Hadn't been here in a few years until recently. You order slices at the counter, and they are ready fairly quickly while they warm them up. I got their pepperoni slice, and we also tried their ham and pineapple slice. The pizzas are good, but I think there are better local pizza shops. I tried their cinnamon roll pizza, which was delicious! That took a bit longer to be ready, but it still tastes delicious reheated. There is plenty of parking and seating available. The staff were all friendly and service was quick. read more

Pizza My Heart - Pizza Near Me - Capitola, California

See all

Great friendly helpful staff, good food for thr family, and nice seating area with sports. Easy access location with easy parking. A go to for a easy quick lunch meal for family when in thr area. read more

Free Pizza? On a Monday night after the Thanksgiving weekend, my local my handed me a free slice suggesting that it was too small to charge. After tipping generously (of course!), I chewed down what must have been my 1-thousanth slice. Now I'm not so naive to claim Pizza my Heart is equal or better than most NY pizza.., or am I? It's consistently the best pizza in my backyard and I'm a NYC transplant with Ray's Pizza roots. In fact, my wife and I met for lunch dates on the regular at Ray's midtown and she agrees - Pizza my Heart is a taste of home and our Big Apple based LVE to this day. read more

Pizza My Heart - All gone! - Pizza Near Me - Capitola, California

Huge parking lot If it's packed it's worth waiting ! One of the best pizza places I've been to. Foods authentic They have shareable snack, chicken wings 12 chicken wings 24 chicken wings breadsticks Kook ie. cinna-bomb Signature pizzas with me the vegetarian favorite vegan pie Handcraft slices the prices are great anywhere from 5.99 to 6.99 They have California farm salads Everything is fresh. They have a soda machine and it has the real amazing best root beer. !! Don't get the turd if you see that it's packed with people sitting down and there's nowhere to sit people get up and go and you should be able to get seating. It is super packed every time I drove by during my stay down here. Staff seems happy to be working here and they're quick and efficient They have beer on tap and a few tvs with the game not huge but you can see the game. read more

See all

Great pizza, fresh ingredients, and really friendly service. The place is always clean and welcoming, and you can tell they care about doing things right. Definitely a spot I'recommend you check out. read more

Aptos is really lacking in the pizza department, so I'm glad we have PMH now! I got the chicken bacon one and manresa today. Yum! both were a perfect mix of flavors and textures, elevated far above other chain pizza spots. The staff is always so sweet too. Their slices remind me of summers growing up here in SC. I definitely recommend, if not for the memories, for the awesome eats at a good price. P.S. you have to try dipping in ranch and their other sauces! read more

Pizza My Heart - Pizza Near Me - Capitola, California

This piece of my heart is a solid four stars. Friendly service, good selection shirts, and they heat up the pizza slices to perfection. Also has a nice local beer selection and large seating area. read more

Pizza My Heart - Pizza Near Me - Capitola, California

See all

My son was eating a slice and thought a hair was in his food.. Turns out it was a RUBBER BAND. I understand these things happen however this was a 5 year old child that could've easily chocked, please make sure your staff is more aware as this is a huge health concern! read more

Pizza My Heart - Pizza Near Me - Capitola, California

Food is Very good. They sell pizza by the slice with cool t shirts. Very friendly staff. great atmosphere. read more

Pizza My Heart - To go box and T shirt - Pizza Near Me - Capitola, California

Pizza was good except it was a bit oily and the crust was soggy from all of the oil as well. Flavor was good and toppings generous. read more

Pizza My Heart - Big Sur Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Capitola, California

Great pizza! I have been to this location a few times. It is fast , efficient, and fun. Try it out

New pizza in town!!! I have been a fan of the awesome staff, fun attitudes, and delicious pizzas for a very long time!!! This family run business is supportive of the community and ad a teacher I can't say enough good things about taking my students here for a field trip! Pizza Mike and the staff always go above and beyond, and it is always my students favorite field trip of the year hands down!!! "Pizza my heart is the best pizza" a quote from a 4 year old on our trip! And I concur!!! Thank you pizza my heart read more

