Fresh out of the over taste! The pizza and wings I ordered were nice and hot. The service was perfect. I tried using an online coupon but it wasn't working correctly. The cashier was very helpful and applied it to my order at the store with no issues. The store ambiance was very friendly and welcoming! read more

Romeo's Pizza - Small Buffalo Chicken Pizza and 10pc Chicken Wings - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

I ordered two hours before pickup. Pizza was sitting in cooler and employee just forgot obviously to cook it, I had to wait 15 for it to cook. Never once did the employee apologize, I sat next to a man waiting who had the exact same experience. I get that mistakes happen but an apology is always nice to get. When I got home everyone laughed at how horrible the pizzas were cut. The sizes were horrible. On all three pizzas. Very very unprofessional place. This was my first time in and I sure didn't get a good impression. One of the pizzas was all wet in the center. Very disappointed. read more

Romeo's comes thru every time. I know it's a chain but I don't care. They have always made masterpieces for us. We love the sweet sauce and they don't skimp on the toppings. Btw the customer service is always on point. read more

Romeo's Pizza - Large sausage, mushrooms, red onions, half pep with extra cheese and sauce. - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

This Romeo's is close by, fast, and reliable. We appreciate the range of crusts you can get and their different dipping sauce options. They usually have decent deals, too. It is a solid meal choice if you are good with sweet pizza sauce. read more

First time try so I kept it simple. Small pizza with pep, mushroom and sausage. Crust wasn't too bad, I little thin for me but ample around the edges. Plenty of toppings and decent amount of cheese - another plus. Sauce though was rather sweet - did not like their sauce. And whatever that Capone sauce was on the side....forget it. read more

Romeo's Pizza - Pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms on a 10-inch pizza - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

Not a good pizza or experience. To be honest. I've had a good pizza from here, but this time it was not good. I ordered a old world pepperoni pizza with mushrooms and black olives. - The pizza arrived cold!! - The topping we uneven, skimpy and scattered. You can see in the photo that I attached that the black olives are mostly on a couple of slices of pizza while the rest of pizza has hardly any. This is just plain LAZY! When you add toppings you want to make sure they are fairly represented. Come on! Things just went down hill from there. read more

Romeo's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

See all

Had a large order placed for work for 22 people at the Grandview location. Order was ready when we arrived and the woman helping us was great, very friendly. The pizza was delicious as always! love the sweet sauce. Great service and great food, everyone was happy! Thank you Romeo's. read more

Romeo's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

First-time customer of Romeo's, which I ordered for delivery. I have been craving this style of pizza lately! I know a lot of pizza snobs will claim that this isn't even pizza anymore, but I disagree. It has all the components of pizza and then some. I went with spinach, meatballs, and caramelized onions for my 'toppings', even though they aren't on top. The crust was a little crispy, but I did heat it up again so that could have been the reason. The toppings were good, though there could have been a little more spinach. The one thing that we didn't like was the sauce-- it's definitely a little too sweet for my taste for sure. It was also served with a side of sauce labeled capone sauce, which wasn't my favorite. It's almost like a spicy ranch or something, but it almost made the pizza sauce taste even sweeter when paired. Overall the pizza was pretty good and the leftovers did get eaten, but I would love to see a change in the pizza sauce recipe. read more

Romeo's Pizza - Italiano deep dish with caramelized onions, meatballs, and spinach - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

I've had Romeo's Pizza before but it's been about three years and that was at a different location. However, over the holidays I found myself craving a Chicago style deep dish pizza and after a little digging around, I discovered they had one and I decided to give it a try. I ordered for delivery and got a small pizza with banana peppers. I was shocked at how quickly it arrived, especially knowing that these take a little longer to cook. The delivery driver thought it was ok to travel with a pizza vertically so when it arrived, it didn't look very nice. The entire pizza was smashed with sauce on the top of the box and the pizza was all squished to one side. Very annoying but that was the Doordashers fault, not theirs. The sauce here is sweet so some crushed red pepper flakes were must. Other than that it was pretty good. I wish the crust was more caramelized but for being an Ohio pizza place, it'll do. read more

After switching to their new app they changed the delivery radius. Now will no longer deliver to my house despite it being only 2.5 miles away read more

Good food but slow service. I called after 50 minutes to check on my order that hadn't been delivered and the girl said it hadn't even left the store yet! read more

Pizza was delicious. Plenty of rich sauce and toppings. Nice and thick. Came with Capone sauce, personally not a fan. Too tangy for me. Only a few complaints, pizza was delivered and was cold. Also description said 10 slices and it was only 8. read more

Romeo's Pizza - Pepperoni and banana pepper deep dish - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

