Always enjoy a small, intimate, funky country restaurant that takes pride in several signature dishes. The steaks and rack of lamb were marvelous, and a team approach to waitstaff ensures great service. If you are in the area, go. We met a delightful couple of approximately 80 yrs young that drove a bit just to get the Escargot! Gotta love that! read more

First, definitely make reservations so you get a seat at a table. If there is any room for walk-ins, you are almost seated at the bar. If you like that, still call and request it. If you are not a steak eater, there is plenty on the menu for you too. However, go for the steak! We go a few times a year and it never disappoints. Dress is casual, kind of an old looking dive bar vibe with great food. People are nice, servers know their menu and can make good suggestions if you're a first timer. Reasonably priced for everything except the steak. With the steak, you're paying for quality. Always a great meal, and almost always leftovers to take home. We've never had dessert because dinner is so filling, so no review on dessert here. read more

See all

Came here on a Saturday at 4pm (when they open) I made reservations a week beforehand because I've been there once before a year ago I and it was packed and you needed reservations. We took the hour long drive thru the small towns of NJ. Once we got there we waited in our car a few minutes because the wind was unreal outside band was very cold. There were people outside waiting to be the first to get in but we jumped out of the car with a minute to spare and was ushered in with the waiting crowd. Place is an old relic of a place nice bar but not much seating if your coming with a big party def call at least a few weeks in advance. There was a sign when we walked in that our time dining will be limited to 90 minutes for tables up to 6 over 6 you get to stay 120 minutes. We were seated at a basic table definitely no frills as basic as you can get. I ordered a cocktail the Cupid... it was strong and delish. My son had a craft beer and he enjoyed it. We were greeted very warmly and fast by our waitress since we basically knew what we wanted it was simple to order. It seems they go from who they've seated 1st then served drinks too then over to take the order so one table after the other and when the food comes out it's like that too like all at once. I got the Wolfe Cub 8oz medium with Garlic Butter with a baked potato side of butter and sour cream. Husband & son both got the Loki Cut 24oz (one medium rare with the Garlic Butter & with the dirty mashed potatoes & one medium with the a sweet potato with cinnamon butter) I wish I took a video of when our dishes came out. I've never been so impressed in my life. Sizzling meat that had everyone around us turning their heads (ours came out first of the people that were around us because we didn't order any appetizers or salad. My husband's and son's steak was so thick and perfectly cooked that it took my breath away it was that thick with a perfect char on it. Mine was definitely smaller and I could only eat half but it was the best steak I've ever had up till now. My son and husband also agree with me. My husband was able to polish his off plus his sweet potato, I don'ti know how he did it but he did. My son ate half and all of his dirty mashed potatoes. We both bought our left overs home and my son re heated his yesterday in a pan and said it was just as tender and flavorful as when it was fresh. My husband will be having mine tonight since he's been eyeing it since we bought it home. If you are looking for an absolute genuine steakhouse and are not pretentious about being in a regular restaurant this place is for you. You don't have to dress up just come for the food! For us to travel over an hour out of the way just to eat is not like us but like I said we went once before and my husband wanted to return so bad. I wish I lived closer I'd be broke but in steak heaven. I feel the prices for the steaks are very fair and they get you with the drinks and all the add ons ($6.00 for a scoop of garlic butter on top of the steak but so worth it.) They have an extensive menu and I would love to try other items but it's the steaks that pull you in. Overall an A+ in my opinion and we will be back to enjoy once again. read more

Red Wolfe Inn - Special drinks - Steakhouses Near Me - Belvidere, New Jersey

See all

We were able to call and get a reservation for a Saturday evening at 8:30. I read a few of the reviews saying not to show up without one. The food here was delicious and plentiful. The onion rings could easily feed four for an appetizer there's that many. My NY Strip was cooked perfectly with garlic butter as an add-on. Creamy and so tasty. My husband had the ribs and said they were amazing. The staff was super friendly and pleasant all around. The only reason I didn't give it five stars was that it's unbelievably loud in there. It's really hard to have a conversation while dining there. It's got more of a bar vibe to me, so maybe that's why I found it hard to hear. But I would definitely go back but probably earlier before the crowd gets heavier. read more

If you like an unassuming restaurant that has the most delicious steaks and unique menu options out on the western border of New Jersey's premiere corn, veggie fields and Christmas trees. Red Wolfe Inn is the place you will want to come back to after eating their steaks Reservations required unless you want to sit next to the front door for punishment. This is a true find you won't need to dress up for, nice casual dress is fine. Don't think this is fancy, it's not, it is delicious! read more

