Primo Pizza NY Style

27

339

706

1 year ago

I stopped in after passing this place many times. The girl behind the counter is the nicest person in the world and makes this establishment. I ordered 3 slices, 2 Sausage and 1 meatball. I also asked for the made well done. This did not disappoint. The pizza is as close as being in manhattan. Excellent service and NY style pizza that is amazing. . read more

See all

Helpful 2

Thanks 1

Love this 2

Oh no 0

Tim K.

23

243

573

1 year ago

In Raleigh for graduation weekend for my oldest daughter. It was getting late and we were hungry and we love trying "new to us" places and my daughter chose Primo Pizza. Typical pizza shop menu, decent size eat-in area as well and it was clean. Great aroma of pizza when you walk in. Several folks came in for to-go orders while we were there. We walked to the counter and ordered an 18-inch pepperoni and three fountain drinks. $25 not bad! The staff was friendly and efficient. We had a seat at a table. The pizza arrived looking like it was from a commercial. Absolutely beautiful. It was a little greasy on top but nothing a few napkins couldn't deal with. The slices were huge as you would expect from such a big pizza. The pizza was hand-tossed. It was baked to perfection with brown bubbles on the crust and a golden brown bake underneath. The cheese and pepperoni were plentiful. The taste was wonderful. A very good pizza. Definitely will be going back. Good pizza is hard to find. This place is a keeper. read more

Primo Pizza NY Style - Menu - Pizza Near Me - Cary, North Carolina

Primo Pizza NY Style - Our glorious 18-inch pizza - Pizza Near Me - Cary, North Carolina

See all

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Andrew L.

0

120

59

1 year ago

The server was very friendly, and the food was fast. I got an Italian sub and it was super bland. There's nothing wrong with it per se - clean, cost-effective, good location ; but there's nothing amazing about it either. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Tobias C.

0

5

6

1 year ago

Love this place the pizza is amazing!!! This is my family's favorite spot in the city!!! Really love the margarita pizza!!!

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Bernie S.

94

23

27

2 years ago

This place had the best pepperoni and moxarella pizza I have had in decades. Simple but delicious. We had an extra large and it stuffed 3 200lb adult men. read more

Primo Pizza NY Style - Seated inside table Primo - Pizza Near Me - Cary, North Carolina

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Ronald G.

0

2

0

10 months ago

I ordered a strombolli ,after the first couple of bites it tasted weird. But I tried to pin it down to something inparticular but I couldn't, im thinking maybe bad vegetables, but either way Im sick and my stomach is still hurting. I know what it was supposed to taste like after eating there often. Something was very wrong. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Adam S.

0

2

0

11 months ago

hands down the best pizza in the triangle!!! as soon as you pick it up and get in your car with it, you can tell it's a true NYC pizza! I am originally from up north and this is the only place I've found that comes anywhere near true NY pizza. I know people will read this and immediately become skeptical, but before making that judgement.... give them a try!! you will not be disappointed. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Chris A.

97

437

1398

4 years ago

So we had a delivery to our hotel while visiting the area. PLEASE keep in mind I grew up & live in NJ 10 minutes outside of NYC. I have eaten in my lifetime some of the best traditional NY style pizza in the country. So I am rating Primo as a NC pizzeria, not to be compared to NJ\NY. The pizza ( did half plain \ half with sausage was OK, not bad. Definitely worth a shot if you are in the mood. We also ordered a Greek salad which was a good size, very fresh, and full of all the ingredients to make it a true Greek salad (olives, feta, pepperincini) We ate very bit. read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Adam B.

Elite 26 All-Star

751

1263

502

4 years ago

Got a 14 incher with tomato and bacon on one side, sausage and mushroom on the other. The pizza came out in about 10 minutes. It had a good thin crust with some chew on it. Flavorful sauce, proper proportion of crust to sauce to cheese to toppings. For beverages, they have Pepsi products on fountain, or you can go with one of a large variety of cans in the fridge. My complaint would be the staff wasn't overly engaging or welcoming, always remember a smile goes a long way. read more

Helpful 2

Thanks 0

Love this 3

Oh no 0

Liann A.

Elite 24

10

18

40

4 years ago

Best pizza I've had in a few years. The amount of sauce on this is perfect and the flavor is really good! Ooo and the crust isperfectly crisp. I've been in a few times to get a single slice and I've never disappointed. This is my first time ordering a full pie and they are still on a perfect streak. They said 20-25 minutes and it was ready on time, the service was fine. I definitely will be ordering again. read more

Primo Pizza NY Style - Cheese pizza - Pizza Near Me - Cary, North Carolina

Helpful 3

Thanks 0

Love this 2

Oh no 1

Lauren W.

3

46

11

3 years ago

So good!!! Exactly the type of NY style pizza I've been seeking for years. Love the laid back atmosphere and the prices, especially the 2 slice & drink special. This is going to be my new lunch spot when I'm in Cary for work. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

El C.

