This place is a hidden gem! We are always looking to try new places and we're in the right area at the right time. Must try their sampler platter and cream of mushroom soup. Everything was cooked fresh and you can tell it was homemade. I cannot wait to bring my mother and show her what we found. She loves stuffed cabbage and I have never had a better one. read more

Great food. Great staff! They should use pictures of real food instead of the weird AI slop in their website. read more

Polish Plates - Wonderful meal there! - Polish Near Me - West Milford, New Jersey

I went with my husband and a friend. We ordered the polish plate. It was like a sampler with stew, pirogi and keilbasa and some other stuff.. couldn't eat it all but loved it all. Wasn't sure what to expect - never had polish food before but I will absolutely be going back. read more

Very tasty. $100 for dinner for five. Will be back. Only reco is to add sauces to the kielbasa and perogies read more

See all

I saw this advertised a few days ago. I looked at the menu and was only familiar with a few of the items on it, but everything looked great. Tonight I decided to give it a shot and I'm glad I did. This is a quaint little place, seats about 35 or 40 max. Their service is wonderful. Their staff is professional and friendly and helpful, and the food was out of this world. I can't even remember the last time I had roll ups. I took a picture after I had already inhaled one. All of the food was very tasty, prepared to order, fresh as could be and expanded my knowledge of Polish food. I will be back. The only reason I'm giving this place five stars is because I can't give more. read more

See all

I have eaten here 6 times. Each time it was a special dinner. It's cozy, authentic Polish and great tasing food. The pirogies were delish and come in many varieties . Soups taste 100% home made. This place is a "must try" next time you go out for dinner. read more

Thank you for opening Polish Restaurant The food was delicious. Remind me of the old days. The service was very fast and courteous The atmosphere light Definitely will return and bringing friends The pierogies were to die My favorite though was the sour soup Next time, looking forward to trying the Ukrainian red Bursh. read more

Polish Plates - Polish plates restaurant west Milford nj - Polish Near Me - West Milford, New Jersey

We all went here Saturday night & had an amazing Real Polish dinner!!! Everything was delicious. The service was great also. The place is so clean. Can't wait to go back. read more

Ordered takeout including meatballs, chicken cutlet, pierogies, and mushroom soup--everything was excellent. The mashed potatoes and coleslaw on the side were just as good. The pricing was very reasonable for both the quality and portion sizes. Pickup was seamless; everything was ready right on time, and the staff was extremely friendly and welcoming. Highly recommend--will definitely be back. read more

The cream of mushroom soup was excellent as was the potato cheese pierogies and kielbasa. Fair prices for the portions. Excellent service and the decor was pleasing. We will be back soon. We also loved that we could BYOB. read more

I rarely leave critical reviews but feel compelled to do so after our experience. Such an incredibly disappointing birthday dinner. Food was very tasty & good. Food runner was the ONLY positive aspect of our experience. Food runner was pleasant throughout. He helped us because we couldn't get the waitress to pay attention to our table. She NEVER cleared the table, never checked in and failed to deliver anything we asked for. Service overall was the worst I have had in a long time. It took her 30 minutes just to take our food order. The waitress was disinterested, inattentive and basically ignored us while chatting with other tables, eating at her work station and she did not provide anything we asked for (water, food boxes, never checked in, never cleared dishes, didn't bring the check), If it wasn't for the food runner, we would still be there waiting for the bill. It's a nice space with good food. To the owners: Please, please, please find someone else to serve your customers. Your business is in jeopardy if you don't find someone capable and interested in serving your customers. We will not be back. read more

Polish Plates - Table never cleared throughout the meal. Had to put things in the floor to make room for food service. - Polish Near Me - West Milford, New Jersey

Tried Polish Plates for the first time and I have to say the food was excellent. Every dish we had was great. We will definitely go back there soon. read more

My husband is Polish, so we were excited to try this place, but unfortunately it was a disappointment. The potatoes were burnt and mushy--we couldn't even eat them. Nothing about the food felt authentically Polish. Sadly, we won't be returning. Oh yeah and it took forever to get our order read more

