Wowzers!!!!! If you're considering giving this place a try, stop considering and start going!!! You won't regret it!!!! About my 10th time here , ALWAYS excellent service, and outstanding food( and cocktails)!! Went last night with some friends, Faith , was our server. Pleasant, attentive, hell, she was on the ball!!!!! I tried the special, filet medallions and shrimp with pasta in a spicy Alfredo sauce!!! Holy moly it was awesome!!!! Very different, not as heavy as I thought and the meat was awesome!!!!! My friends also had the special, the standard filet( with Gorgonzola cream sauce, yum) and the ahi tuna. All loved their meals!!! We also had various cocktails, the black honey sangria being the star of the show!!! The bourbon bear was amazing as was the lemon drop martini!!!! Came once on a Saturday and they had mystery cocktails..... you pick the base(alcohol) tell them what you like/dislike and they make you a custom cocktail. It literally blew my hair back!!! Desserts were delicious as well! Quality dining......from the hostess, service, beverages, food, it is an experience you'll enjoy. Highly recommend!!!! read more

My partner and I are visiting the Poconos for a birthday staycation, and we stumbled upon this absolute gem. The restaurant has a moody industrial decor, with a grown adult vibe. We were served by Jacob, which was honestly so kind and knowledgeable about the food and area, he went above and beyond in giving us a nightcap option after sharing that it seemed like things shut down relatively early. For starters we shared the Caesar which was delicious and truly made with love, it was enough to share, but I definitely wanted more. For dinner I had the bone in ribeye with roasted carrots and mash potatoes perfectly seasoned, and delicious hardy piece of meat and my partner had the special filet covered in mustard peppercorn with a guava reduction reminded me of something I can't put my finger on it. But damn it was good. 4/5 all of it read more

See all

Excellent service and great menu. Enjoyed the steak medallions (black jack) and mussels fra diavolo. read more

Garlic - Black Jack - Steakhouses Near Me - Stroudsburg, Pennsylvania

GREAT EATS IN THE POCONOS AT NYC PRICES So I gave them 5 stars on the strength of their Lobster Mac & Cheese. The Mac is made from a wonderful bechamel sauce that served as the perfect base for the 3-4 cheeses used in this dish. They were pretty generous with the amount of lobster as they should for that price point. And yes, they are actually using chopped up lobster tail for this dish. It was so good that I'm already planning my next trip back. Other details... 1) Crispy Calamari was a good appetizer to share between max 2 people. The same applies for the Fire Shrimp. 2) If you're a fan of eggplant, good for the Eggplant Stack. Add on the linguine to make it a whole meal. 3) Try the Black Jack if you're feeling snackish. It's a small amount of food with a small amount of flavor. 4) Chicken Parm Ricotta definitely is an elevated American classic. It is also a pretty big portion with great flavor. 5) Expect a high bill but solid service which makes an overall very good dining experience because the food is worth it. read more

See all

This place was considered one of the nicer restaurants in the area (as opposed to us going to a bar) and the vibe was great for a Friday night. Our server was the absolute best. He helped us with dining suggestions and was a pretty funny guy. I am an old-fashioned cocktail gal but the one I had here that was jazzed up w/ passion fruit I think did not hit. I'd say go with a traditional old-fashioned if you come here for a drink. The Mac and cheese slapped. It was so cheesy and delish. Also the calamari appetizer was a hit with the table, very crispy but not overdone. I'm not a big eggplant fan but I heard the eggplant parm was good. And for my main I got the steak medallions. It was okay but I think I should have went with a seafood option. Overall a good vibe for date night (in the area). Be warned it is a bit pricey for the area. read more

See all

I have been back three different times since my last review. Each with a different member of their wait staff -- oddly enough, it's been the same bartender though. So, my drinks have been stellar each time. The most recent visit was with a party of 14. We came for a vendor/work dinner. We called in around noon and made the reservation for 7pm. Upon arrival, we were told we couldn't be seated due to policy until the entire party has arrived. I'm somewhat unclear on why restaurants do this --- maybe so everyone has the same timing and experience from start to finish. It makes sense to someone somewhere i'm sure. However, after working all day long -- and having people driving in from 2+ hours away --- we wanted to sit down right away. So, to the hostess -- i'm sorry via the internet if i was a little demanding that we be seated -- because we didn't want to stand up in the lobby. Onto the service, i don't recall either of their names but we had a very nice gentleman who explained the menu to all of our diners from start to finish -- made a few recommendations, and was very attentive to our questions. His parter was also very receptive to the tons of questions thoughout our table being thrown her way. The food was very good again -- calamari was great, lobster mac was tasty, but what really got me this time was the crab cake -- it was phenomenal. Some people complained about their meat not having any seasoning to it -- tasted like it wasn't even salt or peppered.... but mine was just the way i liked it. Rare and with some salt. It is unfortunate that I will likely not be back -- due to my job ending and me heading back home. But this is a must try place for anyone in the area. read more

