Went in to buy a piece of plain cheesecake to go. Very nice assortment of cheesecakes available, so I'll try some other flavor next time, like the Biscoff. Slice was a nice size and absolutely delicious. Creamy, moist, perfect!This was my first visit there and it won't be my last. Recommended. read more

There were 8 of us for dinner. My brother is here from California so he wanted some Gyro and disco fries. We ordered three Gyro platters with disco fries one regular meat Jairo with disco fries, one regular Gyro with a side salad ,chicken franchise with chicken matzoh ball soup. A side order of corn, beef, hash, and matzoh ball soup. I'm gonna start with the soup. The matzoh ball soup was so salty. It was really unbearable to eat. Even with the extra hot water to add to the soup, it was still salty. The three of us who ordered the Gyro platter Enjoyed it very much. There were five strips of Giro meat and 4/4 of pita bread. The salad was very good all the lettuce, cucumber, tomatoes, or fresh. And the rice wrap in grape leaves was not that bad as well. My brother who had a regular Gyro meat sandwich loved it. He polished it and enjoyed it very much. The disco fries were so good. It's been a long time since we had disco fries. We asked for extra gravy because the platter of disco fries was so much that the gravy was not enough. The gravy was OK. It tasted more like powdered gravy mix. My mom had corn beef hash on the side and it was very generous portion. It was actually huge for a side. She enjoyed it very much and she finished it easily. She did not complain about how salty the matzoh ball or chicken matzo ball was. As for the chicken franchise, it looked very appetizing, but the chicken was not tender. The lemon sauce was too thick and it could have been more thinner so it would've been more enjoyable. One of these. The Buffalo hot wings were really good. It was a little crunchy on the outside and nice and tender on the inside. read more

See all

We came here on a very early Saturday morning and it was very nice that they allowed us to reserve prior since we were a big group. The service was very nice, but I do have to mention that they add a 20% gratuity tip to groups bigger than four. I ordered an omelette with mushrooms, ham, cheese, and avocado. I have to say that this is my first time ever having an omelette where the avocado is not on top, but rather mixed in with the rest of the items inside the omelette; it was definitely not my preference and a very interesting way to add avocado to an omelette. OK, I ended up adding hot sauce to it to let it have some sort of flavor as it seems that they don't use any spices at all. The home fries were also only OK, they were very plain and they didn't have much flavor to them. Overall, there are much better diners in New Jersey, this one is nice as it is spacious, but the food really doesn't live up to that . read more

Randolph Diner Bar & Grill - Create Your Own Omelette - Diners Near Me - Randolph, New Jersey

It was 4th of July and you have a power outage, where do you do? To a Jersey Diner of course, but this is no regular Diner. First time visiting Randolph Diner and I was quite surprised how large and modern it is. While waiting was looking at their bakery display case has a ton of delicious dessert options. The wait time wasn't long (5-10 mins) for us to get called for our seating. The wait staff was friendly, quick, and attentive. We ordered their breakfast--had Eggs Benedict and an Omelette--it was all great. Definitely will return to taste some of their other items on the menu and leave some room for dessert. read more

Came here for lunch and servers are all standing around on their phone. My server only came over once right after the food got the table and then left without even letting us know she was leaving. Some other server brings the check and says here you go so I had to ask where our server went only to be told she was gone already. Extremely unprofessional. Normally I'm pro server but we sat there without getting drink refills and an MIA server. This place really needs to do better. Out of the 6 servers working there was maybe 1 that actually was checking up on his tables more than anyone. The food runner is great though so that's the one positive I can say about my experience today. read more

Went on a Sunday afternoon, very busy. Nice diner. We were greeted right away and a 10min wait. Waitress was good. I ordered avocado toast with eggs. It was ok, I've had better. On the other hand, my 2 guests loved there orders. Greek omelet and Jersey wrap. It also looks like a good spot for watching sports. Will definitely be back to try other foods. read more

Randolph Diner Bar & Grill - Avocado Toast - Diners Near Me - Randolph, New Jersey

