Average pizza at best. The thin crust was a decent attribute but both slices were overheated and a ton of condiments were needed to make it tasty. There are a few tables inside plus a TV if you're aiming to catch a sports game but there wasn't much that jumped out in terms of ambiance. read more

Pizza Pete's - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Great pizza, sweet staff, no frills, just everything as it should be for this very amenable, dependable UWS pizza joint. (Except they offer a surprisingly large array of deep dish slices. No comment.) read more

Just wanted two slices quick. Pizza Pete's can do two slices quick as lots of pies are in the case. Man at counter was very nice. It is a tiny place in a busy block with lots of eateries. I had a plain slice and one with jalapeños and bacon and pepperoni. To go. Pre-made pizza has its purpose, but also makes you realize how much better a fresh baked whole pie is. But I was in and out in five minutes, and Pizza Pete's was fine. read more

Pizza Pete's - Ready to heat - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Decent cheap slice. Not super fresh but a good, greasy drunk snack. Could be cleaner, limited seating, soccer on the TV. Cashier/employee was friendly and pizza was fast to come out. read more

Pizza Pete's - Pepperoni & Cheese - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

First time here and the pizza is decent, but the service was terrible. Can't figure out why people in the service industry are so grumpy? Don't think anyone asked or made you take your job. Sad for a place I was recommended to. Won't ever return. read more

Fairly friendly staff, decently clean place, albeit a little small. Incredible pizza. Incredible.

Pizza Pete's is good! I got a slice of pizza, garlic knots (5) with marinara, and a side of ranch all for $8! I was impressed with how quick my food was ready too. I know it's just another pizza shop in ny but it was pretty good! I will say the garlic knots were probably not worth getting and were a little dry. Totally get the pizza though! read more

Pizza Pete's - Cheese Pizza & 5 Piece Garlic Knots - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

Just what a slice should taste like! Good crust, good sauce and good cheese. Lots of regulars!

Thé worst pizza I've ever had. I ordered twice at this place. First was four cheeses kind of pizza. Actually it was only 2 cheese pizza. Cheep American type cheese and cheep mozzarella kind of... just plastic rubbish. Second time I ordered pizza margarita. I regret I didn't take a pic. There were some spots of dry tomato paste, just a paste. Not juicy sous, not, why to bother yourself to make some souse. My husband asked for Parmesan on top. "Parmesan" didn't look like Parmesan nether tasted like one. Rubbish ingredients won't make delicious food. Love yourself don't eat there read more

Tasty NYC Pizza and friendly. Good descent price. We went there while we were waiting for the Bus. Inside and Outside seating are available. It's old fashioned. bathroom is available for the customers. Open late. read more

Very Solid pizza. Plain cheese is the best. Great crust. Clean bathrooms. Friendly staff.

Stopped by for a slice after a years-long hiatus and their slices still hit the spot. Great specialty slice selection as well. Glad the pizza is as good as I remembered. read more

We were just walking Central Park and around the area. Found pizza Pete's and decided to give it a try! So far this has been our favorite slice of pizza while in NYC. Pizza was thin and crispy, perfect amount of sauce and cheese! We were able to eat outside, wasn't too cold! It was but two slices get a drink for free. It cost $8 total You really can't beat that! Super good. Would definitely recommend. read more

Pizza Pete's - Pepperoni & Sausage/Pepperoni pizza - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

This place is totally a dive. They literally had 3 or 4 small tables inside and 2 tables outside. They did have a lot of foot traffic for take out. There were a bunch of high school kids hanging out and eating having a good time. Which to me means that the food must be good. So we decided to eat here. We checked out all the pizza that they had to offer. They did offer many different delicious looking pies. I ordered a plain cheese slices, white pizza slice and their buffalo chicken slice. Their buffalo chicken slice which was surprisingly in a very good way delicious. It was a bit spicy which took me off guard with just the right amount of buffalo sauce topped with a lot of breaded chicken. Definitely a slice I would recommend if you like buffalo chicken. Their plain cheese slices was pretty tasty with the right amount of sauce, cheese plus their crust was light and crunchy. Their white pizza to me was a bit bland. For a no frills pizzaeria this place was really a good find. read more

