Not sure how you mess up pizza but it was aweful!! Save yourself & go across the street.read more

Pine bush has its fair share of pizza restaurants. However, Pudgys also has a menu serving…read moreeveryone's taste buds-a little something for everyone. I do have to say my favorite thing about this place is, Consistency!!! Chicken bacon ranch slices-salads-tostadas-and the wiiiiings(so many flavors) I think I know what I'm ordering tonight.

Decent pizza at a good price. Service was fast and efficient -- great if you're looking for a quick…read moreand affordable meal.

Food/Drink: Pizza by the slice! Pretty good New York style pizza. Large amount of options and…read morecombos. Full Italian style menu, appetizers, entrees, pizza, soups, salads, and desserts! Pizza: Nice brick oven style and Sicilian. Dinning Area: Pretty large, open, area. Benches, large counter. Plenty of seating! Prices: Relatively cheap. 2 slice and fountain special for $12! Parking: Plenty of space, side lot. Bathrooms: Bathrooms were small and clean. Atmosphere: During the weekday lunch rush, It was crazy. Staff/Attendants: Staff overall was decent, and unsociable. Been a few times and will return.

Let's begin shall we?…read more April 17th I ordered a cranberry walnut salad and seltzer with delivery off the slice app. Salad arrives with no salad dressing or cranberries. I call and they say they can't do anything and if I can drive in to pick up the dressing and cranberries. So I say to myself ok "small business" it's a mistake don't worry I'll give them another shot. I was wrong. April 19th today I ordered a pasta dish. 2 seltzers, rice ball & a cranberry walnut salad. Again the salad has no dressing, the seltzers are missing and no rice ball. I call again now a-little more angry than last time. Request a refund. They tell me they can't do anything. To call the app and ask for a refund. I call the app to request a refund for the salad that has no dressing for a second time. And they only refund me for the missing dressing? Where they said they will give me a refund for the salad. Who eats salad without dressing? I do not recommend this place. I only recommend if you like eating dry salad without dressing.

What a disgrace. Ordered a plain cheese pie, a jamaican beef patty and 2 cannoli's. Paid to have…read moreit delivered. The food arrived and was left on the front porch. The pizza was ice cold, it's 30 degrees outside and you just leave the pizza on the porch!?! Moving on to the beef patty, we all know these are pre-made, frozen, and pre-packaged, but this was definately old, freezer burned, and rock hard. Even my dog wouldn't eat it. Lastly, I should have known not to order the cannoli. It you can't reheat pre-packaged food, how would you know how to make an Italian dessert. Lesson Learned!

Food/Drink: Pizza by the slice! Pretty good New York style pizza. Large amount of options and…read morecombos. Full Italian style menu, appetizers, entrees, pizza, soups, salads, and desserts! Pizza: Needed more crunch and little doughy. Dinning Area: Pretty large, open, area. Benches, large counter, double closed off entry way so mo breeze. Plenty of seating! Prices: Relatively cheap. 2 slice and fountain special for $12.95! Parking: Plenty of space, side lot. Bathrooms: Bathrooms were clean and regular size. Atmosphere: During the weekday lunch rush, It was empty. Staff/Attendants: Staff overall was great, and sociable. Been a few times and will return.

Grabbed a menu and was not rushed to make decision and the counter person was pretty friendly. My…read moreorder did seem to take bit longer then I would thought. The pizza slice was great, plenty of pepperoni coverage and sauce and cheese melted well, plus the crust was not burnt, but I will say the slice itself was pretty greasy. Now the panini the bread was well pressed and toasted, plus plenty of cheese, chicken and thousands island dressing, but fries on side, were a salt bomb, I mean they seasoned alright, but way too much salt on them, I had throw them out. Otherwise I mean great beside that. Now the Nutella knots, I loved those, knots cut in half and spooned on Nutella on them like little chocolate dough sliders with powdered sugar on top.