A hidden gem of a restaurant. This place has an interesting menu with several appetizers you would normally find at a French restaurant, such as escargot and frogs legs. Their main area are steaks. First place I've seen where you can pick from several different sizes cuts. We both had the NY Strip steak. Ordered mine medium rare but was closer to medium. My only real criticism is that they don't serve Rib Eye. I'd have liked this place a lot more had they included rib eye on their menu. read more

I am almost tempted to give this a fraudulent negative review to deter additional competition for a reservation. The only thing stopping me is that I cannot bring myself to say something bad about this delightful restaurant. Red Wolfe is Warren County's best kept secret. This unsuspecting little institution smack dab in the middle of nowhere is a divine haven of flavor and quality for a reasonable price. This is exactly what I was looking for. This is true rural luxury. The food is outstanding and high quality. Especially their signature NY Strip "Wolfe" steaks. It's tried and true and full of flavor. It is full of rustic rural character and charm and the best part is, that it is REAL. This is not some yuppie faux dive masquerading as something sacred. This is true earned character. It is made for Warren County and we love that it's here. Good luck getting a reservation, if it's a Friday night, odds are you are competing with me. read more

Needs a good cleaning. Board of health should be all over this place. What temp is the meat stored at?

We started with escargot that was delicious. We had steaks that were cooked to perfection, and the side of garlic shrimp was awesome. Service was good. Great spot where you would not expect! read more

Red Wolfe Inn - Filet mignon with blue cheese - Steakhouses Near Me - Belvidere, New Jersey

Amazing food, great alcoholic beverage selection, laud back atmosphere, and decent service. Make sure to book in advance. They are busy every night. Closed on Sundays so keep that in mind when planning. Highly recommend their NY Strip steak. read more

What a great dining experience! The staff, the menu selections, and the food we ordered were ALL Fantastic! We started with the escargot, frog legs, French onion soup, and Caesar salad. Then we got the rack of lamb and NY strip. We finished with the tiramisu. The drinks were also perfect. Definitely a great place! read more

See all

Make sure you have a reservation because you may not get a seat otherwise. The steaks are spot on and the servers are friendly. Never had a bad time at this place. read more

Definitely the best area we have tried in the area. Lots of options and a good price. Our server was great!

I'm not sure about the great reviews here but maybe it's because there is almost no where else to go in the area. I met a friend here on a Friday night and they had line at the door when they opened. They said they had no seating so we sat at the bar which was fine. Service was ok. I wasn't impressed by the food though. My London broil was super chewy. I almost didn't eat. The mashed potatoes were good and asparagus a little tough. I was still hungry after dinner. The waitress said they had crème brûlée cheesecake which sounded interesting so I got that. It was definitely pumpkin. It was good, a little too sweet but it definitely wasn't what she said it was. I'd skip this place if you can find somewhere else to go. read more

Red Wolfe Inn - London Broil asparagus mashed potatoes - Steakhouses Near Me - Belvidere, New Jersey

The food was great and so was the service. I loved the ambiance of a small tavern when the world was young. I will be back. read more

Red Wolfe Inn - Steakhouses Near Me - Belvidere, New Jersey

See all

Good food. Very slow service. Initially I let them slide, because they were new. But now, more than a month since opening, service is still painfully slow. read more

Great steaks, cozy atmosphere! Great place for a first date or intimate dinner! I highly recommend it!

Red Wolfe never disappoints. Food is always delicious. I've had the fish with lump crab meat, the cub steak, and the pork tenderloin special with cranberry glaze and many more dishes. These are just my favorite. This place is a gem. read more

What a diamond in the Rough !!!! I can't emphasize enough how amazing the food is from salads, to steaks to the garlic butter for a topper over your choice of steak its amazing!!! This is a must place to go for a nice meal !!! And you will return for another meal staff is phenomenal!!!! Attention to every little detail, from entering the restaurant to our waitress.... And the deserts wow I now need a wheel barrow lol !!!! I've rambled on enough you will enjoy !!!! read more

Great evening here. Reservations are definitely recommended as it is small. We sat at the bar. All the servers and workers were happy and made my experience great. My steak was cooked exactly as I ordered it, medium rare. It came out hot and tasted amazing. I had bourbon sweet potatoes as a side. I am glad I tried them as they were great. Overall, this is definitely worth a stop if you are in the mood for a steak. read more

