Okay food. Horrendous service. I don't know if these bartenders/servers are deliberately…read moredismissive, inadvertently inattentive, or just plain stupid, but they go out out of their way to not notice you, even when the place is nearly empty. I understand I probably come off as snobbish and pretentious by expecting cutlery to come with my food, but is it too much to ask that someone glance in my direction once every 20 minutes to see if I need a refill?

The beer is good and cold but the food was mediocre, the bartender was super slow and took forever…read moreto get her attention. If you're not a local, don't bother wasting your time here.

Great food. Great service. Eat there every chance I get. It's a family tradition. Why do they…read morerequire 85 characters?

I've always loved this place, but recently went In and they were super rude and charged $1.60 for a…read morecup of sauce.... when you get them free eating in. Disappointed for a small down.

Stopped into Casey's on my way out of town tonight and the gentleman working at the counter was…read moresweet, kind and very nice to talk to. I said goodbye to my sister today/held her memorial service and he helped to make my day a little brighter. I didn't catch his name but if you know him thank him for me.

The food is delicious! Unlike a certain pizza chain restaurant nearby, the pizza crust tastes and…read moresmells like fresh baked bread. We also like the house salad and the lasagna is wonderful. I can't wait to go back.

Make sure and read all of the negative reviews. They are probably the most objective and they hit…read moreall the highlights. Disclaimer: this visit was on Mother's Day so we understood that it would be crowded with longer wait time. First time in restaurant. The tables are packed claustrophobic tight. Or table was smack up against the side of the salad bar. I was afraid my hair would get in the lettuce. Every time someone walked past our table they bumped into the chairs. Payment is No cards, cash/check only and this info is NOT published anywhere but on a notecard taped to the cash register which was blocked from view as we were seated. Not on the door, not on the website. I see it's here in the comments on Yelp, but I had poor signal and didn't do a review search, just looked at the website. Poor treatment by owners - attitude was not "I'm sorry for your poor experience" but "I'm sorry you're complaining, get lost." Carry out orders and friends and locals seemed to receive priority service. Mediocre, overpriced food. "Baked" pasta dish was runny, mozzarella barely melted, meat sauce with barely any meat, way too sweet. Garlic bread with very little garlic. Pizza crust was hard, flavorless, over cooked on edges. Sauce (to me) has a weird chemical-like taste. Toppings were not fresh, mushrooms were canned, pizza was under cooked in the middle. Wait time - it was one hour until someone told us it was ready to come out in a couple of minutes..... then it actually was another 30 minutes or more later, during which the waiter avoided us like the plague until we flagged him down and asked when our food would be out, then another ten minutes after that. After reading reviews, it would seem that the time deception is a sanctioned tactic. Finally, after going to the car, retrieving an old checkbook, and writing a check with a generous tip in spite of the deficiencies, we politely expressed that they should publish their payment policy and how wait time was misrepresented. Received a very curt response. Left an honest comment on the community fb page and was threatened, cursed, and called every name in the book by most of the friendly "locals." But hey, social media, right? The rudeness on a busy day could have been easier to forgive if everything else had been five star, but the food really isn't worth the price and the wait. And jeez, Monticello....I'm afraid to drive through town, much less eat at this restaurant again.

While visiting ISU we stopped in for some pizza to try something new & WOW were we surprised. We…read moretried the beer cheese appetizer, those who took part said it was delicious. We had chicken wings garlic flavored... yummy! And the gluten free pizza was the best I have ever had ANYWHERE! Oh my gosh Becky.... Deeeeelicious! Our server Ayden was fantastic and tentative . The ambiance was welcoming with a laid Back vibe. Loved it! Cannot wait to eat there again.

Order online for pick up. Get home and the Meemaw's dip is burnt. Had it a week ago and it was…read morecreamy and perfect. Can't even get it off the bottom of the dish. Called the store and Bret was minimal help. Tried to tell us it comes out a little brown. This is more than brown. This is burnt and dry. So disappointing.

Food was alright one of our pizzas was slightly overcooked, the waitress was kind, place was clean…read moreenough.

They have amazing pizza! Mimi was great. Such a nice person. We love this location. Worth the drive.read more

Arrived early to have a table for four. The restaurant is pretty cool inside so make sure you have…read morea jacket. We needed to wait for our party and Brittney was generous in allowing us a delayed order until our party showed up. We ordered one cheese pizza and one pizza with sausage, onion, mushrooms, peppers, and artichokes. Our full pizza was delicious! I really like their sauce and their crust. The crust is crispy and has great mouth-feel and the sauce is sweeter than I have normally have which is why I like it...it's really good. We ordered the larger pizza so I could have leftovers....so good!

Cute tiny spot and really tasty pizza, just try to go at an off time because there's only so many…read moretables and not too many spots to stand around and wait if you haven't been seated yet. My absolute favorite thing about this place was that if you were waiting for a table they let you place your pizza order while you were still waiting which minimizes how long you're sitting around waiting for your pizza once you do get the table. 2nd favorite thing is the pasta looked really really really good. We mostly had pizza and apps but the next time I go back I'm definitely trying some of the pasta.

Stopped in for a speciality pizza to try tonight and OMG I want to eat all of it. I've been told…read morethat they have speciality pizzas that are very unique and today's flavor was "The Big Dill": housemade garlic Alfredo sauce, mozzarella, sharp cheddar cheese, kosher dill slices, homemade dill slices, bread and butter chips, fresh dill, and dill ranch drizzle on a thin crust. The crust was thicker than Monicals but was very good for a thin crust and had full flavor. I will definitely be looking for more creative flavors from them in the future. This is the best pizza I have had in a long time. Slight downside is cash or check.

Pretty Darn Good! We love the original dough nuggets with spicy nacho cheese sauce! Yum we enjoy…read morethe super stuffed, thin, and fair crusts! My spouse LOVES the HONEY BADGER pizza! They always have a pizza of the week as well. Definitely give them a try!

My first visit in SO SO many years, and I must say they hit the ball out of the park! Fabulous…read morePizza, great Toppings, Crust and Sauce flavorings. My Friday night, end of the week cheat meal and it was SO worth it!

Best pizza by far!!! Always wonderful and delicious!! Their breadsticks are awesome too!read more

Pretty much as good of pizza as you can get for 8 bucks. Fairly fast and cozy joint. Cheese on top…read moreis great.

Great food and service! Loved the pizza. The atmosphere was amazing. Great vibe. Would highly…read morerecommend.