Priester Pies

7.3 km

Megan was a delight to work with and does a beautiful job. Her cake and cake pops were delicious…read more She created a custom tiered cake for my son's tropical birthday party and it was a hit! Highly recommend.

Hands down the best macaron I've ever had! I am a snob with macarons and she blew me away with her…read morebanana pudding macaron. Do yourself a favor and get some. She is now our go to for macarons. Will have to try other things from her once we go through all her flavors.

Brownies

Cake jars

See all

Custom cake for 1st birthday

The Whisk It Shoppe

6.9 km

Jessie is amazing. She made 3 different cakes along w two pies for our wedding and I still to this…read moreday have friends and family who talk about how great desert was! We go to the whisk it Shoppe for every celebration. Next time try the lemon cake w lemon buttercream , it's amazing

Jessie is AMAZING!! I ordered birthday cakes from her twice...so far. Since I was ordering in…read moreadvance from California, communication was key. I was able to get beautiful cakes for my niece's and nephew's birthdays. Not only were the cakes perfectly themed, they were delicious. I'm not fond of fondant, so only buttercream was used. The kids and adults loved the cakes! When I'm in town for the next family birthday, I'll be ordering another cake from The Whisk It Shoppe. The process was easy and everyone was friendly.

The Whisk It Shoppe is a bakery serving up sweet and savory treats to brighten your day or make your events more special!

See all

Woodland Creatures Baby Shower Cake

Sweet Boutique Bakery

4.6(8 reviews)

10.5 km•Ballantyne

I am not from Charlotte and decided to try this bakery. I stumbled on this location online and…read moreliked the images viewed. I had the opportunity to order my cake months in advance. Below are some helpful tips to help you determine if this is the bakery that you would like to try: There is an online payment system available, which makes it easy. The prices are higher than your typical bakery, at least three times higher. Despite the prices being higher, they do not deliver. The cake topper broke that was on my cake for my milestone birthday. This was not a good experience. The cake did not look as desired for my photos. The cake was not moist but dry. It had a great deal of flavor of the vanilla, but was not the tastiest cake that I have tried to Charlotte so far. I am not sure how long is sitting in the refrigerator prior to pick up and when it was made or how it was stored, but I have a problem with that. Out of 15 guests not one person like the cake. I found it a bit embarrassing as the host. Hours of operation for pick up are limited. Good luck!

We ordered a custom mushroom cake. Thank you so much for the beautiful cake! Everyone agrees that…read morethe cake is outstanding and special. Very detailed! So pretty that you feel bad about cutting it. :-) I'm sure it's going to be so memorable for the birthday girl. We got the vanilla flavor cake and it is tasty. Thank you, Sweet Boutique Bakery!

See all

B'zzz Cakes

4.5(39 reviews)

8.5 km

This is a nice cupcake boutique in a small shopping center. There's plenty of shared parking. They…read morehave a variety of flavors of cupcakes and a rewards program. And the more cupcakes you get the cheaper your price is. The police was clean and they had great customer service . Had the opportunity to try the pineapple upside down cake, death by chocolate, coconut cream, and crème brûlée. The crème brûlée was very delicious. The coconut cream was nice texture and flavor. The pineapple upside down was a big mess for me. it wasn't fresh. Death by chocolate was OK. I hope that you have a great experience and definitely a cute little place to try if you have a sweet tooth.

I tried this cute bakery last week and loved the cupcakes I got to try! I got a 4 pack and out of…read morethose I got to have the Biscoff and the Peanut Butter Oreo. Both had delicious frostings, fillings, and the cake was nice and moist. The other 2 were demolished by by son. I will definitely be back to try some more flavors!

See all

Zombie brains (jelly filling)

Cupcrazed Cakery

4.0(299 reviews)

3.3 km

•$$

In addition to the cupcakes being so delicious, they did a same day, custom order for gender reveal…read morecupcakes. The staff was super nice and helpful. Highly recommend.

I was in for the gluten free cupcakes. I tried red velvet and salted Carmel. Red velvet was my…read morefavorite. Salted Carmel definitely tastes gluten free to me. If you know you know. Staff was super friendly and shop was decorated really cute. I'll be back for the red velvet!

Decorated Dozen

Cupcakes and cookies! Cookies are oatmeal cream pie, banana pudding and s'mores!

