Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Rumors

    3.1 (11 reviews)
    InexpensiveNew American, Pubs
    Open 6:00 am - 12:00 AM (Next day)

    Order Rumors Takeout or Delivery

    Rumors Photos

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Rumors

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    4 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    5 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 1

    4 years ago

    Everything took way too long. The food ended up being decent, in a tv-dinner kind of way, but not even close to being worth the wait.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 1

    4 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 1

    7 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Gwen B.
    12
    12
    3

    12 years ago

    Helpful 3
    Thanks 0
    Love this 3
    Oh no 0

    10 years ago

    Helpful 3
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Ralph M.
    430
    69
    11

    10 years ago

    Helpful 2
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    6 years ago

    Business owner information

    Photo of Stephen L.

    Stephen L.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    13 years ago

    Outstanding dinner amazing chef!!!! Great food, great drinks, great friends.... Recommend highly...

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Dru W.
    0
    13
    0

    10 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Ask the Community - Rumors

    Is there karaoke on a Saturday?

    Every Friday at 9PM.

    Don’t See Your Question? Ask Away!

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for New American 703 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    The Port Bar & Grill

    The Port Bar & Grill

    4.1
    (24 reviews)
    1.7 mi

    This little divey spot has unexpectedly delicious food that will keep you coming back. I started…read moreoff with an order of the Crabby Bites. Basically mini crab cake balls, deep fried and served with a side of the house cajun ranch. It was a great size for sharing, but I could have easily put down 2 orders of these. They were moist inside, perfectly fried, and the ranch had a nice flavor without being too hot. For my main I ordered their Maine Lobster Roll. Fresh cold lobster mixed with mayo and celery salt and comes with a lemon wedge on the side. I've had some really good rolls while visiting New England and this roll stood up to the others. Generous lobster portions, and the perfect ratio of mayo without making the sandwich soggy. It was delicious and hit my craving. At the Port, the outdoor seating is where it's at. A fully enclosed patio, fans, and a full service bar. Inside, they have a fully stocked beer wall with loads of beers on tap to try. The down sides here are that it is in a residential neighborhood with on street parking. Get ready to drive around looking for a spot and be prepared to walk. The Port is currently rated a 9.1 on my Beli and is worth a stop whether you're looking for some good beer or delicious pub food.

    Still one of my favorite spots when visiting the area. This time we sat at the bar, which was…read moregreat. Our bar tender was a sport and kept the zingers coming. Did the wing special for the table, and a garlic cheesesteak- no photo unfortunately. Great food and great service!

    Photos
    The Port Bar & Grill
    Crabby Bites
    Crabby Bites
    Maine Roll

    See all

    Maine Roll
    Deer Lake Pub & Restaurant

    Deer Lake Pub & Restaurant

    4.1
    (59 reviews)
    8.8 mi
    $$

    Where should I begin ?…read more The chose the name Deer Lake Pub & Restaurant. Their name could not be further from the truth. It is a bar, not a pub, and certainly has no right to call themselves a restaurant. I have been to many, many true pubs and this is nothing even close. It is a low tier bar, at best. The "restaurant" is a drab room with square tables, no table cloths, the room has no decorations or environment. It is drab and blasé, just like their grossly overpriced poor quality food. The Manheim Diner a few miles North serves MUCH better food tan here and it is a third of the price. I have actually had far better hot food from vending machines in bus and train terminals. I ordered the crab stuffed haddock and my wife ordered the 12-oz. ribeye steak. We asked for rolls with my French onion soup while we waited for our entrees. We decided the soup had to be made in fifteen minutes as it tasted poorly, onions were hard and NOT caramelized at all and there was no bread whatsoever under the cheese. Our requested rolls was not forthcoming until after our dinners were half eaten. The "rolls" were actually a small piece of halved hoagie roll which came to the table charred, hard as a rock and fully burnt on the entire bottom. We could not eat them as they were so hard and burnt. And, they charged $3.99 for that ! I requested the crab-stuffed haddock only have the light lemon butter sauce with no added salt, pepper, Old Bay, oregano, etc. it came to the table overcooked, dry, hard and tasteless. The "stuffed crab" was the same and had portions burnt on the bottom. My wife's "12-oz. ribeye" was more like eight ounces, tough as leather, appeared to us to have been hard beaten with a tenderizing mallet and almost unable to be cut with a steak knife. It was hard to chew and had little taste. We seriously doubt it was a ribeye as it was as tough as a flank steak and was most likely a cooked frozen piece of meat. The entire dinner cost almost $100.00. It was worth, at most, $30.00. We dine out a lot and enjoy good food. This was definitely NOT good food. It was not even mediocre. It was just poorly prepared low tier bar food. Save your money and go get hot food from train station vending machines. It will taste better and be appropriately priced.

