First time visiting. We were just walking by and the pizza looked great and it was. We tried a special thin pizza. Super crisp. Very tasty and fresh. The Fresh zeppoli station is a must. We did Carmel and Nutella stuffed. Highly recommended as an indulgence Place was clean Staff is friendly read more

See all

I had a mixed experience here. The pizza itself was decent not the best I've had, but still enjoyable, especially when ordered fresh. The inside of the shop is also really nice, and they have a great variety of options. The staff was friendly and welcoming, which I appreciated. Unfortunately, the desserts were disappointing. The red velvet cake had an unusual smell and didn't taste fresh, so we ended up throwing it away. The cheesecake also seemed a bit stale. I'd definitely come back for the pizza, but I would skip the desserts. It might be worth revisiting the freshness of the cakes or limiting those options so customers have a better experience overall. read more

See all

Their grandma slices are insane the bruschetta, chicken, cutlet, chipotle divine their big Mac slice grandma divine the white slice outstanding. Also their house made Zeppoli yes. read more

See all

I haven't been able to frequent here as much as I'd like but was so happy to be able to order from here today. I got a medium pie for my family and I. Everyone loved it! Everyone in this pizzeria is lovely, consistently. I didn't call ahead, I walked in to place my order and was in and out within 20 minutes. Love it here! read more

See all

This place has a wide selection of different pizzas and other Italian dishes. They even have gelato and different desert options. There's plenty of seats and benches to sit comfortably. I loved their regular slice in addition to their Sicilian slice. I lived the crispness of their slice which had a good blend of cheese and sauce. Their Sicilian slice was well spiced and was actually quite light and fluffy. I gotta go back and try their other slice varieties. read more

Pizza One - Regular and Sicilian slice - Pizza Near Me - Scarsdale, New York

Westchester can never have more than enough pizza joints! One of my friends recommended we meet here on a Monday night for a slice, and I'm so glad we went! My friend ordered the Big Mac slice and I ordered a mushroom. They have a lot of pizza options plus other Italian handheld delights. I will have to return to try the others! We were full so we didn't have dessert but I would definitely also try the gelato. read more

Pizza One - Big Mac Pizza and mushroom slice - Pizza Near Me - Scarsdale, New York

Ordered pizza on 3/30/26 The pizza I ordered was not what I ordered, they need to update there website if they are gonna add what they want to the pizza I didn't ordered Chipotle sauce on pizza, so I had to waste my my money and throw the pizza in the trash, this is the 3rd time they messed up my order, never again There are better pizza places around and I definitely will never order from this place read more

I have celiac disease and Pizza One has the BEST cauliflower pizza. There is quite a lot of variety if you eat gluten. Nice staff - nice environment - delicious food. read more

Great place with lots of selections. Sauce is on the sweater side but not overly sweet. Save room for dessert! Galato!! read more

The inside of this restaurant looked amazing inside. The owner was very nice. I decided to get the beef patty and the eggplant sandwich. The beef patty tasted good . On the other hand the eggplant tasted good too but it was missing something. Also I would have liked another piece of eggplant on the sandwich not just only one. Other then that the pizzeria place was a good spot to come and get lunch. read more

See all

Picked up pizza the other day was good nothing great I could go back for something else.

A nice find with a good selection of pizza slices. Friendly service and good desserts .

We really wanted to try a place with a variety of slice options and decided to check this place out. The inside is really nice and has a modern vibe; even the plates inside were really nice! They had a great variety and the food for the most part was pretty decent. I got the Sicilian slice with no moz (a very exciting find since I can't eat moz) but it really lacked flavor for me. We didn't get any marinara with our knots so they were quite dry. Otherwise it was pretty good. I'd try it again with different choices and see if it's better. read more

See all

This is a very nicely decorated small pizzeria with a great selection. The Big Mac pizza is delicious with crisp crust. The marsala pizza was also delicious. They have quite a few amazing desserts also which are homemade including zeppoles stuffed with caramel and drizzled with assorted choc and toppings. Gelato was fantastic too. They should so very well considering how good the food is and great selection. read more

See all

Real good, and stop buy often for their pizza. In addition, we have had several meals delivered to us and with gelato to enjoy for dessert--my wife and kids were happy. read more

Pizza was perfect and wings were nice crispy juicy inside. Service was excellent and the place very well decorated and clean. First time here and definitely will go back. read more

Excellent high quality pizza. They need to invest in an AC though. Gets super hot in there!

