Finally stopped into B. Antonio's…read more.. Unfortunately, it was rather underwhelming. The service was friendly, the place was clean, but the pizza itself was just ok and ridiculously overpriced ($43 w/ tip for two 10 inch thin crust pizzas). Plus, they were out of both mushrooms and sausage (I don't know how that even happens at a pizzeria?); the attendant at the counter was nice though and did comp us for not having the ingredients. All-in-all, I'd say Dave Portnoy would call B. Antonio's your typical "drunk pizza"... Average at best, but wouldn't be considered good unless you're hammered drunk. 5.8 out of 10.00

I haven't been here for a while. Pizza was good like I remember. I love the stuffed breadsticks…read more But they weren't the same. They used to be large and thick and gooey with cheese. Now they're mediocre a lot smaller, and not full of as much cheese.. disappointing in that since I was looking forward to it from my last memory of it. Change your stuff cheese sticks to how they used to be.

We frequent this establishment and find when it is good, it is very good, but unfortunately, it is…read morenot consistent. For example, the chicken basket purchased this evening is a 50/50 chance of being a fail. Tonight was a fail (again). The Chicken was very dark and dry to the point of being unpleasant to eat. We have had them forget the sauce in the past while giving inconsistent portions. But they topped everything tonight..... a couple of the potato wedges were actually ROTTEN. I have never eaten a rotten potato until tonight, I can tell you a rotten potoato tastes just how it woud smell and immediately kills the appetite. In the past we have received salads with missing ingredients, so stopped ordering salads. It always feels risky ordering take out from the Italian Grill. We have attempted to notify management in the past , with no response or care. If you like playing food roulette, you may enjoy it. But for me, I think it is time to take them off our take out list.

To me, this is the best family owned restaurant in Auburn! This staff is always excellent. So many…read moremenu options to choose from include a dessert tray with carrot cake, numerous cheesecakes, and cannolis. Everyone that comes here says how great the food is. I LOVE the minestrone soup (it's vegan!) You have your choice between bar seating and family room. You can't go wrong!

6/24/36 - Ordered the Misto Trio appetizer for lunch. I wanted to remove the mozzarella sticks and…read moreadd more eggplant sticks. Trying to reduce my dairy intake. They wouldn't do it. Said they could technically do it but wouldn't. Very poor customer service.

TLDR; highlights - rotisserie chicken…read more- dessert menu - limoncello - fresh seafood This was my first time visiting Casa, and as an Italian American raised around traditional foods, I *need* to go back. The first step through the door felt like Thanksgiving to me.. the low hum of chatter as families talked amongst each other, clinking of glasses as people said 'cheers!' and the immediate sight and scent of home-cooked food. Their slow-roasting rotisserie chicken filled the air as we were being sat and seeing them turn over and over in the open ovens had me drooling before I could even ask for water. Because we're in a landlocked state, I always order seafood whenever I catch it on the menu.. but choosing the Fettucine Tutto Mare instead of the Rotisserie Chicken entree has now filled me with a severe case of FOMO. I was impressed with how fresh the crabmeat, mussels and clams were in my dish and it reminded me of my late uncle (who would always demand we go to a restaurant with clam linguine). Paired with the Limoncello Spritzer, it truly felt like I was back home with my family. The dessert menu was filled with a lot of my personal favorites, like tiramisu, but I was too full to order any (which, truthfully, isn't a bad problem to have). But I'm thinking we'll start my next visit to Casa with dessert first... then maybe finish off with a rotisserie chicken

I started eating pizzeria pizza back in 1969 when I moved to Grove. I knew the original owner and…read morethe family that purchased the franchise from him. I can definitely say that since I have started eating their pizzas. I have found them to be the best around. Quality is the most important ingredient in their recipe that started with Tom Cartwright and has continued through to the Schaefer family. Very pleasant business to purchase your pizzas and a lots of other things from. They even get to know your voice if you order regularly. A small business that is large on dependability. Larry E

Only pizza place in Ottawa to consistently make what I order and have it ready when they say they…read morewill. Don't taste bad either.

This was, without a doubt, the worst pizza experience I've ever had. The dough was undercooked…read more--disgusting and inedible. I specifically asked for extra sauce and got almost none, making the whole thing even worse. It was so bad that I couldn't even force myself to eat it, and for the first time in my life, I actually had to throw away a pizza. The thought of it makes me nauseous. Trying to get a refund wasn't even worth the effort. There's absolutely no way this location is connected to the Swanton store because their quality is worlds apart. I wouldn't take another pizza from here even if it were free.

Pleasant staff, pizza way undercooked for my preference , almost doughy . Could benefit from…read moreanother 5 minutes in the oven

Good local pizza and subs. Clean, well maintained restaurant. Nice place for family & friends.read more

Ordered the Chicken Alfredo bake. Lots of cheese and even came with some garlic bread. Order this…read moreif you're really hungry, you won't be disappointed. Owners are nice and very helpful. Try it out soon.

Small town Pizza place from St. Joe, has found a new home in Butler, and I am one happy guy!…read more Finally another sitdown option is available, and I don't have to order pizza from a gas station! Rumor is there may be a possible beer/wine option in the future! BONUS!! Ordered carryout, but when I walked in to pick it up, I saw lots of seating options. They even put in a small stage? Possible future events are in the works? The menu is full of school/football themed names. Absolutely love it! The staff was very friendly and the service was spot on. Order was ready when I arrived 5-minutes early. I ordered a small The Hot Route; chicken, hot sauce, and banana peppers. Delicious. Wife had their Cavatini. Awesome. Order of bread sticks with cheese was the perfect appetizer. And their beer cheese was absolutely great!! This is their first review and I want to get this new to Butler place started strong! Very happy with everything! I will definitely be back! Just imagine when they have an ice cold beer to offer as well. Great job Cheesy Does It!

Definitely worth trying if you haven't. Sausage roll was better than Oleys and Redwood Inn in Fort…read moreWayne which they say is the best in town.

Pizza subs are awesome. Service is great, Only problem is it's hard to find them open!read more

We went for lunch first time I had wings and they were hot on out side but when I bit into second…read moreone the bone was ice cold on my lips and looked and it was pink! Ask waitress if these just came out of freezer and she said yes. We had heard so many saying how good they were. Told her to tell cook....