Amazing food and service! Me and my family have been coming here since they have opened so the waitresses know our order by heart. The staff here is incredibly friendly. No question this place is five stars! read more

Nothing better than a small business with a great product!! Awesome sauce and crust! I look forward to enjoying again!! read more

The Red Pepperoni - YUMM!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Pepperoni!! - Pizza Near Me - Madison, Indiana

They had lots of choices on the menu and we decided to order the chicken wings and cheese bread. The chicken is bone-in and large pieces and very reasonably priced. It came out steaming hot and they let us have a ranch and blue cheese for dips. All the food was tasty and hot. Also, they have a very extensive list of beers. The service was very friendly and the food came to us in a reasonable amount of time. read more

Best pizza in Madison IN. I always pick up an order when I'm in town visiting family. Friendly stafff and great service

We were in Madison this past week and were looking for pet friendly patio dining. We found Red Pepperoni fit that need and dropped by for lunch. Our server April was very welcoming and we felt right at home. My husband asked about the beer list and April advised she would go grab one for us. My husband asked her to surprise him with an IPA in lieu of her running back inside. She brought out a beer that he had not had before and made an excellent choice. It was a great beer. We then ordered wings and loaded fries (we were on vacation, so calories don't count). Both the wings and fries were delicious! April was very attentive and took great care of us. We would definitely return to Red Pepperoni! Thank you April for your warm and professional/friendly service!! read more

Try the Sicilian. It will change your life. These people love what they do and are passionate about great food and excellent service. I've been twice to sit down and about ten times for delivery and am always impressed. Salads and breadsticks are awesome too. read more

This small town pizza place would still be a favorite in a big city with infinite options. The owner has done the homework and nailed it in all areas; great family friendly atmosphere, delicious New York Style Pizza and an excellent local craft beer selection. The staff are friendly, appropriately attentive and professional. Never a bad experience and always satisfied. I guarantee that when you leave, you'll already be thinking about coming back again soon! Bon Appetit! read more

The pizza was amazing! We had the Sicilian and our kids had a cheese, which they said was the best they've ever had! Service was friendly and fast!! We will definitely be going back! read more

It seems the Reds have a finger in every pie in town. First pizza choice was closed, so they sounded solid. Rolled the dice on the Thai chicken pizza. It was hot, it was good. But it wasn't great, and it didn't really taste very Thai-peanutty. The "Caesar salad" was just weird. Onions and teeny-tiny lil tomato bits, with a sort of thin Caesar-esque dressing that probably (hopefully?) came from a bottle. Now I know Indiana has fully reopened, so the place was kind of crowded but no one was going out of their way to give 6' of space. The single cashier seemed to be the point of contact for dine-in and carry-out. I was waiting for carry-out among people waiting for a table. Masks were kind of hit or miss, a little more miss when I saw the kitchen door open. And I'm sorry, WTF are those tiny clear plastic face shield "masks"? I get that people want to see and hear their server in a busy dining room but studies have shown those are ineffective at keeping one's spit to oneself. read more

Good pizza. Large selection of micro brews read more

The Red Pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - Madison, Indiana

The food and service were both excellent. We had the chicken Parmesan Alfredo, calzone, and buffalo wings. All were worth raving about.

Terrible place. Menu lies and they never have half of the things advertised. Don't get me started on any because COVID crap... The rest of us still have to do our jobs and don't raise prices, give worse products/services, and still get along just fine. read more

Red Pepperoni is one of our favorite places to go in Madison. The service has always been quick and attentive, and everything we have tried tastes amazing and is a great value. We have tried several appetizers on the menu including the wings, breadsticks, and cheese bread and were pleased with all of these options. As for pizza, we usually get the pan crust and various toppings. This usually leaves enough food for both of us to have leftovers the next day. They also have an extensive beer list with options for everyone including ciders. If you find yourself in Madison for the afternoon or evening, I highly recommend checking this place out! read more

