Stopped by and picked up a cheese pizza and a Cooper beef sandwich to take home. Highly recommend that sandwich, it was huge & delicious!! One of my favorite food items I've ever gotten there. read more

Great find on road trip. Nothing fancy about this place but service was quick and accurate and the food was very, very good. Cheesesteaks! Philly style but a bit different as these tend to be anywhere more than 30 miles outside of the city. But really good with housemade roll and generous amount of high quality steak. Pizza looked excellent as well. read more

The place is warm beautiful and such a great family that own it. They always talk to their customers. Randazzos we love you! The food is top of the line. read more

Was in town for an event close by and was craving some good PA pizza as I am originally from PA. Did a search on yelp for Grandmas pizza and found this place. Pizza was cooked perfectly. Plum sauce was just sweet enough without being overly sweet. Large slices and nice crust. Also bought some dessert - chocolate peanut butter cake was amazing. Staff was friendly and while I only visited the checkout area, the location and inside seemed nice. read more

Randazzo's Pizza - Square Grandma's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Lancaster, Pennsylvania

I ordered a special pizza not normally made and they were the only ones that would make it for me. Let me tell u they outdid themselves. It was the best pizza I've ever had, and it was their first time making it. Amazing read more

Everything is always delicious here Recommend the chicken cheesesteak and of course the pizza! read more

You order from a menu with no prices on the wall. I had to use a paper menu on counter. After placing my order for Stromboli, sandwich and breaded cauliflower at 39.99 was told if I used a card there would be a fee. Plus they asked for a tip onscreen (which I felt strong armed to pay another 5.17. I was already being totally ripped off. Then...the food. What a disappointment. My sub was oily, tasted off. Cauliflower was cardboard flavor. While 8 ate this or half of it, my husband waited....and waited and finally after 1/2 hour his lukewarm Stromboli that we paid 14.00 for finally was brought to us. It was not good. This was an unhappy experience nobody was in this restaurant which was freezing cold...I had to keep my coat on. Never returning. read more

Love this place! A dozen years ago this used to be a Mennonite Farm store. After the farm sold the surrounding farm this became an Italian Pizzeria and Restaurant. The owner's also own Roma Pizzeria in downtown Lititz. The dad runs Roma and the Son's run Randazzo. The usual Pizza and Sandwich fare is great. Sandwich bread is a choice between Philly rolls or fresh homemade pizza dough bread. But the real surprise is Randazzo's Pasta specials. They're amazingly great. You wouldn't expect this from a Pizzeria/Sandwich shop. I'm dead serious. The Veal Piccata is my favorite!!!!!! Stop in and give the Pasta specials a try! Excellente Delicioso!!!!! read more

The best pizza in Lancaster. Don't be afraid to try their gluten free pie. It's delicious! Other favorites are their eggplant parm sandwich and salted caramel cheesecake. Great service. Owners are kind and know their customers. Highly recommend! read more

Hot traditional wings were great along with the boneless garlic parm wings. Some of the best around. The pizza could be cooked a little more but not bad. read more

Decided to try takeout from here last night. There is no other word to describe this place other than "okay". Nothing stood out to us as being great, yet nothing was bad either. I did like that the pizza has a very thin crust. The sauce and cheese ratio was great, however our pepperoni pizza was abnormally greasy in my eyes. My husband ordered a chicken panini, and he felt there wasn't enough "stuff" in it - which resulted in it being pretty bland. The one thing we both were pleasantly surprised with was the corn nuggets appetizer. They tasted like little balls of delicious corn fritters and came with honey for dipping. They were really great! Considering the price of everything (which was low), I wouldn't rule out coming back here. I'd like to try some of their Italian dinners, as I have heard they are pretty good. I wish I could give half stars, because this place is a solid 3.5 out of 5. Not the worst I've ever had, but also not the greatest. read more

I hate leaving negative reviews, but, this pizza was so bad. We ordered a gluten free pizza and the Randazzo's special pizza. They were both honestly the worst pizzas we've tasted in years. Everything tasted bland from the meats, vegetables, cheese, sauce, to the crust. The red sauce tasted like they had spread store bought tomato paste on the crust. The crust had an unpleasant texture and very bland taste. We tossed most of it because it was just horrible in every way. Sorry Randazzo's, but, the pizzas we had were just terrible. read more

Fresh, delicious food. Amazing service all the time. Always enjoy the bruschetta and the Godfather sub.