0

2

0

3 years ago

Dear primo's staff y'all service has thy wrong and I had two orders and thy has forgot the bacon on both next time thy shall up their service.From your fellow customer read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Matthew M.

1

100

10

3 years ago

Good and tasty! Some quality basic football New York pizza. The cheese on the pizza has that gooey stretch and the crust has that sweet crunch. It's definitely consistent and fairly priced. Their Stromboli's are pretty good and I have yet to try the pasta but it also looks good. Primo has been my go-to for awhile now and I'm glad to see that they've still got it. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Kim C.

101

189

485

6 years ago

Here is another fabulous local restaurant in Cary that has a drive thru window to pick up an excellent NY style pizza! I always get the supreme as they have great toppings! We get a large and eat on it for two days! Love this place and really appreciate that they are open! Please everyone if you are ordering out, give Primos a try. You won't be disappointed! read more

Primo Pizza NY Style - Entrance to pizza heaven! - Pizza Near Me - Cary, North Carolina

Helpful 7

Thanks 0

Love this 6

Oh no 0

Jacqueline C.

11

3

92

6 years ago

I'm years late writing this review. I have been going to this place since it opened. The owner is amazing and hilarious, the staff is right there with him, always smiling, laughing, joking (even through the masks you can see their eyes smile!)... However, the food is still the star!! If you haven't had Primo Pizza you're missing out!! Truly the best NY pizza I've had outside of Brooklyn, plus you can't beat the price. I HIGHLY recommend: 1) ANY PIZZA. To be honest, I go with cheese, because when the pizza is perfect, that's all you really need. Sometimes extra cheese. 2) The appetizer meatballs are the bomb! I'm serious, try these, thank me later. 3) The pastas are also delicious ! They give you enough sauce, al dente pasta (not too soft, not too hard, goldilocks style, just right!) and garlic knots, yummy! 4) The CANNOLI!! OMG, they do it right, fill the shell fresh and all. Then they jazz it up a bit and make you feel like it's your special day any day. I have no pictures of the food, just my order history from when I used the slice app over calling. Trust me when I say, I call in way more orders than I put through the app!! All in all, I love this place. read more

Primo Pizza NY Style - Former orders through the slice app. I call in way more than this. Some favorites to consider! - Pizza Near Me - Cary, North Carolina

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Carly D.

92

62

19

3 years ago

It was exactly what we wanted. A simple cheese pizza, lightly baked. That's what we got. Ratios were right, staff was nice and price was where we thought it should be. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

John C.

280

283

1839

9 years ago

A nice friendly establishment in Cary. Everyone from the customers to the staff were all friendly and amiable. I noticed they have a deal for each day of the week which is pretty cool. I just wanted some good pepperoni pizza and that's exactly what I went for. The pizza was fantastic. I got myself 2 slices and they were amazing. I was in the area for business and wanted something that would be quick. Next time around I'm in the area I'll make sure to grab a slice of pizza or maybe the deal of the day before heading out of town. read more

Primo Pizza NY Style - Pepperoni pizza - Pizza Near Me - Cary, North Carolina

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Windell B.

24

5

1

3 years ago

Excellent food , excellent service. We ordered the Tacos and they were delicious. Will definitely be eating here again when we return.

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Desiree E.

1

16

3

5 years ago

Have been ordering pizza here for a year and have been happy. Of late whenever I call they try to talk me out of delivery. This last pizza order was almost burnt, dry, cold and not worth it. Officially looking for a new spot! read more

Primo Pizza NY Style - a slice of pizza in a box - Pizza Near Me - Cary, North Carolina

Primo Pizza NY Style - Almost burnt pizza - Pizza Near Me - Cary, North Carolina

See all

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Aniree D.

0

4

0

3 years ago

At Sergio's their food is a little good then I expected to be like but at Primo 's their food is so good and amazing so as their wings and so as their calzones and pasta which I have never tried before at Primo's Pizza for thousands of times I've tried their amazing NY cheese pizza and wings thousands of times in my life and At Primo's I really want to try their cannoli's and their Hawaiian pizza And so as their Philly cheesesteaks So once again at Sergio's their food is always not what I expected to be but I will try Primo's Pizza because their pizza wings pasta calzones cannolis and cheesesteaks and Hawaiian pizzas are the best At Primo's and at last their subs are also Amazing At Primo's Pizza so I think I will try out their amazing food their. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Lura G.

20

19

0

4 years ago

Good pizza and delicious cannolis! So glad to have Primo Pizza as one of our go-to pizzarias!

Helpful 3

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Zach M.

4

11

4

5 years ago

It's decent, sauce has some flavor cheese isn't skimped on. But it's a hit or miss, 9/10 times it just tastes like cheese. Crust has little to no flavor. It is however well priced with some killer specials. So why not? read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Brittani J.

