Best kept secret. I've lived in Southampton full time for 12 years. I've passed by this place many…read moretimes because I figured if it's in a Dunkin' Donuts it must be like a supermarket frozen pizza . Was I wrong! The food is excellent. The chicken parm hero is huge on toasted bread. It's not overly cheesy so it doesn't hid the taste of the chicken. Sauce is very tasty. It's now my go to pizza parlor. The pies are cooked perfectly. I don't like a lot of toppings. I get the plain. Again the correct amount of cheese. Not the kind the cheese slides off the slice. Along with great tomato sauce it's a winner. (Also it's easy to hold) . I've eaten a few calzones,as well , & they were equally good. Remember when you were a kid & people would say " you can't judge a book by it's cover"? It's totally apropos in this case PS: don't forget the more than ample parking in the rear PPS: there is a very friendly staff. The long standing pizza shop in SH that I won't name doesn't appreciate the customer. They are surly & when they are busy actually rude. I'd rather spend my money where I'm appreciated

Pizza was fine, nothing to write home about. The person preparing the food was wearing a bandana…read morethat covered his nose but not his mouth when he met me at the register. At the time he was guiding his fellow employee on cutting our pizzas, he had taken this makeshift, non-mask off so he was completely unmasked and hovering both over his colleague and our food unprotected. Very upset that they are putting people at risk without any thought for safety whatsoever. Tell them with your business that you do not support this sort of carelessness and won't return until they enforce strict safety guidelines.

Stopped here for a slice on our way to Sag Harbor to see a show. It's inside a dunkin' donuts so we…read morealmost didn't see it. Plenty of parking in the back. Unfortunately the counter service was pretty unfriendly. Not sure if it's off season or what. The pizza was OK. They advertise "clean bathroom" in big letters on their sign outside but the bathroom wasn't really clean and it had a broken soap dispenser. Wouldn't stop here again.

Great little pizza joint! Had their "peters drunken grandma" slice, pepperoni rolls, and garlic…read moreknots. All was tasty. Service was outstanding, the guy behind the counter was so kind and friendly. Even gave us italian ice samples to try!

La Parmigiana has great food, generous portions, and is consistently good every time. It's a…read morelow-key gem and a great option for larger groups, with both indoor and outdoor seating available. The pizza, mussels, and gnocchi pesto are all excellent and definitely worth ordering.

I love this spot bc it meets every need- a quick slice, a drinky lunch or or a sit down Italian…read moreItalian dinner. If you're low carb or gluten free, they got you and if you're like Alexis Rose "up for anything", they have even more. The pizza is great but so are the pastas and sandwiches. Everything is really delicious. What I love most are the dual entrances so you can get a quick slice at the counter, they sit on the breeze patio or indoor casual bar space if it's raining. The service is super friendly and it's just tops!

Food is always good. Try the 2 for $30 Mon and Thursday…read morespecials. Its not just pizza.

Decent pie, I hear their flan is a definite have. I've only had take out but I've always been…read moregreeted with a smile and good service.

Stay away from Pellegrino's - they have gone downhill. Dinner check: $400 - including charging $2…read morefor bread! Called owner Pam to question the charge; left 3 messages with host - no response. Host confirmed she received messages. The answer is greed and "because I can". My $400 will be appreciated at Cappellette's - which is a far better restaurant!

Had dinner here on Saturday…read more Ambiance is nice and lively and service is friendly. Food is just okay. The pizza was average and the crust undercooked, the pasta was also undercooked and needed seasoning. Prices are really high considering the quantity and quality. I doubt we will return.

Restaurant has changed hands, and as customers of the original Paul's Pizza for 25 years, we…read morewanted to give the new folks a chance... in fact we gave them several chances and now we will NEVET GO BACK! A Pizza and a salad to go cost $44, and both were VERY BAD. I didn't want to go back out, otherwise would have returned the food... we didn't eat it. Not even on par with chain store Pizza. In fact, Dominoes would have been much better. We are sorry that as Southampton residents... we can't even get good pizza in this Village...

"And now for something completely different," as Monty Python puts it. I've always been a fan of…read morePaul's pizza. It's a neighborhood joint for a slice and their Grandma Pie is excellent. And now they feature... TURKISH CUISINE! And it's delish. You know longer have to drop $200 on tacos and a margarita at you-know-where when for a fraction of that you can get the Mixed Grill and feed four people and then some. Lamb and chicken Adana, Gyro, etc. It's all so tasty. Why not do an American style mash up and get some garlic knots as an app while you're at it? Assim is a great guy who's eager to show you something new. I'll be back to try the lunch options. Did someone say, "Falafel"?

GM Andrew Tubin (formerly The Palm), besides being a competent and charming host, has his service…read moreteam(Roberta from Roma), fine tuned to serve chef/owner Agusto's fresh pasta dishes. My linguine w/white tender clam sauce was the best ever!‍ The special pistachio mousse cake was fabulous. Ambiance, food, service, and excellent management by Andrew make this a worthy destination.

The service was great and the place is super good!…read more However, the food was okay. Most of it was good but not great. We got the tiramisu for dessert. The audacity to call this a tiramisu. It was 2 lady fingers with WHIPPED CREAM. $18 for whipped cream and no Marscapone. Also, charging $11 for San pelligrino is wild when you can get it for $4.

Here I am again giving it another chance. Ordered a cheese slice and it was just meh. No sauce just…read morea hint of red food coloring that gives the appearance of sauce topped with cheese. Again, had to add a ton of chili, oregano and garlic.

Food 4/5 Service 5/5…read moreOverall 9/10 I eat here often after work (just before they close) and staff is very agreeable and service is quick.

Favorite restaurant in Southampton and one of the better spots out east overall. It has that…read moreupscale Hamptons feel but still keeps things intimate and comfortable. The Paccheri Rosa was SO GOOD! Rich sauce, perfectly cooked pasta, and tasted like something straight out of a homemade Italian kitchen. My wife got the Rigatoni Strofinati, also excellent and definitely brings the heat with the spice. The Centocolori salad was also fresh and a good lighter option to balance everything out as a starter. Service was smooth, attentive, and exactly what you'd expect from a place at this level. It's also connected to a bakery, which is a dangerous situation if you have any self-control issues. Prices are on the higher side, but the food backs it up for sure and worth every penny. Easily one of my favorite spots in the area so far, and definitely somewhere I'd go back to.

We have dined here every time we visit Southampton and have always looked forward to coming back…read more Unfortunately, this was by far our worst experience. Our server was rude and inattentive and never even told us about the evening's specials. The most disappointing moment was when my husband's salmon was brought to the table upside down--with the grey underside facing up and the beautifully grilled portion pressed against the plate. It was such an unappetizing presentation that he completely lost his appetite and sent it back. For a restaurant we have enjoyed and returned to repeatedly, the entire experience was incredibly disappointing. We expected much better, both in the quality of the service and the care taken in presenting the food.

Didn't know if we would like it as much as World Pie, but better!…read moreDelicious food, attentive service, not too noisy, very good casual restaurant. Delicious pizza, excellent salad, looking forward to trying the pastas.

I am writing this review because we were charged $14 for "flat water" that we did not request. The…read moreserver just asked if we wanted water not giving us the option to request local tap water. We were all shocked to see the charge on our bill. Will never go back!