Pie in the Sky did the catering for my daughter's baby shower in May of 2025. From my 1st telephone call with the owner and the subsequent calls with the manager, the service was friendly, professional, and very accommodating! The food was on time, made with care, and absolutely mouth-watering delicious. As the Grandmom to be, I was thrilled that we decided to use Pie in the Sky for this event. I would highly recommend. Thanks Guys!! read more

Absolutely the best!!! We got a pepperoni Sicilian pizza with extra cheese. It was the best as always!!!

This place has mastered the cheese steak and the Italian hoagie. The best local sandwich shop in Lancaster! Let's start with the toasted Amaroso carefully layered with thinly sliced meats, cheese, lettuce, tomatoe, with hots on the side ... a two hander, dressed the way you want! Oil, mayo, or sauce on your cheese steak A working man's quick stop. Call ahead and it'll be waiting for you or grab a chair and enjoy iin house. Service and presentation the best! Check the varied menu for other options. Great place, one of my favorites. read more

The best pizza in lancaster Everything is excellent! The staff is friendly,treat you like family. Service is fast. It's my local pizza and sandwich shop- read more

The pizza and service were excellent! I would eat here again if I'm in the area. Prices were reasonable too.

Mild wing sauce is terrible, nothing but grease no flavor. Would not get the wings. Also one of the wings had most of the meat missing. read more

Pie in the Sky - Chicken wing - Italian Near Me - Lancaster, Pennsylvania

We used to eat here a-lot! Its gone down hill since they had a new guy making the Pizza. Its not nearly as good. Its chewy and has no flavor! Still love these guys and hope they can make it better! They do alot for the community! read more

We are new to the area and looking for our go to pizza place. Everyone needs one. Pie, etc. was okay. The crust was "okay." The sauce was "okay." So was everything else. It seems they are happy being the little neighborhood pizza joint. So, it is about average. Still looking... read more

I was up in Lancaster visiting my Girlfriends parents so we stopped in here to grab takeout. I had an Italian hoagie and we also grabbed an anti pasta salad. The inside is small but it was extremely clean and organized. There were several family members working that night and it was fun to see them argue. I'm not sure what language they were speaking but it reminded me of the pizza shops in Philly. The hoagie was pretty good but the salad wasn't that great. They put pickled veggies in with all the meat and they mix in the salad dressing. The veggies were horrible and they don't put too much lettuce in the salad. I read that this place has great New York style pizza so I'll grab one next time we are in the area and write an update to this review. read more

Being a New Yorker you appreciate a good Pizza. I also love there subs and calzones (Stromboli ) read more

Love these guys! Always glad to see you, always on time with your order! The subs are fresh and stuffed with fresh meats and cheese and clean crisp veggies! Special orders don't upset them, always helpful with suggestions! Watching them all work together to get the job done is a true joy! Bravo PITS! read more

One of the best Pizza in town. Friendly staff. Good food. read more

Pie in the Sky - Full Menu - Italian Near Me - Lancaster, Pennsylvania

Pizza is all this writer needs. It's a pizza shop claiming NY style. First stop it. Nothing out here is close to any style from NY. The pizzas here trash. All fit on one hand. Service. Trash. Also ambiance trash. It would help if there was a good guard over the counter. The pizzas sit on a counter and all I had to do was sneeze and it was have been contaminated. Get a counter shield read more

Love his place.. great pizza and grilled chicken salad-always fresh! But most importantly the guys here are so friendly and take good care of you! read more

The closest to New York pizza! Love the entire crew! Everyone in there is so friendly... my kids love this place and food. if you want good food without spending so much, THIS IS THE PLACE TO GO! You ROCK "PIE IN THE SKY" read more

When we visit our family in Lancaster, PA for the weekend we always require them to get takeout from Pie in the Sky at least once while we are there. The food is so comforting and always consistently prepared. We have never had a bad takeout experience. Our favorites are the chicken cheesesteak, buffalo chicken cheese steak, tuna sub, pepperoni and sausage pizza, lasagna and baked ziti. The lasagna and baked ziti are huge portions and so good. Very cheesy and we love the sauce. The bread and side salad are also very nice to make a complete meal. The sweet peppers and the fresh tomatoes on the salad have a good flavor profile. Food is always well packaged and well made. Service is always friendly and efficient. Sometimes it may take a few repeat calls to get through to place your order but then you know that you are ordering from a popular place. It is great to be able to support such a nice small business that has consistently good Italian food at a great price point. That is why we always make sure we stop by when we are in the area. Highly recommend. read more

New to living in Lancaster and have been looking for "our pizza place". Location is perfect for us, and the Sicilian is delicious!! Restaurant is clean and staff friendly. SADLY.... they offer delivery, but through Door Dash. When we had our favorite Sicilian delivered, a regular pie came in its place. Pie in the Sky didn't take responsibility, telling us it wasn't there fault we got the wrong pie.!!! We cringed are this! Very poor customer service. Customers should be told to pick up themselves if they want guarantee of getting the correct food....... not sure if we'll go back due to this back to our search..... read more

