Had the Pizza and a Chicken Parm Sub and they were both fantastic! Come from Long Island so it was…read morenice to find real Italian pizza upstate New York!

Ok for starters the service is excellent. Our waitress Sidney was great. She didn't stop the…read moreentire time checking on us, asking if things were ok, offering new plates. And cleaning up everywhere else constanly The lasagna was good. A little sweet and maybe missing something minor it good The pizza was good too. Ask for it wee I'm giving 4 starts because of exceptional service and great food.

We stopped at BC Pizza in Deposit, NY today while taking a scenic drive from West Point to Fort…read moreDrum, and we're so glad we did! BC Pizza is a small, adorable restaurant with outdoor seating. It's very clean, beautifully decorated, and has a menu with so many options that it was hard to decide what to order. I was with my daughter and my two grandchildren, and we all ordered personal pan pizzas. My daughter and I also had side salads. The owner, John, greeted us and took such wonderful care of our family. He was incredibly friendly, personable, and amazing with the kids. When he brought out our salads, he surprised the grandchildren with their own little plates of salad and a dollop of ranch dressing so they could enjoy a salad too. It was such a thoughtful gesture. Our pizzas came out very quickly, and John paid attention to every little detail. The adults' pizzas were cut normally, but he cut our two-year-old's pizza into tiny bite-sized squares and sliced our four-year-old's pizza into very thin pieces that were easy for him to eat. They were both so excited! Even more impressive, our four-year-old--who is an extremely picky eater--ate his entire pizza, which almost never happens. Before we left, we decided to pick up dinner for later and ordered Reubens along with a quart of the smoky chicken and fire-roasted vegetable soup. Everything was absolutely incredible! It's rare to find a place with delicious food, outstanding service, and such genuine hospitality. John made us feel like valued guests, and those extra touches made our visit truly memorable. We don't get through Deposit very often, but BC Pizza has definitely earned repeat customers. We'll absolutely be back the next time we're in the area!

This is my second review omg again amazing blt hero there bread is home made . The price is very…read morefair the staff is very nice and friendly

Tasted like Nonna was in the kitchen!…read more We stopped here for dinner on our motorcycling tour in the Catskills. Boy am I glad that we did! The thin-crust pizza was perfect, just crispy enough that the cheese was still loose and stringy. Also got raviolis with a tomato sauce; the sauce is incredible! It came with fresh mozzarella melted on top. You can tell they use fresh, quality ingredients here. Felt like I was back in Italy! 100% recommend & Will certainly be returning next time I'm in the area.

no WI-FI for paying customers. they have it listed just for show. C'mon, give your customers WiFi.read more

UPDATE: Unfortunately the food didn't agree with our stomachs. My husband and I both felt sick…read moreafterwards. Very disappointing. I taught at Roscoe school over 15 years ago and had one Italian kindergartener at that time. I knew his family owned Raimondo's. The kid only spoke Italian and my first thought was, well, this muse be a real Italian restaurant. 15 years later we were on our way back from the wedding upstate with the family and I remembered this restaurant and finally decided to try it. I expected an old fashioned Italian restaurant, but unfortunately it was more than just old fashioned. It needs serious renovation. We are talking musty carpets, old sad furniture, brown flowery curtains. The worst part were the bathrooms - tile was cracking under my feet, rust on radiators, rusty stains on walls. It was bad. My husband said the men's bathroom was renovated- go figure. Now, the food was decent. My family had pasta dishes and I had a panini. My husband who also happens to be Italian said that the tomato sauce "okay" which is what he says when he doesn't like something. I had a beef and barley soup, which was my favorite part of my meal. My daughter liked the taste of her pasta, and my husband enjoyed his Chicken dish. The service was average. There was only one waitress, and she tried, but the service was still somewhat lacking. No bread was brought until we asked. Dirty plates kept piling on the table (she eventually cleaned them up once she saw there is no room for food). The most confusing part was when she brought the check and didn't explain that we are supposed to pay upfront. We wasted time waiting. The prices were decent, no issues there. Overall, this place might be okay for Sullivan county, but if you expect nice Italian dining, this is not it.

Was able to walk in on a Friday evening with a group of 4 with no reservation. The staff were…read morefriendly and attentive to my friend's dietary restrictions. What is super nice is that the prices are very reasonable for the portions, and all pasta dishes include soup/salad and hot Italian bread. The salad tasted pretty fresh, and the homemade Italian vinaigrette was very good. I got the spaghetti with meatballs, mushrooms, and Italian sausage. The sausage was cooked a little too long, and the sauce was okay. I thought it was a little strange that the mushrooms weren't mixed into the sauce. Would come back to try the pizza though!

We always receive great food , prices and service . Daily specials ..Great pizza . Highly recommendread more

This review is not about the food, We were grossed out as we were placing our order. We already got…read moreour coffee. The lady came to take our breakfast order, she was couphing and hacking really bad right over the table, and our coffee. I meen she was pulling up lungers right over us. You can hear it coming up from her lungs to her throat, swallow then repeat. At that point, I cancelled our order and left. As I was paying for the coffee, she asked why were leaving. I told her, and she wasnt 1 bit phased. I guess its her NORMAL

This is the second time they got the pizza wrong ! My wife doesn't eat meat and they put sausage…read moreand pepperoni on it-not even close to peppers, onions and mushrooms. Then they refused to make another, said it was the last one for the night-at 6:00 ??? We're done, T's Hitchin Post from now on.

Randomly found myself in the Hornets Nest on my way to the Catskills. I had my doubts about this…read moredive bar but the friendly service and pizza won me over. The pizza was surprisingly good. It was a pan style pizza and was loaded with cheese and pepperoni. The service was great. Very friendly bartenders/servers that were accommodating and seemed to be running both the kitchen and bar. Place was packed with regulars. Worth a visit!

The curb appeal is lacking. No sign on the door and we walked into an ugly, empty closed box of a…read moreroom. A young woman came out immediately and said "we have no tables bc I'm very backed up. And did you guys know it's cash only?" Turned and started cashing out a customer. A neighbor recommended the food and I hear it's quite good but good gravy, if their service is always so useless I don't know how they'd stay in business. All she needed to say was "I think it could be about an xxx minute wait. And if you need cash, there is a Wayne Bank 2 minutes down the road to the right." Another awful PA dining experience with staff untrained in any sort of hospitality.

This place is good for a nice pizza nothing special but nothing bad. Just they burnt the crust once…read moreand also there was so much crust. Just a normal pizza place

Omg What happened to this place? It used to be so good…read more. We just went there for slices and they are using pre-made pizza crust kind of like Dominos.... yuk!

Going here is always a tradition when my family heads to the Catskills for our annual vacation. We…read morealways take advantage of the specials and we are never disappointed. You can't beat the prices compared to the pizza place down the street- so if you are looking to feed a crowd- this is the place.

Chicken Caesar wrap and a ham and cheese on a roll. It was decent for being in the middle of…read morenowhere, boarshead deli meats in the case. Fries were hot and had a great seasoning on them. Little pricy at almost 30$ but it hit the spot. The establishment could use some sprucing up. Also have to mention a huge black fly was hanging out where they were preparing the grub, hard not to notice.

Deliciousness! While looking for another ice cream place that ended up being closed, yelp has to…read morelearn to update things like that after covid! Or I guess I should say people on yelp who live in the area. Anyway suddenly we saw huge sign saying ice cream and we went in. Looking this up on yelp you might not realize it's an ice cream place too but I made sure to let it be known now lol. One of the best in the area and this was by total accident we stumbled upon this place.