Best pizza in town and the artichoke dip is awesome! They do serve alcohol so that's a plus and very nice customer service. Never had a drink go empty. Great place for a family to grab lunch! read more

My wife and I absolutely love this place! Their beer selection is outstanding, and the knowledge the waiting staff has about their beer and food is impressive! While their pizza is phenomenal, their loaded cheese fries are truly a treat! Every time we visit Madison it is a no-brainier that we have to go there. Even if we aren't hungry, we know we can find some rare beers here at a great price! Love Red Pepperoni! read more

Best pizza place in Southern Indiana. Spud McKenzie or All American definitely puts this place on another level. Great service and a great lunch special. I'll return over and over again. Every time I get something different and it never disappoints. From the Cobb salad to the wings, everything is always delicious. Keep up the good work! read more

We love going to this place after a day of hiking at Clifty Falls. They don't just serve sausage and pepperoni pizzas they have a wider variety of pizzas than most places. The Spud McKenzie has french fries on it! How many places can you say put french fries on their Pizza?? They have a really good buffalo chicken pizza too. I don't like Peppers but this one comes with green peppers and I can totally eat it it's so good. I've also had the ravioli which was really good. They also have sandwiches and the Italian sandwich is amazing. Probably one of the best Italian sandwiches I've had anywhere. The Italian sandwich is my go-to sandwich. So I've had quite one at quite a few different places. There's probably a total of 20 tables in this restaurant and normally there is three to four open tables at anytime. Not overly busy but they do get people in and out efficiently. They have a decent sized beer menu also. Quite a few different options. The walls are covered with beer signs. Most I've never even heard of. I highly recommend eating at the red pepperoni and walking down Main Street to all the shops and checking out lower Madison. read more

Wonderful little pizza joint. Fast service and awesome food. We actually had 2 servers. We had the Roasted artichoke and white pizza. The roasted was good and the white was awesome. read more

Tasty Greek Pizza and Lasagna! Erv liked the blond Upland Wheat Ale with the orange slice. The side Caesar salad was very nice with lots of tomato bits, some onions. Many Indiana Brews available. Polite and helpful servers. read more

The Red Pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - Madison, Indiana

Amazing pizza! Just wish they delivered and stayed open a little later on the weekends.

While I've never had a bad pizza from the Red Pepperoni, I can say that not every pizza has been closed to "wow"ing me into that being the best pizza joint within driving distance. There always seems to be one aspect of it just slightly off from making it great. It's consistent with it's small inconsistencies to still warrant it much better than the chain pizza places in town. read more

From someone who's not usually a big pizza fan, I was highly satisfied with our pie. Will definitely be back next time we are in the area.

Amazing! Blue cheese wedge is the best I've had. Along with best pizza in town. Service is great as well.

Omg I absolutely love this place! Their breadsticks are amazing. They have so many different types of pizza top choose from. Their pastas are also a good choice. They also have over 80 different types of beer. read more

Great food. Fast service. Breadsticks are amazing and served piping hot! Calzones are really good also.

Went in for pick up while visiting Madison and was impressed by how good the pizza was. Lots of toppings, chewy and delicious crust. Would definitely recommend if you want a quick and delicious pizza! read more

Just tried the red pepperoni for the first time. Artichoke pizza was fantastic! The baked ziti was good - maybe a little spicy - but very good! Cheesy bread was terrific. Good service. Typical college town Italian pizzeria. Good food, reasonable price and good service. This will not be our last visit. read more

The Sicilian pizza was delicious! Loved the beer selection. Friendly service. Relaxed atmosphere. Great choice for a delucioys aardvark relaxing evening! read more

Really great pizza and good service. Great selection of craft beers. Excited to come back and try some other things.

Very tasty pizza joint in Madison Indiana. We had the Mac Daddy and Italian sub. Delicious! Drinks are reasonably priced at $2. Atmosphere is unique and our server, Thea, was exceptional! read more

Great pizza , cold beer, and the staff was prompt and friendly. A must stop in Madison Ind.