Garlic - Turtle Cheesecake - Steakhouses Near Me - Stroudsburg, Pennsylvania

This is a nice classy place. The food is definitely tasty and a good variety of menu but too pricey. The have a bad wine selection but there cocktails are good and cute presentation. Staff was super friendly for sure! But I wouldn't go back here though way too pricey for the quality. read more

Get the filet mignon. Super delicious and melt in your mouth. The stars are for that and the garlic butter. The burrata was pretty good as well. The carrot side was not good. You get like 6 mini black carrots that weren't appeasing or tasty. Their truffle fries were crisp and good. Their shrimp tortellini, which we subbed out chicken came out fine initially but ended up being greasy and oily. Their molten chocolate cake was rich and flavorful. I would get that again. I would come back but would change my order based on what we've already had. read more

See all

The place is amazing, food is very delicious, I would recommend the shrimp Pasta better. It's a big plate, me and my husband shared it. We also had garlic fries it's delicious. The servers are all nice and place is good. read more

Garlic - Cajun shrimp pasta and lobster ravioli - Steakhouses Near Me - Stroudsburg, Pennsylvania

Amazing dinner experience from drinks, salads to entrees and wine. Emily was wonderful with helping us on our food choices and on things to see in the area. The ricotta arugula salad was so different but yummy and fresh and the chicken parm ricotta was delicious. My husband enjoyed his Caesar salad and the calamari fra Diablo was deliciously spicy! The negroni was really good too! Excellent evening! read more

See all

Rating: 3.5 stars We were visiting Poconos and wanted to get together with a local friend for dinner. After did some search roughly on Yelp, this place caught my eye because there is another restaurant also called Garlic in Vermont which is where we often go to when we visit Killington so we decided to try it. The restaurant is right next to the main street and it looks fancy inside. They served a basket of complimentary bread with butter garlic which was pretty good. We ordered some special cocktails and entrees. Our server was very friendly and attentive and would keep checking in on us to see if we needed anything. Most food was good but they were not worth the price. Also the portion was small. However this place is definitely good for special occasions and if you don't mind an expensive bill then you should go try. read more

See all

We had such an awful meal at Garlic. Probably the worst streak that I ever had. Incredibly tough and just an awful taste. Actually had the taste of cheese. There was no grilled flavor. The garlic fries had a ridiculous amount of garlic. Just awful. Ambiance was nice. read more

Our server was super sweet. I wish I remembered her name but Saturday night , they were fairly busy and she was nice. We ordered the mystery cocktail and a Negroni, the mystery cocktail was basically just lemonade but it was fine. We placed our appetizer orders and waited a bit, then placed entree orders. Our entrees came out but we never got our apps. Our server was just as confused as we were. We told her to hold off on the apps we may not want them now that we already had our meals, she was super sweet about it. 2 minutes later our apps came to the table. Again - she was just as confused as us. They were gracious enough to remove the apps from our tab because we couldn't take them to go as we're staying in a hotel. There was clearly a breakdown in communication somewhere . Chicken parm was delicious, lobster ravioli wasn't worth the price. The fire shrimp was good. Overall, food is okay, ambiance is nice, we may have just had an odd first experience but if we go back it will be because our server was so genuine & kind about the whole thing. read more

Garlic - Steakhouses Near Me - Stroudsburg, Pennsylvania

Nice and cozy decor. stopped in for dinner on our way to PA. Started with the burrata salad and ordered the Ahi tuna and fried rice, and surf and turf special for our main meals. Tuna and rice were really good( tuna was over-seared but not to a point that I would be disappointed), and the steak and lobster were ok. Ended the meal with a donut cheesecake. staff was pleasant and accommodating. We sat outside but it got really hot and they moved us in. They have surprise drinks on Monday and you pick your spirit and they make you a surprise mix. A little pricy for what you get but overall good experience. read more

See all

Words can not express the sheer bliss of enjoying my apple pie martini special and our multiple appetizers we shared. This place is absolutely perfection. The bacon wrapped scallops with Thai chili sauce and cucumber were scrumptious. My eggplant stack is somewhat of a comfort food for me because I enjoy my eggplant. This was NEXT level! My friend ordered the lobster Mac n cheese & I tried a bite ~ causing a mini (ahem, mouth explosion).... Everything was so so good. We could not have expected more! read more