Had Romeo's for the first time yesterday for a work lunch party. Tried the thick and thin crust and really liked both. All the pies were consistent and the sauce has a nice sweet flavor without that acidic taste you can sometimes get at a fast food pie chain. The spinach and feta with caramelized onion was my favorite. Will defiantly go here again. Thank you! read more

I want to love Romeo's pizza. I keep trying, I really do...but I just don't. Tried it again last night. Salad, pepperoni pizza, medium wings, and cinnamon bread. The cinnamon bread was the winner out of the bunch. Everything else is super average. The Capone sauce is OK...sort of like Frank's and garlic sauce. The garlic sauce isn't nearly as good as Papa John's...tasted of straight up oil. Next time, I will go with someone else. Sorry, Romeo's. Ya basic. On the plus side, my delivery driver was so sweet! She admitted to dropping my salad (while still in the bag and the lid stayed on.) No biggie. read more

Food was fresh and hot . Tasted great and was on time. Ariana Reed was nice food was even better knowing a good person like her was apart of it read more

If I'm honest I had never had Romeo's Pizza let alone heard of it. Then recently Cam Atkinson teamed up with Romeo's Pizza and ever since it has been on my radar. Yesterday we decided to try it out for the first time for lunch. We placed our order online. My fiance went with the Original Meat Stromboli and I ordered a small cauliflower pizza with (reg pizza) cheese, olives, red onions, and mushrooms. After clicking purchase our order was quoted as being ready for pick up in 15 mins, so super quick. We hopped in the truck and headed to Grandview to pick it up. There was one visible employee in the pizza kitchen when we arrived. She already had our orders boxed up and waiting. So the transaction to no time. The entire process was incredibly quick. We hopped back in the truck and headed home to eat our hot lunch. The aromas filling the cab of the truck were mouthwatering. I could not wait to get home. When we walked in the door we settled in to eat our perspective lunches. I noticed that my box had a sticker on it that said Attention, Romeo's pizza gluten free crust is prepared in our kitchen where gluten is present. It has an additional statement but it is not important for this review. The point I'm trying to make is, this is the first time I am EVER having Romeo's pizza, so I am uncertain if they put that sticker also on their cauliflower crust pizzas or if the pizza I got was actually a gluten free crust as oppose to the cauliflower crust that I had ordered. I do not know to this moment. What I do know is that my pizza was absolutely amazing!!! I truly loved it!!! Way more than I expected. I just really wish I knew which crust my pizza was on. I wanted to try the cauliflower pizza crust, and I am not convinced that I did. I also want to note that so many pizza places do not offer red onion, and I was beyond thrilled to be able to get red onion pizza on my Romeo's pizza. It truly MADE the pizza for me. I am hoping to order again in the future from Romeo's and I am certain I will get to the bottom of this pizza crust debate. read more

See all

My buddy and I ordered carry out last night for my first time with Romeo's. He orders it every weekend and I just had to try it. After reading some reviews with delivery issues, we decided to carry it out. We placed the order and it was done in about 20 mins - hot, fresh, and beautiful. I've gotta say, he wasn't wrong - it was really delicious! I knew to anticipate a sweet sauce and it was but I didn't think it was overpoweringly sweet like some reviews said. I also loved dipping it in the Capone sauce (also tasty and a bit sweet). I wish I had crushed red pepper flakes around - I think that would've leveled it up a bit. Definitely look forward to ordering from here in the future! read more

Romeo's Pizza - Pep and cheese with a good amount of both toppings - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

Great pizza good service friendly staff You must try the Capone sauce with your pizza. The ambience was cool

I have ordered from here many times and have always been pleased with my order. I usually pick it up but this time I had it delivered. It took about 45 minutes and when I received my order, it was incorrect. I ordered a large stuffed crust Tuscan pepperoni with cheddar cheese and received a burnt traditional pepperoni pizza. I tried calling back but was put on hold for a good amount of time and no one picked up. I understand it was a Friday night but still was upset with everything. read more

This sauce is just so overwhelming in not a good way. It's like they poured vats of sugar into their pizza sauce mix. I couldn't taste the cheese or the pepperoni that was on it, just overwhelmed by this non-diabetic friendly sauce. Garlic bread is hard to screw up, but not much flavor to it. I mean garlic butter on toasted bread is hard to screw up and they didn't, but could have been a lot better. Was hoping for more since it was so close. read more