This is probably the best pizza I have ever had. Barbecue chicken, buffalo chicken, and spinach artichoke are the only ones I've had and are all super good. The spinach artichoke dip and fried ravioli are amazing too. The prices are super reasonable and service is always fast. Perfect place to come after hiking around Clifty Falls! read more

I enjoy trying new restaurants, and this one has a nice outdoor and indoor seating. The staff is nice and quick to make sure you have what you want. I tried the personal ultimate veggie pizza, which I would recommend. A friend I was with tried one of there salad and liked it. Another person tried just a small mushroom and sausage pizza and really liked it. read more

I arrived at 6:15pm and it took a considerable amount of time to just be seated. I ordered the 6" Macdaddy and it was delivered piping hot. It was quite tasty. If you are not in a hurry, I would recommend this place. read more

Okay so the homemade spinach artichoke dip appetizer is so amazing it almost doesn't make sense. We ordered their version of a meat lovers pizza and it was topping overload! The selection of craft beers rivals that of any restaurant we visit in Indy. Delta our waitress was super friendly and on the spot, even though they were smoking busy. Absolutely love this place!!! read more

Good pizza, fried ravioli, and cheese fries. Friendly service. Horrible dill ranch dressing!

I've never had better pizza. Came through for a graduation looking for a quick bite to eat. Service was quick, pizza was crunchy, very flavorful, and delicious. I'd definitely come here again if I'm back in town! read more

We are from outside of Chicago and we have the best pizza anywhere at our fingertips, so we were not expecting a whole lot. We are very happy to say that we were incorrect!!!! It was fantastic pizza! Service was good, as they were very busy with lots of customers.. Hubby and I had two salads with their home-made bleu cheese and dill ranch dressing. He said his was "not bad" and my dill ranch was very good. In fact, I was told "you aren't going to really take the leftover dressing home, are you" and I said "well, yes I am and if it disappears, then you know where the doghouse is." (I had ordered a second container). We ordered the small specialty RPD pizza (sausage, pepperoni, onion, green pepper) which was more than big enough for the two of us. It was Sunday night, so we could have gotten a large for almost the same price, but since we are a hotel, really had nowhere to store the leftovers and knew we wouldn't be in the room to eat it. One side salad could almost be shared by two people. It had a healthy does of banana peppers (LOVE those), mozzarella cheese and green olives (LOVE those too), along with some white onions. Did I mention the dressing??? So good!!!! The pizza was a thin crust, but not crispy, with a healthy dose of toppings, just the right amount of cheese and sauce. It had good flavor and was baked perfectly. We had leftover pieces after eating the huge salads. The price was less than $25 and well worth it for what we received. Restaurant had good service, was clean and excellent pizza. We would definitely go back there when in town. read more

This place is small. Went on a Thursday and it was pretty packed so I'm assuming Fri, Sat will be more so. So be prepared to wait on table....but it's worth the wait! The interior is kitschy with beer signs, neon lights, etc. Speaking of beer, WHOA! They have an enormously extensive beer list. They have a lot written on a chalk board but it's hard to read. They also have a beer bible that tells what they have. I was satisfied with this Peach beer. It didn't taste like peaches but it was a good beer nonetheless. On to the pizza....got the artichoke pizza and added chicken. It was delicious! The crust wasn't too thin or too thick. The sauce was really creamy and satisfying. If you are to order this pizza, stick with a personal pan or a small. To me, the cream is so rich I couldn't eat more than two or three slices of it. The waitstaff was really on it too. Our waitress was very pleasant and it seemed most of the staff were local school kids. But they all seemed great and did their jobs well. Give this place a try! The End. read more

this is my first stop each time i go to madison. I get there about once a month. Pizza is great. Fun, family atmosphere. My favorite is the sicilian. But you can't go wrong with any pizza here. read more