Freshly made. Somewhat disappointed that the chicken salad disappeared from the menu. I'll miss it. read more

All right folks if you've not been to Rick's Freshmade, you gotta hit this place up. Their banana pudding was off the charts delicious. The grilled ham and cheese was hot and a good size portion for a big guy like me. Customer service was on point. Can't wait to hit these guys up again. read more

Rick’s Freshmade - Banana pudding - Sandwiches Near Me - Pickerington, Ohio

See all

Best darn Ruben's around! Always made fresh, very consistent on the quality. Would definitely recommend read more

Rick’s Freshmade - Reuben - Sandwiches Near Me - Pickerington, Ohio

See all

This place never disappoints! The staff is super nice and accommodating. Today's special was coney dogs. Who doesn't live a good coney dog?! As usual it looked amazing and it tasted the same, simply amazing. I'm so glad I found this place. I can see myself eating lunch here daily. Stop in, ask what the special is. It's always something read more

Rick’s Freshmade - Coney dogs - Sandwiches Near Me - Pickerington, Ohio

Stopped in on a day off during the week to get lunch to go! Upon entering we were the only ones in the restaurant and everyone was incredibly nice, patient, and helpful. we waited for the sandwiches to be made, and it was a pleasant atmosphere with good music and seemingly clean. The sandwiches were ready in no time and off we went to enjoy. They did have a bar inside you could eat at, as well as a little patio with tables on it. The sandwiches were delicious! We got the Italian, which was grilled and SO GOOD. My favorite of the two. The onions were perfectly thinly sliced and the sauce and herbs on it were just delectable. An amazing fresh deli sammie. The other we tried was the ultimate fresh made, which was PACKED. It was also delicious but just less my style. The honey mustard sauce really made the sammie stand out and was a great compliment to the meet and veggies. Definitely a great experience all around, and would recommend if you're in the area looking for a quick, fresh, delicious sammie and friendly staff to greet you behind the counter. read more

Rick’s Freshmade - The Ultimate Freshmade - Sandwiches Near Me - Pickerington, Ohio

See all

Your Itallion Subs tasted GREAT! Thanks Rick! I will definatly be back sometime soon. One of the Best Sub shops around.

Just met the owner, Rick. Incredibly nice guy who seems to have his food priorities right! Wound up going for the grilled ham and cheese and it was magnificent. I was heavily in need for comfort food today and this could not have better hit the spot. The sandich was made by a female employee there whom was also incredibly friendly and helpful. She certainly nailed the food. This place is a gem amidst an over-bloated local corporate sandwich scene. Prices are comprable to anywhere else (besides subway), but the quality is lightyears ahead. Definitely try them! Once you take your last bite, I know you'll agree. Thanks Rick and team for the great experience! read more

Rick’s Freshmade - Grilled Ham & Cheese Sandwich - Sandwiches Near Me - Pickerington, Ohio

See all

Just ate at Rick's Freshmade for the first time and it was great. Everything was very fresh and delicious.. The staff was super friendly and the music was even good. I would recommend this place for anyone wanting a great sandwich. read more

Just passing through. Cool spot. Excellent sandwich. I wish I could stay and try their other sandwiches. Two thumbs up Rick. read more

Rick’s Freshmade - Reuben on Rye - Sandwiches Near Me - Pickerington, Ohio

Awesome!!! The chicken salad sandwich was delicious and highly recommended. Will. E going back again!!!

Stopped here for a quick lunch. The guy working was very friendly and super helpful. I ordered the hot Italian sub. It was very good with lots of meat! The onions, tomato, and lettuce added a nice fresh crisp. My bun tasted a little sweet, so I would prob try a different bun next time. The pasta salad was delicious as well. There was multiple veggies- cucumber, olives, carrots that added a nice crunch. Will definitely be going back! read more

Rick’s Freshmade - Italian sub - Sandwiches Near Me - Pickerington, Ohio

See all

Attentive service, delicious sandwiches. Different choices of bread. Made very quick, seats inside and out.

Good solid food! Pricing moderate and choice is plentiful. Very clean very efficient.

We arrived before the lunch rush. The owner was very nice and helpful. All of the sandwiches our group ordered were fantastic. I got a melt that was probably one of the best I have ever had. The place is small and seating is limited, so prepare to use the counter if you eat in. I will definitely be coming back when I am in the area. read more

Very small mom and pop place with just a few stools at the front window to sit inside. They had an outdoor seating place also. I had the chicken salad sandwich with was excellent and my friend had the blt and said it was good as well. I will definitely go back if I'm ever in the area again read more

Our first visit to this new sandwich shop and catering business. I ordered the Italian beef sub with jack cheese ($10) and it was super tasty. They forgot the cheese but the dip made up for it - very flavorful but for the price point I would have expected a bit more beef since you only got the sandwich for $10. The Mrs got the chicken salad sandwich and that was super tasty as well and the bread was nicely toasted. The sandwich special was $10 and you got a drink and small side of pasta salad. Also pretty pricy for the size of the sandwich and location of the shop. Based off the flavors we will most likely be coming back to go down their list of sandwiches for sure! read more

See all

Awesome sandwiches and friendly staff. We walked in right before they were supposed to close (normally we wouldn't do that) but we've been wanting to try it. The girls were friendly and didn't appear to be frustrated with last minute customers. BOMB rice crispy treats with fruity pebbles. We will be back! read more

I loved the Italian sub sandwich... you can tell they use great quality ingredients and have nice thick, soft bread. My favorite part was when you grab the sub and see all the beautiful, flavorful layers. Great portion size, good price, and nice textures and flavors for a classic Italian sub. read more