First visit to Polish Plates. Nice room with soft jazz playing. It did take us a minute or two to get seated, but apparently one of the waitresses had called out. Started with the Cream of Mushroom soup, and, MAN, what a way to start out! This soup was fantastic! Creamy and thick with diced mushrooms, it has a few small mushroom piergies in it as well. I almost ordered another bowl to go. My friend and I both ordered pierogies, Potat and cheese for me, mushroom and sauerkraut for him. We did a switcheroo with one of each other's. The piergies were boiled, not fried. The casing was soft and the fillings delicious. We also ordered a plate of hand cut fries, which were plentiful and tasty. It's BYOB with a liquor store a few steps away. Service was friendly. The menu doesn't really list 'sides,' but we asked about the fries and there was no problem. I only wish that sides of the potato pancakes were available. Also found it odd that with three soups, there wasn't a borscht offered. Maybe from another region of Poland. Anyway... well worth the trip to W. Milford. Don't miss that soup! read more

Don't see how there could be bad reviews. Three of us ate there I had the pork Schnitzel it was awesome the size of it was big. The breading was very good what ever they cook it in is crispy clean really get to taste the pork patty. Mash potatoes were pretty good. My kids meat pirogies were excellent. Three dinners barely $60 usually we are over $120 at other places. It's a BYO and a liquor store is in same lot. The buildings are unique and quaint. Our server blonde woman didn't catch her name, did an excellent job. Will be back to try some more unique choices. Oh and their noodle soup was topnotch. read more

If you are looking for fast food that is full of salt, this is your restaurant. How this place can call itself a restaurant is beyond me. No one comes to your table, you go up to register and place your order, they give you a beeper and when it goes off, you go back up and pick up your food. There is NO service here. The place was somewhat clean, there was food on the floor when we came in, and it remained there when we left. Nothing is fresh; its all pre-cooked and heated. The prices are what you would see in a "real restaurant," so its no bargain. One can get better table service at the local hot dog place. Would not recommend, but I am sure they will have some type of following given the food choices. Won't go back read more

Food was amazing!! Little hole in the wall charming place. Surprised it wasn't packed.

The food, service and atmosphere were perfect . Everything is homemade and delicious! BYOB. Save room for dessert, the poppyseed cheesecake was amazing. Generous portions. Friendly service. Great place for a romantic dinner and also a good place to bring the family. We will definitely be back! read more

We loved this food!! It was so delicious. We got the stuffed cabbage, pierogis, potato pancakes, and borscht. Couldn't recommend it more! Our server was amazing and brought everything out in perfect timing. Thank you!! Ambiance was a great vibe too! read more

Polish Plates - Stuffed Cabbage! - Polish Near Me - West Milford, New Jersey

See all

Beautiful decor, friendly service and fantastic food! Best stuffed cabbage I've had in years. Great pierogis too! Don't miss this lovely little place.!​ read more

I'm Polish and was looking forward to visiting this restaurant as we not only live in a food desert, but a Polish food desert. The restaurant is tucked away in a mall, so we circled the parking lot to find the entrance. It is bring your own, and there is a liquor store next door. Our friend that recommended it told us it was counter service, so we were surprised to see it was converted to sit down/service. Paul, the owner, was our waiter. He was attentive and gave us a history of how the restaurant came to be. We ordered pickle soup, herring, and cheese pierogi for appetizers. For dinner I had the sampler plate, which was pierogi, Hunter's stew, stuffed cabbage, and kielbasa, and my husband had stuffed cabbage with red sauce. All was delicious. I couldn't eat after for 2 days as there was so much food! It's important to point out, if you are expecting Polish food a certain way...how Busha made it, remember there are different regions of Poland that prepare food different ways...sort of like getting a pulled pork sandwich in southern USA vs. NJ-it's very different. We were excited to return with family, but they were closed due to an emergency. Bummer. We'll try again... read more

Good real Polish food friendly service nice ambiance. We will go back bringing friend and family

Friendly service and food done right. We love the polish plate and stuffed cabbage. Very comfortable

food was amazing!!! will definitely be coming back! We had the stuffed cabbage and chicken schnitzel but the chicken was WAS AMAZING!!!

We had another wonderful dinner at Polish Plates tonight. The newly revamped interior created a fantastic ambiance, complemented by the staff's excellent service. The food was outstanding; I ordered the stuffed cabbage in tomato sauce, which was fantastic, and my wife raved about her super crunchy and delicious cod. Both generous entrees came with a side of fresh, homestyle coleslaw or carrot salad. We're already looking forward to our next visit! read more

Visited the place yesterday. Beautiful and very clean restaurant with very nice decor. Food was amazing, fresh, wide variety to choose from, and huge portions. I chose the polish plate, and it was excellent, perfect pierogi, stuffed cabbage, bigos and kielbasa, that you can really call home made. Service was excellent, fast and extremely polite. Too bad it's so far away from where I live but will definitely go back whenever in the area and recommend to others. read more