This seems to be the spot to go after games or whatever occasions. They've got great salads to go with a slice and the coke machine that has all those flavors. Even during midweek expect it to be busy till around 7 pm. You can order online not only for takeout but to eat in, which I did recently. The pizzas were ready exactly on time and we were able to sit outside at the tables. read more

Love this place I get it every time I come to Santa Cruz!it's just some good pizza and the merch is iconic and cute and the slice with a tee or stickers is a totally good deal!it's a got-to-try kind of place. read more

Delicious! Perfectly cooked thin crust pizza!!! I don't know how they are able to achieve such thin crispy crust without it being soggy, it's witchery! It's order at the counter with no seating or tables, but it's practically on the beach so no big deal! Fast service. A+++++ read more

Pizza My Heart - Pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - Capitola, California

See all

The young man that helped me was patient, helpful and friendly. He helped me choose this slice and it was one of the best pizzas I've had. And I got a shirt. All for around $10 read more

Pizza My Heart - Manresa? - Pizza Near Me - Capitola, California

I don't go out for "fast food" to often, but Pizza My Heart is one that is always on my friends and my list. The 41st has a big parking lot, usually crowded but almost never completely full. There are set pizzas or you can make your own. They have freshly made pies that you can order a slice of two, wings, salads, desserts and drinks. A cousin from NY said the pizza is the closes to "Old School New York" pizza you could get out here. read more

Our favorite pizza spot in Capitola and the Santa Cruz area. The crust is thin, the sauce is fantastic, and always made to order. The cheese pizza is a must and all you need. They also have a variety of pre-made pizzas that you can order slices of. They have a wide variety of pizzas that also include vegetarian. They have about five options of fresh salads with different dressings. The chicken walnut salad is fantastic with Mixed Baby Greens, Candied Walnuts, Chicken, and Gorgonzola with their Balsamic Dressing. The place seems clean every time we go, and the staff is always friendly and helpful. We went for dinner the night of and then again the next day. I also ordered a pizza to take home with us. It was soon a good leftover and was a pleasant surprise for the hubby, who wasn't able to make the trip but also loves their pizza! My mouth is watering typing out this post! read more

Pizza My Heart - Large Cheese Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Capitola, California

I'm so grateful that they use Miyoko's vegan cheese and that they offer vegan pizza options! So few places do this. Thank you thank you!

Fatima gave me excellent service!!!! She helped me out over the phone and I appreciate her kindness. She handled the situation and I will be back again! Really happy she works here because she knows what she is doing and is an asset to this team. See you again! read more

Terrible service. Burned our pizza because the kids that work there were too busy talking to each other and hanging out. The cashier that was helping us was very rude. Everyone that worked there doesn't seem to care. Terrible customer service. Dont waste your time and go to the other locations. read more

Best pizza and service. They are always busy but attend in a timely manner. I've ordered to eat there and take out and they're attentive. My go to pizza in Capitola read more

The overall experience was decent. The lady who took our order seemed like she was annoyed. But I get it. Lots of foot traffic in the Capitola area so maybe she was exhausted. Who knows? Aside from that, my family and I ordered a large box to go and a few slices on the side. The slices were good! We enjoyed the Big Sur and the Maui Wowie. Worth trying out if you're in town. read more

Just got a cold pizza delivered in a box that looked like it had been stomped by an elephant! Driver doesn't need to speak English, but he does need to be able to follow Google Maps! Unacceptable! Shame on you! read more

Mike taught me everything I need to know about how to make the best pizza and it's true, their pizza is the best. A large pesto is my favorite! read more

Who doesn't love getting pizza!? Best part, the original pizza my heart in Capitola is pretty cool!!! There's plenty of street parking. You can order your pizza and walk to the beach to eat it. There's no seating inside the restaurant but it's worth getting since their pizza is always so delicious! We also joint their logo T-shirts for less than 10 bucks as a souvenir! The service was quick and the people who worked there were happy! It's a fun stop to eat pizza! read more

See all

We enjoyed a Togo pizza and a lovely salad yesterday. Hubs was excited by a grabbing a t-shirt and pepperoni slice Togo.

