Pie in the Sky

I'm no Alton Brown, who famously raved about this place, but this is just a quick note to Leeann…read moreand Taylor and their amazing teams at Luca. I dined there yesterday, Sunday, September 20th, and I can't say enough about the great service. Big smiles, polite discussion with us, everything. Kelly waited on us at Luca and she was fantastic. We enjoyed the burrata and the focaccia as starters, so delicious. I had the ravioli in the sun gold tomato sauce and loved it, and my husband loved the Sunday meatballs. For dessert, Affogato has long been my favorite dessert whenever I see it on a menu. Luca's is one of the best I've had. My husband loved the olive oil cake with the blackberry jam! This is a beautiful restaurant with comfortable seating and while buzzing with energy, not so loud that we couldn't chat over our meals. Lancaster is indeed lucky to have such a great fine dining restaurant!

This was such a fantastic meal, with Housemade pasta, sauces, and ingredients. My friend and I were…read morelucky enough to get a seat by the kitchen, so we enjoyed watching the chef's hard at work! One of the chefs even gave each of us a small tasting plate during our meal, which was such a fun and intimate gesture for this space! We absolutely loved both of the pasta dishes we got. Everything tasted amazing, and so incredibly fresh!! We ordered an appetizer of the bread to start with, this was the only disappointing part of the meal to me. The bread was very crusty, which is not my preference, I was expecting soft bread to dip into the sauces. The flavor of the sauces on the side were excellent. I would definitely come back here. If I lived near this location, the ambience is casual, yet it gives fine dining vibes with the quality of food! The service was great as well, and we really appreciated them fitting us in on a busy Saturday night!!

Reception counter

Burrata

See all

Crowd

Valentino's Cafe

4.2(26 reviews)

3.3 mi

Really, really, not good. Ambiance was horrible…read more It was attached to a bar, and was very low class.

Nice chill place if you're a regular. But if you're someone who doesn't frequent there every week…read moreand they don't recognize you. Be ready to wait for a drink! The bartender clearly plays favoritism with the regulars. I waited 35 minutes for one cocktail after she (the bartender) looked at me 4 times and continued to serve people who just walked in!

Garlic bread

Ravioli with meat sauce

See all

Garlic bread pizza

Pasquale's Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria

4.0(284 reviews)

1.1 mi

Gave this place another chance after a while…read more Allergen info: they do offer GF crust and dairy free cheese Food- pizza has been solid the 2 recent times we have gotten it. Love the old world pepperoni option. Offer all the regular toppings. Lancaster doesn't have many good pizza options and I'd say this is one of the better ones

I only get subs here. They are packed with meat and cheese. I also only get the Italian. The…read morerolls are firm on the outside and very moist and soft inside. I believe a half sub can be eaten by 2 people. Although you can eat inside the Italian restaurant and they have unbelievable deals, we just get the sub to go. The owner is always friendly and engages in a chat everytime. Pasquale's I will Be Back

Fish tank. Kiddos will enjoy this!

Homemade Meatballs with Melted Cheese - meatball sub and a side of marinara sauce, "to-go"

See all

Front of business

Lombardo's Restaurant

3.2(218 reviews)

2.8 mi

So this was a very nice restaurant, fantastic hosting and good service. Overall I would rate this…read morea 4 because the veal with spaghetti came out cold. When we asked them to heat it up, they did, but it was warm and still the same amount. You think they would give you a new plate after serving you a cold plate. So a little disappointed with that, otherwise the food was good, not great.

Food 5 stars- service 1 So 3 stars is all I could give and…read moreit is ALL BECAUSE OF THE SERVICE- beyond horrible! Started off good enough hostess was gracious and wished us a happy anniversary- Server was cold, distant and seemed annoyed to be there- We ended up starting with the Classic CAPRESE- yes basic but when done correctly amazing- this was done correctly! I ordered the Cod Special which was excellent. Added a side of rigatoni nice but $10 seemed a little pricey. My wife had the Parpadelle Bolognese which she enjoyed. Problem was the tables around sat empty and dirty for far too long. When our entrees arrived our caprese plates were never cleared nor were we offered any additional bread- Half way through our meal the server shows up- "how was the first bite"- REALLY?? Never offered to pour our wine and had ZERO personality. Food was very good so would consider returning BUT- when you are charging premium prices it's the overall experience you expect which Sarah P was far from delivering.

Ambiance

Mamma Mia

See all

Very clean lines and Italian feel inside

Ciro's Italian Bistro

3.5(275 reviews)

6.8 mi

Everything was wonderful Food was a good portion size and…read moretasted amazing Our server was fantastic Definitely recommend

Ordered the fettuccini alfredo with chicken and asked to add spinach. They are so great about…read morecustomizing your dishes there! Ate on the patio and finished it off with gelato. Have been dining here for 14 years and it is our absolute favorite spot in Lancaster County.

