We're new to the area so we're trying to various pizza places near us. We came here off a recommendation from a neighbor. It's fairly close by to our house and saw that it was Best Pizza winner of 2015. Prices seem fairly cheap compared to other pizza places we've tried recently. They made our pepperoni pizza super quick and it smelled really good. Thank goodness we didn't live far so we could dive in. I like the taste of the pizza sauce. It had a bit of a tang to it. You could smell it as well. It's probably not our top pizza place at the moment but definitely willing to go back to have another. read more

I think their pizza is super yummy! I've ordered from there a few times and the delivery is quick!

Decent pizza. The service is mainly what keeps me coming back for more. Waiters are super nice and always making sure you are ok. Pretty clean for your average pizza place. Not usually very crowded so I love that aspect. It's located in a shopping center, so I like to stop in Dollar General before heading back home. Overall I recommend this place. read more

For wanting casual pizza dining, this place was great. It was clean (even though I wouldn't have given it a chance unless I had read previous reviews on yelp). The staff was friendly. The food was great. Just ordered basic cheese pizza and it was delish. Also ordered a salad and it was fresh and tasty. I'll definitely order there again. read more

See all

Pizza plus never disappoints!! Amazing pizza that is ALWAYS right on time and so so good!!!

Pizza plus has become our go-to pizza place. The pizzas are always great and the salads are always really fresh. We order at least once a week. Their delivery times can sometimes get a little long but we chalk it up to the pizzas being made fresh!! read more

I tried the triple cheese philly and it was delicious. I'm excited to go back another time and try something different to see how the other food taste! Great customer service also! read more

They have the best calzone around! And they're huge! Do not order the large unless you're feeding a family of 6 because the regular sized one can easily feed 4 people. I love the subs too. Oh, if you want fries, just get one order because like the calzone, it will feed about 3 people. We stumbled across this place a few years ago Geocaching and never miss hitting them when we're on that side of town. Definitely worthy of a visit. read more

Good food. Fast service. Excellent garlic knots. We were in the mood for subs. I ordered the chicken philly and it was delicious. Someone else got the turkey and loved it. Never had anything we didn't like from here. Their biggest competitor in our area is YNot and I'll always choose Pizza Plus over YNot any day. read more

By far some of the best pizza I have had in a while and without a doubt the best pizza in Deep Creek. Just recently came back to them based on a neighbors ravings. First pizza I ordered from there several years ago was horrible and made me never want to order from there again... BUT my neighbor talked me into it. I am so glad he did!! we order from here more than what we should but it is just that good. If you are looking for a good new your style pie than this is the place!!! read more

Pizza Plus - Italian Near Me - Chesapeake, Virginia

Terrible service tonight! Ordered my pizza on line at 5:00. Pizza was supposed to be ready at 6:00. I arrived at 6:00, they hadn't even started my pizza yet. It wasn't ready until 6:40. No communication from staff. I watched several people cancel orders or wait extended amount of time like me. I will not be returning! read more

The pizza is good. It is a New York thin crust so you have to enjoy that type of pizza. The garlic knots are also good. The marinara dipping sauce did not have a good flavor. Overall a four out of five. By the way, they have free delivery. read more

Everything I've eaten from here has been yummy. The staff is friendly. The prices are right. The wait time can be a little long but I guess that's what you get when everyone loves Pizza Plus. read more

My friend and I went here to eat last night and it was amazing. The chicken wings...the 18 inch pizza..the garlic knots...and their marinara sauce was all soo good!!! The server named Autumn was awesome!! Prompt service mixed with great food made for a very enjoyable dinner for us! The prices were also great!! A family of 4 could easily eat for under 25 bucks...I have nothing but good things to say about this pizza place!! read more

I have been a loyal customer of pizza plus since its inception to Deep Creek. So when I reached home with the half pepperoni / cheese pizza and the kids in tow. I was quite surprised that the pizza looked old and the dough was tough. My kid pulled the cheese off and said he didn't like it. My kid loves cheese! I immediately called the store and informed the girl the concerns I was having. She offered no solution except to say, sorry your experience was not pleasing. The bottom line is the pizza was only $10. I was not looking for anything free. I would have been happy if Pizza Plus had offered to remake the pizza and deliver to my house. We normally spend between $35-$50 three times a month with pizza plus deliveries to our home. I am disappointed because pizza plus lost their fan base over $10. read more

Probably the worst pizza I have ever ordered. The pizza is very bland and much like what you would get at a mall food court. The garlic knots with cheese have no flavor and the cheese literally can come off in one entire piece. We paid $20 for food that we ended up throwing away. I have no idea why this one best of chesapeake ever because it's sad to say that I would rather eat Pizza Hut than a local pizza place. Never again. read more

Pizza Plus - Aparently cheese? - Italian Near Me - Chesapeake, Virginia

Do not recommend....I normally give Pizza Plus a 5, but the last couple times they have messed up the order every time. I'm not sure what's going on there and we love their food but getting the orders right is no longer a priority to them. I'm not sure that I will continue to order from them and have found a great place pretty close called Rays Pizza who make sure the orders are right, the food is hot and very good. read more

This place is just not good I do not understand why it has such good reviews. Do Virginians just not understand what good food/pizza places are? There's not much else around so I've had to order from here from time to time, and every time I hope for the best but the pizza is soggy, the ingredients are CHEAP but the food is not (frozen chopped spinach? Really?), I'm confused by stuff like their "Italian" sandwich that has artichokes etc in it? Ummm it might taste fine but that's not an Italian sandwich. Biggest issue is the soggy pizza and cheap ingredients. Oh and we found a meal worm once (it happens , they can get into flour bags) and the owner was a complete jerk about it when we called. read more

