Goodfella's Pizzeria

We stopped by to get some food, pizza was delicious Greg was so nice and sweet! Super helpful and…read moretold us about the deals and the best flavors. The inside seemed super clean. Will be coming back for sure!

We found Papa G's a delightful little drive through pizza joint. There is only outdoor seating,…read morewhich on a hot day was not ideal. However, the pepperoni pizza was delicious. My first impression was "where's the pepperoni?", but then i discovered it was tucked in between two layers of cheese. This was great! Also, I am used to dabbing grease from my pepperoni pizzas with a napkin. Not so here! It had the right amount of grease. The crust was battered with salted butter as well. We will be back!

Small Italian sausage pizza

See all

Chef salad

Domino's Pizza

4.0(7 reviews)

1.0 mi

Best pizza in town I've never had an issue when I come here and they always make my pizza so goodread more

Pizza was good as expected price was good place was clean got our food quick good experienceread more

Deluxe on hand tossed with no green peppers

Closeup of deluxe (no green peppers) on hand tossed

See all

Closeup of deluxe with no green peppers (hand tossed)

Bricks and Brews

4.1(41 reviews)

12.6 mi

Pizza is absolutely amazing! Great location. Friendly environment. Has a beautiful outdoor arearead more

Haven't been here for awhile. I'm not sure what's happened but it wasn't great today and service…read morewas spotty. Took forever to get our food and kitchen staff seemed to be arguing with wait staff. We weren't impressed. The ranch was literally the consistency of milk. Mac and cheese bites were undercooked and not nicely browned. Salad bar was mediocre. Used to be so good so this is unfortunate.

Voodoo Child (left) and don't remember the one on the right but the homemade meatballs were great!

See all

Bar area

Pizza Hut

2.9(9 reviews)

0.1 mi

Always order pizza before I go into work at 11 PM fast service great customer service ordering…read moreonline as fast picking it up at the window as fast

Dry stale crusts, overcooked breadsticks. And I don't mean once I mean every single time for the…read morelast 5 years AT LEAST!! Whoever is in charge needs to probably clean up a little better and not prep the dough so far ahead of time. I've worked at a Pizza Hut before and other pizza restaurants and this is poor quality at its finest Cardboard tasting disappointing what the heck happened to both locations the quality took a faceplant I keep retrying and everytime it's soggy and nasty

See all

Pizza Hut

2.0(4 reviews)

1.0 mi

The worst pizza I have ever had…read more It was like it was covered in burnt grease I would never order another pizza from pizza hut

New management. New staff. Fresh dough. New furniture. New carpet. Better quality of service. Most…read morehorrible pizza I've had on a long time. DONT GO THERE!!!!!!

See all

Playland Lanes

2.3(3 reviews)

0.4 mi

Out of business I suppose No working phone numbers…read more Boooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooppppopooooooooooooo sorry I needed 85 characters to leave the review

Drove all the way from Grove, called ahead to reserve a lane, they said it was fine, got here and…read moresaw 4 open lanes but the guy at the counter said they didn't have any and there was nothing he could do.

See all

Easter Special

Turners Tastee Table Treats

5.0(2 reviews)

10.1 mi

Delicious pizza at this small but very professional restaurant in Wyandotte Oklahoma.read more

amazing food, customer service is awesome. prices are just where they should be. breadsticks is one…read moreI wouldn't pass up.

Peach cobbler cheesecake

Coffee cheesecake

See all

Beccaronnie Roast Beef, chedder cheese and bbq sauce

Casey's

3.3(7 reviews)

12.1 mi

Hot food. Cold drinks. Gasoline. Parking. Handicapped accessible. Bakery items. Friendly staff…read more Fast service. Pizza available.

I went to Casey's at 8:25 am. I grabbed a soda, got money from the ATM, grabbed White Castle…read moresliders. At the register I asked for 5 number 21's from the lottery tickets. I leave and here someone on the PA say something about money on the counter. I go back in and she handed me the money I left. THANK YOU!! I thought there is no way 5, $2 lottery tickets, sliders and a drink cost 10.72. She didn't charge me for 4 of the tickets. By now I'm at work, so I call Casey's. The first time, I got hung up on. When I called back (it was obvious she was being interrupted) I told her what I thought happened and she said " Well what time do you get off work?" I told her 4. She said "just bring it in after work, we'll see you a little after 4. I said okay but if she (the cashier) needed it for her drawer to be correct she could come get it. She said we don't have enough people to do that. I said okay. She said bye. I can not remember the cashiers ( I believe she is a manager) name but she was awesome!!!! No complaints at all about her and I thank her and appreciate that she let me know I had left my money there. Cassandra did not say thank you for letting us know. I felt that she was being impolite and I was bothering her.

Pizza Hut

1.8(5 reviews)

12.5 mi

Literally Terrible. Do not order from this establishment. Placed an order at 5:50pm on 09/13/2026…read moreit's now 8pm. No food and I live 3 minutes from the place. This is the second time I've placed an order and i had to wait and hour and 30 plus minutes.

Great food. Buffet options. Call-in orders. In room dining. Drive-thru pickup. Kid friendly menu…read moreand seating. Handicapped accessible. Friendly staff.

See all

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

3 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Rick L.

10 months ago

I just had a pizza from Goodfellows It is the third worst pizza I have ever had in Miami I will not order from them again read more

Kat M.

