Meeting up with a group, this Oklahoma chain is spacious with plenty of seating. They are known for…read moretheir pizzas, but we also enjoyed their fried mushrooms and garlic knots. To feed five of us, the large Pollinator was perfect with its garlic glaze, meat, banana peppers, and hot honey. It was so good!

Awesome service Good pizza…read more Fast service Clean Right down in the middle of several business walking distance eat and shop

Poor customer service. Found my chicken Parmesan sandwich to have yellow on the inside. I…read morecomplained didn't even eat the food and they still tried to charge me full price for the meal. I asked the young waitress about comping the meal and she said we can either make you a new one or give you half off. I said I would rather have half off.

Food is good, maybe a bit high in price. Service is also good. Really no complaints. Extensive…read moremenu choices.

Was staying over night to have brunch at the mercantile and wanted to try this place after reading…read morethe reviews. We were greeted right away by friendly staff and seated immediately. Our server could not have been more helpful and sweet. Elizabeth was awesome! My sister and I decided to split the lasagna and each of us had a chopped salad. The lasagna was fantastic! The only complaint I had is I wish they would have given us something to serve ourselves with after we cut it up, instead of trying to scoop it with a spoon, but that is minor. The lemonade was great! Ranch dressing on the salad was also good and you can tell it was homemade. I don't know where another person got the place was dirty? It is an old building with worn floors but everything was very clean. If you happen to stop here for the night and need a place to eat, you can't go wrong with this place.

Immediately we were greeted & taken to our table.The Waitress was friendly , didn't rush us & told…read moreus about her favorite's to eat there. I had to ask. The Pizza was to die for. The Cesar Salad is awesome, you can split It as It Is Huge. The garlic not nots are delicious & don't forget to take home your dessert of Cinnamon not nots. Easy to heat up. Going here you will be treated like family. The small town vibe ,ambiance , & People Are Awesome.You Will Never Be Let Down at P Town so go in today as you will be glad you did !!!

As soon as I walked in I knew just by the smell that the pizza was gonna be great!! This to me is…read morethe best pizza in Oklahoma. I'm from nyc so I'm used to great pizza and this is the closest you gonna get to it. I will drive to Blackwell just for this pizza!! The sad part is I left my leftovers ‍‍ we didn't realize till we got home lol. The owner was so nice and told us he gets there at 5:30 every morning just to make the dough. Will return!!

Best pizza around. Lots of toppings, lots of cheese, great crust. Wings are the best around!!read more

My dearest Casey, your location was a Godsend to my family and I as we traipsed across the Kansas…read moreterrain. We were coming from out East back to our dainty town of Beverly Hills when we needed to fuel up the Skipper (Our Honda Odyssey). That's when I heard a familiar growling coming from the region between my pectorals and my waistline. It was none other than my TumTum demanding some pizza pie! Usually, the family and I would go for a Papa John's Double Cheeseburger Pizza, but there wasn't enough time. We were hungry, and we were hungry NOW. Thankfully, Casey, your General Store has some of the BEST pizza I have ever eaten. We went with a classic onion and banana pepper pie, and one sausage and pepperoni for my girls Scarlett and Trina. Everyone was howling with delight. You would have thought there was a full moon! Highly recommend! 5 stars! Wish I could give 6! Happy New Year, Casey and Crew!

Great pizza! Great donuts! The cashiers are always nice. One star off for the arrogant, boastful,…read moreunprofessional, and very unpleasant manager. I always avoid the place if I know he is working.

This place is great! I love brick oven pizza and this place doesn't disappoint. They have a wide…read moreselection of alcohol to accommodate all taste buds. They are friendly and very helpful with a noob like me who isn't familiar with how to run a tap. I am always looking forward to my next visit.

Beer selection was good. Food was great. Service was good. Pizza was great. Fun spot and…read moreatmosphere. In

Visiting Newton and area for a couple of days. A local recommended Back Alley Pizza. Excellent…read morerecommendation! Ordered a BAM (aka Margherita) to go. (But it did look like a great place to hang out, too.) The pizza was a perfect size for one person. Wood fired pizza is my favorite. It was delicious.

The food was amazing, and the other employees we interacted with were helpful and kind…read more Unfortunately, our experience was overshadowed by our interaction with the manager, Desiree. We ordered a child's meal for my aunt, who is currently going through cancer treatment and has not been eating very much. Desiree approached us and told us, in a rude and dismissive manner, that the child's meals were only for children 10 and under. We explained our situation and why we were trying to order a smaller meal for her, but Desiree simply reiterated the restaurant's policy and told us we would have to order a regular menu item. When we asked Desiree for her name, her response was again rude and dismissive. Rather than showing any understanding of the situation, she reiterated the policy and told us that she was writing a note for her manager about the interaction. Given the way the situation was handled, this felt less like an effort to address our concerns and more like an attempt to document the situation from her perspective before we had an opportunity to speak with management ourselves. We understand that restaurants have policies, and we were not asking for the policy to be changed. However, there are ways to communicate a policy with compassion and tact, especially when a customer explains that they are dealing with a serious health situation. We were simply trying to find an appropriate amount of food for someone going through cancer treatment. Desiree's approach felt rude, insulting, and completely lacking in compassion. The food itself was excellent, and the other staff members were helpful, but this interaction significantly impacted our experience. A little kindness, understanding, and professionalism would have made a big difference.

The pizza here is AMAZING! I can't wait to try their new sandwiches. Truly worth the drive to…read morelittle Leon, Ks. The staff is also very friendly.

Great food and service. We needed pizza for lunch for the wedding party. We called ahead and they…read moremade sure we had delicious bread sticks and pizza ready for pick up. Clean restaurant!

The pizza is consistently great even delivered! They used to…read morehave gluten free crust. I've never eaten it. I didn't know they had other Italian food and sandwiches! Gotta try it!

Love the pizza. Be sure to allow plenty of time as they stay quite busy during warmer weather…read moremonths when the lake is popular.