    I was here for a special occasion. The food was ok, maybe not the place I would go to celebrate…read moresomething or a fancy night out - but it wasn't a total bust. Casual night out for drinks and a cheap bite, this is your spot. I ordered off the specials menu. For a starter I went with the house crab dip and chose the toasted bread. It was surprisingly delicious and full of actual lumps of crab meat. For my main I did the surf and turf. Filet with lobster tail. My tail was overcooked and rubbery. My friends was cooked to perfection. Maybe I was just unlucky. My steak was a little more done than preferred but it was tender and had good flavor. You could choose one side and I got mashed potatoes and gravy. They tasted like instant potatoes and canned gravy. It was the biggest disappointment of the meal. The service was ok, our waitress was somewhat attentive to us. The atmosphere was very casual even for a special evening. I was hoping to see a little more effort put into table centerpieces or general decorations.

    Photos
    Exterior
    Exterior
    (my side plate of fat)
    (my side plate of fat)
    Exterior

    See all

    Exterior
    Market Cross Pub

    Market Cross Pub

    4.1
    (332 reviews)
    62.1 mi
    $$

    Friendly service and delicious food! We are new to town and…read morethis was a great first stop. The cheese steak was fresh and perfectly seasoned. The fries were crisp and tender. My son enjoyed the burger and my husband says the fish and chips were fantastic. We'll be back!

    We've heard so much about steak night on Tuesday so we decided to go. We both had steak. I had…read moremine with mashed and asparagus and Jenni had mashed with green beans. The steaks were okay -- they seemed tough and mine, for medium seemed slightly over cooked with hardly any pink inside and what there was was very light pinkish / brown color. Jenni said her steak was done to her satisfaction -- medium well. I would say mine was probably also medium well. My steak had a lot of fat and gristle that I didn't eat. The mashed potatoes were amazing. My asparagus seemed stingy in size and number of stalks and added little taste or filling to my plate. Jenni said her green beans were okay. The iced tea was great. My Pepsi didn't taste flavorful though Alyssa said she checked the soda bags and they were full. I swapped for sweetened ice tea. Alyssa was a super friendly server who checked on us regularly. We want to patronize local businesses but we probably wouldn't get our meals again and would try something else. Jenni said she'd rate our experience as a 2.5 which is exactly what I'd give so we're going to round up since maybe our experience was just a little off this evening.

    Photos
    Market Cross Pub
    Fried Chicken Sandwich
    Fried Chicken Sandwich
    Peach mule

    See all

    Peach mule
    Rusty Rail Brewery

    Rusty Rail Brewery

    3.7
    (363 reviews)
    47.3 mi
    $$
    Locally owned & operated
    Family-owned & operated

    My kids took mom and dad on an expedition on July 11th that involved the local Wild Animal…read moreSanctuary and then we went to the Rusty Rail for lunch. I had a brisket sandwich, wife had a really immense chicken salad. My son had a ruben sandwich and I can't remember what my daughter had. However, all the food was really great and I really did enjoy myself. After lunch my daughter took me to the Rusty Rail store and I bought a nice T-shirt. If you do buy a T-shirt, I want to say, while the shirts are great, wash up nice and feel really comfortable, make sure you buy an upsized shirt. Normally I take a large but I decided on an XL and I am glad I did because after washing the XL fits perfectly. And I got to speak with (I think either the manager or owner) about the music they were playing. They were playing songs from my favorite singer, Bob Seger. I have every Bob Seger song he ever published on either, CD, Cassette Tape (yeah, still got one that works), or vinyl record. Told him he needs to check out the Bob Seger song Little Victories. I actually have a vinyl record with just that song. It is the large 78 version. That was a rare find and I actually found that in Germany in the mid 80's. The song says a lot. Anyway, after speaking with the man, my daughter said I could pick out and mix my own six pack of beer. Let me tell you, Rusty Rail makes some really, really fantastic beer. I would have to say my two faovrites are Wolf King, a stout with coffee & oatmeal and the other is Fool's Gold, Peanut Butter Hefeweizen. Oh my God, those two are absolutely great beers. I should be living in Mifflinburg because I would be making a weekly stop at the Rusty Rail. And for all you ex-military people, the Rusty Rail does give a discount to military. I hope my kids take me to the Rusty Rail again next year. Oh, in case I did not say it. The kids took mom and dad to the Rusty Rail and the Wild Animal Sanctuary as a gift for our birthday's and Mother's Day and Father's Day. It just so happens my wife was born on Mother's Day and I was born the day after Father's Day. The atmosphere of the Rusty Rail is great, it is simply a real nice place to socialize. And as a compliment to the Rusty Rail, I want to add this. When I go out to eat, one of the first things I do is use the restroom. Why? To see how clean the restrooms are. If a venu's restrooms are dirty, find another place because if they can't keep the restrooms clean, then they don't care about your food much either. The restrooms at the Rust Rail were immaculately clean. JUST TO BE CLEAR, THE RESTROOMS AT THE RUSTY RAIL ARE IMMACULATELY CLEAN. Thank You Rusty Rail for a wonderful time with my family.