0

4

2

4 years ago

Every Friday night in our family is pizza night. We just moved to Cary so we needed to find a spot that met all the needs for our family of 6. Affordable, preferably NY style(moms from NY), and for now, in Cary. We had to pick our daughter up from CHS and I caught primo out of the corner of my eye. Checked it out online real quick and stopped in for some pizza. They have daily specials! We got 2 XL (18in) pizzas a penne Alfredo and an order of garlic knots. Everything was delicious! We had leftovers which made for an even better lunch the next day! Will def. be back! read more

Primo Pizza NY Style - a pizza with a slice taken out of it - Pizza Near Me - Cary, North Carolina

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Davia N.

0

2

0

2 years ago

The pizza is amazing! I ordered for my son's party at Notasium. Customer service was great, they delivered on time and the pizza was delicious. Highly recommend!!! read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Katie V.

Elite 26 All-Star

70

425

437

6 years ago

The pizza and crust was good. My husband didn't really care for the marinara sent with the mozzarella sticks and garlic knots. It was slightly watery. I did appreciate that they had anchovies available for their pizza topping options. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Kat I.

Elite 21

0

47

15

8 years ago

BEST NY style pizza/food! There's a different special every day of the week that are all great deals. Husband got two slices of pepperoni pizza and I got a calzone with mushroom and sausage (and of course mozzarella & ricotta) - both were way freaking delicious and we left feeling sooo full. The top of the calzone had garlic... I about died it tasted so good. The very friendly lady working there told us that literally everything is handmade here- sauce, pizza dough, mushrooms are freshly sliced, etc. And you can really tell because the food is so delicious. We sat in and the food was ready quickly. This is for sure our go-to pizza / quick Italian place now. And I didn't get her name but the lady working there was so friendly she made our experience. Props to her... I hope management reads this because she deserves a lot of credit and probably a raise because she's half the reason why we would go back. All I know that might identify her is her husband was a marine. She rocks. read more

Primo Pizza NY Style - Calzone - Pizza Near Me - Cary, North Carolina

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Chris L.

0

21

6

2 years ago

Always good service and good pizza and etc. highly recommend them. Support local business ILO of the big chain restaurants.

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Tammy M.

58

683

1131

11 years ago

VERY GOOD !!! We really liked the crust. Sauce was slightly sweet. We got meatball and it was tasty. I would get pizza there again. read more

Primo Pizza NY Style - 18" Meatball Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Cary, North Carolina

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Elsie T.

43

48

7

3 years ago

We ordered pizza over the phone and picked it up using the drive through. Once there, I decided to order a ceasar salad, which they gracefully made. Both pizza and salad were great, fresh and delicious! read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Stacy P.

327

163

403

7 years ago

Sooooo good !!! The best i've had since moving from NJ. Omg very impressed. My kids really enjoyed the pizza as well!!!! So plus plus plus to Primo Pizza. read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Fadma A.

36

31

51

7 years ago

I grew up in Europe so I am used to some pretty amazing pizza and it is hard to find a good pizza here in the US in my opinion. But I can finally say that I found a place that has some pretty awesome pizza! And their wings are really tasty too. We also got a Greek salad which I thought was the best I've had in any pizza place around here. Overall I'll say that this is my new favorite spot for pizza. We payed $45 for two orders of wings, large pizza and a salad. Everything was done quite fast. Love this place! read more

Primo Pizza NY Style - Half cheese and half pepperoni & sausage. So good!!!! - Pizza Near Me - Cary, North Carolina

Primo Pizza NY Style - Almost gone - hot wings are tasty! - Pizza Near Me - Cary, North Carolina

See all

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 1

Fadma M.

Elite 24

16

98

139

5 years ago

I grew up in Europe so I am used to some pretty good pizza and it is hard to find a good Italian pizza here in the US in my opinion. But I can finally say that I found a place that has some pretty awesome pizza! And their wings are really tasty too. We also got a Greek salad which I thought was the best I've had in any pizza place around here. Overall I'll say that this is my new favorite spot for pizza. We payed $45 for two orders of wings, large pizza and a salad. Everything was done quite fast. Love this place! read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 2

Oh no 0

P.j. F.

75

28

0

4 years ago

Good food and they have decent daily and weekly specials. They were very busy the whole time we were there.

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Chuck F.

0

129

2

6 years ago

I'm a Philadelphia Italian so mark my words, this is a great pizza. Perfect crust, perfect sause, perfect mozzarella, Every bite is a JOY to eat. Hadt he NY'er but subbed some pineapple for the onions and green peppers. Pure Pizza Perfection read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Mohammad A.