See all

Mad Batter Bakery

81.7 km

If you're in the market for an amazingly tasty and beautiful cake for ANY occasion, I HIGHLY…read morerecommend Mad Batter Bakery! I personally know the owner, and have known her for years. She is insanely talented, and bakes the greatest tasting cakes. I bought a German Chocolate cake from her last week, and everyone in my entire family LOVED It. Even my father, (who I can't ever please,) said it was the best tasting cake he's had in a long long time. Her cakes are very moist, fresh, and rich. You will NOT be disappointed. She can decorate and customize any cake you need for any occasion, and they always turn out so beautiful! Tasty and beautiful actually- almost too pretty to eat, but too delicious to turn down! Her business is new and local, so help spread the word by giving her a try and liking her page on facebook! I promise it'll be the best cake you've ever tasted! Hands down!

She made my baby shower cake exactly how I wanted it. The cake was moist and so delicious. Highly…read morerecommend!

See all

German chocolate cake

Southern Belle Bakery

96.6 km

I ordered a cake for a 250th Marine Corps birthday celebration. It was beautiful, exactly what I…read moreasked for, and it was also delicious. Rebecca was friendly and easy to work with. I highly recommend Southern Belle Bakery.

This is a wonderful business! I ordered my daughter's birthday cake through Rebecca and she was…read morepleasant and so professional and sweet. The cake was delicious and designed beautifully. Thank you so much, Rebecca! It was an absolute pleasure doing business with you

Wedding cake

Wedding Cake

See all

Custom cake

Cold Stone Creamery

3.9(19 reviews)

2.7 km

I found this on my ride home as I needed to take a work call. I went in after parking close by. The…read moreemployee was very nice and helpful. I tried something new. The lemon ice cream with lemon Oreos. She suggested it and it didn't disappoint. It was extremely good and refreshing. I will definitely return to this location in the future. There aren't many cold stones in the area and this may be one of the closest to me.

This Cold Stone location in Fort Mill is much better than the Rivergate location in Steele Creek…read more I'm a little closer to the Rivergate location, but this one is worth it coming the little extra way. Each time I've ordered, whether online or in person has been a great experience. One time recently, I tried ordering online, and it would not let me use my coupon - kept saying I needed to add valid items to my cart. I would add different items, and still nothing would work. I went inside and explained the situation. They tried to do the order in the system first before making my order to see if it would work. They had no issues applying the coupon that was on my account to what I wanted to order. Allison J. was on the receipt that time, which appears to be a manager based on other reviews. She is excellent - friendly and helpful! I do hope they bring back the Don't lay a finger on my Butterfinger creation because it was very good - peanut butter ice cream with Butterfingers, caramel, and chocolate. Yum!

See all

Cupcake Delirium

4.7(133 reviews)

10.0 km

•$

This is the lil hidden gem in Charlotte/Pineville with big flavor. The shop is so cute, almost like…read morestepping into a colorful cupcake. I started my fandom at their food truck and was so happy they opened a shop near me. They post on FB the daily cupcakes which I think I've had most of them but my favs are: the Elvis (banana cupcake, and candied bacon on-top of whipped peanut butter icing), the pecan pie (vanilla cupcake with a small slice of pecan pie baked in, whipped vanilla icing and a roasted pecan on top), Snickers, strawberry fields, death by chocolate, animal cracker and blue berry French toast. You can't go wrong with any deletion but they have a great deal, buy a box of cupcakes (4 or 6) and bring the box back to get free cupcakes.

This is a cute shop. I loved that they offered more than cupcakes. It was hard to decide what to…read moretry especially when you have no self control and with a teenager. The service was awesome, friendly and welcoming. The cupcakes and cookie were delicious.

Dirt cupcakes

One of my favorites - the carrot cake

See all

Cute names

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

19 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Derrick D.

4 months ago

I cannot recommend Priester Pies enough! My entire experience was phenomenal from the initial intake conversation all the way through the follow up after the service was completed. I had a last minute request for a homemade apple pie that I needed the very next day, and Christine went above and beyond to make it happen. She personally called me that evening to discuss exactly what I needed while also sharing the history of the company and the passion behind their services, which I truly appreciated. From that moment forward, the level of customer service was top tier. The next day, she kept me updated on timing and expectations throughout the process. Even when I was running late due to inclement weather, she remained incredibly understanding and encouraged me to travel safely while coming to pick up the pie. When I arrived, I was greeted with such a warm and welcoming spirit. During our conversation the night before, I casually mentioned how much I loved red velvet cake while browsing her website. To my surprise, she included an extra box with a red velvet dessert along with my apple pie. That level of attentiveness and genuine care goes a very long way with me and speaks volumes about how much Priester Pies values their customers. The desserts themselves were absolutely phenomenal. Both the apple pie and red velvet cake were packed with incredible flavor and moisture. The apple pie had the perfect balance of sweetness, spice, and fresh apple flavor with a buttery homemade crust that tasted amazing. The red velvet cake was rich, soft, moist, and full of flavor with an incredible cream cheese icing. My friends and family could not stop talking about them during and after dinner. Everything tasted homemade with love and intention. Priester Pies has earned a lifelong customer. If you are looking for exceptional desserts paired with outstanding customer service, this is the place to go!p read more

Rachel W. G.

