Hands down the best pizza made in Grove, Ok., even a late call in for an order to pick up gets great attention and the taste proves it.

Friendly. Great food. Not a lot of traffic for dine in. Lunch specials too. Will be back again.

We enjoy the pizza at Goodfella's every Friday. Theirs is the best we've ever eaten. The staff is always friendly and helpful. They keep thier restaurant exceptionally clean. read more

Such a fun, small town pizza place!!! Great pizza...their pre-set designed pizzas are a great price for a ton of toppings!!! (I'd really like fresh mushrooms, but the pizza was delicious!) It was 20 minutes from order to piping hot pizza on our table. You can also call ahead your order, and they even offer take-and-bake We ate inside at a tall table, but next time we're going to try the comfy chairs out on the covered/lit patio. We'll be back!!! read more

Had dinner here tonight for the first time! It's order at the counter, seat yourself. We shared a garden salad that had very good ranch. We shared buffalo wings, which were very tasty. And a hit man pizza. It's basically supreme. It was also very good. It's a cute little spot on the Main Street downtown with indoor and outdoor seating. I'd definitely eat here again. Good local pizza. read more

Goodfella's Pizzeria - Leftovers! Wings and hit man pizza - Pizza Near Me - Grove, Oklahoma

See all

When you walk in the restaurant is so clean, a bit of country charm. I've only been here twice. The service was amazing both times. Both times I ordered a meatball sub. It was so good the first time I needed another one. I asked for extra meatballs on this one no problem... Definitely recommend this place. I got my food to go since I worked all day and just wanted to go home and relax. ... They definitely don't short you on cheese . read more

Goodfella's Pizzeria - Meatball sub with extra meatballs. - Pizza Near Me - Grove, Oklahoma

Ordered the gangster and it was so good! The crust reminded me of a higher end Tostito pizza- so flakey! I will try the wings next time but def worth the trip to grove read more

Goodfella's Pizzeria - a pizza box on a table - Pizza Near Me - Grove, Oklahoma

Love everything I've tried here! My favorite is the chicken bacon ranch sandwich. The calzones are great, pizza is great, and I've heard the spaghetti is also great! read more

Goodfella's Pizzeria - Chicken bacon ranch sandwich - Pizza Near Me - Grove, Oklahoma

Pizza is definitely mid, especially for the prices. Might just be a preference thing so you might want to try for yourself. We like a lighter pizza dough. read more

I came to visit grove Oklahoma and had food delivered from good fellas pizza one item was the chicken Alfredo which was delivered without any means of eating it short of using my hand, so I left the motel drove a third of the way across town to get a simple plastic fork to eat with. For the prices they charge one would think they could've included the utensil to eat with I won't be ordering anything from them again when I come back to grove again and sure won't recommend them to anyone. read more

Very disappointed! My order was 45 min late. No excuses for poor service. They used to be better.

Best pizza in Grove! Great service every time, wonderful atmosphere and great location. It's a must try!

Great pizza, best in Grove, Ok Gluten free crust option but nothing dedicated so not celiac safe Order for staff multiple times it's everyone's favorite read more

This is a cute place, not too big but can fit a decent amount of people in there. There's outdoor seating too, which also looked nice. It looks clean, and was pretty busy on a Saturday night, which is a good sign. I didn't stay there to eat though, just ordered the pizza and took it home. We got a few different flavors because we had people with some different pizza topping preferences. I'm not sure if we did build your own or if we ordered pre-set pizzas... We had a pepperoni, one with all veggies, a pineapple and canadian bacon, and one with green olives, jalapeños, and pineapple. The only one I didn't try was the pepperoni. I really liked the other ones, especially the one with jalapeños (I know, shocker... not). I wasn't sure about the combo of the jalapeños with green olives but it was actually pretty good. The slices weren't cut very consistently but I didn't mind. I actually kind of liked how some of the wives ended up being g quite small, because then I was able to try more of the flavors we ordered instead of just one or two big slices. read more

See all

THE BEST PIZZA EVER! So fresh and the thin crust is amazing! Lovely patio outside to enjoy a cool afternoon. read more

