While walking in the area, noticed this unusual pizza spot which was very busy on a Saturday afternoon so after debating about where to eat decided on giving them a try. First thing I noticed is the style of the pizza, which is an enlongated square or a flatbread style. The space is not that big but has several tables, and a bathroom which is always a plus when eating at a pizza establishment, many do not have restrooms. After some thought I decided on the calabrese pizza and my mom had the pepperoni. I wanted to try something different than my normal margherita/original style pizza. The sauce, cheese and crust on this pizza is delicious. Love the thinness of the square and how it flaked when taking a bit. The staff is friendly and they greet you in Italian, that was a nice surprise. The space was kept semi-clean, i guess it's hard when you have limited staff and many patrons visiting constantly. Will definitely visit again and try a different square pizza. read more

Pizza Collective - Pepperoni Pizza and Calabrese Pizza - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Gave this pizza spot a try as the toppings served here sounded unique. For slices, it appears that you get two square pieces, which makes sense for the price they are charging. I got the Carbonara Slice ($7), which consisted of aged mozzarella, egg yolk, guanciale, pecorino cheese, and black pepper. No tomato sauce so it was very different from what I was used to, but enjoyed it. The guy that was at the counter that served me was not very friendly and was very off-putting. He tried rushing me for an order. When I told him I wasn't ready, he proceeded to just look at this phone. Seemed like he was filling in for someone that asked for a bathroom break as that guy emerged and looked a bit friendlier. So deduction in stars for that. read more

Pizza Collective - Display Case - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

See all

I went to this unique pizza place with an almost factory-like aesthetic a while ago. Compared to some others, this isn't typical NYC pizza, being more Roman-style pizza al taglio, as it's cut more in a rectangle instead of a square. You can also find similar at My Pie Pizza Roma in Midtown East/my neighborhood, and like there, the crust is slightly thicker than a typical NYC slice and has a nice crunch to it. Along with pizza, they also sell custom pasta, sandwiches, and salads, with a notable number of vegan slices. The prices might seem a bit higher than the typical place, but they give a much larger portion. I was a bit unaware of this, so I got two, and this happened to be a very filling meal. The first was the Plain Cheese for $4.50, with aged mozzarella cheese and fresh tomato sauce. Due to the cheese selection, this was a bit less salty than other places, which I liked. For the sauce, it was bright and tasty, though I have preferred some other spots. It was good. My preference of the two was the more expensive slice, the $7 Emiliana, with aged mozzarella cheese, imported mortadella, pistachio cream, burrata cheese, and basil. This felt like more of a rich and indulgent slice due to the burrata and mortadella. Also, the unique nuttiness from the pistachio cream worked surprisingly well. While I usually don't like white slices, the various toppings more than made up for the lack of sauce, and this was easily one of my favorite white slices I have had. This is a tasty and unique slice shop. Would go back and try more. read more

See all

Actually really liked the build your own pasta. The meatballs and cacio e Pepe was great and the vegetables were fresh. It is actually made to order so it took a bit of time. But it also stayed piping hot during my walk home of about 15 minutes which was impressive. read more

Pizza Collective - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

There's a whole separate vegan pizza menu! And you can split flavors on one pizza, perfect if your is I've like me! I got pepperoni, plain and buffalo chicken read more

Pizza Collective - Vegan pizza - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

Thank you thank you Pizza Collective for having gluten free pizza dough AND vegan cheese. I really appreciate that because it's somehow hard to find both. Now, can you please train your staff better, and have gf and df pizza slices available? Because it requires quite the patience to order the pizza and then to wait for it. And then it costs a fortune, of course. But I do it! Because it's definitely one of the better gf/df pizzas I've found. So I'll be back. But I'm still praying that one day, ONE DAY, I'll walk in and there will be a section for all of us gf/df folks, and there are a lot of us! In fact, it took me a long time to even walk in because I didn't realize you even had options for me. read more

See all

Amazing deal on too good to go. Love their bbq chicken pizza. My friend loves the vegan options and goes every time she's in town

I love this pizza! I'm so grateful that they have vegan gluten free pizza and that it actually tastes great. Their non gluten free vegan pizza is amazing too. read more

I was here with my friend to grab a quick bite after watching a movie in the evening. The pizza was good, the staff were nice. I liked the decor of the place, but it was a bit busy with customers in terms of not being able to form a line to order & trying to find a place to sit read more

Pizza Collective - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Can you be transported to Rome with one bite? YES. Gabriele and the team are cranking out delicious pizzas and Italian classics here. You can come in for something you know or branch out and try a unique flavor like cacio pepe. The vegan options are elite, and honestly cannot be beat. Service is friendly and quick. Ambiance is laid back for being so close to the craziness of the city. read more