See all

Definitely lovin' Pizza Pete's. A friend introduced me to it and now it's the only Pizza shop I want to visit. If you go expecting some lavish or beautiful restaurant, this isn't your place. However, if you go wanting to get a really good pie then give them a shot. Their special pizza with veggies and sausage is super tasty. My son loves their cheese pizza. Everything has a really good flavor. And the prices are good. $24 for the large special. The guys who work there are super nice, too. read more

The grandma slice was very good but the Buffalo chicken slice wasn't that great. I could have overlooked not enjoying the Buffalo since and maybe gone to 4 stars if it wasn't for the rude little guy who works the counter. read more

Pizza Pete's - Buffalo chicken and grandma slices - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

I've been in nyc for 3 months, this is the best pizza. The correct amount of sauce. Perfect bake. 6 veggie slice options that are all great. Thank you. Keep on keeping on. read more

Great staff--friendly, welcoming atmosphere. Nice assortment of pizza by the slice, too. Especially fond of their 'meatball' pizza (often called lasagna pizza elsewhere) that has ground meat, ricotta and mozz. Chicken pizza (with cubes of regular breaded chicken or buffalo style) are also a favorite. Even their plain pizza is good. In the unlikely event that they don't have what you want already made and you're willing to wait a bit, they can turn a plain slice into whatever suits your fancy. read more

Ordered a large cheese pie. Got home to find that the pie was reheated. It wasn't made fresh. It was burnt on the bottom from the reheat. Not happy read more

Great little place with one of the best fresh mozzarella and basil pizza in the city.

I'm updating my review of this place. It was a 4 and now I'm giving it a 3. It's definitely still a good place if you want a quick bite and you're in the area; their service is fast & friendly and when their slices are fresh they taste great. But lately their selection hasn't been very fresh. With the exception of maybe one type of pizza at any given moment, everything else looks like it's been sitting out for a long time. I do come a little later in the evening, like around 7 or 8pm sometimes, but, in my opinion, that's not really an excuse. I've never came for lunch, so I cannot speak to that end. read more

Pizza Pete's - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Great slices! Crispy bottom, tasty, non-oily cheese and a lightly sweet, well seasoned sauce. The quintessential NY-style slice. Decently priced at $5 for 2 plain with a drink. Will definitely be back. By the way, there was actually a Pizza Pete, but he's long gone apparently. read more

Pizza Pete's - yay pizza - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

Pizza Pete's is long in the tooth, not particularly friendly, somewhat scuzzy, totally devoid of frills, slightly overpriced and absolutely delicious. In other words, it's the quintessential New York slice joint. I've been coming here for years and can totally see why some people would write brutal takedowns of this spot. Try as I might, I can't totally ignore that Pizza Pete's is kind of filthy and that its prices are kind of high, given that the slices aren't very filling and certainly aren't sporting artisanal ingredients. But I end up at four stars because the slices -- the remarkably thin, super-crisp, eminently foldable slices -- are positively textbook and easily in the upper echelon of old-school NY slices. That's saying something, and it's well worth overlooking some rough edges, imo. read more

Pizza Pete's - Textbook NY slice: Ultra-thin, crisp, foldable, delicious. - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

See all

GREAT pizza!!! None better on the Upper West Side. It comes fast, and it never disappoints!

Great local pizzeria. Nice pies. Thin crust. Ordered twice in a day, lunch and dinner. Plenty of varieties. Good value.

Good NY pizza by the slice with an authentic neighborhood hole in the wall feel. Lots of delicious options to choose from. The guys working here are great. Always greeted by a smile. read more

Pizza Pete's isn't just a great pizzeria, it - genuinely- might just be the most criminally underrated pizza spot in American culinary history. The fact that I have never seen it mentioned - anywhere - on any list of New York pizza spots - when what Pizza Pete's is doing comes out so *visibly* different from what you would get at *any* other pizzeria in Manhattan - to me - is completely crazy. read more

Fairly average slice. Tried it bc it was near where I was -- and wanted to test it against neighborhood mediocrity

A very good slice. Much better than the other spot down the block, but with less space to sit. Just a cozy hole-in-the-wall for housing a legit NY slice read more

Not bad. I was hungry and someone recommended it. I liked the base of the pizza, easy to eat. But not as cheesy as I imagine New York pizza to be. If you need a quick fix that you can eat with one hand on the go, this is a good pizza. read more

Pizza Pete's - Slice of the buffalo chicken - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

Small restaurant, I always take out! Or eat outside! I like their pizza very much! Delivery is usually prompt! They forgot something for my order last time! I won't hold it against them! read more

My favorite white pizza in the neighborhood by far! Crust is perfect and staff is awesome.

