We've been ordering from this pizzeria for years, and it's always reliable. The buffalo chicken…read morepizza is a standout--no tomato sauce, just a cheesy ranch base, buffalo chicken, and celery. Super flavorful and unique. Their pinwheels are great, and the penne alla vodka has become a must-order for us--surprisingly good for a pizza place! The chicken Alfredo is also solid depending on what we're in the mood for. It's a staple in our rotation--right between Pizza Port and New Park, but it definitely holds its own

Over 2 hours for a dinner delivery less than 2 miles away is unacceptable. I was quoted 1 hour…read morewhen I ordered. And for the food to just be lukewarm when it finally arrived is insulting. But when you are starving after waiting that long you'll eat cold hard garlic knots and starchy cold pasta with cold and oily melted cheese on top. It might have been good when it was fresh, but we will never know. $35 (with a $5 tip for the driver) was a lot for an inedible meal.

First time trying this place and the pizza is delish! We got a white pizza with pepperoni and…read moresausage. The slices are massive, crispy and flavorful. Definitely try this place if you're in New York.

This pizza spot shares the location with Dunkin Donuts. I enjoy getting the pizza garlic knots and…read morethe lunch special ( 2 cheese slices and a drink for $7.50). The pizza has a nice crust, taste pretty good and is always fresh. The pepperoni garlic knots are so tasty. The employees are always friendly. One of my go to lunch spots.

Can't believe these folks reviews added up to 3 1/2 stars?…read moreThis place in Jamaica NY has the BEST PIZZA, we have enjoyed the pizza with sausage!!! Holy cannoli!!! They also have great empanadas (I love beef n hubby chicken) And Jamaican patties!! Whaaat!! Everything's Irie here man! We are here on work project, happy for good while, hubby's has lots of meals here with long work hours to have a good appetite- he be bragging about what he ate each day!!! Says everything you choose is consistent every day. Never a disappointment!!! You must give Mario's a try! You'll be happy your living in this neighborhood!! wish I did! Come n get it! Order, grab a table and Enjoy!!! Mario is a genius!! Very nice man n cook n family as well!!

Great quick pizza for a travelers. Got the 2 slices with a soda for $8. Tablespoons to sit if…read moreneeded and staff was right there to help us find napkins, Togo containers, cheese garlic, and anything else we could need.

Margherita Pizza is hands down one of my favorite pizza places ANYWHERE…read more I've been coming here since the 80s, so this isn't some "I found a great pizza spot" review. I have HISTORY here. The crazy part is that so much of it still feels the same. Same old-school setup, same narrow green-and-white interior, oven right in the middle, limited seating in the back, and people constantly coming in for a slice and keeping it moving. And the pizza? Still the reason I come back. This is not a fancy pizzeria. It's old-school Jamaica Avenue. In the summer it can get HOT in there, seating is limited, and most people grab their slice and go. That's part of the experience. And yes, they're STILL cash only. In 2026. So come prepared because apparently some things really do never change. Some places are good because they're new and exciting. Some places are good because they've been doing the same thing forever and never needed to become anything else. Quick and efficient, know what you want and get out of the way when you get it.

Just had my first UYE (unofficial Yelp event) at Margherita Pizzeria. My small group of 4 ordered…read morethe regular pie. I really enjoyed this event and the location on Jamaica Avenue was a convenient meeting place, looking liking a small cafeteria. The service was very friendly and cordial. They bought napkins and plates along with our drinks. When the pizza pie came out; hot and fresh, they delivered it to our table. This is a very small place and we were lucky to find a seat and there's no restrooms. My very first small bite, into the slice of margarita pizza was absolutely delicious, it had a sweet savory taste and looked like Vodka sauce. This is a cash pay system and they do allow you to stand and eat at the counter. I will most definitely be returning. I'm very satisfied with this visit... Inspire more, Yelp more!

Yeah, so, over 10 years ago I used to work in the neighborhood, and when we'd finally get out of…read morework, we'd be so hungry (one of those horrible work through lunch type bosses. ugh). This place was a welcoming beacon shining out at night under the elevated train, and it was always open late. In and out, grab a slice, eat it on the train, done. One thing that always irritates me when people complain about smelling food on the train, is that not everybody has time to make their dinner. Some people have to walk and eat, or eat on the train because of time and hunger. Don't like it, take a cab. Facts. This place was an easy, filling, good tasting stop on the way home. And guess what? It's still a great slice. I took a red slice home and it holds up. It's similar to L&B, tomatoey sauce, not sweet or chunky with tomatoes. Minimal cheese. They have plain, regular Sicilian, etc....friendly guys, sit down booths, the standard. Pass Papa John's. This is the place.