Hey all! I've been going to the Randolph diner since I was a kid, prior to the renovations and beautification of their building. Probably 15+ years. I still remember it from when I was a teenager being quite different. The large interior gives this place an upscale feel, but the food maintains the diner status for sure - they have it all! I have never waited for a table longer than a few minutes, even with a group of 8, because of the amount of space. Parking can be tricky yes, but it proves that people keep coming back! Wait staff are friendly, though sometimes could use more training. I think it's tough when you have to have so many people working at once, but the food is really the focus here. I've gotten plenty of things off the menu but have a couple favorites: red velvet and chocolate chip pancakes, the waffle (with fruit, chicken, or however), vanilla milkshake, the fries (and brown gravy!), and the chicken finger panini or wrap. Very rarely am I disappointed with my meal - and usually it's something small and they are happy to make sure you have a good experience. Recently I tried their Moscow mule and loved that, too! I'm excited to continue exploring their menu and supporting Randolph Diner! read more

Randolph Diner Bar & Grill - Chicken Finger Wrap - Diners Near Me - Randolph, New Jersey

There is a reason why this yelp page is unclaimed by the Randolph Diner. When you have so many negative feedbacks and are caught scamming customers with frozen food, lousey service, and staff that think they are right when they do something wrong, you always run and hide. Walking into the place there's nothing wrong until the wait staff and food come. The food was frozen and reheated from a box, ordered the chicken parm sandwich and the chicken was so thick you couldnt even bit into it, and when you did frozen center! Instead of taking it off the bill, they only discounted it $3.00 for one bit taken into a frozen center, called my credit card company to dispute the bill and never bothered to sign the cc receipt of the bad food. Thats all you hear was nothing but excuses and not taking responsibility for anything. Walked into the place flies everywhere, flying onto the table, hanging across open doors, this is the table they brought us to, complete filth! read more

Randolph Diner Bar & Grill - Under our table. Complete pigs, they had no problem clearing the table and they knew the mess was there. Clear table to rip off someone else - Diners Near Me - Randolph, New Jersey

Pretty good dinner in the area. I do like the food selection and the gyro plate I got was really good. Service was quick and helpful. I like the diner setup and there is an event area upstairs if you do need to book a spot. read more

Randolph Diner Bar & Grill - Diners Near Me - Randolph, New Jersey

We've been getting food to go. My husband liked the Chicken Murphy. I like the French dip. I just wanted to update because I see improvement there. read more

I hate leaving bad reviews, but after the past 3-4 visits, I feel like I have to. Every time my brother and I come here, we get seated in a corner, and it feels like we're forgotten about. We've had to wait much longer than other tables just to be acknowledged or have someone check on us. From my experience, it seems like younger customers aren't treated the same as everyone else. We always try to be respectful, but it honestly feels like we're overlooked because of our age. Good service should be the same for every customer, regardless of how old they are. i am so disappointed with how this diner is the food is good but the service is absolute trash the waiters look at us like we just spit in their faces and it's disgusting how they treat us read more

Large menu including cocktails. Very good service. well prepared food. Good portion sizes. read more

Randolph Diner Bar & Grill - Cheddar burger with frizzled onions - Diners Near Me - Randolph, New Jersey

See all

We love their pork ribs and order them often in catering size when we go to get togethers. read more

Randolph Diner Bar & Grill - Local agent - Diners Near Me - Randolph, New Jersey

We had just finished dinner when my mother-in-law quietly mentioned that her chicken fajitas were extremely dry and inedible. As a result, she barely touched her meal. My mother-in-law is a very shy person and did not feel comfortable complaining during the meal, so we only became aware of the issue at the end. When we brought it to the server's attention, the manager/owner came to our table and immediately demanded to know why we had not complained earlier. Rather than handling the situation professionally, he put my mother-in-law on the spot and embarrassed her in front of the entire table. It was completely unnecessary and made an uncomfortable situation even worse. What was most disappointing was the apparent assumption that we were trying to get something for free. The manager's response claims that the meal was "half eaten," which is simply not true. Hardly any of the fajitas were touched, and anyone looking at the plate could clearly see that. Instead of acknowledging the issue, he attempted to portray us as dishonest customers looking for a discount. Mistakes happen in restaurants, and most people understand that. What matters is how those mistakes are handled. A simple apology and offer to make things right would have been appreciated. Instead, we were met with confrontation, accusations, and an embarrassing interaction directed at a guest who was already uncomfortable speaking up. This was a very disappointing experience and not how customers should be treated. read more