5 years ago

I just ordered an italian cream cake from Priester Pies for my birthday. Oh my goodness!! It was amazing. Everyone at the party raved about how wonderful the cake was!! I have also had the chance to order several different cakes over the last few months from Priester Pies and they all have been perfectly cooked, moist, and really great. She even created cupcakes for my 8 year old son's birthday party, packaging each one individually due to COVID-19 concerns. She meets any task with excellence!! Christine is an amazing baker and I highly recommend her and her business for any of your bakery needs. read more

Kirsten A.

6 years ago

What a gem!!! I ran across rhus business searching google for a professional pie baker. After reading the many fabulous reviews, I ordered some sweet potatoes pie tarts for a small gathering. I also ordered a peach pie. These were some really really good pies. The sweet potatoes ones had a candied delicious top and the filling was manifique! They taste like my grandmother's use to. God Rest her soul. Everyone at the gathering just kept asking who made the pies and I told them Priester's Pies. I strongly recommend this place to others . All their pies appear to be beautiful and delicious! read more

Kathey T.

1 year ago

The sweet potato pie by Priester Pies was awesome. The pie was so moist that it melted in my mouth, and it was sweet to my taste buds. I would purchase this sweet potato pie again for myself and any special occasion. The pie tasted like it could have been baked by my grandmother. My grandmother was a baker who knew how to bake anything. Priester Pies are baked by a real baker too. If you try the sweet potato pie, you will want another one to eat again. Please get you a sweet potato pie soon. Yours Truly Kathey Tate read more

Giovanna P.

256

6 years ago

15/10!! I live a few states away and was looking to order baked goods to be delivered in the local SC area, and Christine went above and beyond to answer my questions and let me know about a few items that weren't featured on the website. Everything that they bake, they make it FRESH and with LOVE. Christine is quick to reply and follow up if you have any pending questions. The only downfall is that I'm not closer to be able to order and pick up their baked goods more often! You best believe I'll be ordering from here again read more

Dorothy P.

1 year ago

I love EVERY dessert from Priester Pies! My addictions - sweet potato pies, sweet potato tarts, banana nut muffins w/extra nuts (!!), red velvet cake sliders, lemon pound cake w/lemon glaze. And, on and on. I guarantee you'll NEVER regret ANY purchase! Dive into the succulent and decadent taste of down home pies, cakes, cupcakes, cobblers, etc., just like your mother and grandmother made! She can create your old fashioned dessert or one of her NEWEST ideas. Don't miss the chance for your palate to be thrilled! read more

Mary P.

6 years ago

Check out and order from Priester Pies. I did and we were pleased. We had an event in March and we ordered a peach pie for my family event and it was a hit. It was fresh and it tasted so good. We should have ordered another one. Go ahead and place your order today. I have eaten other products from Priester Pies...sweet potato pie, pound cake, pineapple and apple shooters, and oh my...red velvet cake. read more

Jessica G.

6 years ago

I can't say enough good things about Christine and Priester Pies! I called her last minute for a same day delivery gift and she was so accommodating and understanding. She delivered a fresh baked pie within a few hours along with a hand-written gift note and texted me to let me know it had been delivered. I hear the pie was delicious as well! I will definitely be ordering from Christine again! read more

Rae G.

6 years ago

You all let me tell you--I have really enjoyed my experience with Priester Pies!! We ordered a strawberry cake for Easter. The cake was so moist, and the cream cheese frosting just oozed out of the piece I cut. It was so good--I just had to go back for a second piece. Christine is always so kind and gracious, and I really am so grateful to have her wonderful skills right here in our backyard. read more

Cedric B.

1 year ago

I was gifted from Priester Pies a Lemon Pound Cake with Lemon Glaze, and a Sweet Potato Pie. I'm a baker but let me assure all in the USA and around the globe, Priestess Pies is where we should all be ordering our weekly, holiday, special occasions, and anytime Desserts. Make Priester Pies your go to for your Desserts, Pies, pastries, and all they have to offer. read more

Sam F.

6 years ago

My boyfriend sent me a surprise strawberry cake for my birthday and it was AMAZING. Great flavor, consistency, and just gorgeous to look at. Christine took the order on Sunday morning even though they are closed on Sundays, and delivered the cake herself, and was such a sweetheart during the whole process. Can't wait try more from here! read more

Nicole W.