0

3

1

4 years ago

This is the worst experience, their calazon is horrible and so so so small it's not like the picture they provided at all . Don't go there people read more

Primo Pizza NY Style - This this a scam, just look how small the calazon is. Don't go there people - Pizza Near Me - Cary, North Carolina

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Tonia C.

40

431

503

9 years ago

Great Service! Clean! The 18 inch cheese pizza we ordered was great! The only problem was it wasn't enough. Will be back. read more

See all

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Yvette V.

0

15

0

4 years ago

Very good pizza! Staff is very nice, lunch specials are great prices. Best pizza in the area

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Elizabeth M.

5

10

6

7 years ago

I went to Primo Pizza today and I purchased a 14" Pepperoni Pizza for dinner! I really enjoyed the pizza, it was the best pizza I have tried in Cary. The sauce was flavorful and the pizza had a perfect amount of it. The toppings were fresh and delicious. The crust was appetizing, I normally find crust to be bland, but their crust was very good. I really enjoyed their pizza, they have a clean restaurant, friendly employees, and great customer service. I recommend it to anyone. read more

Primo Pizza NY Style - #localguides #supportlocalpizza - Pizza Near Me - Cary, North Carolina

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Stan H.

0

14

0

4 years ago

Placed order online for (2) two-slice pizza specials with a soft drink. Both were wrong and missing topics paid for. Drink was a can soda and not the size you would get in the restaurant. Disappointed to say the least as we have been long-time customers. Last time we walked in there to order the two slice special the guy at counter said he was too busy to deal with the order if I couldn't order a full pizza, then it couldn't help me. I guess my business will go back to NY Pizza! So long Primo! read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Page 1 of 5

See more reviews

More info about Primo Pizza NY Style

682 Cary Towne Blvd
Cary, NC 27511
Directions
(919) 380-2729
Call Now
Order Takeout or Delivery
Start Order
Visit Website
http://www.primopizzanystyle.com/

Full menu

Hours

What time does Primo Pizza NY Style open?

Primo Pizza NY Style opens at 11:00 AM on Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday, Friday and Saturday.Primo Pizza NY Style opens at 12:00 PM on Sunday.

What time does Primo Pizza NY Style close?

Primo Pizza NY Style closes at 9:00 PM on Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday and Sunday.Primo Pizza NY Style closes at 10:00 PM on Friday and Saturday.

Mon-Thu 11:00 AM - 9:00 PMFri-Sat 11:00 AM - 10:00 PMSun 12:00 PM - 9:00 PM

Payment methods

Does Primo Pizza NY Style take credit cards?

Yes, Primo Pizza NY Style takes credit cards.

Food & Alcohol

Does Primo Pizza NY Style have catering options?

Yes, Primo Pizza NY Style does have catering options.

Does Primo Pizza NY Style have a drive thru?

Yes, Primo Pizza NY Style has a drive thru.

Does Primo Pizza NY Style serve alcohol?

No, Primo Pizza NY Style does not serve alcohol.

Indoor Amenities

Does Primo Pizza NY Style have TVs?

Yes, Primo Pizza NY Style has TVs.

Outdoor Amenities

Does Primo Pizza NY Style have bike parking?

Yes, Primo Pizza NY Style has bike parking.

Does Primo Pizza NY Style have outdoor seating?

Yes, Primo Pizza NY Style has outdoor seating options.

Does Primo Pizza NY Style have parking?

Yes, Primo Pizza NY Style has parking options. Private Lot Parking

Other Amenities

Does Primo Pizza NY Style have free WiFi?

No, Primo Pizza NY Style does not have free WiFi.

From the Business

Specialties

We offer the freshest pizzas at the the best prices. All our crusts are made fresh and hand tossed just for you. We offer a wide variety of pastas and salads as well. Church and civic group discounts and specials are always available, just call and ask for George.

History

Established in 2009.

After working in a variety of restaurants for the past 10 years, the enterprising Gonzalez brothers decided to take the leap to business owners early in 2009. The brothers' focus has been on growing the business, never losing sight of their goal of providing quality pizzas and pastas and a great price.

You might also consider

Verify this business for free

People searched for Pizza 11,555 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

Verify this business

Explore benefits

Rigo’s Pizzeria

4.5(162 reviews)

2.5 mi

After a day of thrifting I needed sustenance and began scouring Yelp for recommendations since I…read morewas in a city I didn't know. Thankfully Rigo's came highly recommended and was not far away. Rigo's Pizzeria is an authentic Italian Pizzeria. They have a huge selection of food and their pizzas are huge! I ordered the Grandmas Pizza. It was loaded with cheese, marinara, basil, and garlic! Each bite was incredibly flavorful and delicious! If you're in or around Cary or Raleigh, I definitely recommend you check out Rigo's!