Met up for brunch. First time coming here and I heard only goods things even though their Yelp rating was mid. The place is not your average Jersey diner. It's got a contemporary look and with higher end decor. I was impressed. We sat at the bar and our server was eager to help. He got a Denver omelet with semi burned white toast. They put the burned side on the inside so upon presentation, it looked OK. He wasn't happy but he also wasn't gonna make a big deal about burned toast. I got the Crispy Chicken Sandwich with fries. Both delicious! The chicken was HUGE! In true diner fashion, the portions were enough for two meals for this big girl. The dessert case had me salivating but I was just so stuffed. Fruity Pebble cookies...one day! read more

See all

Spacious and modern dining establishment with an upstairs area (for private events I'm assuming) as well as bar/counter seating. Service is professional and not too pushy. Menu items contain the expected comfort foods from a diner (disco fries, Greek and Italian style dishes, burgers, sandwiches and breakfast items). The dessert case has an array of cakes and pies (all huge). We got a western omelette with home fries and pancakes. We also got a portion of plain French toast. Portions were generous. The omelette was very yummy (had plenty of onions, peppers and ham). The home fries were shredded potatoes that were perfectly browned and crispy on the outside. The pancakes were also big. The French toast had some crispness as well (with cinnamon flavor). Overall a great place for a filling meal for a good value. read more

Randolph Diner Bar & Grill - Western OmeletteWestern - Diners Near Me - Randolph, New Jersey

See all

I can't speak to service or ambiance because the food was delivered. I got the American cheeseburger sliders and fries during lunch time. I enjoyed the fries. The fries were crispy and fresh. The sliders were good, nothing spectacular. I do think it was a good portion size nonetheless. Seems like standard diner food. read more

Randolph Diner Bar & Grill - American burger sliders and fries ( comes with 4 sliders) - Diners Near Me - Randolph, New Jersey

Went for breakfast there this morning. The food was close to the worst I have ever had (and I am 72). Everything single thing had a rancid aftertaste. The eggs, home fires, Taylor ham, omelettes and French toast tasted like they were cooked with stale cooking oil. Even the carrot cake was disgusting. Also, their pricing is way out of line. I would never go back or recommend it to anyone. read more

So I thought it was okay to order a Greek salad with grilled chicken. I asked for extra dressing and was charged .50. No big deal except when I saw what looked like oil & vinegar and questioned it, I was told it's Greek dressing... the seasoning has settled. Well no it was just oil & vinegar. One stuffed grape leave for a salad that cost me $28? The chicken was rubbery so now I won't even trust this place for a salad. read more

Greeting at entrance not so friendly or embracing. The waiter's service was okay. The place looks really nice. You almost forget it's a diner. The calamari was delicious. Lightly cooked and with both sauce options. The chipotle was the fave. The red velvet pancakes were pretty good according to my other half. I would've just had the sausage for my breakfast platter. The bacon looked old. The pancakes were soggy under the eggs. The syrup was delicious though. We don't live nearby so it's really a top place I would take the long drive for. It was just somewhere new to try when we were in the area. To me it's just okay. read more

See all

What's with the hostesses?!?! They are the first people you see when you enter the diner; they're unwelcoming and unfriendly. They don't greet you when you come in nor do they smile. The entire experience throughout our meal is seeing these un-smiling and un-friendly hostesses as they seat other customers. It should be "Welcome to Randolph Diner". When you leave, "Thank you for coming, come again!". A simple greeting with a smile would go a long way. read more

OK, I keep trying this place and this is the last our server was very nice. My cocktail was nice. The food was absolutely horrendous. I had a cheesesteak wrap that had no flavor was disgusting. The potato salad was so sour. My husband's Panini was not edible. He just ate the chicken out of it. The manager took a couple dollars off of the check ridiculous this is the end. read more

