that I didn't even need it. My only little complaint was that the escovitch wings came out wet rather than dry, which I personally would've preferred. The happy hour pricing was also a win. Most of the bites were $15 or under, and the portions were actually really decent. By the time my main dish came out, I was already full from the appetizers and ended up taking my Badmon Rasta pasta home as leftovers. It comes with shrimp, lobster, and salmon pasta, but they weren't serving lobster at the time I went, so I substituted with extra shrimp. Even with that, the pasta was tasty and the portion was generous. Definitely enough food to leave with tomorrow's meal already handled. Now let's talk about the rum punch because that rum punch was PUNCHING. It was GOOD good. I sat at the bar, and Chas was my bartender. She was super nice, attentive, and honestly made the experience even better. She gave great suggestions whenever anyone in my party was hesitant about what to order, and she was always checking in without being overbearing. The service was quick and everything came out in a timely manner. The atmosphere was also really nice. The music was playing at a good volume, so we could actually enjoy it without having to yell across the table at each other. The restaurant was clean, including the bathroom, and they have a BIG mirror if you need to check yourself before leaving or, naturally, take a few pictures Overall, I had a really good experience. Good food, good portions, good music, good service, and a bartender who knew what she was doing. Sally's Erskine definitely passed the test for me. I'll absolutely be back! read more

Had a great dining experience at Sally's. Our server Anthony was super friendly and attentive, our drinks were delicious (and strong ) . Now let me tell you about the food, everything my group ordered was delicious.. the curry goat, brown stew chicken and the grilled lobster all amazing and highly recommend for your visit here. read more

My server was extremely customer friendly. Her name is Yvonne. I give her a 10 ratings. Very pleasant and professional.

As someone that used to visit the Original Sally's that was located on Ave D in Brooklyn I was looking foward to experience the new home in Gateway. Ambiance was ok. But could be a little more Jamaican vibe brighter. Service was good waiter was attentive and honest. He wanted to make sure we were satisfied. The fish was ok could have been seasoned a little more and more spice could have been in the escovitch sauce. To not serve plantain with any entree in a Jamaican restaurant was disappointing. You could only get it as a side. The jerk wings were the most disappointing. Its a fried wing with wet sauce no spice no taste of jerk anything. They were dry and seemed old. I would pass on that. The Mac and cheese was good but I could tell it was microwave In the plate it was served in. As a west Indian person those wings were disappointing. The live DJ was a WWWWWHHHHHOOLLLLEEEE VIBBBBBBEEEEEEEE. Hubby and I were dancing in our seats. The drinks we ordered was a mixed bag my mango drink did not taste any mango just a bunch of Vodka. Changed it for a Sally's sunset. It was delicious. Bartender took the criticism and was willing to fix or make a new drink. She was great. They just need to really work on presentation of the drinks and food. They have a big name to live up to and alot of competition out here. Hopefully this review helps. Good luck Sally's. read more

See all

Went for the first time on Friday, and I'm sure I'll be coming back! Anthony, our server was amazing. Very attentive and hospitable. Dj was great, we were dancing in our seats the entire time! It wasn't packed, the ambience was nice and the food and drinks were really good too. We ordered a sally punch, sidecar, spicy margarita, some wings, oxtails and the pepper steak- no complaints : ) read more

Great service. Food is always tasty. . I love the ambiance. It's always a vibe . Music on point

Horrible customer service,hair in food and gave me an allergic reaction.Ordered a Jamaican Rum Punch and the bartender put peach schnapps in it..Im allergic to peaches and never in all my years ever had a rum punch with peach on it.Also they have a B rating smh. read more

Saniyyah was super sweet and welcoming!! Will definitely be returning. Amazing food and service. I loved the vibes, read more

Sally’s Restaurant - Shrimp Rasta pasta - Caribbean Near Me - New York, New York

Great customer service. The owner came out she was extremely accommodating and friendly. My family and I dined in on a midweek afternoon. We ordered Sally's punches (authenticaly made with wray and nephew rum) from the happy hour menu great food and drinks options for the prices. I believe 3p to 7p. We each had a lunch special item Great portions for the price . I ordered the curry goat with white rice and steam veggies. Tender succulent pieces of goat. My one critique would be it could've been a little spicier as curry traditionally is, however I understand that the masses can't always handle heat. I was able to get some pepper sauce on the side . That did tun it up!. 8/10 We ordered the carrot cake for dessert. It was moist and tasty not overly sweet 7/10. Sally's has offered carribbean delights to nyc specifically Brooklyn for decades. I use to frequent the flagship store on Clarkson Ave as a child. Ill be back to enoy some more of the menu. There is convenient parking in the back . Spacious tables and bar seating. A great floor to ceiling mirror by the restrooms . Nice to check out your fit before heading back over to the table lol. read more

See all

The food n drinks are good. I love their jerk wings and fish and chips. A must to go when u in Gateway. The service is great and you can always watch sports on game days. read more

The food tasted quite Amazing. Just somethings on the menu weren't available. The place looked very clean. Service was decent. Been here befire intend to go back again and maybe again read more

See all

I live in the neighborhood . They're fairly a new restaurant. I had some appetizer and a meal walk-in it was decent.