1st let me be clear - their NY Strip Steaks are extraordinary. Cooked to perfection, arrive at the table sizzling, tender, juicy, and delicious. Everything else, IMHO, is overpriced, mediocre at best and has gone down hill over the past several years. Service has been good every time we have been here (about 6-8X a year), until Friday night (3/21/25) Waitress ignored, ignored, ignored us, despite my attempts to get her attention. Not sure what I did, but she won't be welcome as my server next time we go. read more

Recently moved to the area and people kept recommending Red Wolfe. Went last night and Red Wolfe did not disappoint. The staff were very friendly (& very busy) and made you feel welcome. We ordered a strip steak and filet mignon both were cooked to perfection. A little divey, but not in a bad way at. We can't wait to go back! read more

Red Wolfe Inn - Filet topped with blue cheese & a baked potato - Steakhouses Near Me - Belvidere, New Jersey

My wife and I arrived at this restaurant for the first time at around 6:20 PM. Unfortunately, we were turned away because there was no seating available for two for dinner. We'll be back soon and this time we will make a reservation for dinner. The BIG ANT o read more

Upon entering we were kindly welcomed and seated. There an extensive menu choices as well as daily specials. Food was prepared fresh and served hot. Nothing was salty or over seasoned. Excellent chefs! Portions of food were average to above average and for the quality and quantities of food the prices are very reasonable. Servers were great and the server we had (Colleen) knew details on every item on the menu questioned and for the daily specials. Her suggestion for the chicken breast dish was spot on. Although there was a loud party at the time we dined (and reservations are a necessity) we made the best of the evening and did enjoy all of the food choices made. We will go back. read more

The food here is excellent and the servers are good. I love the 16oz steak! Ok now for what i dont love... if you want cajun seasoning on your steak it's $4.50 for the sprinkle and if you want garlic butter its $6.00 for a pat of garlic butter! The 16oz steak is $44.00 which im fine with (its worth it) but the cost of the extras is OUTRAGEOUS!!!!!!!!!! I mean c'mon, A whole 1/4 lb container of cajun seasoning is $4.50! Just sprinkle it on for $0.50 will ya read more

Hold in the wall restaurant, but don't judge a book by its cover! They know how to cook a good steak for half the price of most steakhouses! I had the NY strip with garlic butter and a side of onion rings. All steaks also come with a salad. I ate every last bite! read more

Red Wolfe Inn - Strip steak with garlic butter - Steakhouses Near Me - Belvidere, New Jersey

Great place to grab a bite to eat. Lots of beers on tap. Great selection of beef, seafood, foul and pasta. I will definitely eat here again.

Revisited after many years an it still has that locals vibe. Cozy with rustic decor like it's been there for a hundred years. The strip steak was absolutely delicious served on a hot cast iron plate. Had the 12 ounce but should have gotten the 16 ounce it was so good and prices are reasonable with friendly servers. Definitely will be back. read more

We had been trying for a reservation for quite some time but to no avail. Actually we never got through by phone and no one ever returned our calls. Well we finally got through and went on a week night. VERY disappointing. The stuffed clams and stuffed mushrooms were mostly breading, not at all as described on menu. The beef rounds wrapped in bacon and brushed with bbq sauce were drowning in bbq sauce and tough. The entree's and sides were less then average at best. It seem as if there wasn't any care put into the meals. The sizzling steaks looked good and maybe that's what you go for. The restaurant is small and unappealing. The sever seemed as if she had to be somewhere and it was a bother waiting on us. I'm very sad to say It's hard to find anything good to write about this experience. read more

Supebowl Sunday. Listed hours were 4pm to 9pm. Called for a reservation. Left message. No call back. Still drove 45 minutes to get there to find the place closed. No signs or anything saying they would be closed. I was dissatisfied and disappointed with this. Please leave a notification online or at the establishment. Very unprofessional read more

What a beautiful surprise. From the rustic stone exterior to the warm, friendly welcome to the awesomely delicious burger I was impressed with everything about the Red Wolfe. It's a little out in the boonies so I was shocked to find nearly every table full. I ate at the bar. Even though the guy next to me, and nearly every review, suggested the steak I wasn't quite in the mood or ready to spend the money on a steak dinner. But my burger was hearty and delicious and satisfying and I left very much wishing for the chance at a second visit. read more