Pizza Collective - Vegan options are crazy!!!!! :) - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

Delicious pizza with high quality and fresh ingredients. How do I know? I can tell just by the taste and smell. This kind of pizza makes me a proud New Yorker. They serve quickly and have great energetic music that doesn't let you get tired. read more

Pizza Collective - Margarita and Pepperoni Slices - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

I love that I can get a slice of pizza and a soda for under $10, and although they have a lot of fancy toppings I don't always go for. they always have pepperoni, and they don't skimp on it either! For a place that is inexpensive, they have decent seating and you can people (watch on Broadway. I have only been there for lunch but it's never been loud or crowded . I have been there a few times and the service has always been courteous and prompt. I only get a chance to eat out in the area a couple of times a month. If I had a complaint, it's that I want to try more places, but I probably won't unless the next time I am in the area, I just really, REALLY don't want pizza! And I always want pizza... read more

Weak pizza, rude staff. Pizza burned without apology or replacement. Music too loud, otherwise ok ambiance. read more

Pizza Collective - Burnt pizza - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

Found a very large black hair on my pizza that was clearly not mine nor anyone I was with. This is not pleasant to have in your mouth. The guy behind the counter gave me a very weak apology, no refund nor offered a replacement slice. Not a way to treat a repeat customer. I will be taking my business elsewhere. read more

I tried three different slices, and two were just really rich and bland, and the other was just bland and I needed to eat another meal. I guess I just don't like anything about this pizza. Very oily and heavy; very salty and bland. And dry. At least their pink boxes are cute! read more

My husband and I were in the area for a show at the Beacon Theater and looking for a late dinner- Pizza Collective came to the rescue! The place is fast casual but the taste/quality is proper casual/hip Italian- your eyes will be delighted by the selection of pizzas. Note, these aren't the round style slides, but square kind, so its a rectangular pizza. We got slices of the Calabrese ($6), Chicken BBQ ($5.50) and the Emiliana ($7, along with two beers ($7 each). They heated them up for us, so the crust was nice and crispy and with gooey cheese- delicious! The Emiliana featured mortadella, pistachio cream and burrata, and was fantastic. My husband was super happy with his two slices as well. I saw that they have many vegan options and pastas as well! I need to find some more reasons to head up to the UWS so I can try their octopus pizza and cremini mushroom pizza next. read more

See all

I have working in the 70s on the UWS for several years and never saw this place until today. I ordered a calabrese. He stuck in oven for over 5 mins and it came out cut in 4 pieces. I had the honey on the side, but it turned out hot pepper wasn't the only thing it needed: the honey added a great touch. And a diet Dr Pepper hit the spot. Nice guy behind the counter, relatively quiet on Sunday @ 530p, and I very much enjoyed the slice. read more

Pizza Collective - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

See all

3.6. Not great service. They were focused on what was on tv. And the air was not working. It was hot. They burnt the edges of my pizza slice and smoke was coming out of the oven. Wanted to rate 3.5. What is good is that is right down the street from the movie theatre. read more

Pizza Collective - Burnt pizza slice. - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

The pizza here is actually surprisingly good despite not being New York style pizza. This pizza is a square deep dish style. However, the bread is not completely dense like deep dish. This is a little airier and reminds me more of focaccia. They have a Margherita pizza, however this is nowhere near what you expect. This one has a thick layer of cheese covering the top. I personally really enjoyed the taste of this, I just think it was more appropriately named cheese pizza as there was also just a very little amount of basil. The fungi pizza was also really good. If you love mushrooms, this has a ton of great umami flavor baked into the slice. Prices of pizzas are fairly standard for a lot of the upper-end slice joints (around $5-6 each). Staff are pretty friendly and bring the pizza to your table after you order it. Overall a pretty good experience with pretty good pizza. read more

See all

Walking by, the smell of pizza wafted across the sidewalk. It hooked me in. Very visually appealing display of thick crusted pizzas with terrific toppings. I opted for a margarita slice. The crust was thick but bubbled with strands of well-formed gluten. Crisp, chewy, well-fermented crust. Zesty and tomatoey sauce with oregano. Great quality mozzarella and flecks of fresh basil. If it is not your present style of pizza, try it. It might well become your future style of pizza. Nice sized slice, too! read more

Pizza Collective - Margarita slice with a nice char. - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