I've been to this establishment numerous times. Always satisfied and never disappointed. A very solid pizza slice - always a great lunch special. read more

Great service, yummy food! We tried almost a quarter of the menu and everything was really good! read more

Pizza Plus - Supreme "small" calzone! - Italian Near Me - Chesapeake, Virginia

I couldn't be happier to live a mile down the road from this gem of a pizza place. My favorite pizza from here so far is the buffalo chicken pizza, and I always get their delectable garlic knots. Highly recommend. read more

This is a pretty decent pizza place and in Deep Creek your options are limited. With that being said, be prepared to wait and wait and wait on a weekend. If you use the pizza app to order you'll find the time isn't very accurate for actual pick up and most often you will be delayed longer than desired (longer than 75 minutes shown in app) so add another 15 minutes to whatever the time on the app is - this has rung true now each time I've used it on the weekend. Weekdays it's fairly accurate within 5 min or so delay. Prices are pretty reasonable and specials are good. read more

Best local pizza place I've found. As close to NY style you'll find in Virginia. They use great quality toppings and have great sliced Italian sausage. Sandwiches and apps are good, not great. I'd stick to the pizza. read more

Excellent! Just moved to the area and this will be my new GO TO pizza spot!!! Great crust, not too much sauce!!! The Parmesan wings were great (I ordered crispy and they arrived crispy via delivery)! Will be ordering again very soon!! read more

I learned about pizza plus from my coworker on Thursday I've order twice from them I must say it's by far the best New Yorker Style Bianca Pizza in the Hampton Roads Area read more

Pizza Plus - Bianca Pizza with Spinach and Broccoli! - Italian Near Me - Chesapeake, Virginia

Great pizza, fast delivery and great service. We love Pizza Plus and need to try more options on their menu but we love their pizza so much, we always order that!! My neighbors love their wings and maybe one day I will try those, when I'm not tempted by the pizza every time! read more

Fabulous pizza, really nice staff. It's our go to place when visiting my parents' house. The garlic knots are delicious! We love their specialty pizza options. read more

Everything we have ordered has been delicious. I'm pretty picky about my pizza and this place has the best pizza. I absolutely love their salads. You can even get a delicious burger and gyro here. Definitely my go to restaurant when I can't or don't want to cook :) read more

The pizza here is excellent and the owner/staff are as pleasant as they can be! It is definitely worth a visit if you are a fan of mom & pop pizza places. I can't wait to stop back by and try a pasta dish or one of their fresh burgers... read more

Pizza Plus - $4.99 Lunch Special At Pizza Plus! - Italian Near Me - Chesapeake, Virginia

We are new to the area and their is not many food options. We ordered take out. My husband got the chicken parm, I got Chicken Marsala and the kids shared a pizza. Honestly, the pizza was the best of it all. The Marsala was bland and I would not attempt it again. I didn't even eat half of it. The chicken parm was meh. But the pizza was good. The place was alright. Might go back if we were desperate. read more

Absolutely love it. Just moved to this side of the water and very glad we discovered this place. Amazing pizza and everything else we have gotten has been good as well. And the cheesecake read more

Bon Appetite! Amazing pizza and canole's! Pizzas are amazing for the price and are similar to Ynot Pizza and other New York style pizza restaurants. Definitely a thumbs up on the canoles! Simply, if your looking for a pizza shop and happen to be in Deep Creek Chesapeake, VA Pizza Plus is a great way to go! read more

I simply love this place. The food is amazing. My favorite is the New York style pizza. Pizza plus is an excellent neighborhood pizzeria. If you are looking for authentic Italian take out. This is definitely the place. read more

We always order takeout & the pizza is truly amazing! And a large is HUGE! Perfectly big enough to feed a group of 4.

Im not sure what is happening over at Pizza Plus but the last 3 times we have ordered from there it has been horrible. The first time it took 1 hour and 45 minutes to get the pizza and it was cold. The second time the pizza was cold and they forgot my soda. This third time the pizza came 1 hour and 15 minutes and was the worng pizza and it was cold. The meatballs had no flavor. The chicken wings were undercooked. We used to be a happy customer now we are happy we are not customers any longer. read more

Love the pizza! Great cheese and meat, better than the national chains. My pizza of choice on the weekend.

I've been a customer since Pizza Plus opened their doors but unfortunately I think I'm going to have to find another pizza joint. It's a shame because the food used to be fantastic... especially the pizza. Now it's comparable to low grade dog food. Prices have continued to rise while quality and service have plummeted. If you don't mind picking up & paying $20-25 for a pizza while the employees stand around checking their phones then this place is for you. Hell, the guy that seems to be the owner isn't much better so why would a bunch of young kids know any better? Currently I'd much rather walk next door to Food Lion and buy a couple of $5 Tombstone's than give my $$$ to Pizza Plus. read more

Pizza Plus - Worker in the, "weeds" while I wait for my order which was supposedly ready 10 minutes ago. - Italian Near Me - Chesapeake, Virginia

I just moved in the Deep Creek area and was looking for some take out. After researching onYelp using the android app I decided on Pizza Plus. I was impressed. I ordered the $12 take out special which I brought home and was given thumbs up! Some seating is available but mostly a take out business. read more

Decent prices, had plain cheese pizza and it was okay. Maybe it would be better with different toppings? Overall, average.

Pizza plus has the best pizza in Hampton roads! So glad I'm lucky enough to live in the delivery area. The inside service is good to however. Generally, we use deliver and get the family deal which is an amazingly priced combo you get two pizzas, a liter of soda, a salad, wings, and garlic knots for 40 bucks. Their house dressing is amazing on salads. Definitely worth it! read more