See all

10/10 from the time we walked in to dessert. Our food was slow for a Monday night but everything was amazing. Walking in it's like being transported to a high end restaurant in NYC or LA. Definitely on my list if we return to the area. read more

See all

Love the atmosphere of this place and our waitress and host were great! We had the calamari appetizer, Cajun shrimp tortellini, and chicken parm ricotta. The calamari and shrimp were good, the chicken parm tomato sauce was a little sweet for my liking. The prices were a little high. read more

See all

Great dinner. Should change up the menu to feature either some Asian/Middle Eastern fare for variety. All the local establishments offer steak, maybe lamb or pork instead of pricey steak. They ran out of Mezcal! read more

Greeted and seated right away(had reservations). Ordered mystery drink and was very good. Husband ordered his drink and then decided to also order mystery drink because he liked mine, but found the drink was made differently, didn't taste the same as mine. We advised the waitress and she apologized and offered to bring him another drink of his choice. Meal was good. We got our bill and was charged for the mystery drink that was not good. Waitress said we don't waive drinks. A little disappointing... read more

The host was a little unusual, in that we walked in, and he just stared at us and kind of shook his head like he was waiting for me to speak. Most generally a host will ask you how you are, and how many in your party. I had to say hello and let HIM know how many were in my party. Just a little odd. The server was extremely friendly and informative about the popular dishes there. She checked on us often. There were other servers as well that kept us filled on our complimentary rolls and refills. The atmosphere was quiet and nice. Would highly recommend the cheese ravioli. The red sauce was amazing. No picture. Was too busy eating! Had the homemade hummus for an appetizer which was very good. My dining partners had the shrimp ceviche and scallops which they enjoyed immensely. read more

Garlic - Lemon raspberry cheesecake cake. - Steakhouses Near Me - Stroudsburg, Pennsylvania

Well, my girlfriend and I had been looking to visit this place and finally we got in. The decor is nice, the server was very good. Unfortunately the establishment charges way too much for the product. The menu isn't very expansive which limited my choice between 42.00 plus beef to 30.00 plus fish. I'm not saying I didn't expect that pricing but I better get a damn good meal. I was not disappointed with the calamari but we ordered a crab dish for an appetizer that was served in a minuscule mini dish and it wasn't cheap and I saw virtually no crab. I ordered a couple margaritas and my girlfriend ordered a peach or pear martini. Decent but the margarita glass was small. Drinks priced about 16-19 a pop. My entree was jerk shrimp and the presentation was better than the taste. I literally counted 6 shrimp and a ball of rice with the glazed sauce and some bland, tasteless vegetables. This meal is NOT worth the 208.00 minus the tip. Last summer my girlfriend and I paid about the same in Greenwich Village after seeing American Buffalo. That I expected. Justified pricing. This place won't get my business again and my advice is a complete makeover with the menu. I don't want to appear cruel but this simply wasn't at all worth the money. I expect way MORE. read more

Garlic - Jerk Shrimp - Steakhouses Near Me - Stroudsburg, Pennsylvania

Service was excellent from the moment we entered throughout the dining experience and until we left. They are training their staff very well Filet mignon came out perfectly cooked medium as requested . Slightly salty but good The Mac and cheese was delicious but a bit runny . The mashed potatoes were delicious but a bit salty . The decor is very modern and hip and the restrooms are clean read more

Garlic is a cool looking establishment with a great bar but with a limited menu. I've enjoyed their food very much, specially a beef tips appetizer and their filet mignon. Although the bartenders are nice and fun, they have a problem understanding what "dry" means. After my first failed experience, I made a point to mention that I "hate" sweet drinks and avoid simple syrup. Regardless, my Manhattan and Old Fashions were as sweet as juice. Still, the atmosphere is wonderful and that's a hard thing to ignore. read more

Bartender was awesome, he made me a killer old fashioned. Steak was great, will return.