1 year ago

I recently ordered 6 of the biscoff cheesecake shooters and they are phenomenal! They are the perfect ratio of cheesecake to cookie. The owner Christine is also extremely friendly and always available for any questions. Thank you Priester Pies for your continued wonderful service and delicious items! read more

Heather T.

6 years ago

I searched all over Charlotte for a peach pie as requested for my son's birthday. Priester Pies was the only place I could find that offered it. It was AMAZING! The owner also delivered to Charlotte. We have since tried the apple pie too. Ordered one for home and one for work. DELICIOUS!! read more

Kelly R.

4 years ago

I recently ordered an apple pie from @priesterpies for my dads birthday and it was hands down the BEST apple pie IVE EVER HAD! If you need a dessert for a special occasion or just want to satisfy a craving- I highly recommend. I'll be trying the sweet potato pie next! read more

Andrea J.

121

6 years ago

I have had several of her cakes and pies...which are all absolutely delicious!! But....my favorite is her strawberry shortcake It's light, with fresh strawberries and whip cream, just an amazing cake!!! I can't recommend her enough!!! read more

Shakira H.

1 year ago

Yall let Me tell you the truth! Priester Pies added a new cake to the menu! Moist yes it is! Go on over there and get your Sour Cream Pound Cake! read more

Chanda K.

6 years ago

Professional Delicious!!!!!! The apple pie is so wonderful. The Apple jelly shooter are great. Everything is good.

Ebony H.

6 years ago

One of the best almond bunt cakes I've had hands down. Will defiantly be ordering again soon!!!!

Kevin H.

6 years ago

Fresh and delicious! I originally bought them for the family but they never made it to them lol

Priester Pies - desserts - Updated October 2026

Browse Nearby

BEST of Fort Mill, South Carolina Restaurants near Priester Pies

BEST of Fort Mill, South Carolina Coffee near Priester Pies

BEST of Fort Mill, South Carolina Ice Cream near Priester Pies

BEST of Fort Mill, South Carolina Things to Do near Priester Pies

BEST of Fort Mill, South Carolina Parking near Priester Pies

BEST of Fort Mill, South Carolina Bakery near Priester Pies

BEST of Fort Mill, South Carolina Boba near Priester Pies

BEST of Fort Mill, South Carolina Cookies near Priester Pies

BEST of Fort Mill, South Carolina Shopping near Priester Pies

BEST of Fort Mill, South Carolina Thrift Stores near Priester Pies

Best of Fort Mill

Things to do in Fort Mill

Browse Brands

Brands by name

Browse Articles

Articles by date

People who viewed Priester Pies also viewed

Cupcake Delirium

4.7

(133 reviews)

•$

Cupcrazed Cakery

4.0

(299 reviews)

•$$

In addition to the cupcakes being so delicious, they did a same day, custom order for gender reveal…read morecupcakes. The staff was super nice and helpful. Highly recommend.

Edible Art Cake Shop

(2 reviews)

Phenomenal cakes!! I had the pleasure of eating Edible art cake for my baby shower and it was…read moremagnificent!! They specialize in works of art made into cake. We did a sheet cake for my shower as we wanted the cake to be the star. Their catalog of creative cakes is incredible!! Their location in Matthews is a beautiful little shop in Matthews station (near the CM public library & Pizza Peel.) They have lemon or almond cake by the slice daily or today's special was key lime cake. $5 a slice is very reasonable for such yummy flavors. Plus the slices are huge and shareable size if you want. Truly a mouthful of happiness with strong lovely lime and citrus in a buttercream frosting of key lime. I highly recommend their cakes and thinking this combination of cakes and library books is wonderful!! Parking is in the public lots or spaces in Matthews station.

We ordered my son's cake smash cake and birthday cookies from the shop and was amazed by their…read moreattention to detail and delicious flavor. I sent them a picture of the nautical theme we were looking for and they were spot on with the design. The cookies were a hit at the party for their taste and the designs. We will be ordering from them again!

Summerwood Sweets

(1 review)

Purchased the cookies on the recommendation of my wife. Working for a German company I thought the…read moreOktoberfest designs would be a hit. In my experience there is an inverse relationship between the beauty/detail of a baked good and the taste... well, not with Summerwood! These cookies taste amazing! They look amazing! And people were blown away by the total package. I will definitely be buying again. Hopefully some Thanksgiving and Christmas cookies. Maybe even a cake. Definitely recommend this excellent small business.