The food is amazing! Far beyond the typical pizza shop, Randazzo's has great Italian pasta dishes too. They also have catering. We have never been disappointed. The pizza is the best around. We also recommend the Antipasto salad (generous portion of meat and cheese) and the cheeseburger sub (our family's favorite). Service is warm and friendly. Highly recommend! read more

We just stopped there after picking up a car. The quality of the pizzas are very good. Not as greasy as is common with a lot of places in the US. Would definitely come back here if occasion grants. read more

Very Rude on the phone, would not take an order, I tried using website, website would not accept my phone number i have used for 5 years

The people here are super friendly. The restaurant is always clean and pleasant. While they have a large menu I haven't sampled much of it. It's impossible for me to order anything other than their eggplant parmigiana. Love it!!!! read more

Came here late one evening and it looked like the place was ready to close up for the night. The waitress eased our concerns and proceeded to serve up a delicious Grandma pie, complete with pesto drizzle. Two of us split a medium and it was more than enough with extra to go. Worth the stop in you're in the area. read more

Randazzo's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Lancaster, Pennsylvania

The pizza is the best and they make one of the best Italian Subs around. Service is great and staff is friendly.

Verdict: Like the name, Randazzo's isn't quite grand but it's far from getting a razz. My pizza slice offered a good tasting cheese and the sauce blended nicely. The dough was thin and decent overall but nothing special after you get past the cheese. The chicken cheesesteak had good bread and sauce. The meat had some lower quality moments but the price is pretty competitive so maybe that's the trade-off. I'd get one again. It's a comfortable place inside the restaurant and the location provides easy access to the highway. (That is, until they start that upcoming construction.) I hope this place lasts if they choose the 283 exit for a long while. It'll be up to the locals. read more

We got a couple of things: 1. Generic fried wings, flavor was ok nothing fancy 2. Knots - pretty disappointing. Taste like a dinner roll covered in butter and garlic. I would be surprised if they make these themselves. 3. They call it brick oven pizza. The pizza has no crisp to it. It's pretty floppy, not much grease and the sauce is a little sweet but that's a Lancaster county thing. Staff is very friendly and the place is clean. read more

Randazzo's Pizza - Knots - Pizza Near Me - Lancaster, Pennsylvania

We placed a large order for our field hockey team online about an hour before they closed. Pizza, salads, chicken fingers, etc. Staff was super friendly. We did not eat there but did takeout. The restaurant looked cute. The grandmom's pizza was so good. Would def stop back when near Spooky Nook again. read more

Service is a 10/10 the food was amazing and tasted so fresh and the food is a 10/10 I highly recommend it

Pizza ok. Kitchen wearing masks... around their chins. They don't work too good around your chins, people. Prob not returning.

Anyone who reads my reviews on the regular knows I'm not a fan of pizza joints. Rarely do I patronize them and when I do it's to get a sub or salad. But when Randazzo's opened nearby I was excited to have a new eatery in this neck of the woods where good take out is scarce. I passed the building every day during the renovation and couldn't image that they could transform the place the way they did. In it's former life it was an older farmers market type store - very dated with a barn like exterior. While the exterior is the same the inside is pure Tuscany, and I hear they did the work themselves. Kudos for a job well done! They have dine in waitress service and also take out. We dined in a few times when they first opened and service was horrible. I think since than they've worked out the kinks. The owner is young but he comes from a family with a well known pizza business in Lititz. His whole family is on hand to help ensure his success. They're a friendly bunch and make you feel welcome. Often when it was slow we'd see the employees dining together as a family which was nice. Teamwork, pride, and a quality product make this place successful. Since I'm not a fan of pizza I will tell you they make some good wraps and were always happy to tweak them to my liking - extra this, that, and a good press to make sure they're warm and toasty. I'm also a huge fan of their broccoli bites preferring an order of ranch dressing to the marinara they serve with it. Try it and you'll be a fan too! Subs are made on their homemade bread - which is a little too soft for me, which I why I appreciate that they give you the choice. Portion sizes are adequate and orders always come out fast. The place is also spotless. On your way out check the little refrigerated display by the door - I've had one too many of the delicious desserts they feature. Yum! read more

This was a lil town gem we found! Amazing Italian food!the dinners are generally priced and the food is great quality and the dinners come with a side salad and bread stick and THIS is the "side" salad and "breadstick!" The portions are huge and the garlic bread is made fresh and hot, it is sssooo good! I highly recommend this lil place!!! read more