Called in my pizza ahead of time just so I wouldn't have to wait because I have children with me…read moreand we were on the go after a really long day , I usually go to my go to spot but I been trying to try new places in the area so so having to pick up a quick lunch doesn't always seem repetitive when it comes to location however you get way you pay for , I order a large pie regular cheese pizza well done and some mozzarella sticks , the mozzarella sticks were good for the most part , typical mozzarella sticks noting wow about the but good , the pizza not so impressed the crust of the pizza was really thick and even asking for my pizza well done and I know they did listen because from sight it looks well done , the thickness just took away that crunch I was looking for as well as the bite was off , the sauce was not anything special and the cheese honestly just came all Off my pizza so quick and the pizza got cold from the pizzeria to my home which is a total of 6 minutes driving distance ... was not impressed the pizzeria itself is very clean and welcoming and the staff was friendly and respectful but not a fan of the pizza it didn't do it :/ if your looking for a quick slice on the go it gets the job done but for anything more when it came To the pizza , no thanks

One of the best regular slices in the Jamaica area…read more Service is quick. has plenty of seats for dining in.

Gabys never disappoints…read more This is a thicker slice. Cheese-heavy and balanced with a sweet sauce and a crunchy bite. A structured pizza that fills you up. Opened since the late 90s, Gary's has maintained their quality, always using fresh ingredients for the best taste and having the same disciple for years. There's history on the walls. Celebrities, community, decades of people coming back again and again. It's pizza done right!

Ambiance and Atmosphere: The atmosphere was great, giving old school Italian brick oven pizzeria…read moreshop with tables and chairs. Service: Since the order was placed through Doordash, the food was ready after a few minutes after providing my name on the order. The service was great and they were polite and helpful. Food Quality: I ordered a grandma pie, BBQ Wings, and penne vodka. I enjoyed the grandma pie not the best but it was good and fresh. The BBQ Wings could have been better, didn't taste fresh, and the penne vodka I was highly disappointed, it tasted like it wasn't fresh at all and had no flavor. Value for Money: Everything I ordered was worth the money, as the portation was huge! Overall Experience: I would be coming back as this is at the moment the best grandma pie near me. Final Thoughts: I believe this would be a perfect family dinner to take out or dine in.

Hidden gem! Very…read moregood pizza. Their Sicilian is delicious. Reasonable priced as well. Will order again when I am in the area for my doggies veterinarian appointments.

A neighborhood gem! This establishment is super popular, the owners are very kind and the food is…read moreexceptional. The pizzas are delicious! I have yet to eat-in, but that's my next move. Even though I order takeout, I have always been greeted when I enter the place and this is greatly appreciated. It feels like you're family when you walk in. The sausage and pepper hero is one of my favorites. The food is so good. I highly recommend.

We were back home to NYC for an event and staying at an AirBnB in Howard Beach. The owner suggested…read moreGino's. And we went there immediately for lunch because we were dying for NYC pizza. Gino's did not disappoint. We got a small plate of bruschetta and cheese bread the minute we sat down, courtesy of the house. We got the special pizza that had meatballs, sausage, pepperoni, roasted red peppers, and mushrooms. We also got an order of spumoni. The 12-in pizza was more than enough for two people and filled with all the ingredients listed. I like sauce on my pizza, so I asked for a little extra on the side and it was so good I could have sucked it down without the pizza, which was hot and delicious! The small spumoni was a half scoop each of strawberry, chocolate, and pistachio ice cream. Not the official spumoni roll that I expected. The place was very packed and kind of noisy. The one thing that was noticeably lacking was the service. While it was efficient and fast there was no cordiality, it was just perfunctuary (no smiles, no kind words, nothing). Despite this, we would definitely recommend the restaurant because the pizza was excellent. We also welcomed the 20% lunch discount on the food. The bill was $30.57 for the pizza, ice cream, tax, and tip.