Pizza was surprising good, with just the right amount of char on the crust. Only wish we had ordered one to go for late night!

Our food was full of flavor, the customer service was excellent, and the ambiance, they get a big thumbs up.

Their food is great and the waitress there Arianna is amazing and so kind. The atmosphere is nice and welcoming. Tables are good and seating is good also. If there is a wait , you should wait. It's worth it. read more

Combination restaurant and bottle shop. Very casual atmosphere with great food! White Pie

We were searching for a quick bite in between parades. The location was about the only thing I found to be good. It was pretty crowded on a Saturday afternoon, seemed promising that locals approve. We ordered quickly as we were on a time limit. 2 slices of cheese pizza for me, a slice for my granddaughter and hubs got an Italian sub. It took over 45 min to get our food. Ok, they were busy so can forgive the delay, but the pizza was flavorless. Like zero. Would have been better off with frozen. 2 stars cuz hubs did enjoy his sub but fries he got came out cold and soggy. Pizza Amore in wf is much better choice! read more

The food is good but the atmosphere leaves a bit to be desired. Service is average but very nice folks. It's really convenient for folks in the Redwood community but a little out of the way for others. Overall it's pretty good for pizza and sandwiches! read more

We have yet to have anything bad from here! Typically we just call in our order for dinner and go pick it up. The actual restaurant is always packed, so that tells you something right there! It is definitely a go to for locals, but don't be shy if you're passing through or searching for something new to try out this way. A must order is the chicken alfredo; it does not disappoint...in taste or portion size!! Not a dish for those looking to watch their waistbands. If you're a little more conscious of that, there is always the antipasto salad. It's got roasted red peppers, olives, and carrots in addition to the meat spread you typically see...mmmmmm!! I'm determined before we move from the area to try one of everything on the menu, so I'll update my review if anything catches my eye even more than those two. read more

I was forced to return here last evening for a family get together, and with the same results. Soggy/greasy pizza mia special and heartburn/indigestion all night. No more do-overs for me in this place, I think the next time I'm told "We're getting together with... ... at Pizza Mia" I'll just tell my bride I'm skipping it and I'll deal with the family fallout later. Beer selection was sparse at best, all the watery (but for some reason popular) standards are on the menu - so I ordered a Heineken - "Sorry, we don't carry that any more." Maybe a menu update is in order. read more

Nice people.....that's about it. Apparently salt doesn't exist in the kitchen. Food has no flavor. Philly cheesesteak tasted like a lettuce wrap. (Also, don't put lettuce and tomato on a cheesesteak.) I've had the pizza before too....also not great. Everything here is flavorless. Being in a small town, the staff knows everyone. So don't expect fast service. Boyfriends and friends are more important than a customer standing at the door apparently. One girl hardly left her boyfriend (I'm assuming) the whole time I was there. Kitchen was also in no hurry. Took 30 mins to make a salad and a sandwich. All in all, go to Arby's or Wendy's down the road. Or the Chinese place beside the grocery store read more

If you are looking for some kickass food prepared and served by friendly, good humored people, you can't go wrong with this little tucked away gem of a restaurant. It is one that I meet with friends at often and it is delish every time. My personal suggestion is the turkey sub, the fries are my favorite. read more

Decided to try this place between parades in Creedmore & Butner and thought since it was packed that it'd be a good place to try. Unfortunately, because it was so busy it took forever to get our food and when we got it, my fries weren't even hot, they were luke warm at best. My wife's pizza had little to no flavor. On the plus side, the server was very good and my sandwich was real good. Would I try this place again....not too sure yet, we'll see. read more

We have been eating there for the past 6 years and never had a bad experience until today. 19.99 for a eggplant rollatini and this sorry excuse for a 8.00 capris salad. No lettuce and hardly any of the ingredients that it's stated in their menu. read more

Pizza Mia - Italian Near Me - Durham, North Carolina

So in a small town like Creedmoor, people are eager for the opportunity to enjoy a new restaurant. Unfortunately, Pizza Mia's name wasn't the only thing that lacked originality. Pizza Mia's decor, immediately is able to be identified as a Andy's fast food crossbreed, but if only it tasted as good. After the first time I visited Pizza Mia I said I wasn't impressed and decided not to go back, but once my wife was close to her due date and knowing Pizza Mia had Jalapeno Poppers on the menu, we decided to give them a second try. I must say both times the fried jalapenos were great, but not 6 bucks great. My sweet tea glass stayed empty for close to 15 minutes during the main course which made it impossible to eat my calzone that was served hot, the temperature of hell hot. My wife ate a few bites of her eggplant something another, got a box for it, and it wasted away in the freezer. My wife doesn't let restaurant left overs go bad... ever. read more