My boyfriend and I decided to go here right before they closed this past Saturday. Amazing service! Loved how spacious it was inside. Got our slices quickly and they were perfect to end our Saturday night. No complaints here. 10/10. read more

Pizza My Heart - Pizza Near Me - Capitola, California

This is some of the best new tour style pizza around. Slices are heated in the oven to order. Service is fast and friendly. Ranch is free and the root beer is cold. If you are craving pizza in Santa Cruz this place is great! Would recommend, would return . read more

I don't know what happened to PMH but serving old slices that taste like they are a day old is just unacceptable. This pizza is not fresh. Not sure what else can be said about it. read more

Pizza My Heart - If I wanted pizza that flops like this, I'd buy it and warm it up in my oven tomorrow - Pizza Near Me - Capitola, California

Easily my favorite pizza eating establishment in the great city of Capitola- it's always delicious and a fun hang. The blonde girl seems to be running the show! I saw her serve customers, refill lid/ napkin stations, replace trash bags, answer phones, and all that within a 25 second time span! She was working extra hard to make the overall ambiance in the restaurant enjoyable for everyone and I just want you yelpers to appreciate that. Calvin out. read more

Inexpensive and good pizza. We had the classic pepperoni pizza. What more could you ask for? A true South Bay classic!

My family ordered takeout. The have an efficient and friendly ordering and pickup process. The interior has fun surf-oriented memorabilia that livens up an ordinary strip mall storefront. I felt pretty disappointed by the pizza. It was undercooked and soggy. I enjoyed the spicy sauce but otherwise, this is squarely subpar pizza. read more

This store is amazing and so sweet! The food is excellent and the whole team is just great. My daughter ordered online and she almost had her food stolen by the door dasher but when she called to report it the manager and staff were going to personally redeliver the order. Love and would recommend this place the pizza was flavorful and having caring people handle your meal means you can trust them to deliver every which way. read more

It was a place you could take the kids after the soccer game but still find something interesting if you have a more sophisticated palette. The manager was very accommodating of my wife's request. It fills exactly the market they are trying to. read more

If you're a pizza lover, you have to try Pizza My Heart - it's nothing short of amazing! Mike truly knows how to create an epic pie. From the perfect crispy crust to the mouthwatering toppings and fresh ingredients, every bite is a flavor explosion. Whether you're a fan of classic combinations or looking to try something unique, PMG has got you covered. You can taste the passion and skill in every slice. Hands down, the best pizza around! read more

The pizza was pretty tasty for someone that doesn't like pizza. We also got wings, definitely not worth the cost,breadsticks were meh too. The service was awesome and I love the location to the water. I'd go here again but I'd limit it to pizza and salad only. I love the decor as I'm a huge fan of the water and surfing community. read more

We had a class trip here today. It was incredible. Mike, dude man, was so wonderful with the large mass of kindergarteners. He also had some great jokes for the parents. This location is extremely clean, front house and back. The food is always delicious. Fort point and Big Sur are my favorite. Don't skip on the ranch. FIVE stars from the whole family. Thank you pizza my heart for caring so much about our community, we love you. read more

Pizza My Heart - Making personal pizzas - Pizza Near Me - Capitola, California

With all the barely three-star reviews in capitola, I was excited to see a pizza my heart. And I'm glad I tried them out. I've eaten at Pizza My heart in other locations, and this one did not disappoint. The pesto cheese pizza is fantastic. Even the plain cheese pizza is excellent. The service could not be friendlier. Prices are a bit high, but it's well worth it. Dining room is large and clean. Employees seem to love their jobs. I walked, but if you drive there is plenty of parking. read more

Pizza My Heart - Pesto cheese - Pizza Near Me - Capitola, California

Pretty good for pizza in California. The pesto pizza is on point. Friendly staff, would definitely go back.