This pizza is pretty good! I've tried it twice, I thought I loved it but for some reason I just don't love it. It could be because the sauce is sweeter than I prefer, I just easily tired of it. I tried the buffalo chicken pizza and added onions and was pretty impressed! I also had Dante's Peak add black olives. I ended up liking the buffalo chicken better than the Dante's Peak. I felt like the sausages were big and spicy and had an overwhelming flavor, which is appealing to some people. More for you as for next time, I'll do without those. Plenty of toppings! If you love toppings and sweet sauce then this is for you. I just can't handle that sweet red sauce after the first piece, especially mixed with the spicy sausage pieces... I honestly don't think I'll get this again. I liked it a lot, but didn't love it like I hoped. The people were nice enough, if not a bit lazy-looking. One girl was biting her nails, but she wasn't the one making food (at least that I saw). The guy working there that looked like the manager seemed eager to please and was very, very kind. If I ordered from here again I'd probably go with a "less-is-more" tactic that I enjoyed a bit more on my first visit where I had a decent pepperoni and black olive pizza. Don't knock the buffalo chicken, I would recommend trying it! I have a feeling that this is a place that, while I don't care for it so much, deserves some recognition that a lot of people will probably really enjoy it! I've tried LaRosa's and love their sauce way more. Not sure what the difference is, I'm just not a big fan of Romeo's sauce. read more

Romeo's Pizza - This is a large buffalo chicken pizza with added red onions - yum! I ate a piece before taking the photo, obviously. - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

Always great pizza from here. Can tell they take pride in what they make. It never looks or tastes sloppy. Trying the gluten free tonight for first time. Hoping we like it! Def love their regular pie! read more

Romeo's Pizza - Gluten free pizza. I was pleasantly surprised at how good it was! - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

Amazing sauce! I love the deep dish pizza. Quick delivery to the short north area. They seem to make great pizza consistently as I've ordered a few times now (usually wait to review after a few times). 10/10 ! read more

If you want pizza from a sub-par chain then look no further. The meatball sub I received from here was beyond terrible, and there was really only two things they needed to do: 1. Don't burn the balls 2. Add SOME cheese Otherwise this would have been an "acceptable" sandwich, but turned out to be a a couple of charcol nuggets with an apathetic ladle of sauce on stale bread. Don't make the same mistake as I did. There's a handful of better pizza in the area, and this is a far cry from Rotolo's or even Pizza Hut. #yikes read more

This was just delivered to us. No sauce as ordered. No spinach as ordered. Dry and falling apart. Going in the trash. Appalling that they would let this be delivered to a customer. They just lost us. read more

Romeo's Pizza - Romeo's Pizza on 5th in Grandview just delivered this Veggie Stromboli - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

Loved it! We got the Buffalo chicken pizza, replaced the regular cheese with the **reaper** cheese, and a swirl of Buffalo on top. It's absolutely delicious, really nice spice. Next time I would get both the regular cheese and the habanero, but that was just user error on my part! The ranch sauce on the pizza is really good, I'm not a huge ranch fan and it's not overwhelming but very tasty, so I'm thrilled. The Capone sauce is really interesting, I don't even know how to describe it, it's both sweet and zesty, definitely worth trying. The delivery was on time and they offer contactless. Really excited to add it to our pizza rotation! read more

I got the boneless wings, and they were dry and a complete rip off. Instead of saucing the wings, they put it on the side. I got the garlic Parmesan and it was just a cup of butter on the side. Never again! read more

Romeo's on 5th in Grandview caught my eye coming out of Fortin across the street. Saturday late afternoon and no food plans, I took a shot. Not a dine-in place, Romeo's is delivery and pick-up. Orders were light on for 4pm on Saturday (I thought). Calm before the storm or poor product/service? I was greeted well and shown a menu. My order was a personal size pizza with extra thin crust which, I was told, their crusts are homemade - no frozen crust. I chose the Veggie. Told it would take 10 minutes. I waited in my car and at 9 minutes returned; told it was coming out fresh and they were true to their word. Crust is sweet to taste, like nothing I'd tasted and at the end I loved it. The veggies were sensational. All fresh as could be. Chunky tomatoes and mushrooms. Good black olives and peppers. It really worked well even though being so fresh did not make them pizza hot. But I'm a fresh veggie guy so cool was fine. Here's why not 5. If this pizza was delivered my guess is it would hold up well. The veggies would be shaken off the top and the thin crust squares would break apart - quite sure of it. I'm going to try one of their thicker crusts and a meat lover style. Pick-up at Romeo's, I'm betting, is the way to go. read more

Received a smashed up pizza. Called. Was told that they could not send out a new pizza and they would credit our account 19 dollars. Please keep it, and delete our account. The mashed up cheese and dough didn't even taste very good. Complete slop. read more

Romeo's Pizza - Just got this pizza. Called. Was told that I would be credited 19 dollars. Couldnt just get a new pizza. Leaving this outside for raccoons - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