Mangotini and key lime martini

See all

Peanut butter gelato

Capricio's

4.4(118 reviews)

3.5 mi

Great costumer service! Wonderful family friendly atmosphere. Owner and wife kept coming over to…read moreask how the meal was and how they could serve us better. Food was amazing. My husband and I had the manicotti and the chicken ziti. Portion size is larger than I thought and the prices are reasonable. Our meals also included a house salad and garlic knots. Everything was made quick, fresh ,and tasted wonderful. Overall my husband and I walked out paying $26. You really can't beat the price. Highly recommend this restaurant if you are in the area.

We were visiting from out of town and came here for some pizza and salad. Our hotel was close, the…read moreratings were high so we figured this would be a great place to go for some pizza. The slices they had out looked terrible and I should have walked away at that point. I ordered a margarita pie and my wife got a salad. She said her salad was disgusting and she hardly ate it. I wasn't impressed with the pizza either. The sauce was very plain. There was barely any cheese and the crust was a little too floppy for my liking.

Eggplant Parmigiana Sub

See all

Outside of the restaurant

Fiorentino's

3.2(226 reviews)

6.9 mi

I sat outside at a table on the patio. Everything was…read moregreat, the service and the food!

We stopped in for dinner before a movie. I got the smash burger and my wife got the fish over…read morerisotto. Both of our meals were OK. I wouldn't return for either one of them, but I didn't hate them either. Our service was fine in the ambience was just OK. Overall, I will be looking for another place to dine next time.

A little attention to detail would really help this place more hospitable.

Loved this gem! Watch planes take off and enjoy a beach bar-meets-Italian vibe

See all

Carrabba's Italian Grill

3.3(143 reviews)

3.8 mi

We were in Lancaster for 4th of July and stayed at Eden resort. Carrabbas was just across the road…read moreso gave it a shot. What a pleasant surprise. Reminded me of Olive Garden in some regards. Great menu with big portions and good prices. I had steak and shrimp combo and it was phenomenal - garlic mash was yummy and roasted vegetables solid. Side salad was size of full salad elsewhere. Great value. Wife went for fettuccine Alfredo and you could feed 5 people with that dish. Overall food was excellent, service prompt and prices very family friendly. 5/5

If my grandmother was alive she would of jumped back on the ship she came from in Italy, I would…read morehave been beaten with a wooden spoon for a year offering this food to my family in my ancestors presence. Service was great, very eager young staff that was more excited to see me than my kids opening Christmas gifts. Their oil is really good, high quality. The bread was ok. I wouldn't return here if you offered me a lifetime eating pass. Sorry. I never wrote a bad review I think ever in my life. What kind of bozo chef sends out cold plates. Anyways. I hope you can improve. Being in PA this might be amazing for your community but a black eye on the Italian history of culinary culture cuisine.

See all

Deli Grassi

5.0(5 reviews)

2.4 mi

I've watched the nice lady preparing a line of sandwiches one day, took great care in each of them…read moreand the presentation was excellent! Today I got the Dutchman. Blend of sausage and onions and cheese. Delicious!! While eating I got to converse with some kind people while enjoying my lunch. God bless.

What a find! Searched for restaurants in this area and Deli Grassi popped up. Friendly Mom and…read morePop owner/manager made sure we had all we needed. We ordered salads, lasagna and eggplant parmesan. Everything was as good as a home cooked meal. Wish we lived closer, but will stop next time we are in the area.

Deli Grassi. Central Market.

The Dutchman. Blend of sweet and hot sausage.

See all

Deli Grassi

Caruso's

3.5(51 reviews)

4.6 mi

Very good pizza. We got cheese, Sicilian and a garden. So not really anything that would keep me…read morefrom ordering again, but I'm used to heavy Sicilian pizzas and this was more airy if that makes sense. Again I had no issue with it and overall each slice is lighter, making the lunch hour not so sleep inducing but yes the dough is bit airy. Came on time even with a large order

Great food! We had pizza, gluten-free pizza, and a small calzone that I would have called a medium!…read moreThe GF pizza was dough, not cauliflower, and was delish! They have eat-in and take-out. Staff is friendly and helpful. Will def return!

Penne Vodka

See all

Grilled Chicken Salad

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

9 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Micah A.

0

2

0

12 years ago

Live right in Lancaster City which is extremely close to the restaurant. We have gotten their pizza many times and it is pretty tasty. Although, their subs are their specialty. They are very juicy and tasteful. The fries are also great. The building is relatively small and is very clean unlike most pizza joints I have been to. It is family friendly and the workers are very welcoming and seen to remember us each time we come. I haven't tried the pasta yet, but everything I have tried so far is great. 5/5 read more

Kim K.