Red Wolfe Inn - Steakhouses Near Me - Belvidere, New Jersey

See all

Was pretty happy to have found this place on a very random recommendation. Way out of the way from my house but happened to be in the area and got a early reservation (seem to be a must on the weekends, only about 12 tables and a number of groups waiting as we ate.) I got the Loki sized NY strip (24 oz? And they come even bigger) and it came out sizzling and perfectly cooked. It was excellent (and I've tried many a steak in the tri-state area). My wife had the filet and she really enjoyed it as well. Very causal place, cozy woods-y atmosphere (perfectly named, BTW), but see the line out the door on its busiest nights and you'll have a sense as to why steak lovers with a huge appetite come to this place. Absolutely worth a not-so-short trip for this delicious meal. read more

Red Wolfe Inn - Loki-sized strip steak, topped with optional (mountain-sized) garlic butter. - Steakhouses Near Me - Belvidere, New Jersey

Came here last Sunday with my family,I was visiting from San Diego and trying to find a place not to far from Columbia,there is no many choices, so I made a res based on reviews and this place was friggin awesome!!!!Started off with great round of drinks,Warm welcoming waitress which come to find out lived in every town my sis lived in.We started with 2 sampler app's that came out hot and delish, Our table of 6 ordered steaks, ribs(that I had)Flounder dish(my Dad)And everything was soooooooo good!Coming from San diego that has become quite a food town,Red Wolf was honestly as good or better than restaurants double or even triple the price.(I know, prices are crazy out here)Cool thing, during dinner one of the girls got the attention of everyone to sing Happy Birthday to one of the patrons and everyone happily joined in to sing!!!So,to sum it up,Great Food,Great Drinks,Great Atmosphere!I dont know if there family owned, just well managed, but they sure seem to take pride in what they are putting out there!My only complaint is that I dont love here anymore and I will have to wait a while till I can come back!!!Thanks for a Great Night! read more

Since the new renovations the steaks are not as well prepared as before. You really don't even notice the renovations but I assume it deals mostly with the kitchen. All our London broil below the top layers were Luke warm and some cold, veggies as well as potatoes. The staff was more interested in getting drinks then customer attention. When it came to paying the bill, I was shocked at a service charge....service charge for what, paying by credit card? And no notice that I saw anywhere on the menu about that! After coming here moor over 20 yrs. it's not the same, I'll wait until it gets better before I come back. The mushrooms stuffed was the best part of the meal, hot and tasty. read more

Red Wolfe Inn - Service fee? For what? - Steakhouses Near Me - Belvidere, New Jersey

This is by far the best steak I've ever encountered in my life. Time and time again my girlfriend and i take the road trip over an hour away to enjoy this delicious new york strip topped with an amazing garlic butter. The staff is very tentative and they know exactly what they're doing. No delay in service even when the bar is packed beyond belief. read more

See all

My first time here was a grade A experience. The steak was amazing, the soup was delicious, & the waitress/staff were friendly and attentive. I can't wait to stop in again!! read more

My Wife and I have went past this restaurant dozens of times and have always said we should try it. The exterior of this place is very intriguing, it looks like it should be in a mountain forrest environment. Beautiful stone face with a rustic door. Funny that my sister made reservations for our party before attending an event in Pa. Place fills up fast, so please make a res. We got there at 4:45 and it was almost packed already. Started with some hot buffalo wings, not the usual franks sauce but better. Slightly smokey flavor with a very tasty hot sauce, very plump meaty wings. I ordered the 10 oz filet - cooked to a perfect medium rare. The food was super hot and not lukewarm at all. My wife ordered the fish which was delicious My Sister and Brother in law ordered different cuts of steak which were large and perfectly cooked. Only reason I didnt give 5 stars was the overall portion size of the sides. I make larger baked potatoes at home. Ordered garlic shrimp and all I got was 4 medium sized shrimp for $9. You can buy a bag of 2 lbs Extra Jumbo shrimp for $13 at shoprite. For nine bucks they should be using much larger shrimp. Service as top shelf. Always on too of things. Food came out fast. Is it worth a trip back? Yes. One of the better places to eat in this part of the State. read more

Love, love, love their food. I usually get the petite filet, but I've never had a bad meal ever!!!

If you like a good old timey Mom and Pop roadside tavern with excellent comfort food and friendly hospitality, then you'll love this joint. Good tried and true rock and roll hits on the radio and the Giants game on the bar tv. Nothing fancy but oh so comforting in these uncertain times (COVID/Election). I came up this way from Hunterdon County to look at a cabin and hope to move up this way one day. Reservations highly recommended or come at off hours. It's little but in a great way. read more

Red Wolfe Inn - a bar with a television in the background - Steakhouses Near Me - Belvidere, New Jersey

Great food, great ambience. Even though it was super crowded, they were able to seat us right away, at the exact time of our reservation. We will be back. read more