Goodfella's Pizzeria - Whoops! Didn't take a picture of the whole pizza! So good... - Pizza Near Me - Grove, Oklahoma

Great service Good food Clean inside Outside dinning Good music I'm glad I found this place! Check it out read more

Goodfella's Pizzeria - Calzone - Pizza Near Me - Grove, Oklahoma

Great local spot that never disappoints! The pizza and calzones are amazing and the staff is always very friendly and accommodating. The outside patio is perfect for enjoying your lunch or dinner with friends and family. It's also perfect for doing a little "people watching" in downtown Grove! read more

Goodfella's Pizzeria - Outdoor Patio - Pizza Near Me - Grove, Oklahoma

Goodfellas is awesome! This is some of our all time favorite pizza. The thin crust is just absolutely perfect! We always get a large Hoffa & a large Bacon Cheeseburger pizza. Both are excellent, but that cheeseburger pizza is one of my favorite things I've ever eaten. Everything about it is perfect. The staff is also very friendly and accommodating! We've never had a bad experience here. read more

Happened to be over night in Grove Oklahoma and checked out the yelps for local pizza. We can highly recommend Goodfella's pizza. A cute little street front place downtown that has patio dining as well as indoor seating. We ordered a couple of pizzas, a calazone, spaghetti, wings. Way more than we needed to feed our party of nine. The verdict...really good. Everyone loved the pizza. The wings got great marks. The kids said the spaghetti with meat balls was delicious. But the star of the show was the calazone, simply awesome. If you happen to be up Grove way stop in for a tasty slice of pizza or their calazone you won't regret it. read more

See all

My wife and I have had Goodfellas pizza several times and the pizza is always good. The salads and sides are expensive, but quality. I have to post this because, dang; this is the best delivery pizza I have had the pleasure to consume. I mean the most toppings we could get and the crust was still ctunchy and delicious. read more

Wow the pizza here was great. The pizza came out piping hot and looked scrumptious! The dining room was clean. They had a flat screen playing golf. They also searched beer. I tried the Light Circus. It tasted great and paired well with the outstanding pizza. I'll be returning here! read more

Goodfella's Pizzeria - Pizza! - Pizza Near Me - Grove, Oklahoma

See all

Very good pizza, and hot wings. I brought food home. The take out service was quick and easy. No mistakes on order. I do recommend.

Great pizza, great service, and they deliver. What more could you ask for? It was a big hit with our crew. read more

Their quality of food has been going downhill more and more recently. I got wings 1 day for lunch and they were very over cooked. They rudely took them and said they would just credit them back to my card. No offer to make new ones, no apologies for the quality, nothing! We went back about a week later just got an order of their cheese sticks and they were horrible! Not going back for a while! Not sure what is happening here, but not my first choice!! read more

We placed our order online and got the Chicken Bacon Ranch pizza and the Bada Bing (Canadian bacon and pineapple). Our wait was around 30 minutes, when we got there everything was ready. Overall pizza was very good. read more

Holy crap! This IS the pizza I've been looking for! When I was a kid Godfather pizza was the best pizza ever. Nowadays I gotta find it at a gas station. So while in Grove I see this Goodfella's Pizzeria and dropped in. It wasn't real crowded as I popped in at one of them not lunch or dinner times. The staff was friendly and not all over friendly. You're welcome there but they don't make it awkward. Now I ordered a small Boss. What I got was hands down the best pizza I've had since I was a kid. It was like they reached into my memories and said "Here bruh, this is just for you!" I live 2 hrs away but I dream daily of driving back there just for this. I love you Goodfellas. You complete me read more

We are not from the area, but came in on a recommendation from a friend. Best pizza I've ever had. Love it. Staff was very nice and the pizza was simply amazing. read more

The very best pizza in town!! It may cost more than the franchise but it is Well With the fresh wonderful items!!!