Ordered the X-large buffalo chicken pizza and an order of chicken fingers appetizer. The pizza was good. It had a very thin crust, so if you had leftover and heated it the next day, it got a bit chewy, and the crust on the end got very hard. The 5 chicken fingers were over cooked. They were quite dry and not tender at all. The container of sauce that came with it helped a bit, but was not enough for all 5...and one tender was half the size of the other four. Would not order this again. read more

Pizza One - Slice of the buffalo chicken pizza from PizzaOne. - Pizza Near Me - Scarsdale, New York

In terms of basic pizza, this is on the higher end. It's tasty and there are a lot of options. For me, what set Pizza One apart is they have much more seating than pizza places like this usually have (at least 30 seats). They also have a restroom. read more

I stopped in on a recommendation from a group I follow called Westchester Foodies and someone offered their opinion on it and it was a positive one so I decided to try it. BIG MAC slice was awesome and their plain slice was good. Try their specialty slices. All of them look tasty and appetizing. read more

First, the staff were super friendly and professional. Second the pizza was very good. I had the Margarita slice and it was thin enough ( not as thin as Patsy's on 1st ave 118th st) but good enough. The slice was a decent size and the sitting area was clean and comfortable. My wife and I stumbled upon this place when shopping in the Asian market next door. We think we found our new pizza place read more

A $20.00 Gorgenzola salad was very small and had hardly any Gorgenzola cheese. Truly a waste of money!

Outstanding pizza selection with many "alternative" slices to match any palate. Was also able to indulge in a chicken cutlet garlic knot. The service was fantastic and prices are reasonable. Give it a shot. read more

Ordered and ready right on time! Only one who would make eggplant rollatini gluten free. My GF friend said it was delicious and saved me making a second dinner! Will try other stuff there in the future. read more

Lots of options including mini garlic knot sandwiches with a variety of pizza. A lot of staff hanging around. Mushroom spinach pizza was bland. Everything was ready made and needed heating up. Some things including zeppole needed extra time to reheat. Seating was comfortable. Good for quick snack but wouldn't come for dinner. read more

Large selection of flatbread pizzas which were not very appealing to taste. When I went to pay first with cash and then changed to my credit card I noticed the charge jump . Without warning patrons they add a fee when paying with a credit card. The atmosphere is nice but for a simple slice the little dumpy Venetian is much better. read more

Tried this place today for the first time based on so many great reviews this place gets. I don't get the hype. It is beautiful inside and very clean. There is a wide variety of specialty slices as well. The prosciutto and arugula slice was the best of the bunch and came with a side of glaze to drizzle on top. But the chicken scarpiello and veggie slices were not great. The veggie had a little spinach and a couple slivers of onion and peppers but that's it. The garlic knots were very burned and dry and the chicken fingers were extremely dry as well. Got a large thin crust pizza and it was average. I have had much better (Roma's and Gemelli) and much worse at other pizzerias. The service at the counter was fine. I am glad I checked the bag when I got to the car because they forgot my garlic knots and I had to go back inside for them. Wasn't horrible but definitely will not go out of my way to go back. read more

Great food! Pizza is great and the service is very attentive and friendly. Plus they have amazing decor, lots of comfy seats! Definitely give this place a try and give them a friendly welcome to the neighborhood read more

Rated a 4. Pizza is okay but would not go out of my way to eat it again . Sauce is ah. Wings were not crispy and were covered in sauce.