They did not have the items I want. Shrimp was overcooked. Fruit punch and lemonade seem to be from a box music was loud. Only two of us and the wait time was long The Escovich Snapper and Bodman pasta was good. No lobster was availabe for the pasta. I had to substitue with shrimp. The price is very steep. read more

The food is wonderful and the service is always friendly. The ambience makes it a elegant dining experience.

AMBIANCE 7.5 The spot is clean and of course new but the decor and design of the space isn't the best but that don't take away from the top notch service, drinks & food. SERVICE 10 Im big on service. I don't care how good food is if the service ain't hitting I ain't w it. The ladies I encountered were CHASITY (waitress/host) & CHEYENNE (bartender) both were professional and so kind! Cheyenne knows how to make a DRANK! I didn't mind paying the $$ for drinks bc she made it worth it. Also when things weren't on the menu Chasity offered other recommendations. Besides just being attentive and knowledgeable about the menu. The main star FOOD ok so I'm old school I used to eat at the "sit down" sallys on Ralph in Georgetown Brooklyn rip ... the food ain't been the same at the Sally's on flatlands (sallys owner I love you but y'all gotta get that together) I was hesitant to come to this one bc the food wasn't the best at the take out restaurant on flatlands but babbbyyyy I had the OXTAIL, SHRIMP in butter sauce CODFISH cakes (y'all need a better sauce tho, the regular tartare wasn't it) MAC and CHEESE ERRTHING was "10 10 10 across the board". I don't know the chef but they need a SHOUT OUT TOO! Lol I'm so hype to have a nice spot in the neighborhood Check them out bc they have happy hrs Mon-Fri 3-7 and some music on certain nights To the owner let's get some live jazz one night babe lol ;) I'll add pics and edit the post when I get some I tore the FOOD up lmao read more

I'm a chef and a huge supporter of Black-owned businesses. Recently, my friends and I were among the first to enter this business, and almost immediately, the service was bad. The bartender was lackadaisical, and that was a sign of things to come. After being seated, we ordered fried calamari. Fifteen minutes later, we were told they were cleaning the fryer, so that dish is not available. Who cleans the fryer after you open for business? Okay, we ordered two curry chicken roti's, and it took so long that I cancelled the order, but all of a sudden, it was ready. After paying $32 for the food, we had had enough of the poor service and warm beer, and we left. Arriving home, my wife and I opened the bag, and to our surprise, the two containers contained a minimal amount of chicken and someone's idea of roti. The only thing this restaurant has going for it is the decor. There is no way I could recommend anyone, and I mean anyone, to drink, eat, or set foot in Sally's. read more

Sally’s Restaurant - Sally's idea of curry chicken - Caribbean Near Me - New York, New York

Don't never order or come to this restaurant the service is very slow been sitting here a hour and 45 minutes waiting for food and customer service is very bad waiter spilled drinks on me this is the worst restaurant I ever been to don't go to this restaurant it's very shitty read more

The food is ok. The service is hella bad tho. They mad mean in there tho. Never going back

Nice spot, but the service was extremely slow on a Wednesday night. Ordered the Oxtail pasta. It was tasty read more

10/10 customer service, food is delicious, drinks are great! If you haven't been here before sure to add it to the top of your list read more

When I tell you never again that is exactly what I meant. I will never eat at this restaurant again. I ordered honey-glazed salmon with rice & peas and mixed vegetables. It took about 5 minutes for my food... so then I should have known the food was not going to be fresh. Indeed my food was not fresh at all. The salmon was hard as stones so I can tell that the food was not made to order. The only tasty thing was the honey-glazed sauce. $26 gone to waste --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- I should have known that the food was not going to be good, because there were no customers. Get it together!!! If the owner reads the reviews he needs to have a long conversation with his cooking staff. YUKKKKKEEEE read more

You want to go to a poppin' place with live music/DJ on Friday and Saturday, hookah and Fridays and happy hour M-F then this is the spot! I don't know why I've been passing this spot for so long, too long! This is great spot to chill, drinks on point, and food, omg.. rice and peas, oxtail... will be coming again! Mos Def! read more

Im not really a review pserson, but i wanted to leave a review for this restaurant. Its is by far a solid spot for a great time!!. The food? Always hits the spot. They've got an extensive variety on the menu, and everything I've tried has been tasty. Plus, the atmosphere is chill and laid-back. Definitely worth checking out if you're in the area and craving some good eats." read more

Food was cold the roti was stiff the jerk chicken was too soggy and salty,service take too long we waited like 40 minutes for appetizers

This Caribbean food is not it! Idk but they need to add fresh veggies.... Canned vegetables do not taste right with curry or jerk... no cabbage?????? And the curry is super salty read more

I really like the decor of this place!! Cheyenne the Bartender made a excellent Rum Punch!! Five stars to her!! I ordered a Veg Roti, it was just okay. I had much better. Also, I ordered Curried Chickpeas with White Rice for my Vegetarian Daughter and she loved it!! I gave this place 3 stars because of their Veg Roti!!! Please you need to incorporate fresh greens!! Or at least ask what would I like inside of my Roti? I will give this Spot another chance by ordering something different. Hopefully, I can come back with a better review. read more

Great service excellent food drinks was divine ambiance a whole vibe bring your family and friends.