Cancel

Open app

Search

Plaza Garibaldi

3.3 (18 reviews)
InexpensiveMexican
Open • 10:00 am - 10:00 pm

Plaza Garibaldi Photos

You might also consider

More like Plaza Garibaldi

Recommended Reviews - Plaza Garibaldi

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration

Reviews With Photos

Stefan E.

If you want to get away from the pretentious overpriced food of the Main area of Asbury Park and eat some authentic Mexican food, this is the place. You can get any taco you want, including goat, tongue and tripe for two bucks. You get free chips and spicy dip. Actually spicy, not Americanized flavorless garbage. A steak sandwich for six. The food is delicious and authentic. The mole was bitter, and had complexity. The chicken was not processed, you can tell they butcher their own bird. You'll leave full and happy for little money. I would recommend this to anyone who isn't afraid of ethnic people. Their English is limited. When you're in there, you feel like you're in Mexico. I can't believe this place doesn't have more reviews considering it's proximity to the main area of town, the price, and the quality of the food.

Complimentary salsa
Donna P.

This place is awesome Mexican food. Definitely a neighborhood gem. It was recommended to us by someone who lives in the area. Small restaurant that has a dozen or so tables. Looks like nothing from the outside at all. Food isn't pre-made, it is cooked to order so be patient as it is worth the wait. They start you off with complimentary chips, homemade salsa and salsa verde. We ordered the Garibaldi nachos with chicken, steak and Mexican sausage. Wow the flavors were amazingly delicious. Pork taco were so fresh and perfectly seasoned. The people next to us had a chimichanga and burritos and they said they were great. The guacamole was fresh and homemade. The server was so nice and attentive. They give you generous portions. Two people to eat here and take leftovers, plus soda came to $22. So if you like Mexican food, don't care the place isn't fancy and off the beaten track of the more upscale places everyone eats at, stroll on over here for some great food.

Looks good but chicken was bland and the sausage  was burnt.

See all

4 years ago

Helpful 14
Thanks 1
Love this 10
Oh no 0

4 months ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of April L.
276
601
4187

6 years ago

Helpful 2
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0

1 year ago

i loved the service was very good, loved the food it tasted very delicious, the waitress was very nice and they attended me quickly.

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

5 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of Tom P.
13
47
6

7 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

7 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of Stefan E.
160
95
5

10 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

8 years ago

Helpful 3
Thanks 0
Love this 3
Oh no 0
Photo of J T.
3
12
16

8 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

9 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of Mitzi C.
204
27
4

9 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

9 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

9 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

10 years ago

Not hidden, but a true gem! The staff is friendly, the service terrific and the food divine! Real Mexican American comfort food.

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

10 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

10 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

Plaza Garibaldi Reviews in Other Languages

Ask the Community - Plaza Garibaldi

Is there a liquor license?

no there is not. It's BYOB.

Don’t See Your Question? Ask Away!

Review Highlights - Plaza Garibaldi

“The tortillas and sauces incredibly flavorful fresh and homemade.”

Mentioned in 2 reviews

Read more highlights

You might also consider

Verify this business for free

People searched for Mexican 3,642 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

Verify this business

Barrio Costero

Barrio Costero

4.0(477 reviews)
0.1 mi
•$$

One of those places you almost don't want to tell people about... because you want to keep it for…read moreyourself. But I won't gatekeep! Barrio Costero was such a fantastic find! My family of 4 had a 6:30pm reservation on a Friday, and it was the perfect timing, the restaurant wasn't packed, but there was still a great energy and atmosphere. The space itself is beautiful, and from the moment we walked in, the staff was incredibly warm and welcoming. We started with the nachos, and if you're expecting your traditional pile of tortilla chips, cheese and toppings, these are definitely not that! They're individual tostadas topped with guacamole, salsa, cheese and crema. A fun twist and actually really delicious. The kids went with the chicken and cheese quesadilla, which was a huge hit. Simple, but SO good, definitely one of those dishes where I kept sneaking bites from the kids. My husband ordered the Tlayuda Masa, and we actually had to ask our server what it was. He immediately told us it was his favorite item on the Masa section of the menu, so of course we had to trust him. And he was absolutely right! It's essentially an open corn tortilla topped with incredibly tender skirt steak and a seriously good sauce. This ended up being one of the standout dishes of the meal. I ordered the pescado and carnitas tacos, two come with each order, and WOW. Both were packed with flavor and absolutely delicious. I honestly couldn't decide which I liked more, which is always a good problem to have when ordering tacos. And the whole time I kept thinking, "This feels like a restaurant I'd find in Brooklyn." The food is creative without feeling overly complicated, the space is stylish, and there's just a really cool vibe here. We finished with dessert and tried the flan, which was interesting but personally wasn't my favorite. Then came the horchata ice cream... OH. MY. GOODNESS. I have never had horchata ice cream before, and I am officially wondering where it has been all my life. 10/10. Creamy, flavorful and SO good. Our server mentioned that the menu changes seasonally, which gives me another reason to come back. I would love to see what they do with the fall menu! What I'd order again: Pescado tacos Carnitas tacos Tlayuda Masa Horchata ice cream Definitely worth adding to your list!