We got a small margherita pizza and a momo burger with fries. Very pleased with both! Tasted great…read moreand nice sized portions. Reasonable prices. Close to where we are staying so very happy about that.

Pretty friendly here to locals and visitors I noticed here, always a plus. So I ordered a slice and…read moretwo sandwiches to go and I very specific on what wanted omitted and they made both exactly like I wanted and my order was done in almost no time. Both the soprano and the Sinatra has generous portions of the meats, and the fixings, plus for both being basically Italian combo sandwiches in there own right both were amazing. The marghertita slice I would say was bit lacking, I mean definitely could used more fresh mozzarella and the tomato diced more and spread though out slice, plus the pizza crust was bit meh. Should tried the other slices on display here.

A little gem for sure!! I mean what can go wrong when they serve Mexican food and Italian food…read more The staff was nice and gave us free chips and dip which were freshly made. Its a small place they have 3 tables inside and also some outside seating.

Don't expect your food to be delivered if ordering at 7:30 or later…read more Alittle annoyed that when I call at 9pm that the business is closed and my food never arrived and it's now 10pm You take my money ahead of time I pay for a service and you don't fulfill my order. Shame on you. I will gladly share this with everyone. You should had the decency to call me and let me know that you were unable to fulfill my order and gave me the opportunity to order elsewhere or to pick the order up myself. I wish I could rate you zero stars because you deserve to be removed from the Grubhub DoorDash and slice app. Poor excuse of business ownership.

Pineapple pizza is on my point, chicken bacon ranch is good. Phillies are decent, just an all…read morearound decent place for Wurtsboro

I mean I had it a few times not my fave. But I rather show my support to them than stellas across…read more209. The woman is nice, the man should not be dealing with the Public. I miss Andre being there.

Little on the pricey side, but they have good food and good people and plenty of seating room if…read moreyou wanted. Makes a makes a good pizza.

First off, pretty much a perfect slice, although smaller than most, priced at $2.50…read more Tonight, I was perusing their current takeout menu, comparing their Shrimp Parm hero price to Mountainview. The menu claimed $11.50. I also ordered 3 slices, 1 with sausage( menu claimed $2.75). $19.50, became $22.50( why bother printing paper menus if you can't honor or pen-in changes)? There were 3 tissue-thin sausage slices. The shrimp were large(4), but not properly fried to create a sufficient crust to handle sauce...it was wet mush and the hero roll was meh, not fresh for a Friday night. At 5:45, only the owner's friends were there, empty dining room...meanwhile, I picked something up at Mountainview-packed ! Will stick to the occasional slice(s), as that was not a $14 hero value.

Called in my order when I arrived it was done on time exactly the way I wanted it great placeread more

They made crust reheating like a rock!! Waste of money when they can't keep correct time to reheat!…read more Meatballs were good & lite type cheesecake ok.

I called in a take out order of Bacon Cheese Burger Deluxe w/ Fries and a Crispy Chicken Cesar…read moreWrap. And picked up a slice of meat lovers Chicago style and a slice of MVP (Marinara, Vodka Sauce, Pesto). The called in order was done when they said it would be. It's a small place with a couple of tables but could get crowded quick. The Bacon Cheese Burger Deluxe was seasoned well, had lettuce tomato and onion on a sesame seed bun. The bun was fresh and soft. Next time I'll ask for condiments on the burger. The Cesar Wrap was good, lots of Cesar dressing. The Fries are good. The Meat lovers Chicago slice was delicious. If you're into a deep dish style pizza this is a good one. The MVP was interesting, my first time having one. Love the Pesto, the Marinara was a bit sweet and the vodka sauce was good. I'll be back to sample more slices.

Wanted to love it, had great garlic knots, but food can be inconsistent. Has interesting flavor…read moreideas for pizzas, but when we ordered them, we wish we hadn't. Spinach artichoke Alfredo pizza was greasy. Crust is sometimes down right hard.