I have been getting their amazing dinner deals for a year now and it's honestly the best deal…read morearound, rigid is a relaxed pizza place that can feed 4 for at least 2 days on a 20$ meal deal (1 giant pizza and garlic knots) I highly recommend this place to anyone who's tired of overpriced pizza or that frozen taste some places have everything here is amazing and I can't recommend it enough. The service is next to perfect they make every guest feel like family and they even make their own ranch here.

Grandmas

See all

V Pizza

4.1(390 reviews)

1.4 mi

I have a new favorite pizza restaurant in Cary!…read more I ordered for pickup and my Build-Your-Own pepperoni pizza was ready in 15 minutes (there's a Barnes and Noble, Trader Joe's, and other stores in the nearby shopping center where you can browse while waiting). The pizza was delicious, especially after sprinkling on Parmesan and red pepper flakes!!! Customer service was great for pickup. The staff greeted me with friendly smiles and conversation. A few couples and families were dining in. The restaurant had plenty room and, based on my quick visit, seemed like an ideal place to dine for small parties. I wasn't inside long enough to assess the entire restaurant and determine what space may be available for larger parties.

Who says great Neapolitan pizza has to break the bank? I scored an incredible buy one, get one free…read moredeal on Uber Eats and got two 13" Vegetariana pizzas for about $26--easily one of the best pizza values I've found in Cary. The pies arrived hot with that signature thin, wood-fired crust that's perfectly crisp on the outside while staying chewy inside. The toppings were fresh and generous, especially the huge chunks of marinated artichokes, which really stood out. The mushrooms, spinach, grape tomatoes, mozzarella, and Pecorino all came together beautifully without weighing the pizza down. If you're a fan of authentic Neapolitan-style pizza, V Pizza is definitely worth checking out. I'll absolutely be ordering again, especially when that BOGO deal pops up!

Caprese Plate

See all

Moscato and V Signature Wings

Johnny's Pizza Cary

4.2(475 reviews)

5.0 mi

I was last here about seven years ago because I don't live in the area. We're visiting family here…read morein Cary and based on our great memories of the place, coming to Johnny's was a must on our itinerary. I'm super super happy to say that everything that made this place so wonderful seven years ago is still here. The pizza is still spot on, the portions are still huge, and the value for the money can't be beat. The employees were friendly and attentive and made us feel welcome when we walked through the door and during our time eating . My notoriously picky son who was not here with us seven years ago loved the pizza so much that he told us that he wants to live here in the restaurant (and I'm not convinced that he's kidding). I don't know when we'll next be in Cary, but as long as Johnny's Pizza is here, they'll have loyal customers in me and my family. The pictures I'm going to post don't do the food justice, but by the time I thought to take pictures, the family had already started devouring everything.

Came a few years back for a yelp event and was in the area so made a stop. Probably the best and…read morehottest slice I've had in a long time. Highly recommend.

18" pepperoni pizza with a side of fried ravioli and mac & cheese bites.

See all

View from 2nd level

Di Fara Pizza Tavern

3.5(344 reviews)

1.2 mi

There pizza are amazing A little expensive…read more The size is good though I like the vibe The service is amazing

I like that this pizza is cooked on a stone vs a conveyer. Depending on the pizza you're looking…read morefor, you may or may not like Di Fara's. The dough is quite tough and chewy. Your jaw is probably gonna beg you to stop eating before your stomach. I generally like their pizza but it is definitely meant to be enjoyed in shop. The downside though is it can become quite loud so try to eat outside. This past experience, the pizza wasn't great. It was rather light on cheese. We also ordered the chaos pie. The toppings fall off very easily. These two pizzas and two orders of meatballs (6 balls total) ran us $110. I understand quality ingredients and 18" pizzas are gonna cost more but this was a ridiculous price. The base price should come down, $31 for a cheese pizza is unacceptable. I get this isn't dominos but this also isn't the best damn pizza I've ever had. 100% not worth the price. TL;DR Good pizza, tough crust (main part of the pie with toppings is good), outrageously expensive, skimpy on cheese.

90 sanitation score

See all

Outdoor seating area, Sept 2024.

Mezza Luna Pizzeria

4.4(188 reviews)

6.3 mi

I'm really disappointed that I've lived here five years, and never went for dinner here. We have…read moreordered many many grandma pizzas, but never sat down to enjoy dinner until the other night. There were 4 of us, every dish was excellent, we will make up for lost time and eat here more frequently!