Rick’s Freshmade - Italian sub - Sandwiches Near Me - Pickerington, Ohio

Wanted something different for lunch and had never been to this establishment. First off, I'm impressed! Walked in and Wes immediately greeted by I assume Rick himself. I ordered the Italian Beef and a side of pasta salad. My sandwich was made fresh right before my eyes. I'm about 5 minutes it was ready. I had read other reviews about the lack of meat on the Italian beef, Rick must have read the feedback because this thing was a monster! Loads of beef and pepperoncini's! This was more than I could eat in one sitting, so I halved it and saved the remainder for lunch tomorrow. Upon the first bite, I could tell that Rick took his sandwiches seriously! Soft fresh bun and the warm shaved beef layered in with the peppers made for a great taste. Additionally this sandwich comes with a side of hot Italian Aujus. The pasta salad was great, just the right about of tang in the sauce, peppers and black olives. This is what Pickerington needed! Give it a try! read more

Rick’s Freshmade - Pasta salad, meatballs, salads, banana bread - Sandwiches Near Me - Pickerington, Ohio

See all

If you're tired of going to restaurants that provide crummy customer service, do yourself a favor and try Rick's Freshmade. My husband and I walked in as first time customers and were super impressed by the young lady at the front counter. The food was decent. I ordered a meatball sub and a side of pasta salad. My only complaint was that the bread wasn't toasted, so it was soggy; I had to eat the sub using a fork & knife. The pasta salad included carrots, celery, olives, and green peppers. It was also okay. We'll definitely return to try something else and to support a small business. read more

Rick’s Freshmade - Sandwiches Near Me - Pickerington, Ohio

I was going to stop at the sub shop across the street but saw Rick's Freshmade. I've seen them advertised on Facebook. Being new to the area I enjoy trying small businesses. The Italian sub was really tasty. It had enough of each ingredient to balance all the flavors. I ordered a meatball sub to go and asked if they could make it to where I could have it later for dinner without it getting soggy. They put the sauce on the side. It was perfect for dinner a few hours later! read more

Great local place where you can take home a sandwich and a steak or salmon to make at home. The deli side has 13 different subs/sandwiches (see menu taken 1/18/21), and some soup options. Rick's also sells meat and fish you can buy as if you were at a grocery store to take home and cook later. read more

Rick’s Freshmade - Menu with prices - Sandwiches Near Me - Pickerington, Ohio

See all

This place has great food. Please stop in for a sandwich. the people were helpful with menu choices. I was pleasantly surprised with the size of the sandwich. read more

This first visit was, well, kinda awkward. The young girl behind the counter was very pleasant, greeted me right when I entered, was attentive. The older gentleman - not Rick (I asked), his response seemed a bit curt, like he was ready for the day to end. I did ask a few questions, but I felt kinda odd in the moment. This place is not a "deli" in the sense they don't sell their meats every day by the lbs, but they sell whatever they cut that morning to coincide with there sandwiches. I'm assuming they always cut meat for the sandwiches that are always on their menu: Italian - salamis, ham, etc; roast beef for their Reuben and French Dip; ham for their cold/hot/grilled sammies; turkey for their club. The gentleman also said they didn't have any specials today, it being Easter weekend, but the specials are normally posted daily on their Facebook page. I did see prepared garden salads, shrimp salads and a Salmon salad in the casing, along with proportioned smoked pork and brisket that they do on-site. I sampled their chicken salad sandwich spread with dried cranberries and celery. The sweet taste reminded me of Marzetti's slaw dressing with a similar sweet flavor profile. Rick's is homemade, so I'm not sure what all's involved, but that's my best comparison. It was good, and with a little salty/savory from maybe some bacon and tomato squished between a sandwich thin, mmmmmm. I've only heard great things about Rick, and obviously he's probably been working his tail off to keep Freshmade rolling (he opened this sandwich shot not too long before the pandemic hit), so kudos to his success. I hope to give Freshmade another try, this time to sit down and really enjoy the atmosphere and eatable offerings. read more

See all

Excellent options and friendly owner. Wife and I greatly enjoyed our food experience and anticipate additional visits and exploration of catering services. read more

I just had the best reuben sandwiches ever for pickup!! Omg I'm so glad I blindly ordered two because I haven't even gotten home and the first one gone Highly recommended!! read more

Stopped in for a quick bite but didn't want a huge sandwhich as I just wanted a snack. I got the Grilled cheese and is satisfied my cravings and tasted amazing. Great to see the owner making the sandwhich right in front of you. Fantastic lunch spot to hit ! read more

I have only been here 50 or 60 times. My wife loves the Ruben I started with the Italian beef but the last 15 or so times I get the BLT. Best BLT ever. Have ordered it on a couple occasions twice in the same week. Everyone that works there has been super friendly and helpful read more

Hidden gem in Pickerington. Best sub in town. Meatball taste just like homemade, pot roast sandwich was the special of the day, excellent. Very kind and efficient service. Highly recommend. read more

Friendly service and tasty food. Loved the bread of the BLT and the tomatoes were fresh

Rick did it again. Ordered the Ruben and added extra meat, lettuce and tomato. Absolutely delicious, kraut had a perfect balance of sweet and tart, meat was tender and juicy, and the thousand island dressing organized the symphony all between two slices of perfectly and lightly grilled and buttered toast. If you're into Rueben's like I am, this one is a don't miss...Bravo Rick! read more

We love ordering from Ricks! They have the best subs made with fresh ingredients and also make family meals to go which is definitely needed for our busy household! read more