A great late night find. I really enjoyed the garlic white slice, even though I usually don't even usually like thin New York slice style or white pizza lolzzz. I preferred it over the grandma square slice here which is usually my jam. I think the garlic flavor really came through strong because of how thin the pizza was, and the crust was perfect too! Pizzas were ready super quick, I came close to closing but the worker was very accommodating and kind! I also think the packaging here is really cute- the individually packaged parmesan cheese was a nice touch! read more

Prime Pizza - garlic white slice and grandma square - Pizza Near Me - Mission Viejo, California

See all

NY Style pizza is good. Vodka Pizza is even better. Service: generally great but today waited 45mins for pickup. Pickup mistakes happen but it would be nice if they acclerated the order for the follow up order. Customer service was friendly the whole thime. read more

A Taste of New York While some may disagree with pricing, being from Queens, I can't argue that this is not a taste of New York. The taste is right, and I'm so happy to have this in a such a close by location., Everything in California, definitely Orange County, costs some money, so I'm happy to take a bite of what feels like home to me. The thin crust, the scabby cheese, the slice warm and soft from the oven, the smell, really reminds me of being from my hometown, without having to go there! They have a lot of great options and toppings, including having sicilian/Grandma slices, and even NY water ice! The customer service is great, just be clear about what you want. They are all so nice and helpful. I look forward to being back! read more

When my jet lagged body was not up to cooking dinner, it was Prime Pizza to the rescue! Ordered one of their 18" cheese pizzas ($24) online and it was ready by the time we arrived. The pizza was piping hot and was still hot by the time we got back home. It was the perfect NY-style slice - thin, with a nice sauce and just the right amount of cheese. There were eight giant slices - two slices were about all I could manage. If you order via Toast online, you can earn points towards a future discount. Bonus! read more

Prime Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Mission Viejo, California

See all

I was surprised to see a pizza by the slice store as I was walking around this plaza. I got the cheese pizza and it was delicious! I wanted another one, but wasn't sure what to get, opted for the BBQ chicken and asked if the sauce was overly sweet. The guy said it was his favorite so I got that one too and service is amazing because he gave me a chip for a free pizza just in case I didn't like it. It turned out pretty good lol! I rarely eat pizza and only like thin crust so this really hits the spot when you're craving something fast! read more

Prime Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Mission Viejo, California

We were craving some pizza and needed a snack to hold us over until dinner so we decided to get Prime! We forgot it was also pie day lol! We got 2 pepperoni + bbq chicken and they gave us a free slice since it was the last one of that batch We wait about 10-15 min for it to be reheated, which is a bit long imo. Then they brought the pizza out for us. The pizza was good, but I was definitely expecting a cheesier pull, and it to be hotter. I took a pic right after it came out and you can already tell it wasn't piping hot. Almost missing that super hot and cheesy pull like a Costco pizza. The ranch is a little bit thick. But overall the pizza was good and I would return While we were waiting, the team seems very friendly/talkative with one another. They also collected our trays after we finished! read more

Prime Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Mission Viejo, California

We mobile ordered pizzas for the NFL playoffs.my son went overboard and ordered 3 different pizzas. Really great crust, which is a must for my picky family. The pizzas were delicious . We ordered one square pizza, The Sicilian, and the pesto added just the right flavor to make the pizza. The crust is really thick and filling. If I had to do it over, I would have ordered a round. My son's favorite was the pepperoni with the ricotta. I would put Prime right up there with Brooklyn City Pizza. Even though we ordered ahead of time, we still had to wait. It's nice to have a new pizza spot in South OC! We're definitely going to come back in the future. Food 4.5/5 Service (mobile order) 4/5 Atmosphere 4.5/5 read more

See all

What an exciting time to have Prime pizza local to us now. The service is fast, friendly, and efficient. Although parking is tight, being in a popular spot you can just park further park and snag something. This is a grab and go in my opinion, no seating inside and there's one table right in front. But hey. You don't need to sit down to eat a pizza right? You can eat this delish cheesy goodness anywhere, we took it to go and enjoyed it at home with the kids. There was nothing that disappointed us.. only that we had wished we'd ordered more to try more. You know that a lot of time and love goes into their food. Wings and garlic knots are a must, but try it all.. at least that's our plan when we are in the area. read more