In recent months we have been disappointed by what used to be our go to pizza places. This week we…read moretried Mezza Luna and were very pleased. First let's begin with the crust. It was the most perfect we've had in a long time. Next the toppings were exactly what we ordered though based on how they did what we asked though we may adjust our toppings for our next order. Definitely going back

Lunch on a week day

Grandma Pie

See all

Colletta

4.0(343 reviews)

0.6 mi

we went to colletta for a celebration and it was the best choice…read more The ambience, the service, the Decor, the vibes everything is what you look for in a celebration And of course, the food was the highlight of the evening... one of the best modern Italian we started with focaccia platter and my favorite part was the Apple butter then we ordered Campanelli pasta and Radia Tori Nero. Both were finger licking... I ordered crunchy okra, and potatoes, which were equally good and a great quantity to make it a dinner in itself we also tried non-alcoholic beverages, Italian sunrise and hibiscus bloom our server asked what we were celebrating, and when we said birthday, she brought a small tiramisu parfait with the candle as a surprise, which was definitely an icing on the cake overall, a great experience and we are already planning our next trip

Really lovely experience! Came here for our anniversary and had a reservation for Friday night - I…read moreactually got a message from Colletta asking what our hobbies/interests are, so I told them that we love the beach and pickleball. Once we arrived, they gave us a gift of pickleballs and a really nice coconut beachy candle! We had never had that kind of customer service and generosity before, it was such a special way to start our dinner! Onto the food/drinks, we got a few drinks that were delicious! For our food, we started with the Focaccia and Polpette appetizers. They were so incredible and for my meal, I ordered the Creste di Gallo. Everything was 10/10, no notes or critiques! Our server was so friendly, helpful, and prompt! We had a wonderful time at our dinner - thank you so much Colletta team!!

Inside

Arancini

See all

Focaccia bread

Hot Box Pizza

4.7(15 reviews)

7.4 mi

Holy Smokes! Love me some Hot Box! Literally, tons of smoke coming out of this truck as they made…read moresome delicious AF Pizza. I'm a huge fan of char that I obessively repeat "charrrrrrrr" like a dumb pirate while eating perfectly charred food. Yea, it's annoying, but it keeps people away from stealing delicious charred food from me! Smarrrrrrrrt! But this pepperoni pie had the cup and char pepperoni with the perfect mix of charred cupped greasy pepperoni's and delicious chewy crust. So good! The crust bottom wasn't as crispy as I like, but the flavor and ingredients were top notch. It came out quick too!!! I'd get it again and again. Hot Boxes for everyone!

Welcoming and pleasant staff. I enjoyed the pesto sunrise chicken pizza. The balsamic glaze was a…read morereally nice addition to the flavor profile and so much excitement for my tastebuds Very delicious. The price point here is pricey but I really enjoyed the pizza and would give them another try if I'm in the area.

Hot Box Pizza truck

Pepperoni pizza

See all

Pepperoni Pizza Pie was Perfect

Faulisi Caffè & Enoteca

3.8(208 reviews)

1.1 mi

Faulisi Caffè & Enoteca is such a cute, authentic little spot in Cary. The atmosphere genuinely…read moremade me feel like I was back in Italy, and you can tell they use fresh, high-quality ingredients in everything they serve. The pizza and sandwich bread were both excellent, and I especially loved the flavorful green sauce on the sandwich. The pizza was delicious, although the dough was a little soggy in the center. The tiramisu was rich and tasted very authentic, with a noticeable alcohol flavor, which I personally enjoyed! I also took a sfogliatella home with me, and it was absolutely delicious. Everything else pictured we enjoyed at the restaurant. The staff was friendly, and the space is small but very charming, with wine and other Italian goodies available for purchase. It is a little on the pricier side, and while everything was very good, a few small details kept it from being a full five-star experience for me. Still, I would absolutely return in a heartbeat! Parking is free for two hours when you scan the validation code inside, so be sure not to pay for parking beforehand. We didn't have trouble finding a spot, although I could see it being more difficult on a busy weekend.

Love this spot! Super cute Italian cafe vibes, and I love everything we've tried on the menu. My…read morefav is the roasted cauliflower sandwich - I get it every time, with a cappucino and a sweet treat!

Shop area

Tiramisu

See all

Salvio's Pizzeria

3.6(181 reviews)

3.1 mi

Great New York style pizza. Lots of options and can customize it to your taste. They have other…read moredishes and rotate items occasionally. I usually stick the pizza. They recognize regulars. Family owned restaurant!

Salvio's Pizzas are just award winning perfection on a crispy crust that supports the toppings…read morewithout a soggy pie, 2 Piece Side of Meatballs, Chicken Parmesan Dinner, spaghetti, salvio's signature 14" Cheese Pizza, Side Parmesan Cheese , House Salad with ranch dressing are delicious very fast service, and a casual ambiance that is good for our neighborhood. I highly recommend the award winning Salvio's Pizzeria. It's the best in Cary, North Carolina!

Chicken Parmesan Dinner

See all

The Original NY Pizza

3.8(101 reviews)

2.0 mi

Just came by after doctor's appointment in Cary. Outstanding pizza. Grab a cheese and a speciality…read more Everything tasted great. Plenty of workers available. Would definitely stop by again if in the area.