Just tried the chicken roll and fresh mozzarella pie. Very good Pete...keep it up and you'll be my go to pizza place. Chicken roll was very soft with cubed breaded chicken, mozzarella and ricotta. Fresh mozzarella pie was better than most. read more

It was reasonably priced for its location with 1 topping being $3.75. I had the broccoli pizza and was somewhat dissatisfied. The broccoli wasn't crunchy, but the cheese was lacking. read more

The bathroom door was blocked by a tall heavy trash can. Upon requesting the shop attendant to move it, he yelled " you remove it". I requested him again and he didn't give a fuck. Thee were three attendant guys in the near empty shop,and they all just stood and watched. The pizza was below average. The shop unclean. read more

Pizza Pete's - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

I ordered a pizza pie on the slice app. After waiting over an hour the slice customer service tells me the pizza was delivered according to restaurant. IT WAS NEVER DELIVERED. No refund. straight up stole my money. should've know better. place is disgusting inside. beware. read more

I had some time to kill while hanging in the Upper West Side and was feeling for some quick pizza. Low and behold, I open my trusty Yelp app and Pizza Pete's popped up as the highest rated spot in the area. Located on Columbus Ave between 85th and 86th is where you'll find this small pizzeria. Looking at this place from the outside, it looks pretty much like a hole in the wall pizza joint. The decor is close to non-existent, and there are a couple tables scattered here and there. Nonetheless, it can't hurt to try right? As far as their pizza goes, I did like the fact that their slices weren't overly salty. The pizza crust and sauce weren't very memorable, as I don't remember how tasty they were, but it wasn't horrible enough for me to remember that fact either. Price-wise, a plain slice costs $2.75, and a one topping will run you $3.50. I ended up opting for a plain slice and a Hawaiian. The best part? Buy 2 slices get a free soda. If you do decide to dine here, there is a TV that usually has ESPN going on. Pizza Pete's. Not a bad spot if you're around the block. I could see myself eating here from time to time if I were to live close by. However I wouldn't be traveling here to eat from downtown Manhattan. read more

Pizza Pete's - $2.75 plain. $3.50 one topping. - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

This place sets the standard for NYC style pies, on the UWS. That's according to the experts (my 6.5 year old and 39 year old boys), who now measure every other pie they try against the Pizza Pete's standard, including our old, NYC-style West Village favorites like John's Pizzeria, Joe's Pizza and Bleecker St. We like that the ingredients are low brow. There's a time and place for fancy pizza with Buffalo mozzarella, San Marzano tomatoes, Caputo flour, bresaola, etc., etc., etc.... And then there's a time and place for Pizza Pete's. It's like how you need both quinoa and fried Oreos in your life. (You do.) The folks here are gruff, but kind. Yes, the place has a slightly grungy / sticky feel if you choose to eat in. But delivery is fast, friendly and delicious if you'd rather eat out. I'm proud to say we are still alive and kicking after eating several hundred of these pies. So you have it on good authority that Pizza Pete's is sanitary(ish). read more

Stopped in due to location off Google Maps. Small place. Friendly staff. Generous amount of toppings on the slices from what I could see. Both slices I had did not flop when held. Dough is cooked right. Not undercooked or burnt. Im sure if you wanted warmed up more for extra crispy. You could ask for it. Not chewy or doughy. Nice amount of salt flavor on cheese slice with sweet tomato sauce. Nice crunch to the crust. Nice cheese pull when you bite into the slice. No crazy amount of orange oil grease dropping into your palm. Clean slice. A good all around pizza joint. This is a place to pick up few slices and walk with. read more

Pizza Pete's - Sausage Pizza and Plain Slice - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

Great neighborhood pizza! Lots of competition but they hold there own. Great service for pickup. Pizza is always ready and tastes great. Best consistency of pizza. read more