This is by far the best pizza we've had since moving to NC. The crust is delicious--I'd highly recommend the white pie. Friendly service, great prices. This is our new go-to pizza joint. read more

Great pizza Square and thick is our preference, but they also have a thinner round version. Delicious ceasar salad. Friendly staff! read more

Pizza Mia - Delicious - Italian Near Me - Durham, North Carolina

Great food, great service.. and honesty. Our vehicle was damaged by one of the umbrellas placed in a table outside the store. We were inside eating and one of the employees came up to us and asked if that was our vehicle and that he thought he did something stupid. Turns out he had placed an umbrella in a patio table and when he walked away the wind caught it, lifted it up into the air and slammed it through the windshield of our car parked in the nearest parking space. Not only did they come right to us and tell us about it, they offered up insurance, contact information and paid for every single penny of the repairs voluntarily. Such honesty and ability to stand for what is right / do the right thing.. is so rare nowadays. Our vehicle was fixed and we continue to be customers of this restaurant as not only is the food and service great.. but the staff have proven themselves to be absolutely outstanding as well. They really represent the best of the Creedmoor area. Rosario... you are awesome. read more

Stopped by Pizza Mia in Creedmoor, NC for lunch. On the menu is salads, sandwiches, calzones, strombolis, pasta dishes and of course pizza. Lots of indoor seating available. On this visit I ordered the veggie sub which has eggplant, onions, mushrooms, olives, broccoli, lettuce, tomato and provolone cheese on Italian bread for $5.95. I also had the small Cesar salad. The salad was decent, but the sub is not worth ordering again. But I will be back to try the pizza in the future. Food C Staff B Decor B Location (ample parking if you can find Pizza Mia) (going towards Food Lion) Health Inspection n/a read more

This pizza is amazing. I with you guys could come back to Creedmoor to teach Rino's how to make pizza sauce that doesn't taste like spaghettiO's read more

My wife and I try to hit NYC at least once a year, and one of the first things we do after getting settled in to our hotel room is find a 'hole-in-the-wall' pizza joint. There's something about NY pizza, hard to explain. Maybe it's not for everyone, but it is for me. Pizza Mia captures that same taste and feeling in their restaurant. And it should - that's where the owner is from! For fun, order a large calzone and everyone at the table will laugh when it comes. The size is really funny. Go ahead and ask for a take-home box - you'll never finish it all there. It's easily large enough for two meals! The service is really good, highly attentive, and the atmosphere inside is almost family-like. read more

Craving wood fired oven pizza & came across this Gem. Loved the design of everything from menus to the bathrooms. Ordered Margarita Pizza & Honey Habenero Wings. Friggin delicious. Our server John was super friendly & helpful. Super job Pizza Mia..please keep it up!! read more

Pizza Mia - Italian Near Me - Durham, North Carolina

The food has always been good and quick. I've never been during their busier times but love their pizza, wings, and the Philly cheesesteak is great! read more

Ordered lunch from here to go while in the area. I ordered a caesar salad with banana peppers and kalamata olives. WOW, they put so much of the peppers and olives I was digging through trying to find the lettuce. It also had way way too much dressing on it. All in all not a very good salad. I also ordered the fried jalapenos which were pretty much what you would expect, very greasy but they were good. I would consider going back to try their pizza etc since that is what their main food is but wouldn't get a salad again. read more

This is the best place in town to eat . We love the owners and the food is fantastic. If you are looking a good sit down restaurant this is it . read more

We go here frequently, and always order the same thing. I get buffalo wings and he gets a Stromboli. We recently decided to switch it up and order a ravioli plate, we thought that we'd be able to share with the baby. When I brought the plate home, there were five little ravioli swimming in a puddle of cheese sauce. I went back to the restaurant and asked if there had been a mistake, since the plate cost $12. The woman behind the counter told me there was no mistake. I asked her if the ravioli were really $2 per. She told me once I start eating it it's worth it. I asked if I could speak to a manager and she said said I could not. She told me it's very filling and next time maybe I should order two kids meals (which would have been less pasta for more money). Very disappointed in the food order, but especially disappointed in the attitude this woman gave. read more