Been a customer of this diner for many years last couple times we went we were unsatisfied, but due to the fact that we've been coming here for a while we figured we'd keep giving it another chance. However, today was our last and final day that will be coming here, this Steiner has taken a nose dive completely downhill, my wife had a cheesesteak wrap, and I had a chicken Portobello mushroom wrap they both came out horrible the potato salad they served with it was sour just so happens. The manager was passing by and asked us our meal was and we told him it was absolutely horrible. After being a customer for many many years he took off four dollars of the total bill, don't think that's any way to treat a reoccurring customer four dollars. What a joke we won't be coming back here read more

Have finally had it with this place. There are so many problems with this place with food, service, and the filth this place had, we simple decided to no longer spend our money or time on this place. Most of the people in there not all, are there to two face you to see how much money they can get from you. The food is frozen garbage made by people who have no clue on how to cook. Your paying rip off prices for garbage that flies land on. All this happens in plain view and they will lie to your face, say its not their problem, or tell managers that do nothing about it. There were flies around every where landing on our table at a door leading into a room, and even flying around the desert case. That's one main reason we stopped ordering deserts there. One week later after the waitress Wendy had stated she told the day time manager, nothing was cleaned. The last straw is when we walked into the place and saw both outside doors wide open. Great more flies welcomed. Turned out that a grown person went to the bathroom right on the floor in the middle of the dining room. Bottom line they don't care about anyone except your money, instead of taking care of problems, they deny it, make fake claims as saying that 40% of the negative feedback they received was for the sole purpose of people that didn't get free food. What a load! Were done with this nightmare! read more

The burger was so greasy the bun was almost non existent with that grease saturation making it fall apart. The fries were not crispy and just meh. The turkey wrap was as dry as a bone and not flavorful. Then we decided the desserts " looked good". The mocha layer cake was OLD. So dry and crumbley and you could tell it was refrozen and thawed and awful. Just a gross disappointing meal. I will never ever go back. read more

This place has grown from years ago. Very nice love the inside really nice. The food was very good competitive pricing read more

See all

Pork Chop Chablis $24 Exceptional. Very tasty "Daily Special". Breaded chop covered the plate. Very consistent quality. Service is always courteous and efficient. Very consistent quality. read more

Got extremely sick from unstinted fork. Ruined my memorial weekend down shore. Then my husband and daughter got sick from me. Manager very nasty to me. Refused to turn up hot water on dishwasher. Cheap jerks. Old folks or babies could die. read more

Gleaming clean. Service with a smile bright and and spacious. I ordered a tuna melt but it came open faced. Ugh. Not their fault. read more

Randolph Diner Bar & Grill - The dreaded hot tuna - Diners Near Me - Randolph, New Jersey

Is it fair to even call this place a diner? The food is way better than what I'd expect from a diner and the place has got a sleek, modern design. I loved sitting on the roofed patio, which allows you to enjoy the fresh air or sunlight, but also has shades and heaters so you're never uncomfortable. What I love about the menu is that the prices are perfect. Any other breakfast or brunch spot for the same food would charge you at least $10 more with food that's usually equal or inferior in quality. I also loved that the menu has some generous combo options. If you're like me, you've probably been frustrated with menus where you can't quite seem to get everything you want to try in one order, you gotta sacrifice at least one thing (unless you go to IHOP, but then you probably wouldn't be reading this anyway). With my Build Your Own Omlette, I was able to get pancakes and home fries on the side. Was it way too much food to eat in one sitting? Yeah. Did I love that I got to try it all? Hell yeah! For my tastes, all the food needed more flavor. That's not a huge issue at a breakfast spot since I gotta add tobasco or some other hot sauce to my breakfast food anyway. The omelette was huge, came with generous portions of spinach, mushroom, and roasted red peppers that I ordered. It was cooked to be just the right amount of fried and fluffy. Would recommend! Similarly, the pancakes were serviceably fluffy and cooked just right. Bottom line, this isn't a gourmet brunch spot where you're gonna eat something that's gonna blow your mind, but if you're looking for a nice place to hang out with friends and family for breakfast, then you can definitely expect to get great tasting food that will be worth your money and very friendly/fast service at the Randolph Diner. read more