    What an awesome brewery! The place is huge, with plenty of seating, but I definitely recommend…read moremaking a reservation. We tried stopping in once before and they were completely booked for the night. This time we planned ahead, made a reservation, and were seated right away. At the recommendation of our waitress, we all ordered the chicken and waffles special, and every single person loved it. It was absolutely delicious. I also had the Reuben soup and it was very tasty. They also have a wonderful beer selection. I tried the blueberry beer, which was very tasty with a smooth blueberry finish that really stood out. If you're looking for a great brewery with good food, great beer, and a fun atmosphere, I would definitely recommend checking this place out!

    Photos
    Join us during the Holidays for a refreshing break from shopping.
    Join us during the Holidays for a refreshing break from shopping.
    Grab a flight or fill a growler.
    Grab a flight or fill a growler.
    Bananas foster waffle, 750,000 calories!

    See all

    Bananas foster waffle, 750,000 calories!
    Old Forge Brewing Company

    Old Forge Brewing Company

    3.9
    (270 reviews)
    28.7 mi
    $$

    We stopped here for dinner on a Saturday evening while in town. The place is cozy and it was…read morebustling with live music when we arrived. Our server was Jordan and she was excellent! She guided us with recommendations on what to order. I had the strawberry arugula salad with chicken and it was excellent! My partner had the chicken wings in two flavors and he said they were meaty and delicious. Glass of cab franc was also good and reasonably priced. Overall a great experience and definitely recommend!

    The beer selection and interior design were more impressive than the food…read more Both beers we ordered were poured well and had good citrus and hoppy notes. No complaints there. Besides the staple menu, there was a rotating menu featuring a soup, mussel dish, flatbread, burger, and pasta. The food took some time to come out, and everything was rather bland across the board. The interior was decorated nicely for the holidays though. *Hummus Platter: a huge shareable for $10. The crispy naan resembled the Costco version but fried. The naan itself worked well as a base for the hummus, although the hummus was neither smooth nor flavorful. There was no fragrance from the chickpeas, and it tasted rather unseasoned. The selection of peppers, carrots, and cucumbers was decent. *Garlic Butter Mussels: their monthly mussel dish. The mussels were cooked well and coated in a one dimensional sauce. The sweet wine was cooked down with lots of garlic, while the butter was subtle. I wished there had been a bit more toasted baguette to balance the one pound of seafood. Note there is a 3% credit card surcharge. I could not find this listed on their menu and but I saw the charge on my receipt. I enjoyed the few beers I had, and the food was acceptable for a bar. With some improvement to the flavors, this could be a worthwhile visit for a bite and a drink.

    Photos
    Mug club!!
    Mug club!!
    Turkey pesto
    Turkey pesto
    Old Forge Brewing Company

    See all

    Bulls Head Public House

    Bulls Head Public House

    4.2
    (483 reviews)
    37.5 mi
    $$

    Stopped by Bulls Head Public House to check out their brunch menu, and it was a great experience…read more We ordered the Ham & Brie on a pretzel bun with cheddar, Granny Smith apples, and apple butter, along with the Fish & Chips with a beer-battered fillet, lemon, and remoulade. Everything came out exactly as expected, and the flavors worked really well together. The Ham & Brie had a nice balance of sweet and savory, and the Fish & Chips was crispy and cooked well. Also had a mimosa with brunch, which was a nice addition. If you're looking for a brunch spot in Lititz or just a place for good food and drinks, this is definitely worth checking out.

    Outside dining available, over 90 degrees, at the time we visited Around 3 pm . The Inside was cool…read moreand rustic. Order at the bar pick your table in the bar or lounge area, or outside. Limited items but enough to choose from the theme is a British public house. They fully embrace that feeling I got bangers and mash , I now what a Cumberland sausage taste like, pretty good reminded me of a good breakfast sausage. The mash must have been made with turnip and potato as it was slightly sweet, onion gravy was spot on as were the carrots. The spouse went with the quesadilla. she stated the steak was really good. Ice tea for both of us . unexpectedly water was available for any one from a tap near the doors. Plastic cups, no purchase needed. Great idea! We shall return, nice place and good food is hard get any more. $42.30 plus tip we always tip at 20% ( or the spouse gets testy.) but the server / cleaner didn't get the idea it was for her, I actually had to say " this is a tip, for you! "

    Photos
    Dining area
    Dining area
    Ham & Brie
    Ham & Brie
    Proper pint of ESB

    See all

    Proper pint of ESB

    Rumors - newamerican - Updated August 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...