Our van broke down in Columbus, 150 miles from home. After other shops told us it would be a week…read morebefore they could even look at it, Hometown Service in Westerville stepped up. The owner was incredibly friendly and told us to tow it right in. I was worried that an electrical issue while stranded would lead to 'ghost' repairs and a huge bill, but their honesty and integrity were amazing. They got us into a bay immediately, diagnosed the problem accurately, and fixed it for a very fair price. If you need a trustworthy mechanic near Columbus, go here. They treated us like neighbors and got us back on the road the same day. Truly great people!

I've been taking a very old truck to these mechanics for some years now and I have been pleased…read morewith everything they have done for me... and some of the problems I took to them were big ones. Every interaction was professional and friendly. Their work was always done thoroughly and in the time they had said it would take. I feel fortunate that I found their shop when I did. I highly recommend trying them.

Came here for a pre purchase inspection on a vehicle. These guys are amazing. Super friendly,…read morereasonable prices and they took a lot of time to explain everything that was going on with the car to me. Very thorough and honest! Would absolutely recommend to friends and family.

I've loved using Westerville automotive for all things car since we've moved in down the street a…read morecouple of years ago. Super friendly, knowledgeable, and honest staff. I've always looked for a good mechanic to take all of my cars too, and I'm glad that I finally found them!

Reviews are very positive. But my only experience is not. Made an appointment for 2:30. I was told…read moreit would be about an hour and a half for an oil change and tire rotation. Arguably a significant time for those jobs. But ok. Leave and come back at 4:00 and my car hasnt even moved. Ok, why take appointment if it has no value. Is my first question. Then when you drop the car off. Why not tell the customer that they are running way behind. It would of saved me bothering neighbors for rides I didnt need I wont be back

EDIT: Oxford reached out to me, and I appreciate their efforts to make things right. There was a…read morenumber of things this location did wrong, mainly boiling down to moving too quickly and skipping/missing important steps in the customer service process, but they did work with me on resolving these. They did replace the spark plugs on my car, as they'd replaced them previously and they were under warranty. I did choose to do the ignition coils myself, as I was able to purchase the same OEM parts significantly cheaper (25%) and do the job myself in ten minutes. ORIGINAL: Price gouging and predatory behavior. I've come to Oxford's multiple times before for scheduled maintenance with no issues, but I brought my car (~10yr old Honda, nothing fancy) over after hours urgently, because of an engine misfire and a 'SERVICE IMMEDIATELY' notification. When they opened and checked it in, they sent me an approval form for a $200 diagnostic charge, higher than I've ever had anywhere else, and not waived if you get the repair with them. I called for some clarification, and then a few minutes later found that they had started the diagnostic without getting my approval - apparently Kevin W took my asking a question as implicit approval. Annoying, but I was hoping to go ahead anyway so I let it go. A few hours later, I get another call from Kevin with the results of the diagnostic. I hadn't received an inspection report with details like I usually would have, and he said I needed new spark plugs and ignition coils, quoting me at around $1,100 for this. I can't give the exact value, because I was never sent the estimate, even after I specifically asked for it. I only received the inspection report at that time, but with no estimate or approval request. This is an absolutely absurd cost. I'm by no means a car guy, but this is something I can order all the parts for less than $130, and will only take an hour or so of my time. I have absolutely no idea what the hell they're doing that would make this cost more than $300-$500, at absolute most. Now, if they over-quoted me because they're busy and don't want the work - then just tell me that I'm either going to wait a few days or that I need to take it elsewhere. What this looks like to me is that they tried to take advantage and overcharge someone in a bind, thinking that I'd pay whatever they ask so my car was drivable again. I feel like the lack of a written estimate to look over before sports this. If so, this is predatory behavior from a repair shop, and I wouldn't recommend them to anyone.

