Friendly service, relaxed atmosphere, and quality food. Indoor and outdoor seating. We choose the…read moreoutdoor patio and it was lovely. I really enjoyed the lobster roll here, and the clam chowder. Very fresh and tasty. The French onion soup was good too but I preferred the chowder. My boyfriend enjoyed his burger and fries. Cool place! In the historic Kelley House building, which has been around since 1742!

PROS: Eric was a friendly waiter/bartender, atmosphere was absolutely amazing, wings were fresh,…read moreprices were good, and outside seating available CONS: they never answer the phone, the sprite tasted odd, and the sausage in their bangers and mash wasn't cooked right. The service was very slow and they charge a "kitchen appreciation fee of 3%" which doesn't count as a tip. I fell onto the floor when I saw that OVERALL: I'm not going to come back here due to my poor experience. It's a very cool historical place, but the service needs to be better

While on the island we were looking to enjoy a more elevated dinner on Saturday night in…read morecelebration of my birthday and Atria was recommended to us. The restaurant is a beautiful, elegant but cozy spot. The outdoor seating is absolutely beautiful for a nice evening. We were there right at opening and were seated outside fairly quickly! Our waiter was welcoming and pleasant. Wished me a happy birthday (multiple times) but nice. There was a cute birthday card at the table but nothing more (most high end establishments usually offer a glass of champs, but I digress ) The menu is moderate not overwhelming with too many options. How do you NOT start your meal with Oysters Rockefeller when they are on the menu? Great choice, they were creamy and delicious. I am typically not a pasta girl but something was calling me about the Mushroom Bolognese! So....I ordered it. Along with a glass of Filipa Pato, which was fabulous! The pasta was phenomenal and I don't use that word lightly, it was amazing. My friend ordered the Bobo's Two Pound Wok Fired Island Lobster and she loved it. She paired her meal with a Smokey old fashioned. No notes! So after a great meal we a bought the check and offer up two cards for our separate checks. Somehow our waiter ends up charging both checks to my credit card. I didn't realize it until the next day. How does that happen. An almost perfect review, but attention to detail matters. Would I return, absolutely! Go enjoy!

We came here one night to enjoy a nice dinner while on the vineyard. I was conflicted between the…read morelobster or the halibut and opted to try the halibut which did not disappoint. It came with lobster and vegetables which were all so flavorful. Our waitress was nice and took the time to walk us through the specials. We sat inside but the outside looked beautiful. This restaurant is perfect for a date night or girls night

Wicked Burger's Wicked Mushroom burger!!! This is easily one of the BEST burgers I have ever had…read more Juicy, flavorful(not just salt either) with sauce, pickles, super melted Swiss cheese, and a mountain of fries. Wicked friendly team and fast service to boot. If I recall there were 4 burgers, a chicken sandwich, 3 specials, 4 milk shakes plus a special milk shake, and a wide variety of other drinks you could get from the cooler. The next time you're on the Vineyard you have to check this place out!

From the outside, this place doesn't stand out--it's tucked in the middle of a small plaza with a…read moresmall sign. But the food is really excellent. The burgers are juicy and delicious (better than anything I've had at places like Five Guys, In-and-Out, Whataburger, etc.) and the onion rings and tater tots are ridiculously good as well (the fries also are good). Not a lot of places to sit, so it's most takeout. Service is fast and has been spot on every time. Highly recommend.

The breakfast sandwich is delicious, and my friend also loved her grilled chicken sandwich. It's…read morequite pricey here so that's the only negative. Otherwise, it's cute inside and they have a solid menu. There's limited seating indoors but there's a bench outside and you can of course walk around to find other cute benches too. We didn't wait too long for our food to be ready and we also each got a chocolate chip cookie which was delicious.

Great coffee, great fried chicken sandwich, and great grilled cheese sandwich. What more can you…read moreask for? The staff were super nice and the restaurant is kept clean. Right in the heart of the shops!

Delicious food and very nice inside! My wife had the lobster roll, and it was buttery and full of…read morehuge clumps of meat! My chicken bahn mi was excellent. So many flavor profiles with the acid, spice in the mayo, and tender chicken. I also love shoestring fries. Wonderful meal in Edgartown!

While strolling edgartown, was looking for a place for some lunch and saw Rockfish on the corner…read more From the outside, the place looks very nice. Went in right when they opened and inside looks like your typical nice pub. Hostess was friendly and sat us upstairs immediately. Service was good and both food and drinks came out quickly. Food was nice and hot so you know it was cooked fresh. Started with a blackberry whiskey smash which was perfect. Ordered fish and chips, clam chowder, cheese pizza and mac and cheese. All were very good. Only thing I would not get again would be the fish and chips. The fish just had too much batter. Felt like all you were eating was batter. Overall a good place and would certainly go back.

Whenever we fly back to the island our first spot is a burger fries and of course oysters!!read more

Best meal I've had on the island in a long time and the service was even better. They took our…read moredietary issues seriously (Celiac) and our server, Molly, was so knowledgeable and attentive. She explained the food preparation process used in the kitchen and detailed every ingredient. Lots of options and, the martinis were fantastic too.

Great spot, awesome vibe, generous portions and fast service. We went for breakfast and got biscuit…read moresandwiches. They were really delicious and big. Place was crowded but not overwhelmingly so. Sitting outside on the patio was lovely. Nice gift shop inside too.