I've been a regular customer since 1994 (originally their Harrison store) by now frequent their…read moreTryon location. Love their pizza, and Stromboli

See all

Back of Menu

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

8 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Sim M.

71

3

2

9 years ago

Quite possibly the worst pizza I have had in a very long time this place is awful. We ordered very specifically two hours prior to the pick up time, when we got there not only were they made 2 hours ago, they asked if they wanted it reheated.....but the second time that they were made the order was entirely wrong and raw. It's no cooked all the way through and we paid over $30.00 I want my money back thieves. read more

Andrea D.

0

53

2

8 years ago

Pleasantly surprised! Considering the location I wasn't expecting much, but the pizza was fantastic. Perfect proportions of sauce, cheese and toppings cooked to perfection. The hot wings had such a good flavor and their ranch you could tell was home made. On top of the taste, the price you could not beat, 18" pizza with 10 wings for 19.95 on Sunday's. We will definitely return! read more

Catherine K.

27

15

3

12 years ago

I am the worlds most critical pizza aficionado. Primo's pizza rocks from crust to topping to delivery. It is as close to real NY pizza and we will order again, soon and often. Delivery was on time and friendly and even with a delivery they delivered the Monday Special. These guys ROCK! Run, don't walk, to get a real taste of NY/NJ 'za! Awesome! read more

Noelia T.

35

2

1

9 years ago

I would not go to another pizza shop in this area.. great service, fresh food all the time. Manager is awesome!

Matthew M.

0

22

3

2 years ago

Always good, never had a bad pizza from here. Highly recommend. Good prices, good staff

Lucy E.

95

9

0

15 years ago

Pizza is fair and prices are good for slices and on Mondays there is a good special.

Edward T.

17

10

7 years ago

Great pizza as always! When I'm visiting Cary.

Annette G.

0

9

0

10 years ago

Calzone is out of this world good.... :)

Primo Pizza NY Style - pizza - Updated October 2026

People who viewed Primo Pizza NY Style also viewed

Avent ferry pizza

4.2

(50 reviews)

Spending a quick night in Raleigh and was looking for a close local pizza delivery. Avent Ferry…read moredelivers thru Slice (pizza app) & had great reviews - so I tried it out. Food came quick and was hot & fresh (within 30min on. Sunday at 7p ). Stromboli was filled w/ steak and perfectly cooked (see pics). Chicken tenders were a frozen brand but were still flavorful. Also, the homemade ranch was amazing - and I'm kinda a ranch snob. Definitely worth a try if you are looking for a local pizzeria in the NC State area.

The crust is far and away the best part of the pizza. We had New York cheese steak roll and an…read moreIndian Paneer pizza. Both were absolutely fabulous. The Indian pizza specifically had a heat that was present but not overwhelming and we would come back for. Overall, the food was great and would order again. We made the mistake of eating there, and although there were in fact four tables, it is not really a place conducive to dining. We had to ask for utensils and even then, no knife was available. I absolutely reccomend the food, but get as take out or delivery.

Slice of NY Pizza

3.5

(126 reviews)

The best pizza!!! This is a pizza I always get …read more Love the 2 piece pizza special. The buffalo pizza is my favorite!!

I've had their pizza multiple times, and while I'd say it's slightly better than Mellow Mushroom, I…read morewouldn't consider it anything particularly special. What really left a bad taste in my mouth was an interaction I had with management. I came in about 10 minutes before closing and asked if they would be willing to give me a deal on some of the pizza they throw out at the end of the night if it doesn't sell. A manager or owner told me that they donate the leftover pizza instead. I waited until closing and saw the leftover pizza being thrown directly into the trash, aside from a few slices that staff members took home. I completely understand if the restaurant doesn't want to discount or sell leftover food. They could have simply said, "Sorry, we don't offer discounts on unsold pizza," and I would have respected that. But telling me that the food is donated, only for me to see it being thrown away 10 minutes later, really rubbed me the wrong way. It's not even about getting a discount it's about being honest with customers. If the policy is that leftover pizza gets thrown away, just say that. I'd have respected the honesty a lot more.

Big Sergio's Pizza

4.0

(130 reviews)

This is a new favorite!…read more We got two pizzas for takeout One was just a pepperoni for the kids and the other was the Bianca pizza Oh my word. The Bianca was wonderful great flavor, fresh ricotta cheese, it was even good the next day The pepperoni was good too This pizza holds up. The Crust crisp to it but is hardy around the edges as well. I could've eaten the crust all by itself. They also sell pizza by the slice. I went by a day or two later and got a meat lovers and the cheese. Again, the crust was phenomenal, the ingredients were fresh. They don't chinche on the toppings, and the meats are quality The menu has so much more on there that I want to try. I'll have to come back. This is a cute place. It's not big but has booths and tables and feels very much like an old Timey pizzeria. It makes me want to come back and eat in the restaurant. The guys behind the camera were helpful and very friendly as well.