If you want great pizza from a family owned business with a small town vibe, this is your place! I live a bit away and have tons of pizza shops within the block, but my husband and I stopped here on the way home one evening to check it out. We were warmly greeted by the owner and his family. The restaurant is small, very bright and the cleanest pizzeria I have ever seen. We ordered a mushroom NY style pizza and cheese fries. The pizza was wonderful! It was hand tossed with a very dense and chewy crust (my favorite), the sauce was perfect and there was no skimping on the cheese. The second time we stopped, we picked up a Sicilian style pizza. It was HUGE and just as good as the other pizza. Lots of doughy, cheesy goodness. I was full after one slice (but went on to eat a second for good measure). The owner remembered us and it was only our second time there! I hope to try a cheesesteak sometime. Someone had one made while I was waiting for my pizza, and it looked and smelled awesome. The subs and steaks were huge. Check this place out! In my opinion, they have the best pizza in Bridgeport. read more

Friendly staff and really good pizza. My favorite place locally to get a Sicilian slice.

Mediocre sandwiches and pizza. Great location for locals, but for the rest keep driving.

We've tried several dishes from there several times and everything has been good. Kids are fan of the spaghetti and meatballs. I like the cheesesteak stromboli. My wife and I both like the cheesesteaks and chicken cheesesteaks. The pizza is of course tasty. I will say we always take out, never eat in. read more

This place is OK but nothing to get excited about. Owners and,staff are friendly but the food, including the pizza is mediocre. Drive a little further for a better experience. read more

After a long day of shopping at the Tanger Outlet on a Sunday, I was craving Italian food for dinner. Trying to order takeout was unsuccessful as Olive Garden (not my first choice) estimated a 3 hour wait for pick-up, and my first choice- Luca was short staffed and only doing dine-in with no current availability! Out of desperation, I choose Pie in the Sky based on yelp reviews (mainly for pizza) and it far exceeded my expectations. I ordered the chicken alfredo dinner platter and it was the best I have ever had! Service was quick, it was ready in less than 20 mins and was piping hot, with a creamy, flavorful sauce that was oh so delectable. The pasta was cooked to perfection and the chicken was tender and juicy- grilled first which was nice as it added extra flavor. It was served with a generous portion of fresh warm bread. Their side tossed salad was equally fresh and complemented the meal perfectly. Days later, I am still basking in the afterglow of the perfect meal. Never have I been happier to find an alternative dining option, I can't wait to go back again to try their other offerings! read more

My favorite south Lancaster pizza place. Great thin crust pizza. Subs are great too. Staff is very friendly. Great place to enjoy a meal. read more

I've passed by this place a dozen times, without ever stopping in and finally decided to give it a try. We had AMAZING cheesesteaks - at a great price. Amaroso rolls, with good quality ribeye steaks and copious amounts of cheese -- I'll definitely be back. The pizza looked delicious too - I'll have to give that a try! read more

My family loves their pizza. Family owned, and very friendly. We love eating here.

I often order lunch from Pie in the Sky. We always get the Sicilian pizza, and it is always delicious. Perfect doughiness and delicious cheese. Try it with sausage and sweet peppers for an extra treat!! read more

One of the best NY style pizza places in Lancaster. As someone who grew up in Brooklyn, I know pizza and this is the real deal. The people who are giving this place bad reviews do not know what they are talking about and are most likely from one of the other crappy pizza joints that want this place to fail. Everyone I have told this place about loves the pizza and subs here. read more

These people seriously need to take hoagie lessons but after relaying my sandwich (cheese, cold cuts, tomato/onion/lettuce) it was very tasty read more

Foods great my family and I love eating here everything is made to order and never disappoints I definitely have recommended to my family to come and eat here as well read more

Pie in the Sky has definitely become one of my favorite places to get a pizza. It is absolutely fantastic. The pizza is very good and easily blows any of the pizza chains out of the water. Everything that I've ever had here was very good. The staff are friendly and the prices are very reasonable. I love Pie in the Sky. read more

Really good pizza, on par with Pasquale's and two cousins. Also like the cheese steak. A few tables for eating in, but mostly it's a take out place. Not much in 20oz cokes - buy those at turkey hill next door. read more

Got the spaghetti dinner which came with a salad and bread. The bread was the best part. The salad was so-so and the spaghetti with meatsauce was extremely bland and the noodles overcooked. Very friendly staff, you can feel the family vibe. Maybe their pizza is better but will not go back for the pasta. read more

We were wandering around town last night, not sure of how to find some good local pizza, and we called these guys 5 minutes before closing. They gave us great directions, helped with the menu over the phone, were super polite and patient, and had hot pizza and breaded wings waiting for us when we got there. I can't really ask for more. Family-run businesses rock! Good job, guys. :) read more

Closest thing to New York pizza I've had in P.A. It's the real thing. Fresh, cheesy,crispy and tasty.