See all

I wish I had known about Prime Pizza sooner!!! My new favorite pizza place in South OC.....and my most favorite spot since moving to SoCal. My waistline be dammed as eating their pizza is totally worth it!! They make good dough, use good quality sauce, and the toppings are excellent. Never knew I would actually be able to enjoy pizza without a stomachache or horrible bloat until trying theirs. The crusts are chewy without it being too crispy, limp, or soggy. I liked the sausage kale and their white pizza. Such a giant pie too! Loved the box design for the holidays and everything in the churro box was OMG too. So delicious. Can't wait to go back again soon and I hope everyone in the area tries them out!! read more

Prime Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Mission Viejo, California

Staff: Here is where they REALLY shined. I was so impressed by the customer service here. Everyone was so friendly, genuine, and made me feel very welcome. Customer service of this level is not found often. Quality/Quantity: The pizza here is really good and portions are fair. I opted for the Grandma style which was so good. It is like deep dish, crunchy, and very flavorful. The rest of my party had the cheese and pepperoni slices along with us all sharing the garlic knots. Everything was really good. Only suggestion I would say is to offer the marinara sauce warm with the garlic knots. They were very tasty and this would only add to an already delicious item. Lastly, got to try their chocolate chip cookie which was delicious. It is chewy just the way I like it. Value: Fair in my opinion. They also have a lunch special (see pics). Overall: I was so impressed with my experience on all levels. I'll be back for sure. There are 4 tables outside and a small 2 seater inside. This spot has a nice ambiance and a great addition to the center. read more

See all

Prime was such a great little surprise. We stopped by on a whim since it's still fairly new to the area and we'd heard good things, and it absolutely lived up to the hype. The staff was friendly, welcoming, and quick with solid recommendations. We ordered the wings and each grabbed a slice--the Sicilian and the Pepperoni. Both were delicious, but the Sicilian really stood out. Anything with ricotta is my go‑to, and this one did not disappoint. The wings took a little longer than expected, but the team handled it so graciously--they gave us an extra Sicilian slice to take home, completely on the house, without hesitation. That kind of service goes a long way and it reheated wonderfully in the air fryer. There isn't a ton of outdoor seating, but you can easily sit over by Mendocino Farms if you want to enjoy your food outside. Parking in this center can be a bit of a nightmare depending on the time of day, but honestly, the food and service make it worth the effort. Overall, Prime is definitely a spot we'll be returning to--great pizza, great people, and a really positive first impression. read more

Good quality and very efficient On time delivery and you got try their Supreme pizza read more

I have been reading about Prime Pizza for a while and was excited when they opened this OC location. We stopped at Philz Coffee next door so I had to stop in to try it and see what all the rave was about. It's a light and bright small storefront with its signature red and white color scheme. They have several of their pizzas on display for those that want to buy by the slice. Luckily, they have a vegan option so my daughter was able to get some pizza too. We ordered pepperoni, Sicilian spicy pepperoni and I asked the server, Paul what he recommended, and he said the cheese slice is what made them famous. Paul and the rest of the staff were so friendly and helpful since this was our first time. They brought the hot slices out and also checked on us later. The crust was very crispy, even on the thicker Sicilian slice. They all had so much flavor. In fact, the vegan slice might have been all our favorite. So much so that my daughter ordered another one. We will be back to try the other flavors and probably order a whole pie. read more

See all

So happy Prime Pizza is in the OC!! Tried their El Segundo spot and loved their spicy pep pie, had to get a whole one again to see if it lived up to its og spot. It's a pretty small location with only a couple tables outside so definitely more of a grab and go sorta place. Cashiers were patient and helpful in suggesting pizza slices to try. The lemon pepper wings were extra salty with some of the meat being a little dry but the lemon flavor was there. Garlic knots were also just ok. I'm curious to try their Sicily and Grandma slices as well! read more