0

1

0

13 years ago

I love Pie in the Sky! Their pizza is the best in Lancaster, in my opinion. The dough for the New York style is hand-tossed, very good crust and I love the sauce. The Sicilian style is gigantic and will feed 6 or more for about $13. They have good subs, steaks and sides. The restaurant itself is immaculate. The place is family-owned. They are very friendly. read more

Jaimie A.

7

1

0

13 years ago

We live in the area and I have to say that this is the best pizza in Lancaster County. The subs are pretty fantastic too! It's a small family owned business but I have to say that their staff goes above and beyond. Last time I was there to grab my pizza fix, I witnessed a staff member carry several pizzas out to a busy mom's car. It's a great neighborhood gem! read more

Nick G.

0

6

0

14 years ago

I eat here all of the time. the pizza is, in my opinion, one of the best pies in Lancaster. The service is always spot on as well. Also some of the best prices for an Italian restaurant. Would definitely recommend it to fellow pizza connoisseurs. read more

Danielle C.

0

2

1

12 years ago

We loved it! We are originally from Lancaster, PA, but now live in Texas. We hadn't been to PA in over 9 yrs & couldn't wait for some good Pizza. Pie in the Sky was AWESOME! Can't wait to visit them again. Keep up the good work! :) read more

Katie S.

0

1

0

13 years ago

great family owned business good pizza will keep returning these are the businesses that should be getting money locally

Maria L.

0

4

1

15 years ago

Family owned and operated!! New York Style Thin Crust Pizza!!!! GREAT food and GREAT atmosphere!!! read more

Mike L.

0

1

0

15 years ago

The food is great!!!! I love their food and would recomended it to anyone..

Amanda C.

0

1

0

15 years ago

Food is delicious! Prices are great! I love Pie In the Sky!!!!

Pie in the Sky - italian - Updated October 2026

Browse Nearby

BEST of Lancaster, Pennsylvania Restaurants near Pie in the Sky

BEST of Lancaster, Pennsylvania Desserts near Pie in the Sky

BEST of Lancaster, Pennsylvania Coffee near Pie in the Sky

BEST of Lancaster, Pennsylvania Parking near Pie in the Sky

BEST of Lancaster, Pennsylvania Things to Do near Pie in the Sky

BEST of Lancaster, Pennsylvania Pizza near Pie in the Sky

BEST of Lancaster, Pennsylvania Cocktail Bars near Pie in the Sky

BEST of Lancaster, Pennsylvania Dinner near Pie in the Sky

BEST of Lancaster, Pennsylvania Shopping near Pie in the Sky

BEST of Lancaster, Pennsylvania Wineries near Pie in the Sky

Best of Lancaster

Things to do in Lancaster

Browse Brands

Brands by name

Browse Articles

Articles by date

People who viewed Pie in the Sky also viewed

Capricio's

4.4

(118 reviews)

Great costumer service! Wonderful family friendly atmosphere. Owner and wife kept coming over to…read moreask how the meal was and how they could serve us better. Food was amazing. My husband and I had the manicotti and the chicken ziti. Portion size is larger than I thought and the prices are reasonable. Our meals also included a house salad and garlic knots. Everything was made quick, fresh ,and tasted wonderful. Overall my husband and I walked out paying $26. You really can't beat the price. Highly recommend this restaurant if you are in the area.

We were visiting from out of town and came here for some pizza and salad. Our hotel was close, the…read moreratings were high so we figured this would be a great place to go for some pizza. The slices they had out looked terrible and I should have walked away at that point. I ordered a margarita pie and my wife got a salad. She said her salad was disgusting and she hardly ate it. I wasn't impressed with the pizza either. The sauce was very plain. There was barely any cheese and the crust was a little too floppy for my liking.

Brooklyn Pizza - Grill

4.1

(150 reviews)

The pizza and salad were delicious…read more We had the American Antipasto salad w/ balsamic vinaigrette. It was loaded with meat and cheese. Then we had a medium Brooklyn Full House (no mushrooms or extra cheese). We both agreed it was some of the best sausage we've had on pizza. One salad and medium pizza was plenty for the two of us. Servers were polite and had everything ready pretty quickly. We arrived around 530 pm on a Wednesday night. Plenty of seating inside. Plenty of parking as well. We would go back in a heartbeat!

Food was very good we are impressed. I got the large chicken vodka pizza and some fries for about…read more$30, it was a good quantity so I'd say it was worth it. The parking lot is very small for this location and the store is consistently crowded so be prepared to wait over an hour for one pie but other than that great experience.