It's not GREAT pizza but it's really good. I'd give it 3.5 out of 5. Atmosphere is good, staff was friendly. We are at the one in Grove. Would go there again. Overall, good experience. read more

Beautiful location. The clerk told us it would be an hour wait time to eat and we were surprised when the food arrived at our table after only waiting 35 minutes! The pizza was absolutely spot on and the price was reflective of the good pizza. Overall good experience! read more

Goodfella's Pizzeria - Outdoor seating. - Pizza Near Me - Grove, Oklahoma

See all

Got our order wrong in the beginning and the staff was incredibly nice about correcting and when we wanted to pay the difference they refused saying it was their fault. It was a nice move that we really appreciated. Great food great service great all around!! read more

This was so not worth the price! We were extremely disappointed! The service was the absolute worse! There were only two families in the restaurant but every table was dirty and so was the bar. Then when the server finally came out of the back (only because another patron went to the kitchen door and yelled "Excuse me, can I get another plate? This one is dirty!") to take our order she was rude and acted like we put her out by having to wait on us. The food was okay. They forgot sauces for cheese sticks and the calzone and when asked for them they never said sorry or did they act like they felt bad that we had to wait even longer because of their forgetfulness. They never said thank you and when we did she said "yep". The best thing I can say was that their beer was cheap! But my advise is to find a good happy hour somewhere else and skip this place entirely!! read more

Good pizza sauce and amazing people. Not a huge wing variety or a huge dining area. But overall great food.

THE ABSOLUTE WORST CUSTOMER SERVICE!!! This place boggles my mind! The pizza here actually taste good but the place is definitely pricey. The thing I just don't understand is the incredibly POOR CUSTOMER SERVICE. I ordered a pizza last night for carry out. When I walked in to pick it up the guy said it would be a few more minutes so I sat down to wait. I watched two people come in after me, place an order and get it. Mine still wasn't out??? Frustrated, I went up and asked if they had forgotten me. The guy looked puzzled and asked if I had placed an order. I told him I had called it in 40 minutes ago and had been sitting there for 25 minutes. He checked thru the receipts, found mine, walked to the back and came out with my pizza. He laughed and said, "Sorry boss, it's been sitting there the whole time." No real apology, no can I make you a fresh one, no let me give you a discount or coupon, he just laughed. I don't know who the manager/owner is of this place but they really do not know how to run a business!!! Look at the other reviews for this place. They are all fake! Great way to manage a business, instead of serving a quality product with excellent service, you or someone you know posts fake reviews. read more

Delicious pizza! Clean restaurant and friendly service. We stopped as we were traveling through Grove. This would be a frequent favorite if we lived close by! read more

Very poor service we ordered two pizzas took over 45 minutes and was not very busy and not one person check on us

I would go as a far as to say that this is the best pizza place in Grove... there's a million of them. The only thing that kinda lacks is the length of time on deliveries. The pizza itself is always good. read more

Pizza was just OK, hand tossed crust seemed to be a frozen version. The only masks in the place were the ones we wore in, though there was hand sanitizer available. If I were not vaccinated, I would definitely not have stayed. read more

I'm not a Yelp review person typically but feel this needs to be said due to an integrity problem with the staff. To be fair I understand they just moved locations and one of two ovens went down. BUT, had they communicated this to the crowd waiting for their pickup or other orders at tables it would've been totally cool. Instead we waited 1.5 hours for our pizza while dining in. We were quite nice and patient, making small talk with others lost in their Friday night pizza making fog. Here's the kicker, we were told twice it was going in the oven. To top it off a girl with purple hair dove back into the kitchen never to be seen again to avoid getting asked a question by me when I raised my hand halfway through our wait. We finally left after 90 mins. If they read this the solution for future reference is to have your staff communicate to people waiting what's up. DO NOT lie about orders. Don't hide, don't say "I don't know" about someone's order and not find out. A rough night for them for sure. I'm sure your pizza is good, I'll not know as I am only visiting family. I hope things smooth out with your staff, cuz WOW. read more

I've been to Goodfellas many times for carry out. I decided to dine in tonight with my wife and kids. The pizza was good but the service was slow and you get your own drinks here, so there isn't a reason for a waitress. If you want good pizza in Northeast Oklahoma this is the place...I would get it for carry out though. read more