Easily top two pizza places in Grandview. It's a tough choice between here and Halwani, as neither has never let us down. I highly suggest Romeo's next time you're looking for solid pizza in the area. read more

So annoyed I have ordered here multiple times I will never again the driver handed me a crushed box after he made me meet him at the street he would not bring it to my apartment read more

Romeo's Pizza - Smashed pizza - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

Romeos makes the best chain pizza I have ever had, and although one will never confuse it with an artisanal pizza, there are not many artisanal pizzas I'd rather have than a Italiano deep dish from Romeos. The sauce is outstanding, and of the many toppings they offer, the italian sausage is the best. I love that their sandwiches come on Amoroso rolls They have an excellent loyalty program that doesn't require you to carry any cards - every 100 spent (with no expiration) earns you a 10 dollar gift cert read more

I just wanted to add we recently tried the margarita and it is great! The pesto swirl is attractive and tasty. If you're thinking about trying this one go for it. read more

Their pizzas are almost picture perfect manager/man at the register is always friendly and explains everything Like he was describing a five-star restaurant menu delivery drivers always on time the pizza is always hot and fresh garlic butter that you must request in order to get is way better than Papa John's read more

First time ordering Romeos and it did not disappoint. Ordered the boneless wings as well and the only negative is you have to add the sauce on yourself which I found odd but still great flavor. We decided on a pepperoni stuffed crust pizza and it was so great. It also was delivered in 20 min which was shockong so we were expecting something to be wrong but everything was great! Will definitely order again! read more

This is the best pizza I've found since moving to Columbus. I always special-order my pizzas with BBQ sauce, grilled chicken, and bacon, light on the cheese. Romeo's nailed my order to a T. Will order again, will recommend to friends. Great job, guys! read more

I can't remember the last time I tasted a pizza and thought to myself "I never want to eat that again." Well, I never want to eat Romeo's Pizza again. Our experience didn't get off to a good start. The boy called to make the order & the person answering the phone had no clue what to do. He said it was the first order he'd ever taken. Needless to say, we checked our pizzas before we left the parking lot to make sure they were correct (and they were). As soon as I got into the car with the pizzas the boy remarked how sweet they smelled, was I sure we didn't get some kind of dessert pizza. I must state that my pizza looked disgusting. I ordered cheese with ground beef. I have ordered it before at many pizza places - Grandad's, Panzera's, Papa Johns, Larosas (Cincinnati), etc. Never have I seen a ground beef pizza like this. My "ground beef" looked like rabbit pellets. Yes, it looked like a rabbit relieved himself on my pizza. Obviously after seeing my pizza, I was incredibly hungry (or not). I decided to eat it though and ignore the pellets. My first bite wasn't quite as bad as my first look, but it still wasn't good. The sweet aroma coming from the pizzas was the ultra-sugary sauce. Now I've had some sugary tasting sauces before (Larosa's), but this was too much and just downright bad. The boy wasn't too pleased with his supreme pizza, but none of his toppings looked like pellets. I'd never had Romeo's before this and definitely never will again. There are too many good pizza places in Grandview to give Romeo's your hard-earned money. Stay away! read more

Love the delivery guy who delivered my food. He was funny and sweet and you could tell he genuinely loves his job. He gave me tons of coupons and these scratch off tickets that revealed that I won two free pizzas! How awesome is that? I ordered the garlic bread with cheese and the New York white pizza. I was born and grew up in New York so when it comes to pizza, I'm pretty picky. The garlic bread with cheese is so good. It was cheap and they give you quite a lot. The New York white pizza was also delicious. I dipped it in the sauce they gave with the garlic bread and oh my god. I've never tasted sauce like this before from a pizza place. It's definitely sweet but since I have the biggest sweet tooth, I actually loved it. It's awesome with the savory pizza. It's something different and it's something that works. The dough they use for the pizza is awesome as well as these cheeses they used for this particular pizza. White pizza is my favorite kind of pizza and this was definitely a top contender. I took a star off just because I ordered the small pizza which obviously was pretty small like a personal size and it was over 10 bucks which I think is a little pricey for such a small pizza. Still, everything tasted great so I will definitely be ordering from here again! read more

I'm still kinda on the fence when it comes to Romeo's. I don't mind the sweet marinara sauce - it's very similar to La Rosa's down in Cincinnati and I like that. I guess I'm just not sold on the overall package. Something about it demands it needs to be eaten several more times before I make my final decision though. read more

I've never ordered from you guys, but one of my neighbors did on Sunday, and on his way out of the parking lot your delivery driver chucked an empty cigarette box out his window. It didn't seem to be an "accident" where it might have fallen out as he was getting back in his car. The window went down, cigarette box popped out, window went back up and the car kept on going. Who the hell does that? read more