Randolph Diner Bar & Grill - Diners Near Me - Randolph, New Jersey

Diners are always tricky as they have so many options available, that I feel they are never specialized on anything so everything is ok. The place is family friendly, as they give you coloring paper and crayons when you get in there. The kids menu options are pretty good, but the dishes are just ok. Had spaghetti meatballs from the kids menu and the sauce tasted like pre-made and the meatballs had nothing special. I had the farmer's omelette and it was good, played safe as I feel is hard to go wrong with eggs overall. Service was nice, everyone pretty friendly. read more

See all

Since moving to Randolph, the diner has been one of our go to places as it's close to where we live. However, service and food quality has began to decline. The last few times we've gone it's been a waiting game waiting for our waiter/waitress to come back after taking our orders for meals. This past Thursday we went and we barely sat down and the waiter asked what we wanted to drink- we hadn't even had a chance to look at a menu. He came back shortly and had to ask that he come back as we were still looking at the menu and seemed annoyed. After giving my drink order he went to take the drink menu and I asked that he leave it because I still wanted to look at it. Again seemed annoyed at this request. For the amount of money the diner charged their food quality has seem to go down over the last couple years. Also not sure what is happening in the kitchen as the last few times our orders have come out wrong or over done or with the paper still on the hamburger that keeps them separate when buying in bulk. The chicken tenders are not what they used to be not sure if they switched their distributor but they used to be so much better. Chicken quesadilla can also use more cheese. Mozzarella sticks are they only thing that have maintained consistency. At this point don't waste your money on mixed drinks at the diner. They're usually just whatever the mixer is. We got margaritas the other night and it was pretty much just pineapple juice I was drinking. The drinks also used to be much better and have also gone down hill. Surprisingly their cheesecake was actually very good. Nice and creamy and fresh. Most diners don't seem to have fresh cakes and desserts due to sitting in the fridge. read more

See all

No doubt the Randolph Diner is popular. Full parking lot - the place was jammed. Tuna melt was sizable and good. In fact all orders were plentiful. Service was fair as one particular order arrived wrong. Standard Diner Experience... read more

Place is genuinely beautiful inside but for some odd reason 90% of the staff are genuinely miserable and lazy every time I've come during the afternoon they are so miserable but most of the food is pretty quality as well. read more

Service was friendly and our orders were correct. I had the California wrap and it was very good. The fries were delicious and crispy. My daughter had a cheeseburger and said it was tasty. Portion sizes were huge. We took home half of our meals and happily ate them for lunch the next day. The woman's bathroom could have been cleaner. read more

Randolph Diner Bar & Grill - Cheesesteak wrap - Diners Near Me - Randolph, New Jersey

See all

The first time I reviewed this place was over a decade ago-before their renovations. Over the past 5 years or so I've probably eaten here at least once every two months and it's always great. It's also usually pretty busy, but I've never had to wait for a table...a parking spot maybe, but not a table. We usually come here for either breakfast or lunch, but regardless of WHEN you come, you won't leave hungry. Yeah, it's a little pricey, but their portions are pretty big. For lunch or dinner I can usually pull two meals from an order. They also have a liquor license here so if you want to hang out in the bar area and watch a game...you can. There are. Lot of great diners around Morris County, but Randolph Diner is our go-to. read more

Service is efficient and the staff is friendly and food is okay and environment is clean

Not as bad as a 2.9, it's a decent local diner, but it looks better than it is, prices higher than they should be, but it's not a place to stay away from. The food isn't bad, and service is just ok. read more

Pains me to write this, because I enjoy the atmosphere. However, the front server is not very friendly. And the past two visits there have been flies on the divider adjacent to the booths. So much so that my family lost our appetite and just paid and left. This is not what one wants to see while eating a meal. To top it off, the strawberries provided to our table were literally rotted. How can anyone send out brown and rotted strawberries? Terrible. Won't be back. read more

Very disappointed. First time here I won't be coming back. I will give 5 stars to our waiter. I ordered filet of sole and it came out raw. My husband ordered chicken Franchese it had no flavor and it was tuff. read more