Very much an okay spot. Went here while on vacation in the Poconos and had higher expectations given the pictures. I guess the options are limited in the area. Seems more like a chain restaurant. read more

Amazing ambience and great customer service. Definitely coming back again. Love how accommodating everybody was and how delicious the food is. read more

Garlic - Surf and turf - Steakhouses Near Me - Stroudsburg, Pennsylvania

See all

The setting is very nice and upscale. The food is very good but a bit overpriced. The service was very good and overall have a very nice dinner here. I would return in the future. read more

While away for work I stopped at this restaurant for dinner. When I arrived I parked on the street nearby. I walked in and was greeted and decided to sit at the bar. Jessica was my bartender and she was cool. I started with an espresso martini which was good. For my entrée I ordered the jerk shrimp meal. I asked if it was supposed to be real Jamaican style jerk shrimp and she told me the cook is Jamaican and came up with the meal, so I was sold. When it came out it looked good. I dug in and the jerk shrimp was more like bbq shrimp. This wasn't any way, shape or form jerk shrimp but it wasn't bad tasting. It was very sweet and not spict like the menu indicated. The bill was ok and I paid and left. Had a decent experience. read more

See all

Surprisingly good. Ordered the 18oz steak and blackjack. Great value compared to NYC prices, though they should add that selecting two starch sides (that come with the 18oz steak) incurs a $2 surcharge. The server mentioned it as we ordered it, but I think it should be stated on the menu. I'll be returning when I visit the area again. read more

Great evening at Garlic, we sat outside and it was perfect weather for the evening, our sever Faith was attentive and kind, she checked in on us several times. People said the service was slow or the food took a while, we did not experience this at all. We started with 2 cocktails and the Calamari appetizer- it was fresh tender and the sauces we so good! My husband and I both had the ribeye, sides were the best Mac and Cheese I have ever tasted, I think it was made with coopersharp which if your from Philly you all know how gooey it can be! Our other sides were broccolini and carrots, both good as well. Our steaks were over cooked (asked for medium) it was mediocre but great char and the steak sauce was amazing! If we are back in this area again, we will go back! read more

Garlic - Baked Mac & Cheese - Steakhouses Near Me - Stroudsburg, Pennsylvania

See all

Great drinks, good food, very pricey. It's geared more toward the tourist crowd from New Jersey and NYC who have extra vacation money to spend. As a local, I go here only occasionally for a change of pace, but the prices make me feel a little bit like a sucker. Still, a worthwhile addition to the varied restaurants on Main Street. read more

Overall, this place was good except for the trashy rap crap music. Not sure who in their right mind would play that type of music for a nice restaurant. This place is not a trashy night club. They finally changed it after several people & us complained about it. Not sure why they would play music that doesn't coordinate better with their image. Overall, the food & service was good. Unfortunately, the music ruined our dining experience. read more

Me and my boys enjoyed Garlic. One of the best restaurants in East Stroudsburg. We will be back soon read more

Garlic - Me and my boys enjoyed garlic. One of the best restaurants in East Stroudsburg. - Steakhouses Near Me - Stroudsburg, Pennsylvania

Omg!!! What a find! The food is absolutely amazing. We went with no reservations but we were seated almost immediately. The service, drinks, ambiance, and food were all on point!! Holy moly! Probably one of the best eating experiences I've had in a long time. I love the mystery drink. You choose the alcohol and they make a surprise drink. I choose bourbon and got something that was like an old fashioned. I absolutely can't wait until my next visit to Pennsylvania to eat there again!! read more

Garlic - Salmon! Delicious! And my mystery drink! - Steakhouses Near Me - Stroudsburg, Pennsylvania

It's delicious. Beautiful inside. Nice beet salad. Nice cocktail. Service was good. Pricey $$$

I did not find this place worth the money or overly enjoyable. I got the chicken parm. Most pizza places would serve a better chicken parm at half the price. The calamari seemed bland and fried in dirty oil. My husband got the jerk mahi. The fish was cooked well. The combination of flavors was interesting. Wasn't great, but it wasn't bad. This place had a chain-y vibe. Nothing was really good, but also nothing was outright bad. Not with the price at all though- 1 app, 2 wines, 2 entrees was $120. Pretty crazy for the quality of food.. For what it's worth, the service was really good. I'm guessing this place has such high reviews because there's not much else in the area. read more

This place is incredible! Been here twice and everything from food to drinks were perfect. Highly recommend this place. Look forward to my next visit Marc read more

Over priced sub par food in a very nice place. If that's your thing enjoy but I won't be returning

We had dinner at garlic last night. It was wonderful. Everything from appetizers to dessert was fresh and delicious. The waitress, food runner and manager were friendly and efficient and made our meal memorable. The restaurant is quiet with a contemporary feel to it. That was just the right setting for a pleasant dinner for two. We had two cocktails, both of them were generous and delicious. we live two hours away, but would seriously consider making a trip just to have another wonderful dinner like that. Highly recommended! LF read more

If you want something decent to eat in this town, you'll have to pack a lunch. The drinks weren't good. The food wasn't good. The decor is awful. Just not good. Don't try to be a fancy steakhouse unless you are a fancy steakhouse. This place is not. Save your money. read more