We celebrated our anniversary here after Pride and had an absolutely wonderful experience. From the…read moremoment we arrived, the staff made us feel so special. They even surprised us with a personalized card and gift for our anniversary, which was such a thoughtful touch and truly meant a lot to us. The hibiscus margaritas were fantastic, the appetizer was delicious, and every dish we ordered was packed with amazing layers of flavor. The food was beautifully prepared and absolutely memorable. Combined with the warm hospitality and attention to detail, it made for a perfect anniversary celebration. We are so grateful for the experience and can't wait to return!

Photos
Barrio Costero - Bar area

Bar area

Barrio Costero - Carnitas tacos

Carnitas tacos

Barrio Costero - Horchata ice cream and warm cookies.

See all

Horchata ice cream and warm cookies.

Plaza Tapatia - Sopes

Plaza Tapatia

3.7(188 reviews)
0.1 mi
•$$

Food 9/10. Service 5/10. Improvement needed…read more Walked in and there was a wait which is expected as the place is small. We were seated and it seemed like we were forgotten about. The staff kept walking past us without glancing over. After 15 minutes, someone finally came by with chips and salsa and said that they would be right back. Wonderful for chips and salads, but no waters? I asked if they could bring water and that took another 10 minutes. No straws either. I ended up walking to the bar to get my own straws. I wasn't waiting another 10 minutes for that. The chips and salsa were amazing! We finished the entire thing! Margaritas were also great! Food then came out. Steam and shrimp enchiladas. Very nicely prepared and delicious. Sadly, it was dropped off to us with no utensils. At this point, I was getting a bit annoyed. My boyfriend got up to ask someone to give us a fork to eat. As we ate, we noticed three other tables came in asking for utensils because the staff had forgotten to provide it to them as well. Small things that make a huge difference. Hopefully they can improve on customer service, as it's a shame since the food is fantastic.

So let's talk about the food. Ordered a guacamole, chicken enchiladas and sopes. The food was good…read morenot spicy at all. If you like spice might not be for you. SERVICE WAS TERRIBLE, only ordered 1 margarita because no one came back to our table to ask if we wanted more drinks. had to go find our waitress to get the check. They had no hostess, busser or runner. The place was not crowded at all, all employees were in the back doing other chores. FYI - they automatically add 18% gratuity no matter what size party you have. It was 2 of us at the table.