See all

Awesome service, very friendly and helpful! It's a new place my husband and I always love to try new places. This place just opened up maybe a few months ago. If you are on your lunch break they have 2 great lunch special for you. I ordered one of the lunch special and my husband ordered the other. We always do that so we can share more food choices. I am sorry I don't have pics of my food because we were very hungry next time I will them. I ordered slice of bbq chicken, Cesar salad with a drink (a lot of drink option). My husband ordered the 2 slices one bbq chicken the other one was Sicilian. Ok - so I prefer the bbq sauce to be the main sauce Not on top of my toppings, other than that the pizza was perfect to me crispy on bottom and soft enough on top and the Sicilian was scrumptious! I highly recommend the reason I am giving them a 4star is because of the bbq sauce. read more

See all

Great Pizza option for all the South OC'ers! Ordered 2 pizzas delivered to Lake Forest (The Sicilian Square pizza, and a cheese pizza). Both were fantasy. Crispy, cheesy, Thin NY Style Pizza. Used their app on iOs. In a time where NY/Brooklyn style Pizza spots are popping up and becoming more popular, Prime Pizza has established themselves as a great option. Cannot wait to try their garlic knots and wings. But their pizza? Don't hesitate to call them and place an order. Can't comment on Ambiance...except for the fact that it made my home that much better. Oh, and the way their package their Parmesan? Pièce de résistance!!! read more

See all

A SLICE OF NYC IN THE NEIGHBORHOOD! I'd heard all the hype about Prime Pizza bringing true New York-style slices to LA, so I was excited when this new location opened. I was especially excited since it's surrounded by other food spots (perfect for families who can never agree on dinner). My son and I were craving pizza, and luckily they sell slices so we didn't have to commit to a whole pie! We ordered two pepperoni and two cheese, and these slices are huge. The crust was perfectly crisp on the outside, soft inside, and the flavors were spot-on. Classic, delicious, and exactly what you hope for from a NY-style slice. I also love that they offer square pies, gluten-free, and even vegan options. Super happy to have Prime Pizza nearby, and I'll definitely be back to try a full pie--and maybe some of their pasta or subs! read more

Prime Pizza - Pepperoni Slice - Pizza Near Me - Mission Viejo, California

See all

This is currently my top two New York style pizza in Orange County. Pizza was perfectly done, crust was amazing, and so were the toppings and the overall flavor. It was DoorDash, so popped it in the oven for a few minutes and it turned out perfect. So happy we're getting more spots with authentic New York pizza down here. Thank you! read more

Prime Pizza - Half pepperoni half arrabiata - Pizza Near Me - Mission Viejo, California

See all

We love this shopping mall because there is a target and other really good food restaurants so when we saw Prime was opening up during a recent visit we were excited to check it out. We went on a Friday and there was no line. We opted for the slices and got the cheese, spicy pepperoni square, pepperoni and white pizza. The cheese was ok, nothing special. The pepperoni square was good but way too spicy for my liking that I wasn't able to really enjoy it. The white pizza was my favorite - The flavor was so good and the pepperoni was good too. Overall we really enjoyed it and is a new favorite. The ranch was top notch and so was the lemonade. My only thing - the Parmesan cheese for those eating there was dried out. Second, after you pay it ask for an email to track your points (we got 26) and when i put my email it didn't allow me to hit next, so what's the point? It also didn't let me use a cell number which would be much better. 2 things that can be worked on but the pizza was good. read more

Prime Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Mission Viejo, California

I love the fact that they sell slices and this was my first ever visit after hearing about the LA locations for years. Pros: Quick and friendly service Variety of options including vegan Fair prices Cons: On this particular visit my slice was still cold even after several minutes of reheating it in the oven. While its in a convenient location, it doesn't reach any Top 10 South OC options such as Lunitas, Truly, Doho, B+C, Brooklyn city, etc read more

Prime Pizza - Spicy Pepperoni Square Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Mission Viejo, California