I can't believe the internet hasn't made this pizza go viral ? I can't believe there aren't lines around the block. I guess I'm lucky. This is incredible pizza !!!! Like seriously one of the best pepperoni slices I've had in New York. Served by a real charming Italian. This pizza wins the UWS pizza competition. And that includes Mama Toos. read more

Not my favorite pizza I've had in New York, but I did like the crust. I ordered three slices ($16) and they were absolutely massive. Two is more than enough for a filling meal. I tried the Parmigiana, the Chicken BBQ, and the Sofisticata. The Parmigiana was my favorite and the closest to "normal" pizza, but I thought the sauce was too sweet for my liking. The barbecue sauce on the chicken pizza wasn't my favorite either, but the amount of chicken was ample. The sofisticata was definitely the most unusual with toasted walnuts and Gorgonzola cheese, and I'm glad I tried it, but I wouldn't order it again. I also got a tiramisu which was pretty tasty and served in an actual glass container which I was surprised about. My delivery came earlier than expected and was still hot despite it being a freezing cold day outside, so the overall delivery experience was a positive one. Unfortunately I wouldn't return, but glad I tried it. read more

4.5 / 5.0 - When I first came here soon after it opened in 2020, the slices were not as large. I hadn't been since, so I was surprised to see that nearly 2 years later, the slices are larger now. You can order individual slices (starting from $4.50+) or a pie, and 1 slice is the size of 2 squares. So a half-pie is 3 slices (6 squares) and a full pie comes with 6 slices (12 squares). Last night, I tried: - Margherita: Fresh organic tomato sauce, fresh mozzarella cheese, basil - Pepperoni: Fresh organic tomato sauce, fresh mozzarella cheese, pepperoni - Crostino Zucchini: Fresh mozzarella cheese, organic zucchini squash and ground black pepper - Italiana (without prosciutto): Organic cherry tomatoes, organic arugula What I love about Pizza Collective is that they use fresh, organic ingredients. The crust wasn't my favorite (too hard on the outside and too airy inside), but the tomato sauce and fresh toppings were absolutely delicious. They close quite early (9pm), but it's a great option for lunch or a pizza party. read more

Pizza Collective - Margherita and Italiana (May 2020) - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Pizza Collective was just average for me. The ingredients seemed fresh, but I think the ratio of sauce and dough to toppings was too high -- it hid the flavor of the toppings. Couple that with the pizza being cooked a little too long, and it just wasn't amazing. But the inside of the store is clean, modern, and has a small seating area. You can also order pasta and sandwiches. read more

Pizza was pretty mid. I had the parmigiana ($4.50) which has eggplant on it. Tomato sauce was bland and the entire pizza was just pretty forgettable. I did appreciate the worker cutting my slice in half without me asking, which made it easier to eat. read more

Pizza Collective - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

Wasn't expecting a couple italian boys behind the counter. It's a small spot, 5 little 4 seater tables outside, maybe seats for 15 inside. The pizza is all square, more like Italian pizza than NY style, I guess. I liked it, I'd come back. Worth a visit for a snack if you're across the street, for sure! The service is fast like a pizza joint, but the quality is like a restaurant or a fancy coffee shop. read more

Pizza Collective - Spinach & Cheese Risotto Rice Ball - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

I came at around 9, essentially just when they were closing up to pick up a too good to go order. I've had my eye on this place all throughout the pandemic and was so glad to be able to go with the app perks. Unfortunately, I gotta say the employee was sour faced and brusque. I imagine it was a long day and she was exhausted (and it was basically almost closing time and there were still customers eating) but she openly displayed it which made it very uncomfortable. I got a couple of slices and I'll admit because it was my first time I did take a little time which seemed to only add to her frustrations (again don't blame her) but when she gave me the pizza box it really just felt like she was throwing it at me to get out lol. Pizza was good! I've been wanting Roman style pizza since I come home from Italy in 2019 and was so glad to have the opportunity to try it again. It didn't take me back at all but it was definitely a different take to what I had in Rome. I was so amazed by how bouncy and soft the dough was with all the pockets within. The flavor assortment is tons of fun too and even at that late hour there were plenty of options to choose from. I'd probably come back despite the employee's coldness (but solely because of too good to go). If I were paying full price I would never step foot in the door again even though the pizza was good. read more

Pizza Collective - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Would recommend for (1) a family where people want different flavors (2) a party (3) a casual meal (4) people who love bites of different pies and want to try various flavors Pizza is true NY thick crust pizza. The slices are quite doughy and the toppings were fresh and flavorful. The mushroom (crostini funghi) was ok (would have benefited from some extra ricotta in my opinion), the Margherita was good. I could not taste the honey on the Calabrese (with Soppressata), but that was probably my favorite. The tricolore was also good, as the tomatoes were fresh. I enjoyed having the option to chose different flavors on one pizza, and trying various combos and a little of each. Great concept. read more