Stopped in a little before noon. Wasn't too busy. Ordered a slice of cheese and drink for just a…read morelittle over $5. Those with a big appetite could do a two cheese slice special for just under 7. Pizza came out hot and very cheesy with a crispy crust. Very good! Service was friendly and attentive and pizza was ready quick.

The Original NY Pizza

3.8

(101 reviews)

Just came by after doctor's appointment in Cary. Outstanding pizza. Grab a cheese and a speciality…read more Everything tasted great. Plenty of workers available. Would definitely stop by again if in the area.

I've been a regular customer since 1994 (originally their Harrison store) by now frequent their…read moreTryon location. Love their pizza, and Stromboli

Johnny's Pizza Cary

4.2

(475 reviews)

I was last here about seven years ago because I don't live in the area. We're visiting family here…read morein Cary and based on our great memories of the place, coming to Johnny's was a must on our itinerary. I'm super super happy to say that everything that made this place so wonderful seven years ago is still here. The pizza is still spot on, the portions are still huge, and the value for the money can't be beat. The employees were friendly and attentive and made us feel welcome when we walked through the door and during our time eating . My notoriously picky son who was not here with us seven years ago loved the pizza so much that he told us that he wants to live here in the restaurant (and I'm not convinced that he's kidding). I don't know when we'll next be in Cary, but as long as Johnny's Pizza is here, they'll have loyal customers in me and my family. The pictures I'm going to post don't do the food justice, but by the time I thought to take pictures, the family had already started devouring everything.

Came a few years back for a yelp event and was in the area so made a stop. Probably the best and…read morehottest slice I've had in a long time. Highly recommend.

The Original NY Pizza

3.8

(70 reviews)

The pizza was pretty good at this place. Toppings were a little sloppily cut. The place was near…read moreand clean. Food came out semi quick but there were a lot of workers milling around.

The pizza in this place is so damn good. It's definitely legit NY thin crust. Service is , always…read moreand it had an old pizzeria vibe to it. The square Sicilian slice is out of this world also.

Lilly's Pizza

3.5

(798 reviews)

Lilly's is our go to pizza! It is the most delicious pizza in the triangle! The crust is so good,…read morethe cheesy bread is amazing! Our whole family loves it so much it's become our weekly go to place. In a world where it feels like restaurant consistency is going down hill, I'm so thankful for Lilly'!

Lilly's is one of my favorite pizza spot in Raleigh. It's located in the five points neighborhood…read moreoff glenwood ave. Their pizzas never disappoint. My favorite is the Dantes Inferno and the Super Duper. The atmosphere is very casual and laid back. Parking can be a challenge though.

The Pizza Times

3.2

(41 reviews)

We loved how the slices looked so we ordered them to be delivered. They were thick doughy and…read moretasteless. We expected so much more and it was terrible. I know they can do better. Look at past pictures. Not sure what happened but not good

The pizza and garlic knots are delicious! Thin crust and good prices. Service is always great and…read morequick. Hours are great and open on Sundays!

Johnnys Pizza Raleigh

4.6

(11 reviews)

Johnny's Pizza took over the Papa's Pizza location in the Greystone Shopping Center. The interior…read morehas been redone, and likely the kitchen as well. The dining area seems smaller than before, but most of the business is likely to be takeout. The inside seating consists of six tables, mostly four-tops. There are two TVs, one with sound and the other with captioning. Outside seating is at the picnic tables. Ordering is done at the counter, and the menu is on the wall. Pepsi products are sold here, but they did have Dr. Pepper and Cheerwine. It is available in cans or in the fountain. They do not have iced tea as they do at their other locations, so I hope that gets added, as I prefer tea to drink. They sell slices, personal, medium and large pizzas. Besides pizzas, they have salads, subs and pasta dishes. I had my mind set on Johnny's White Pizza, since that is what I get at the other locations, but I usually get a big pizza and take the leftovers home. But on theatre day, that wasn't going to work. So what they did was make me a special personal-sized pizza. So I was very grateful. The slices they sell are large but just $5 each. So I might try the regular pizza next time, but I am a big fan of Johnny's White.

I ordered takeout through the Slice app from Johnny's on Lead Mine…read more The parking lot is pretty busy with all the businesses in the same shopping center. My pizza was ready in the time they said it would be, and when I arrived, I got it within minutes. Inside has a few tables and booths. They have tables outside as well. It's not huge inside, but a nice place to eat in if you decide. We ordered one of their gourmet specialty pizzas, The White Pizza and added chicken and bacon. $40 for a pizza, I can say it was worth it. We also ordered the Cheesesteak Egg Rolls, 3 for $12. They had a good taste but the filling didn't taste like cheesesteak at all.

Benny Capitale's

3.6

(145 reviews)