Quality control would help. If you order through a delivery service. Paul says there is nothing they can do for you. read more

Prime Pizza - Scorched pizza. - Pizza Near Me - Mission Viejo, California

See all

Great pizza!! The flavor of the toppings and texture of the crust is very well done. Refreshing Arnold Palmer. Spicy pepperoni was really good, definitely has some heat. The garlic knots were really good as well, delicious flavor and soft in texture. read more

See all

I was disappointed in the food quality here. I visited on a Friday evening around 8:30 and while there was no line and plenty of slices in the display case, the food was a let down. We had a chicken parm sub and slice of BBQ pizza, both of which were dry, lacking any sort of sauce, and kind of bland. I was looking forward to trying this place because I thought the branding was cool but I won't be visiting again. One final thing, the young that helped us at the register had an attitude of "I don't want to be here, I don't want to say too much so I'm going to only give a one word answer to your questions and basically hurry up so I don't have to do much work". Sad really. read more

We had awesome time last night for my uncle birthday celebration. Food was delicious, atmosphere was amazing and cozy, service was superior. Highly recommend this place read more

Prime Pizza - Best pizza ever! - Pizza Near Me - Mission Viejo, California

So excited that a Prime Pizza finally opened in OC! Prime is a fast casual joint that allows you to order a whole pie, or by the slice! They have other options like garlic knots or pasta, but my go to is always the spicy pep. They have counters on the inside for you to stand and dine or a few tables outside to dine on. The pizzas by the slice is always a great option if you want something quick! read more

Prime Pizza - Spicy Pep - Pizza Near Me - Mission Viejo, California

Disclaimer right up front: Pizza is a highly personal choice and every person on the planet will tell you that their favorite is the best... This place just opened up in the past few weeks so as you can imagine it is very busy. Best option is to order ahead from their website so your wait time is a bit shorter. Mainly a takeaway place but they do have a few small tables to eat at.. very clean inside with easy to read menu. They sell slices or entire pies.. one slice is plenty for lunch.. From what we can see they were not quite ready at the grand opening for the amount of orders but they are working hard to get the order to delivery times down. Give it time and things will be running smoothly. Tried a few things over a couple of visits.. the grandma pizza was as described and pretty good. Thick chewy crust much like a focaccia in the middle and crispy cheese on the edges. Tried the one with pesto and ricotta on another visit.. very good flavors here. The Caesar salad was okay but a bit pricey for the size.. not sure on that one.. at the end of the day a Caesar salad is just iceberg lettuce and dressing.. I think it was like 17 bucks... the summary is that this place is well worth trying! read more

Prime Pizza - Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Mission Viejo, California

See all

As far as a slice on the go - I would recommend this spot. We got three slices and garlic knots. Heads up - the slices are reheated fairly quickly. The knots took 18 minutes for prep. We finished our slices before the knots were ready. - veggie/ vegan slice: kale with mushroom and red bell pepper. We liked this more than expected. The kale was lightly crispy like kale chips. - vodka slice: definitely basil forward. If you like basil, go for it. For me, not a strong enough sauce profile. - spicy pepperoni grandma slice: best of the bunch. Hard to strike a good balance between bready and crispy dough, but this slice does it. - garlic knots: a bit disappointing. Upside: good but not overbearing garlic flavor. Not oily. Downside: big time gap between readiness of knots and slices. A bit dense. Served with a cold tomato sauce. The sauce helped mitigate the bready dryness, but also did not have a strong flavor. Service was friendly. Only a couple of chairs to eat inside. Better to eat on the patio or to go. Also - they are Dodger fans - so gotta love that. read more

See all

Paid them a visit on their second day of opening as my LA based daughter raved about them. It's a small shop, nestled within other eateries, with a couple of outside tables. I ordered a regular slice and a grandma square slice. Both were delicious; the sauce/cheese ratio is on point and the crusts are thin and crispy but not cracker like, with no flop on the regular slice. The grandma square slice was particularly good as it was feather light yet pleasantly crunchy/chewy and the sauce is a little different from the regular slice. Highly recommended and I look forward to ordering whole pies. read more