Surprisingly good pizza for creedmoor. I've had their pizza pies and individual slices. All very good. Cheese is good and they don't skimp. Crust is slightly soggy just the way I like it. I'm sure you can order it more crispy, but I love it exactly the way it comes out! Very much the way traditional NY pizza is made. I also really enjoy their salads. I've had the antipasti salad and Caesar Salad, both were good. I usually order here about 1-2/month. I've had their subs only the chicken & eggplant Parms......wouldn't order either again. Eggplant was not fresh and sub was mushy. Chicken parm was a bit too salty and sub was mushy. Too. I'm always greeted nicely when I go and interior is always clean. But I usually take out. Haven't tried anything other than items described, but I am a repeat customer for their salads & pizza. read more

This place used to be good. The past 4 times I've gotten food i was less than impressed. The only thing that has ever been good was the pizza but now a days i got a 50/50 chance of that being any good. One reviewer likened the other food they serve to cafeteria food... couldnt put it better my self. Not to mention the service sucks. read more

Facts...... Caprese Salad 6.99 Tomatoes, fresh mozzarella & fresh basil with roasted red peppers, olives, balsamic vinegar & olive oil on a BED of green leaf lettuce * bed of lettuce is typically a LAYER not a handful or pile. Eggplant Rollatini Eggplant lightly breaded & fried; layered with ham, provolone & ricotta; rolled & baked in tomato sauce & mozzarella 10.99 http://pizzamiacreedmoor.com/menu.html read more

A town favorite!! We love coming here for a slice of pizza and a Caesar salad!! Great service and awesome owners!

Good food and service! Would recommend the jalapeño bottle caps and Margherita pizza. food came fast and servers were attentive.

Their food is delicious. The staff is always friendly and they take care of you. I love eating at Pizza Mia. Try the lasagna. Great.

Pizza Mia is the bomb. Chicken philly is great but all the food is good. Friendly service off exit 191 creedmoor give them a try

I love this place! The pizza is thin and tasty, I also love their chicken Philly and their fettuccine chicken Alfredo. All their food is good. I'd choose them over the other big chains anyday read more

Probably some of the best calzones I've had. Great simple restaurant, but a nice variety of subs, sandwiches, and Italian eats. They have a couple different cold bottles in the cooler if you're into that. And no matter your feelings of triteness, they give a 10% discount on Sundays with your church bulletin. Great place. read more

There's a small bar to sit and enjoy a slice and a beer, and the tables are roomy in the well lit and well windowed dining room. The open kitchen lets you see the fantastic staff working their magic. The dough in the pizzas and strombolis is fresh, the sauce is bright and not overly sweet or spiced, the mozzarella is heaped on and the toppings are amazing. The black olives on the Pizza Mia special taste like kalamatas, and are a decadent, briny addition that I highly recommend. The salads are crisp, and the fresh mozzarella and tomato side is to die for. Couldn't ask for a better family pizza restaurant like you grew up going to before PizzaHutDominosJohns took over the market. Get out of the house, put the remote down and enjoy a nice family dinner for a change! read more

Excellent New York style pies. The slices are premade and reheated but a whole pie has pretty good quality.

Got the Sicilian Hawiian. Wonderful and full of cheese and ham. Smells so good while they bake it up! Wasn't planning to get pizza but couldn't resist and do glad I got it! read more

This location is closed on a Monday during lunch hour. Terrible ratings, plus a waste of time. Won't be back to try again.

Pizza, wings, salads & subs are all good here! I have yet to bring someone here & us to have a bad experience. Service is great too!

Really good food. Their one healthy option is really tasty. Grilled chicken and veggies! Quick service and the owner is always available.

My Family has eaten at this restaurant on several occassions. Contrary to some of the other reviews in this site, we really like this place. Everything that I have tried thus far has been very good. Yes, it is a small town pizza joint, and yes it used to be an Andy's but hey, after all, this is the small hick town of Creedmoor NC. Don't let the other reviews scare you away. If you like it go back, if not, drive 20 miles out of the way for something else. read more