I'm sharing this because I really don't want anyone else to go through what I did. I brought my car…read morein for a specific issue, and instead of actually checking the problem, they pushed a $200 "inspection" that had nothing to do with why I was there. They marked a bunch of things in red to make it seem urgent, but completely ignored the real reason I came in. It honestly felt like they weren't even trying to diagnose anything. The mechanics didn't look into the issue -- they just suggested replacing parts and quoted prices that were as high as (or higher than) the dealership. The whole point of coming here was to avoid those kinds of charges, but I ended up paying more anyway. And the worst part? I paid, and the issue still wasn't fixed. I left feeling frustrated, disappointed, and honestly a bit scammed. If something doesn't feel right when you're there, trust your gut and take your car somewhere else.

Be honest. Don't make up fake repairs to mislead customers. 100 percent verified by my Toyota…read moredealer that what they told me my car needed was fiction.

Tilton's has always treated me right. Today I took my BMW in because of a rear end vibration (I had…read morejust replaced the rear suspension) and I thought it was due to an unbalanced wheel. As it turns out I didn't torque down the wheel tight enough (I did it to specs) but Andy explained that the rust on the hub crushed down and loosened, thus creating the wobble. He tightened both wheels and sent me on my way free of charge. I've taken a few of my vehicles there and have gotten absolute five star service each time. Also if you're a Veteran you get a 10% discount to boot. It's a great shop and a credit to Worthington to have them there.

I wanted to be happy with the job that Tilton's performed but I cannot bring myself to it. Someone…read morerear ended me and I wanted to take my car to Tilton's since it is in a convenient location for me. Communication was ok, and the car was done when they said it would be done. However the actual paint job they performed leaves a lot to be desired. They did not paint match the new bumper correctly, and the clear coat is completely opaque and bumpy. There is a very noticeable transition between the bumper and the rest of the car as shown below. They replaced my bumper with a non OEM part, which was the fault of the insurance company and not them, so maybe that is part of it. I also share some blame as I was in a hurry to catch a flight when picking up my car so I did not thoroughly inspect their work. Regardless, it is not a quality job and I would not recommend going there for body work.

Always great service and at a very reasonable cost. Much less expensive than taking a vehicle to…read morethe dealership.

Service not timely, were not thorough and had to come back after car overheated and spend another…read morethousand dollars just to have it returned dirty, no oil in it and a day later. Will not be returning.

Believe all the bad reviews.!! As a real customer who took…read moremy car in TWICE, once with the original issue, and again to fix the damage they caused to my fuel injectors with their "walnut cleaning" Neither time did my original issue get fixed and they even tried to say it was my exhaust pipe rattling. Turns out if they had just replaced my damn Camshaft position actuator the problem would've went away! But no, they had me spend 2 grand OUT OF POCKET the first time, didn't fix my issue, instead I had a new one, and another 2787 OUT OF POCKET yet again to fix the issue THEY CAUSED!! And lied to my face as well as lost my ENGINE COVER! These people are ripping you off! DO NOT TRUST WHAT THEY SAY TO YOU THEY ARE LIARS and I have paperwork to prove it! ALL NEW FUEL INJECTORS, SPARK PLUGS, Intake Manifold Gasket and still the same issue.

Didn't fix issue and was promised. Engine light didn't go off after $2300. I would not recommend…read morethis place.

I had my old Kia in this shop for brakes and and an oil change. Things did not go smoothly but I am…read morevery pleased. During the removal of the brake drums and pads a part was broken and non were available locally, Ron - one of the owners send a man to drive several hours round trip to pick up the part from one of the only places that had one. No extra charge for me. When everything goes well - everyone is happy but I know that always doesn't happen and it is important how problems are handled. This shop did well in spite of problems. I recommend them to any one in the area. Mike Forrest

Trust worthy and good mechanics. I was taking my car to the dealership until a simple tire…read morerotation became a big ordeal. I took it to Tuffy and they fixed everything and told me what went wrong. Ron is honest with you tells what's needed and what can wait. Ron always tries to get you in as soon as possible.