10 months ago

I went and ate with my husband for dinner yesterday and Jeremy was exceptional! We will definitely be back!

Christopher B.

3 years ago

If you're looking for great pizza, fun atmosphere, and great service, look no further!

Goodfella's Pizzeria - pizza - Updated October 2026

People who viewed Goodfella's Pizzeria also viewed

Goodfella's Pizzeria

3.8

(52 reviews)

Hands down the best pizza made in Grove, Ok., even a late call in for an order to pick up gets…read moregreat attention and the taste proves it.

Friendly. Great food. Not a lot of traffic for dine in. Lunch specials too. Will be back again.read more

Goodfellas Pizzeria

4.1

(21 reviews)

The food of pizzas are great to feed a family and the service has always been on point. I hope to…read morestop by soon and enjoy the ambiance of this fine restaurant nearby.

The employees were friendly. The store is very rundown and could use an overhaul with cleaning,…read morefresh paint. The pizza was mediocre: cheese didn't taste fresh, pepperoni was good, crust was mostly tasteless and the outer crust was as crunchy as saltines. It was $16 for a medium 2-topping pizza and that's fair.

Goodfella's Pizzeria

4.4

(27 reviews)

The pizza is consistently great even delivered! They used to…read morehave gluten free crust. I've never eaten it. I didn't know they had other Italian food and sandwiches! Gotta try it!

Love the pizza. Be sure to allow plenty of time as they stay quite busy during warmer weather…read moremonths when the lake is popular.

Woody's Woodfire Pizza

4.1

(148 reviews)

We arrived when they were running the lunch buffet but Mrs. K. and my daughter are vegetarians so…read morewe opted to order two pizzas off the menu instead. The waitress working today was friendly and attentive, keeping our drinks refilled and still managing to handle both dining rooms. The Debbie, with tomato, garlic, feta and topped with fresh basil was delicious but I preferred The Greek with spinach, artichoke hearts, gorgonzola and garlic. Delicious and the leftovers reheated perfectly later. Definitely worth it for the lunch buffet as fresh pizzas appeared constantly with a good variety but there's nothing wrong with getting a bespoke pizza as well. [Review 2337 of 2024 - 398 in Missouri - 23351 overall]

Liked what we got, was good for something different. Was a bit pricey! Just wish it was a little…read moreless of a "bar" atmosphere. Service was great! Would go back and carry out!

Mia Bella

4.2

(38 reviews)

In town for a work trip and I found this place on yelp! I sat at the bar and all the servers were…read moreso nice to ask me how I was doing as they walked by. I loved that they had Waters Edge wine and I enjoyed the.Pinot Grigio & the Pinot Noir. The bread they brought was lightly salted and shining; very fresh and tasty. At the bartender's suggestion, I ordered the Chicken Genovese and it was SO GOOD! The sauce was a combo or Alfredo & Marinara and the chicken was tender and lightly seasoned. Enough for two meals. The ambiance was perfect for date night, but families are welcome here. Reasonably priced. Will definitely return next time I work in Miami!

Here we are a year later after my first review and it's gotten better! They also added more booths…read more Food was amazing. Had a minor service snafu and our waitress comped us some very nice oil dipping sauce and apologized profusely and remedied things quickly. Absolutely top notch.

Gusano's

3.5

(94 reviews)

We came in from out of town and were craving a good pizza, maybe a Chicago style. Found Gusano's…read moreand we were greeted by a very polite and professional Reagan. She also took our order and delivered a VERY tasty Chicago style pizza. The pizza did not disappoint. Great flavor and cooked to perfection. We also enjoyed a very good House Salad. Inside the restaurant were more than 7 or 8 televisions playing various sports events. At first the restaurant was not too busy. By the time we left it was packed. I now see why. I would highly recommend Gusano's Pizza to locals and anyone traveling in or near Joplin. Thanks Reagan for a great meal and dinner experience.

Delicious pizza and calzone my Brother always suggested this…read morepizza place and it's always good pizza

Boom

4.7

(3 reviews)

We were looking for something fun, casual, and comfortable for dinner--and Boom delivered. The…read morespace has great energy with plenty of TVs and fun extras like cornhole and pinball, plus a nice variety of seating from cozy sofas to high tops. Service was attentive and friendly, and the food was a hit. The brick oven pizza and Nashville chicken sandwich were standout favorites--both packed with flavor and perfectly cooked. We also loved the wings and fried pickles with churros or dessert. So good! A great spot for a relaxed night out with really great food!

Service was very attentive for our group and terrific views to watch games from thru the entire…read moreplace. Also the pizza was very good along with a Good cold beer.

Matt's Place

4.4

(112 reviews)

They had my drink in hand as I walked in and was seated all at the same time…read more Good is solid and efficient as is the service. Excellent choices on the menu as well. Does blackened well.

Mom and Pop breakfast place with a small town atmosphere. I devoured the pancake. They brought warm…read moresyrup too! Everything was good. Fresh cream for my coffee. Our waitress was so sweet. Will be back!

Turners Tastee Table Treats

5.0

(2 reviews)

Delicious pizza at this small but very professional restaurant in Wyandotte Oklahoma.read more

amazing food, customer service is awesome. prices are just where they should be. breadsticks is one…read moreI wouldn't pass up.

Blackthorn Pizza & Pub

3.9

(34 reviews)