Pasquale's Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria

4.0

(284 reviews)

Gave this place another chance after a while…read more Allergen info: they do offer GF crust and dairy free cheese Food- pizza has been solid the 2 recent times we have gotten it. Love the old world pepperoni option. Offer all the regular toppings. Lancaster doesn't have many good pizza options and I'd say this is one of the better ones

I only get subs here. They are packed with meat and cheese. I also only get the Italian. The…read morerolls are firm on the outside and very moist and soft inside. I believe a half sub can be eaten by 2 people. Although you can eat inside the Italian restaurant and they have unbelievable deals, we just get the sub to go. The owner is always friendly and engages in a chat everytime. Pasquale's I will Be Back

Rosa Rosa Pizzeria

3.8

(109 reviews)

Great place with Great pizza! We came for the pizza and we ordered a Medium Sausage Pizza. The…read morepizza came out perfectly cooked. The sausage had just the right amount of spice and the right amount of sauce. The size was perfect for the two of us. You order and pay at the counter and then wait for deliciousness. The location is clean and the staff is friendly. There might be a spaghetti pizza in my future.

We saw a reel about this bomber pizza on Instagram and tucked it away in our brains for the next…read moretime we were in the Lancaster area (we live in Pittsburgh) The restaurant itself is fairly rundown and old, but it seemed to be a popular place (more especially for college students). It is counter service with a variety of prepared foods ready to go for a slice or a pasta dish. We got the Lancaster bomber pizza which is half pizza and half Philly cheesesteak. The pizza side is pepperoni and sausage and the Stromboli side is steak and cheese. While it was a fun concept to try, it wasn't "knock your socks off good" haha! But for sure unique. We had plenty of leftovers and finished them up in our hotel that night. Worth a try if you like an interesting take on pizza!

Dominion Pizza

3.3

(51 reviews)

Food is mid. Wings are rubbery and always under sauced. Pizza is dryer than what's advertised…read more Ranch cups are always half filled. Employee's have horrible customer service. And it's a little overpriced.

ATMOSPHERE: There is none, it's a pizza joint…read more PROS: They're open late? I guess? That's about it. CONS: Seems to be managed and staffed by children who could care less about literally anything. Decently friendly tho. The food is about as mid as it gets. Bland, uninspired, frozen "Italian" dreck. If this is your last-ditch effort to fill your gut with something resembling food at the end of the night, go for it, otherwise hit the Taco Bell drive-thru and deal with the disappointment later. WOULD I GO BACK? : Not likely. Given it a few tries, same pathetic result every time. In a town full of pizza shops, one can do much, MUCH better.

Pizzeria 211

4.3

(58 reviews)

Great pizza but the fact you can't buy a slice after 3pm is ridiculous. They really need to change…read morethis rule. Especially for people walking by that just want to stop in and try a slice and not have to wait 30 minutes for a whole pizza. And the prices are way too high. I understand it's quality food, but $21 for a cheese steak with no sides is insanity. With the prices of everything in life up so high, you can't get relief anywhere, especially places with decent food.

High quality ingredients come with a higher price tag! That is the case for Pizzeria 211. Very good…read morepizza with locally sourced higher quality ingredients. In today's world, unfortunately that means its a 23 dollar pizza. I have heard amazing things about the detroit style, I would like to get this next time. This time though I got a regular cheese pizza. Nice crisper bottom, thinner crust, savory sauce and a decent size that is comparable to a large at other establishments. The guys running the show were friendly and the pizza took about 25 minutes to get done. I was in and out when it was time to pick up! Great staff.

Two Cousins Pizza

3.3

(17 reviews)

Yep ordered 3 subs and a small boli and one sub was wrong they said we ordered wrong at 41 dollars…read morethey said we need to buy another sub sad to say been customer for over ten years kids taking orders anymore go to hurricanes they deliver

Always great pizza and fast service. We've had their subs in the past also and they are excellent…read more Really good NY style pizza that is perfectly done and has a great tasting sauce. Highly recommend.

Finazzo's Italian Restaurant & Pizzaria

3.2

(33 reviews)

Ordered itialian sub, took 2 passes to make sure no oil, no mayo. Picked up and when I got home…read morefound the classic stale bread giveaway toasted rolls. So toasted that the 1st one tore the hell out of my mouth so bad I tossed the other half and the 2nd one I was going to eat the next day. $20 for a mouth so sore that I ate cream of potato soup and threw a whole sandwich and 1/2 away. Never again. Screw these clowns, good sandwich shop serves fresh UNTOASTED bread.

Jhon and Tony treated us like family and their food tasted just like my Nana's. Not only did they…read morefeed and deliver to a team of 60 college athletes, they carefully and meticulously cared for two students with severe allergies. Their gluten free options were plentiful and they cooked peanut free, coconut free and sesame free in a separate area to ensure the safety of their patrons. We enjoyed their food so much that we ordered 2 days in a row!! Thank you again Jhon and Tony!

Bella Roma

3.7

(16 reviews)