Randazzo's Pizza - Great quality and prices! Large portions - Pizza Near Me - Lancaster, Pennsylvania

First time customer. Will definitely be back! Ordered a tuna wrap. It was delicious! Wasn't all sloppy even with extra mayo. Was right on point for having to eat on the road. Service was super friendly and fast too!! read more

So this place just recently opened. I will be honest, this place is very nice. However, there is a reason it's not perfect. My mother and I went here to try it and we were satisfied. I mean, it is another run of the mill pizza shop like Venice or Ruffinos, but the inside reminds me Rino's in Manheim. We went in, and saw that most of the staff there were eating their lunch, maybe it's a bit over staffed? We ordered, and I got the Pasta Carbonara. What I liked about it, I was able to choose what pasta to put in it. This was a special on the chalkboard, but what was failed to be mentioned was the price, which my mother was shocked when she got her bill. What I did like was they gave mom the bigger sandwich by mistake, but they only charged her for the smaller one. So she had some lunch for the next day. I do like this place and plan to eat here again when I can. read more

Another fantastic meal prepared by the Randazzo family! The service was great and the food was fresh and wonderful! Love that it's BYOB! read more

Randazzo's Pizza - Vodka Fargalla with shrimp!! - Pizza Near Me - Lancaster, Pennsylvania

Best pizza around, hands down! The sauce is definitely sweeter than others but it is very good and doesn't taste like every other pizza joint around town. This is owned by the same owners of Roma Pizza in Lititz. I'm very excited I don't have to drive up to Lititz every time I need a slice. The subs are very good as well. There is a lot of bread and could use a little more meat but the bread is tasty so I don't mind. read more

Food is made fresh every time one of the best Italian places In the area I highly recommend the pastas homemade the appetizers are delicious and the staff is even better don't waste your time with any other place but this place if you visit the Lancaster area read more

Went there for the first time Friday night. Ordered pizza, wings and a Chicken Cheesesteak. Service was very good. You can tell this place is new and still trying to figure things out. Cheesesteak came out first. Then the wings - we ordered first as an appetizer. We ordered HOT. Wing sauce was average at best and limited. They do give you a dozen - the way it should be! Our son got the Cheesesteak and he said it was very good and the roll was fresh. My wife and I split a Cheese Pizza. Pizza was slightly undercooked. Dough was not crispy at all. Cheese was good. Sauce was sweet. I think they use the same sauce for their dinners. Too sweet for pizza sauce. On another note the decor is nice but the lighting is weird. It may work during the day but they are way too bright for the evening. They look like gym lights. It really makes for a weird atmosphere. I really want to like this place but some changes are definitely needed. It's got potential. We will go back but I think takeout subs will be our next order. read more

Randazzo's Pizza - Menu - Pizza Near Me - Lancaster, Pennsylvania

We visited from out of town and this place hit the spot. Very friendly service and delicious food! Definitely recommend.

Absolutely horrible, mess up my order twice, also messed up my co worker order as well, would not recommend to anyone, complete waste of your time and money. They suck and I asked for my money back. read more

Very tasty food and clean atmosphere. The staff is friendly. Got the garlic knots and a pizza.

We are always pleased with the food and service here. We have only gotten pizza and strombolis, but both have been outstanding. The portions are generous, you won't leave hungry! read more

Hands down the best pizza in the area bar none. I'm a transplanted New Yorker so pizza is a passion for me and the pie at Randazzo's is excellent. The sauce is slightly sweet and all the ingredients are very tasty. Joe is super nice and always friendly. The sandwiches are very good and my wife loves the garlic knots! Give Joe and his crew a try for your next pizza night or Italian craving. You won't be disappointed. read more

Nice place for pizza, we have gotten their cheese pizza and the grandmas pizza. The grandmas is our favorite. We have yet to try any subs or pasta but we will be back for those. read more

The pizza has a hint of sweetness that gives it a really good flavor. A little bit on the greasy side, but still one of the best pizzas we've tried in the Lancaster area so far. We will definitely be ordering from Randazzo's again! read more

A surprisingly good spot for pizza and pasta. The owner was very friendly and the place looked clean. We had two take out pizzas and they were both excellent. Give this spot a try instead of hot Z, they make a better pizza. read more