Photos
Plaza Tapatia - Free estimate 7322855601

Free estimate 7322855601

Plaza Tapatia - Chicken enchiladas

Chicken enchiladas

Plaza Tapatia - Free estimate 7322855601

See all

Free estimate 7322855601

La Sierra El Comedor - Chicken with Mole Negro

La Sierra El Comedor

4.1(11 reviews)
0.2 mi
•$

This is not your ordinary Mexican restaurant! It is one of the best you will find in this country…read moreand I have not eaten better Mexican food whether in NYC, Bay Area, Chicago, LA, Arizona, and even Mexico! Notably, the specialities are Oaxacan. So we stuck to those and ordered a chicken with mole negro and tlayudas (without meat). Wow!!! These were both incredibly delicious. The mole was the most delicious I had ever eaten anywhere including at Oaxacan food festivals and I nearly licked the plate clean!! Every taste of this was heavenly...you could taste the chili and chocolate and many other ingredients complex and rich ingredients that created a chocolate nutty aromatic sauce with a smooth and deep chili burn. The chicken in which it was braised was among the most tender and fall-off-the-bone moist chicken I have ever eaten. The rice and black beans it came with were equally delicious. The tlayudas was my first: wow!!! It was so complex and balanced like the mole,but much lighter and with more complex textures. There was what seemed like a baked flour tortilla buttered with black bean paste and different cheeses including Oaxacan fresh homemade cheese and cheddar cheese and even a type of creamy white cheese topped and layered with fresh lettuce and avocado and vegetables as well as pickled cactus to create a panoply of flavors and textures, light, delicious and perfectly balanced in each bite. Thank you for this wonderful culinary experience!!

Legit Mexican food and baked goods. They're open super early (6am I believe) and that's a good…read moreindicator that the food is authentic because they get a lot of workers coming in for breakfast. You will feel like you're in a family restaurant in a small town in Mexico.. there is no tacky decor or even a bar. It might actually be a little intimidating for some lol You come here for homemade food, not ambiance. The mole is made fresh and was great in the tamales. Squash blossom quesadillas were delicious and a huge portion. Huevos rancheros also hit the spot. The fresh OJ was super sweet. They had tons of breads but we didn't try them. Looking forward to stopping in again next time I'm in AP.

Photos
La Sierra El Comedor - 1/2 chicken w/ rice & beans  & beef brisket taco

1/2 chicken w/ rice & beans & beef brisket taco

La Sierra El Comedor
La Sierra El Comedor - Tlayudas de Oaxaca

See all

Tlayudas de Oaxaca

REYLA - STEAK (GF DF)

REYLA

4.3(313 reviews)
0.1 mi
•$$

REYLA was an incredible first dinner in Asbury Park and set the bar high. From the moment we walked…read morein, the staff was welcoming, attentive, and genuinely friendly. The service was excellent throughout the entire evening, and every cocktail we ordered was fantastic. We started with a few appetizers, which were the perfect way to kick off the meal before diving into our mains. For dinner, we ordered the Duck Rice, Schnitzel, octopus, and mushroom skewer. While everything was delicious, the Duck Rice and Schnitzel were the clear standouts. Both were packed with flavor, and the Schnitzel was an especially generous portion without feeling over the top. It was perfectly cooked and incredibly satisfying. To top off the night, we headed downstairs to their cocktail bar, Laylow, and had an amazing time. The atmosphere was fun, the cocktails were just as impressive as dinner, and it was the perfect way to end the evening. If you're in Asbury Park, I definitely recommend checking out Reyla and making a stop at Laylow afterward. Great food, outstanding service, amazing drinks, and an all-around memorable experience.

My husband and I were staying overnight in Neptune so we came to Reyla for dinner. It was a…read moreThursday night and not crowded but a decent amount of people. We opted to sit at the bar because the vibe looked good. I had a lemondrop martini from the half price menu and it was good but a little too sweet. Then I had the Blood Sugar Sex Magic from the regular menu and it was unique and fun. I then had an espresso martini with dessert. I was feeling good after that. We did three appetizers: hummus, falafel, and the halloumi. The hummus had a nice texture but it could have used a little more lemon and garlic. But it was served with a jumble of fresh herbs on top which was very nice. The falafel was amazing. The texture was perfect: very crispy on the outside and light and fluffy inside. Not like the dense falafel you get in some places. It was serviced on top of a delicious red pepper sauce. The server told me it was an old family recipe. The halloumi was fantastic. Very generous and covered in a very crispy coating. It sat in a pool of hot honey. They brought the appetizers out one at a time, which was the perfect way to pace it. We were pretty full by the end so we shared one entrée. We had the lamb kofta. It was cooked perfectly and sat atop a pomegranate labneh. It was also delicious. For dessert my husband had the chocolate cake which was only ok. I had the baklava malabi which was sooo delicious. Great meal and excellent service. Paul the bartender was friendly and made good drinks.

Photos
REYLA - Seating in front

Seating in front

REYLA - TURKISH HUMMUS GF

TURKISH HUMMUS GF

REYLA - Kachapuri

See all

Kachapuri

Plaza Garibaldi - mexican - Updated October 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...