Jazina's Creations

(5 reviews)

I placed my first order with Jazina's Creations for Father's Day. She made a vegan strawberry cake…read moreand a vegan chocolate turtle cake. Both were delicious. I've since ordered vegan cupcakes and a vegan chocolate cheesecake. Jazina's never disappoints! In addition to the tasty baked goods, the owner is very responsive, flexible, and professional. The items look just like the pictures on the website. I wouldn't hesitate to recommend Jazina's Creations, especially for those looking for vegan items.

This cake was AMAZING! I had a Gamecock cake made for my husband's birthday. It was so good and…read moretasted so fresh. Jazina is a wonderful baker and so professional! I will definitely be ordering a cake from her again for future occasions!

Nothing Bundt Cakes

3.8

(13 reviews)

Amazing treats for the office. Guaranteed to delight and be devoured. The buntinies are a perfect…read moresize for a little bite in the afternoon.

This is a very clean location and there's plenty of parking in the shared parking lot. It's pretty…read morelarge compared to other stores. They have a variety of items that they sell and the cakes are really yummy; however where they lose the stars are the fact that they do not accept certain coupons like buy one get one that are accepted every store, this choice has me wondering how long this establishment will be present at this area. They really should follow what other stores do in the city of Charlotte do to be consistent. It's optional to get your purchase from this location. Honestly after visiting I would go to the other ones. Good luck

The Batchmaker

4.8

(200 reviews)

•$$

Such a charming little bakery! The location is convenient with plenty of parking, and the space…read moreitself is absolutely adorable. The interior is beautifully decorated and feels warm and inviting. I also loved the thoughtful touches like seating, books, and a little toy kitchen set for kids, which makes it feel especially family-friendly. The baked goods were fantastic across the board, but the chai cookie and oatmeal cream pie were definite standouts. Overall, this is such a cozy, welcoming bakery with amazing treats and a lot of character. I'll definitely be coming back to try more!

I was in Charlotte for a business meeting and decided to stop by The Batch House to sample a few…read morepastries and bring something home to my wife. From the outside, it is an adorable spot with a beautiful, inviting building. Unfortunately, the remarkably unfriendly welcome I received inside immediately crushed my enthusiasm and made me regret walking in. I very nearly turned around and left. I can't say whether the staff was simply having a bad day, whether I didn't look like their usual clientele, or whether something else was going on. Whatever the reason, the interaction tainted my visit from the start. I purchased a Funfetti cupcake, a chocolate chip cookie, a snickerdoodle cookie, and a Key lime pie bar. The chocolate chip cookie was merely okay. Personally, I think a standard Nestlé Toll House cookie made at home would have been better. The snickerdoodle, on the other hand, was outstanding and easily the highlight of everything I tried. The Key lime pie bar had a wonderfully creamy texture and a lovely graham cracker base, but it contained barely any Key lime flavor. There was no citrus punch or brightness--just a smooth, creamy custard on top of graham cracker. The cupcake and frosting both had excellent flavor, but the cake itself was far too crumbly. A little more moisture and structure would have made it much more enjoyable and prevented it from falling apart. Overall, the baked goods were a mixed bag but showed some real potential. Unfortunately, I probably won't return. Even good pastries have a difficult time overcoming an experience with staff who make you feel unwelcome, and I don't particularly enjoy spending money somewhere that leaves me feeling that way. To those about to nosh, best of luck--and consider wearing a little emotional body armor.

Honeybear Bake Shop

4.8

(51 reviews)

Honeybear always slaps. This time I tried a Goodiebag, which is a bit of a gamble because you can't…read morechoose exactly what you get. But everything I've had at HB has been tasty, so figured it was low risk. I ended up with chocolate chip biscoff cookies/scones and peach cookies. I personally don't like frosted or iced cookies, because I find them to be too sweet, so I was really happy with my mix. I have 2 requests: 1. It would be nice to be able to add preferences in the notes (i.e. no frosted, fruit flavors, etc). I know they can't promise anything specifically with Goodiebags, but hey a girl can dream! 2. I took a guess at naming what I received, but it would be easier if they were labeled

If you like Crumbl Cookies, then you will loooove the cookies from honeybear…read more My experience with both places has been that their cookies don't really deliver the flavors and ingredients described, as much as they deliver a sugar RUSH. I have a sweet tooth but these cookies would be best suited for any one that loves unfiltered / undiluted sugar flavor which isn't what we expected from the Strawberry Cheesecake, lemon blueberry crumble, key lime coconut, peanut butter, and Oreo s'more renditions we tried and couldn't finish because they were so sugary. The woman that took our order was sweet and the cookies were pretty so I'd still recommend giving them a try if you really love super sweet flavor profiles.

Sweet Stuff by Leslie