Goodfella's Pizzeria

We really like this place. Our waitress was super friendly and very helpful. We got the wedge salad…read moreand it was amazing along with a hand tossed pizza with everything on it. The crust was next level. They have a really cool little bar that is kind of enclosed away from the eating area that looked like they made amazing cocktails. We will definitely stop back by to experience that.

It's been about 5 years since I have been to this restaurant and I'm glad to see that is now under…read morenew ownership. Ironically I got to meet the family that took it over and they are great people whom I believe will revive this place. The service was great and had no complaints on that end. Always friendly and welcoming. Now to the food. I got some appetizers such as the jalapeño pimento cheese dip and cheese curds. It was as expected. I ordered the prime rib, which is what they are supposed to be known for. I ordered my prime rib medium rare and it came out well done. Prime rib is usually served with a horseradish sauce but I didn't get any. I asked for a side and my server came back and said they had to make some. I had no problems with that, but when the sauce came out, it tasted way closer to tartar sauce than horseradish sauce. Truly, this was the worst prime rib that I have ever eaten in my life. I am hopeful the new ownership will turn things around for this iconic spot.

Chicken Alfredo

The "music" room

See all

The Backstage Room

Papa G's Pizza Express

4.5(22 reviews)

21.7 mi

We stopped by to get some food, pizza was delicious Greg was so nice and sweet! Super helpful and…read moretold us about the deals and the best flavors. The inside seemed super clean. Will be coming back for sure!

We found Papa G's a delightful little drive through pizza joint. There is only outdoor seating,…read morewhich on a hot day was not ideal. However, the pepperoni pizza was delicious. My first impression was "where's the pepperoni?", but then i discovered it was tucked in between two layers of cheese. This was great! Also, I am used to dabbing grease from my pepperoni pizzas with a napkin. Not so here! It had the right amount of grease. The crust was battered with salted butter as well. We will be back!

Small Italian sausage pizza

See all

Chef salad

Goodfella's Pizzeria

4.3(25 reviews)

22.0 mi

The food was delicious! Ordered a large gluten free "Hit Man" pizza a it was perfect! Good…read morecustomer service.

Great customer service great food very fast efficient polite, people, recommend eating at this placeread more

The Boss...

Empty plate says it all!

See all

Outside front of the building

Docs Bar & Grill

3.1(71 reviews)

7.7 mi

Shangri La is trying to improve their ROI but shooting their self in the foot. Doc is equal to a…read moresporting events concession. Couldn't even fishing the weird stuff they served. We've stayed here prob 10 times over the past 6 years and rented out blocks of rooms for events we've hosted for our church. Prob like 6 or 7 years in a row. And the food service and hotel service has declined a little every year. For sure not coming back. Good luck Shangri La

The food here is fantastic-absolute resort quality. This Greek Gyro was a very large portion, and…read morethe taziki was amazing! All the servers are very friendly and the service is quick. The ambiance screams classic golf club, with dark wood and muted hues. Must try!

See all

Gambino's Pizza

4.1(25 reviews)

4.2 mi

Love the pizza and sandwich's, lunch buffet is a must! Staff has always been helpful and courteous.read more

Placed an order online. On the website it said it would be ready at 7:15. Our order was placed at…read more6:30. Pulled up to the drive through at 7:19 to be told "Actually since it was an online order it's actually going to be another 15 minutes." So 3 cheese pizzas take an hour to make. Make it make sense. Lol

Menue

See all

Menue

Goodfella's Pizzeria

3.8(52 reviews)

11.6 mi

Hands down the best pizza made in Grove, Ok., even a late call in for an order to pick up gets…read moregreat attention and the taste proves it.

Friendly. Great food. Not a lot of traffic for dine in. Lunch specials too. Will be back again.read more

Outdoor Patio

Calzone supreme

See all

Whoops! Didn't take a picture of the whole pizza! So good...

Pizza Hut

3.3(12 reviews)

10.3 mi

Pizza was made quickly and ready for pick up on my arrival. Great service!! Easily adapted to my…read moreplant based desires. Highly recommend.

I ordered food at work around 6:30 pm and was told it would be delivered at 6:59 it is currently…read more8:46 and it still had not been delivered. This fact is unacceptable for a professional establishment especially when they charge a delivery fee. If this is how pizza hut in Vinita conducts itself then there is no reason for it to be open

See all

Goodfellas Pizzeria

4.1(21 reviews)

10.9 mi

The food of pizzas are great to feed a family and the service has always been on point. I hope to…read morestop by soon and enjoy the ambiance of this fine restaurant nearby.

The employees were friendly. The store is very rundown and could use an overhaul with cleaning,…read morefresh paint. The pizza was mediocre: cheese didn't taste fresh, pepperoni was good, crust was mostly tasteless and the outer crust was as crunchy as saltines. It was $16 for a medium 2-topping pizza and that's fair.

See all

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

3 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Tommy T.

8 years ago

I commonly entertain this facility for my ALL YEAR MENU....They TOTALLY DISAPPOINTED ME, BEING A LOCAL. Actually served me some others pizza, with a smile......and I tipped them because i generally have awesome pizza from this facility. The Dark headed heavy set man, wearing a beard,,,,with a smile, gave me an old pizza they needed rid of....fkn puke i will be back.....and that shit hook should be witnessed by his employers read more

Kim O.

5 years ago

We picked up at the drive thru. 3 pizzas ready hot and just as we ordered. Will definitely try again!

Robby L.