Pizza Collective - Pizza to-go - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Know for the unique pairings - pizza was a quick and just okay. Would much rather go to another place but good to try read more

Pizza Collective - Mushroom - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

The pizza smelled and tasted like oven / whatever they cooked it on . I had to brush my teeth to get the taste out read more

Pizza Collective - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

Based on my delivery experience, Food came on time, I ordered a Coke Zero, received Diet Coke. Ordered half pie with 3 slices, only 1 of the slices I ordered was in the box, other two must have been replacements for the ones they ran out of. I would have appreciated if someone had called and said we are out of these things, can you choose something else? But no, they just filled the order with other things thinking I wouldn't care, but I do. Pizza was just ok, good ingredients but too soft and thick, doesn't travel well in delivery. it will be a while before I even think of trying again. read more

Fantastic pizza. Everything was perfect, texture, flavor, quality of ingredients. Definitely coming back read more

Pizza Collective - Calabrese - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

amazing service !! Danilo and Junior are the best , helping me to get the proper pizza ! best place ! read more

The crust is unusual, but I dig it. The sourdough crust is tangy, springy, and well-toasted on the bottom. It holds up well to the barrage of high-quality ingredients piled atop. The portions are bigger than you'd expect, with each "slice" easily cut in half for what feels like a full slice on its own. -Tricolor: globs of fresh mozz, surprisingly fresh cherry tomatoes in the dead of winter, and basil. Great. -Pepperoni: so many slices of pepperoni which packed a good amount of heat. Almost (but not quite) like the famed Prince St pizza square. This place stands in stark contrast to the typical NYC slice with its paper-thin crisp crust and balance of sauce and low-moisture mozz. Also, please enjoy their completely bat-crap insane website, pizza-collective.com which looks straight outta the 1990s. read more

Pizza Collective - $33 for six slices. Calabrese, Parmigiana, Tricolor, Carbonara, Sofisticata, Chicken BBQ. - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

My friends and I were craving a solid pizza so we happened to come across this place on the Google. Definitely exceeded our expectations and were impressed with the vegan options! My favorite was the parmigiana which had veggies, pesto, topped with cheese. The portion sizes are decently large, I was pretty full from 2 slices. I definitely expect to be back when I'm craving pizza again! read more

Pizza Collective - Right side, top down - Brooklyna, Margherita Pizza, Parmigiana Pizza - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

I love this pizza. Eggplant or white or whatever other types they have are so good. And their crust with the right amount of oil is so rich and scrumptious. You can smell this dough cooking from far away and honestly just perfect pizza dough. Not thin or deep crust - but in the middle read more

After seeing a post of this pizza spot on Instagram I had to check it out. A Roman style pizza joint is definitely something unique. I went here in the afternoon and this place has a steady flow of people coming and going with a solid out door seating set up. After looking at all the slices I decided on the marg and funghi slices to split with my veggie lady. The slices had a soft crispy bottom and the bread had a fluffy airiness to it. Both slices were delicious with a flavor that popped. These slices were unlike anything I have ever had before and highly suggest it. This is a destination pizza spot and if you live in the area you need to check this place out. Getting a tray of this pizza would also be perfect for dinner party with friends. I'm short: - Awesome Roman Style Pizza - Destination Pizza Spot - Great pizza to bring for a dinner party as it looks cool and taste amazing - I'll be back read more

See all

Great authentic Italian pizza. Try the cacio & pepe if you never had it. Mushroom and the zucchine pizza are great too. Staff is attentive to your requests and mostly Italian which is always a great addition. read more

Stumbled upon this place while walking around basically because of the delicious smells wafting out. Takeaway w outdoor sidewalk seating / delivery, and genuine Italian taste. Love they even say "prego " (you're welcome in Italian) if you say thanks :) My husband and I are avid cyclists and are carb aficionados and studied / Married in Italy. Highly recommend! read more

See all

Pizza was good but service could have been better...and it was for take out. I ordered ahead for pick up. I arrive and the guy at the register grabs my order places it off to the side to ring me up but stops to help someone else suddenly. No "excuse me for a moment" or anything so I'm just left waiting. When he does come back to ring it up, I pay and he walks without passing my order. I have to reach over to get it. Not asking for white glove service to get pizza but a little civility would be nice. Like they're doing me the favor of having me spend my money on them. I'll think twice before ordering from them again on that reason alone. read more