Enjoyed an easy breakfast here. Busy and popular early bird gets the warm for patio seating. They…read moresell everything from pastries, to bagels, sandwiches, noodles, salads, and more. Also have deli grab and go options. Full coffee bar. Indoor and outdoor seating.

The chowder fries are fantastic!! A local friend told me to come here specifically for the chowder…read morefries and this was excellent advice. Wow! So good!! Friendly service. Lively ambiance and busy place. Pretty warm inside as far as the temperature. I didn't feel any AC or breezes. They have a bar one side and a restaurant on the other. The bar was packed and everyone looked like they were having a great time. They have an ATM machine too.

Great menu, sat quickly for a late lunch, and delightful server who answered all our questions…read moreabout town. We didn't feel rushed whatsoever which was a welcomed surprise. The strawberry salad is out of this world. The addition of pickled red onions adds a refreshing tang. Would have been great with grilled chicken on top, but I wasn't hungry enough for it. Some of the better fries I've eaten! Great crunch! Don't skip em. Husband loved the fried chicken sandwich (hard to mess up, but it has happened). Pricing is really competitive and portions were good. We'd go back.

On this episode of eating my way through Martha's Vineyard, we stopped at Square Rigger, one of the…read moreisland's well-known staples. All I wanted that day was some fried shrimp and clam strips -- and for me, the strips are key because they skip the extra parts you get with whole clams. Unfortunately, they were out of clam strips, so we went with fried shrimp, fries, and lobster bisque. Since I had to share with my wife, I asked for extra shrimp -- but heads up, it's $3 per shrimp. Not complaining, just letting you know. The lobster bisque came out hot and creamy, but I was hoping for a bit more depth of flavor and a little more lobster meat and a little less bisque. The shrimp were tasty and fried well, but personally, I prefer mine butterflied for that extra texture and presentation. What stood out most, though, was the service. Friendly, quick, and attentive, which matters a lot when you're trying a local favorite. Overall, Square Rigger delivers a solid experience, but I left wishing for just a little more -- especially when you're at a place with that kind of reputation. Verdict: Good shrimp, great service, but I'll be back hoping for those clam strips next time.

My family and I live in Arizona. When we called to make a reservation. We called at…read more5pm(AZ)/8pm(EST) on Friday several weeks before our visit. A member of the family had requested this location for her birthday dinner. The person who answered the phone "Idk. It's Friday night. I don't have time for this. It's busy." This should have been our first red flag. A separate conversation and call at another time, the GM asked over the phone if we'd like a cake or something special brought in. Very thoughtful. "Yeah we'd love that! Thank you!" When we arrived at our reservation time, the table had to be rearranged while the party waited. Our party was 8 people. When we inquired about the cake, no one present had any idea what we were talking about. They kindly offered to put a sampler dish together which we accepted but all other food and drink took so long, we cancelled it because we just wanted ultimately just wanted to leave. This is a steak house. A few people at the table ordered steaks with a medium center. Plates were brought out and we were advised the steaks had a medium. Every single steak was completely grey inside(well done). There was not a spot of pink inside. We didn't ask for a replacement steak, we just let them know so they would be aware for future steaks and someone else's future steak! We didn't bother asking for the replacement steak because it already took incredibly long for us to get our food and we were hungry. The waitress never apologized. She didn't look like she wanted to be there and was awkwardly hovering between the 2 tables they had filled. Two new steaks were brought out which we thought was nice but it was also suspiciously fast considering our previous long wait. We cut into the new steaks, almost completely raw. There was a man that poured water for us when we sat. He was the only one that looked like he enjoyed working there and showed any real customer service. The menu says 8oz sirloin and instead you get a 10oz New York strip. A larger piece sounds good but it's not what we asked for when we were ordering our food. If you're going to serve a different cut and size, why would you not change your menu? Or at least let customers know when ordering. Drinks were HEAVY. Can't complain about the quality of liquor. The drinks would be put on the table and take almost 10 minutes to get the next drink. The bartender was kind a remixed one of our drinks when we asked to sweeten it. Just wish drinks came out faster. The other food was great! We had pastas, salmon, vegetables, and mashed potatoes. They were very tasty. If the service, and steaks were better, this place would be recommended as it had beautiful flavor. The steak would have been perfect too if they knew how to cook it!

We sat downstairs and loved the place. The food was wonderful and the bar selection was world…read moreclass. We had seafood and steaks and i tried all of the items we ordered. Just awesome!! We went back after bar hopping for a while to the late night bites. They had this insane hotdog tower that we just loved with all of the toppings you could ever imagine. I spoke with the Manager Jay and he was great. He told us all about the place and the island. We will be back for sure, this place is great.

I was pleasantly surprise by the amount of high quality restaurants in Martha's Vineyard. Every…read moreplace we went to was satisfying and I can't wait to go back. Alchemy is an intimate restaurant with minimalistic aesthetics. We sat upstairs, in front of the bar. The waitstaff were all so kind, personable, and attentive. For appetizer, we had the half dozen oysters. I can't remember which ones we had but they were all amazing. For entree, my fiancee had the surf and turf. The medium rare steak was a good size, perfectly cooked, and well-paired with the sauce. The lobster was also perfectly cooked and portion size was adequate. I had the halibut with risotto. The halibut was perfectly cooked and flaky. The risotto was one of my favorites because of the perfect creaminess and seasoning.