If you visit the website for Ponsonby Road Bistro, you'll be overwhelmed by their accolades: Top 20 Cuisine Good Food Awards 2013, Metro Top 50 etc etc etc. Does it live up to the hype?
Clearly a lot of people are finding out for themselves - this place was rammed when we visited. The dark wood, dim lighting & buzz of conversation made for a cosy dining environment.
Referring to my previous mention of the website, although it is rather extensive, do not take the online menu as set in stone.
The menu changes often and you can't be sure of getting the current one online. They do mention this online though, and I believe one of the signs of a good restaurant is one that changes its' menu often depending on the fresh produce available.
The Crispy-Fried Calamari entree was as good as I've tasted with a tender & light crispy coating. That's saying a lot in a city where calamari seems to be the entree de rigeur. If I was pulling hairs, I'd say the chef was a little heavy-handed with the salt, but overall it didn't distract from the taste of the dish. The Salad of Slow Roasted Pork Shoulder was accompanied with kimchi, brown rice and pineapple. These are more unusual flavours of showcasing slow cooked pork than the ubiquitous apples and kumara, and produced interesting, almost unexpected flavours. The Chicken Liver Pate was presented beautifully with salads greens and toast, and was very tasty. And our final entree choice of the Grilled Halloumi & Marinated Aubergine was again well received. This was a substantial portion too; vegetarians don't miss out here!
The main courses were more standard, with the exception of the Scotch Fillet, which was perfectly cooked to order and a decent size. The accompanying crunchy roasted potatoes were so popular that they kept disappearing off the plate! With regards to our other mains, they were unremarkable; the Stewart Island Salmon was well-cooked, and the Chargrilled Lamb Kebabs were nice enough. Nothing to complain about, but no WOW factor either.
Unfortunately things went downhill from here. After a 45 minute wait for our desserts and coffee, we finally ambushed the very busy waiter to find out what the problem was. Apparently it was some kind of "coffee hiccup"???? Cue still more waiting.... However, when the desserts FINALLY did arrive, they were amazing. The Valrhona Chocolate Pudding was rich & indulgent, as any self-respecting chocolate pudding should be. The Summer Berry Roulade was light with divine berry and passionfruit flavours. Yum.
To give them their due, the female maitre'd miraculously appeared at our table after the dessert debacle and was very attentive for the short remainder of our stay. She also discounted some coffees because of our wait.
In summing up, Ponsonby Road Bistro is a bistro done good. Elevating them to Top 20 status is slightly ridiculous. For what it is, the food is done well, but very pricey. Wine is also expensive, and the service is definitely bistro-worthy rather than 5 star silver service. Auckland, and especially Ponsonby, is brimming with wonderful restaurants that offer you the trilogy of great food, great service & a great experience at the right price; in my opinion, PRB has no real point of difference, and probably no reason for me to visit again. read more