175

10 years ago

xksjdjfkd ixidieie fididis idigidke isisvi risjckd wiskxjfi3ktmxj2kqks eifiisjdcvggdjdifid read more

Goodfella's Pizzeria - pizza - Updated October 2026

Browse Nearby

BEST of Afton, Oklahoma Restaurants near Goodfella's Pizzeria

Best of Afton

Things to do in Afton

Browse Brands

Brands by name

Browse Articles

Articles by date

People who viewed Goodfella's Pizzeria also viewed

Vip Pizza

3.8

(35 reviews)

Not an artisan pizza or a hand tossed crust. Their specialty is a perfect thin crispy crust. It is…read morevery consistent in form and thickness which leads me to believe that it is factory premade. Premade or not, it forms an excellent base for the pie. This is not NY style pizza, so save your bitchin' for someone who cares. This is a good ol' small town, pizza joint pizza, loaded with a generous thick layer of fresh ingredients. 12" Papa Joe's Supreme. Not greasy, not overloaded with sauce. It is packed with meat, veggies and cheese. We had leftovers. Still tasty, cold from the refrigerator the next day. Big comfortable deck with picnic tables for outside dining. Nice view of the cove. Right next door to Sharky's ice house. I imagine this place gets to rockin' on the weekend. Friendly service. Great place to spend this beautiful spring afternoon. The pizza is good! Someone's dog either bit someone or took a crap on the deck; as of March, no dogs allowed.

Never have had a bad slice. Good pizza and cold beer with a good view of boats and Grand Lake…read more Could life get any better?

Goodfella's Pizzeria

3.8

(52 reviews)

Hands down the best pizza made in Grove, Ok., even a late call in for an order to pick up gets…read moregreat attention and the taste proves it.

Friendly. Great food. Not a lot of traffic for dine in. Lunch specials too. Will be back again.read more

Goodfella's Pizzeria

4.3

(25 reviews)

The food was delicious! Ordered a large gluten free "Hit Man" pizza a it was perfect! Good…read morecustomer service.

Great customer service great food very fast efficient polite, people, recommend eating at this placeread more

Goodfellas Pizzeria

4.1

(21 reviews)

The food of pizzas are great to feed a family and the service has always been on point. I hope to…read morestop by soon and enjoy the ambiance of this fine restaurant nearby.

Papa G's Pizza Express

4.5

(22 reviews)

Padilla's Pizzeria

5.0

(1 review)

Best pizza and bread sticks you can get around the Grand Lake area. We had ours delivered but plan…read moreon going on Sunday for all you can eat. Danny the owner is a great and friendly guy who treats his customers like family. If you're in the area it's definitely a great pizzeria to go to.

Beau’s Delicatessen & Market

4.6

(18 reviews)

A little bit of everything…read more We stopped for a cup of coffee to sip on, on the drive home. I had an Americano with cream. It was excellent. Deep rich coffee flavor, smoothed a little with the cream. Their menu, especially the pastries look enticing. Maybe next time. The Market has various trinkets and whatnots for sale. There are coolers with premade items, take and heat. It appears to be a fairly new business. Check their website. A very helpful young lady working the counter today.

Great Lake spot! Amazing food and atmosphere. Will be a staple stop for us moving forward.read more

Chickanellas Scratch Kitchen

3.9

(24 reviews)

The best breakfast that I have had in Eastern Oklahoma…read more That is a pretty big claim, but I can back that up with over 150 comparative reviews. Many of those diners and cafés are excellent five-star performers, but Chickanellas Scratch Kitchen delivers the best all-around breakfast experience. The décor is a mixture of steak house fancy and a small-town café. Dark wood paneling on the walls, classic antique street lights, high end fancy hand rails at the stairs. Each little booth has its own lamp at the table. Chicken pictures, stuffed toy chickens, chickens on the walls, EAT signs, paddles, carved wooden fish, and fishing lures, balances the steak house ambience with a genuine country welcome feeling. My usual breakfast was perfect. Two bright sunny side eggs. A meat eater's size serving of bacon. A golden flakey buttery biscuit. Freshy made gravy on the side. And a big sweet surprise; a sampling of their delicious house made jam. Add a hot cup of coffee and this is what all breakfasts should be! Check the pictures. The service: attentive, small town friendly, excellent.

Excellent food !!!! Service is great !!!!! Friendly service…read moreand atmosphere .....: delicious food , desserts ..... plus to go soups , pies etc........ very nice bar area!!!

Pistol Pats

3.8

(12 reviews)

we heard they were pretty good and that they had a ding room. Not quite. They have a patio off to…read morethe side with tables/chairs. I'm giving 3 for the food. Anyway, my hamburger was quite good. We're from tenderloin sandwich country where the loin is pounded thin and hangs out the bun. not here. see pix. he was gravely disappointed. the wait is long. I'd say, from sitting in line & ordering, 20-45 minutes After you order. now we were entertained by a charming little girl who climbed into the order window to sell us pink cotton candy. hubby's a softy a gave her $4 for the sad looking sack. quite a while later she returned to reimburse him a couple bucks. he laffed and had her put it in the tip cup. Oh, life at the lake.

I can honestly say that this was the best cheeseburger that I've even eaten. I also got onion rings…read moreand a chocolate malt. They were equally as awesome. And how many places have malts??? My husband ordered the same thing and agreed. My PICKY 17 year old ordered a corn dog and LOVED it!!!

Nu-Taste

3.7

(26 reviews)