After being a client of Scott Cohen's company, Poolmaster, for more than 13 years, I am utterly disappointed that I had to terminate my tech, Emerson Garcia, two weeks ago, along with the company.
On August 18, 2026, I texted Emerson because I hadn't seen him servicing the pool in weeks. He said everything was fine but admitted he was only coming once a week, claiming I wasn't paying him enough. When I told him I was paying the bill Sophy Duarte at Poolmaster emailed monthly, which stated twice-weekly service, he said I could talk to the office or find someone else. I reviewed my security footage and confirmed I was being billed for twice-weekly service but only receiving once-weekly visits. Since I had been traveling for work for months, I don't know how long this had been going on.
On August 19, I called Sophy at 8:47 AM and asked to urgently speak with Scott Cohen. She said he'd just left for a four-month vacation, left instructions not to be bothered, and there was no way to reach him. When I asked for a manager, she said Scott left her in charge.
I explained the texts with Emerson, the video evidence, and that Poolmaster had been billing me for services not provided -- meaning both Emerson and Poolmaster were effectively stealing from me. Sophy said Poolmaster sold my contract to Emerson years ago and that this was his responsibility, not theirs. I reminded her that despite Emerson being called a "gig worker" (their term), it was Poolmaster that billed and collected payment from me every month, NOT Emerson. I stressed the urgency: Emerson was lying to me and stealing by having Poolmaster bill me for service I didn't receive and lying to Poolmaster too -- making Poolmaster complicit. Sophy said she'd look into it and call back.
On August 20 at 9:33 AM, Sophy called to say she'd spoken with Scott. He asked how many months I thought Emerson had been doing this; I said I didn't know since my camera footage only went back 60 days. Scott instructed her to reimburse me four months of once-weekly service, deducted from Emerson's pay. I asked her to mail me a check. At my request, Sophy agreed not to tell Emerson until after that day's service.
Sophy asked if I wanted Emerson to continue or if I wanted a new tech. I said we'd address that after she spoke to him about reimbursement. When I asked why my rate hadn't increased like it had in the past, she said Scott hadn't raised it because we were long-time clients. She mentioned what Emerson charges new customers for twice-weekly service, and frankly his rate was very high compared to other companies I later consulted -- especially given he was never on-site more than 25 minutes. The fact that neither Emerson nor Poolmaster requested a rate increase isn't my responsibility. Later that day, after Emerson serviced the pool, I told Sophy I wanted him back the following week on both scheduled days, since that's what I had paid for in advance.
On August 21, I called Sophy to check on her conversation with Emerson. She said she told him what I'd reported and that the owed money would be deducted from his next paycheck; he said "ok" and didn't argue since the order came from Scott. She hadn't asked him why he'd done it.
I received the reimbursement check on August 24. On August 26, I asked Sophy to have Emerson do the final monthly service the next day and ring the doorbell afterward to return my pedestrian gate key, which he'd lost a few times before. On August 27, per camera footage, Emerson parked in front of my driveway from 2:40-2:52 PM, then stood by his truck talking on his phone. He never returned the key. I called Sophy at 4:06 PM; she said she'd call him and get back to me. I never heard back, and no one answered the office phone at 4:50 PM. When I got home, I found Emerson left the pool equipment in service mode for no reason -- apparently the only thing he'd done in his ten minutes there. It took five more days and several emails to Sophy before I got my key back.
I later learned Scott Cohen had moved to Colorado earlier this year.
I had referred Poolmaster and Emerson to neighbors over the years, just as they were referred to me by my realtor. I hope those neighbors haven't been billed for services they didn't receive. I've since hired a new pool company, which found: a fully rusted gas pipe, a cracked conduit exposing wires, a fully cracked blower top (which Emerson claimed didn't need replacing), dangerously high filter pressure risking a pump explosion, and two cracked tubing pieces affecting the pool vacuum.
The new company cleaned my filter last week due to high pressure. My Poolmaster receipt shows I was already charged for a filter cleaning on May 1, 2026. The following photos show how dirty the filters were just four months later. When I asked my new tech if they should be that dirty after four months, he said, "No." I'm sure I got charged by Emerson for a filter cleaning that never took place. read more