Prime Pizza - Grandma slice. - Pizza Near Me - Mission Viejo, California

The pizza was out of this world. The undercarriage was perfectly toasted. The old school pepperoni was amazeballs. I will be coming here for genuine New York Style Pizza for now on! read more

The pizza is just average, and the Mission Viejo store needs serious improvement to the pickup process. I arrived 15 minutes early, at 6:10pm, for a 6:24 order pickup to see if it was ready, and was told to come back later. But now there is a huge line for pickups, and it's past my pickup time. There are at least a dozen people in line, and instead of calling out orders when they come out of the kitchen, the order processing person is just putting them in a hotbox. Please improve your pickup operations -- or make your pizza so outstanding that it's worth these inconveniences. read more

Prime Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Mission Viejo, California

Great tasting pizza, but hat's been well established at their other locations so I'm not going to focus on that here. Very friendly and helpful staff. Pizzas in the display case are labeled making for efficient ordering. No TVs. No beer or wine. Small standing counter on the inside and just two tables outside so this is very much a takeout place, so order online or by phone and get in and out quickly. Grandma (square) slices are $5 each. Two would be a filling meal. A lot of good restaurants in this corner so don't be surprised if you can't park right in front at busy lunch and dinner hours. read more

See all

The pizza here is actually better than I thought it would be! I got the spicy vodka and it does have it kick which I love! Their customer service is very good and they're pretty fast with your pizza. I wish I had taken a picture of the pizza but the moment I took the first bite it had no chance. The first time I went I got a slice and the next day I went back to get a box. read more

The best NY pizza on the west coast hands down. The best crunch and bite and high quality toppings and amazing ranch to dip. To start get a slice of spicy pepperoni and Vodka to try. read more

Prime Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Mission Viejo, California

Food and service was absolutely amazing! We stuck with the classics pepperoni and supreme! This place didn't disappoint.

Finally. Excellent pizza in South Orange County. If you haven't tried prime pizza yet please do. Easily heads and shoulders better than anything you can get in a reasonable distance. I loved this place when I lived in LA and am thrilled that they are down here. Recommend to anyone. Below is the vodka pizza after it cooled down. read more

Prime Pizza - Vodka Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Mission Viejo, California

Clean. Fast and friendly service. No seating - take out only except for a little bit of counter space. Great selection. The more traditional slices are just right, e.g., cheese or pepperoni. The Grandma, for example, is good but ... may not meet the expectations of someone from Jersey, NY, or CT - but will do. read more

We'd been hearing good things about Prime Pizza's LA locations but were admittedly skeptical since it's a chain. We ordered three pies through their app: a round cheese, a round pepperoni, and the spicy square pepperoni. It's a small strip-mall spot with two tables out front, and the service was proper, nice, and friendly. The round pies were very good, though they leaned a bit undercooked and doughy. The bottom on the pepperoni pie was nice, though. I'll chalk it up to them still dialing in the ovens. But the square pie, absolutely perfect in every way. It's been a long time since I've had a square this good. I really hope the consistency stays strong because I'll be back very soon for another one. read more

Prime Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Mission Viejo, California

See all

I honestly didn't expect much at first, my son just wanted a slice of pizza, but this place completely surprised me. I tried a bite and it was AMAZING. It reminded me of real New York-style pizza, which I've been looking for forever. The pizza was hot, fresh, and full of flavor. On top of that, Paul was incredibly kind and welcoming and he really made the experience even better. It was refreshing to experience someone who truly knows customer service. Between the quality of the food and the service, this place is a 10/10 for me. I'll definitely be coming back and getting a whole family pizza next time! read more

One Bite gave Prime an 8.1 in LA. Just opened one local. Underwhelming Jersey pie. 6.8 . But hey, what do I know? Enjoy read more

Prime Pizza - Cheese pie , well done easy cheese, jalapeno's - Pizza Near Me - Mission Viejo, California

They have a wide selection of vegan dishes and pizza options. Order was ready and on time.