Let me tell you; after living in NYC, and talking pizza in the Catskills, I've slowly come to the…read morerealization that I am a pizza snob. There is pizza rivalry between this spot and Mama's in hunter. THIS PLACE, however, makes the best grandma slice I've ever had. While it's prepared untraditionally (thin crust), I strongly encourage anyone to try it!!! When it comes to a basic slice... ehhh I still veer on the side of Mama's, because they use sesame seeds in their crust (hint*). Get pizza here though!! Also, all these salty people saying they know NYC pizza.. pizza is pizza, stfu! It's either good or it's not! Straight facts

Pretty good local pizza. We had the meat lovers which tasted great. Worth a try in the area.read more

The pizza was amazing! Being a NYC raised person I can say best pizza in this area! Also delicious…read morechurros! Thank you!

I ordered the dinner dish pasta bolognese. It had a miniature of chop meat. The sauce was not red…read moremarinara sauce. It was a creme sauce. Traditional sauce has tomato base made with tomatoes, garlic, basil,(oregano), and olive oil. No Creme. I did enjoy the salad. As for calling them and letting them know they had the wrong order. They stated that is how they make it. I will not order from them AGAIN.

Sun 5/26/26-Large Sausage Pizza to go, still VG, EXCEPT Very…read moreskimpy on the Sausage. Lot less than usual Service was prompt & good as usual Hope it is not a sign of things to come Carl l

After a rough playoff loss, we came here for lunch. A bit off of the beat and path from…read moreDreamspark. They have a small parking lot and there is street parking as well. We wound up parking a block away as they were pretty busy. You can dine in or take out. Table area was very clean. You place your order and they bring everything to your table. Service all around was excellent and smooth. Everyone went above and beyond. The kid got a small buffalo chicken pizza. I got a meatball parm sandwich. Meatball sandwich was very good. Quality of the meatballs was impressive. Sauce had a nice kick to it. They didn't cheap out on the amount of sauce or cheese. I made the right choice. I snuck a piece of the Buffalo Chicken pie. Chicken was on point. Nice size pieces. Not over powering with spicy sauce. Personal preference, dough was a little too thick for me, but again, that's my personal preference. Kid definitely enjoyed it. Boxed up a few slices for later on. A great alternative if you're in the area.

Excellent food and service, will definitely be back. Great pizza in a small communityread more

Roberto's is one of my favorite places! I am obsessed with their Korean bbq wings. I love the thin…read moresliced cucumbers that come on the side along with their homemade blue cheese dressing. They also have delicious pizza! They have made a few pizzas for milestones in my life and I'm never disappointed. It's always busy when I go and the staff is always working hard. There is a variety of drinks offered along with dessert. There is outdoor and indoor seating available. During the warm months there is also lots of seating out back. Inside is a little crowded with limited seating. The owner is so nice and very dedicated to his work. It's a must stop if you are in the area!! (There is also the pub next door!! Same owner, same menu, but it has a bar and a totally different vibe.)

We stayed in Hunter and ordered delivery from Mamas and I was blown away! The pizza, calzone,…read moreeggplant rollatini, mozzarella sticks, meatballs, mac and cheese bites and everything else was so good! The ricotta has a touch of sweetness to it, maybe honey, that makes it irresistible!! We brought extra home from vacation and eating it right now takes me right back to Hunter! Delicious dinner, thank you Mama!

Love their Mama's Special pizza! The staff is always friendly and helpful! It's the only pizza that…read moretastes close to NYC pizza!

The service here is amazing. The staff is amazing. The food is always great. I never can complain…read moreabout it It's always amazing the fact that this place does not have a five star rating is unacceptable. Sadly, I live in Long Island so I can't come here that often but when I do come here, I enjoy it every single time and every time I do go there it's always slam packed.

Their seafood pasta with red sauce was soooo good! It has scallops (deliciously, perfectly…read morebrowned), clams, shrimps, mussels. Also came with garlic knots and a salad. The waitress was very nice. I went during off-season, between lunch and dinner. Very few people. No wait.

Stopped in on our way back to Kingston from oneonta. needed a light meal. We were greeted by…read moreincredibly friendly staff. We ordered 2 12 inch subs. these things were huge, tasty and incredibly reasonably priced! The inside was warm welcoming and quaint. I will definitely make return trips to this establishment!

We stopped into Pizza Plus after a hike at Mike Kill state park. I had a slice of pepperoni pizza…read moreand a buffalo chicken salad. The pizza was fantastic. It was more like a NYC slice than anything I've had near home (Rochester NY area) and it came out quickly. The salad was satisfying and flavorful. Even the desert (peanut butter pie) was fantastic. The service was friendly and the dining room was warm and spacious. If you are going to eat someplace like Grand Gorge with just a few choices, be glad Pizza Plus is one of them.

I can't even comment on the food from this place, as I never received it, but was still charged for…read moreit. I was out running errands and decided to order from their website (and also pay in advance), thinking I could stop by and pick up my order on my way home. Both their website and Yelp listing showed that they were open. I also received an order status text saying my food was being prepared and approximate time it would be ready. When I arrived at the restaurant, the owner was just getting there and letting himself in. He said he had canceled my order since they weren't open yet, but if I wanted to come back in two hours I could order then, I said no thank you and told him to cancel it, to which he said "ok." I found out later that night that the order had not been canceled, and they processed the payment for anyway. Apparently their website orders are processed through the Slice app. I contacted Slice and was told they couldn't do anything about a refund and that I would have to obtain it through the restaurant owner. The restaurant owner in turn told me he couldn't do anything about it and that I would have to contact Slice. I was screwed out of about $25 while they pointed their fingers at each other. So buyer beware - avoid ordering through their website. And to the restaurant owner, maybe get your business off the freaking internet, since you clearly don't know how to navigate it!! And while I'm here, I can comment on the establishment itself: their use of the quaint word "cafe" in their business name is ridiculous - the place is a hole. I guess it used to be a nice restaurant, but changed ownership, so maybe only pay attention to reviews after 2024.

Run, don't walk from this sorry excuse for a pizza place. Don't be fooled like me by the ratings on…read morethis website and others that were accrued by the previous owners. The pizza that I was served was awful, and I was charged about $24 for some sad Indian food that was basically a samosa and some kind of "chicken patty". My first clue that both types of food were going to be awful is that I've never been to a pizza place that serves Indian food or vice versa.

Millrock is such a special place. The staff is so sweet and really make you feel so welcome as soon…read moreas you get there. Inside is a vibe - moody and dark. The drinks are really good and the food was really delish. We got a pizza which was actually awesome and then chicken Marsala which was reallllly decadent. Overall, highly suggest.

In town for my sisters wedding weekend which also happened to include my moms birthday. She…read morecouldn't stop bringing up the Millrock so we had to try it! The hostess was so kind, she kept wishing my mom a happy birthday and checking in on us throughout the meal. Our server seemed a little overwhelmed, but to be fair we were a party of 9. Near the end of our meal he seemed to recruit help from a couple other servers. The food was incredible! I of course had to get the penne vodka pasta. I was a bit bummed when they wouldn't let me add a protein to it, but it was still delish. Since it was the holiday season, I had to try the peppermint chocolate martini. I was worried it would be too chocolatey but it was perfectly balanced with a peppermint rim!

Great pizza well cooked and use hi gf quality ingredients. Staff is friendly and accommodating to…read morespecial requests