I've always liked Otto pizza. Although a bit pricey, I think buying a whole, FRESH pizza is worth…read moreit. I forget to take pictures before we dig in, but we enjoyed each type bought tonight. The only down sides: Butternut Squash pizza comes with black pepper on it (I, personally, hate black pepper, so I wish I knew beforehand). The Buffalo Chicken pizza was inconsistent with the amounts of chicken - 1 person got 2x as much chicken as the other.

The food is good here I guess and its crazy how they turned that breakfast egg place into a whole…read morebar and seating area, food is also okay. However... 21$ FOR A SMALL PIZZA AND A CAN OF DR. PEPPER IS ACTUAL PRICE GOUGING THE PEOPLE OF SANFORD. Owner of this place needs to get a grip, quit smoking cigarettes outside and realize that selling a 10$ slice of pizza should be illegal, its not like it costs more than 3$ to make one for crying out loud. This place is good like once a year at that price maybe.

Foto, Alec and the entire crew there work hard to make great food. Always so good to grab a pizza…read moreor sub, and I look forward to going back every time. (They sell gift certificates, too, which make for great gifts!) Thank you, SHOP!

I wanted to share some feedback about our recent delivery experience. We've always enjoyed your…read morepizza and have been loyal customers, which is why this situation was especially disappointing. When we placed our order, we asked for a price confirmation to make sure we had enough cash for delivery, since that's the only form of payment accepted. Because no one was able to reach us to confirm the price, the order was never prepared or sent out something we didn't realize at the time. My boyfriend waited by his phone for over two hours expecting a call that never came, and when he finally reached out to check on the order, the person who answered said she had tried calling multiple times. However, we never received any calls on our end. It was especially frustrating because we live just a couple of minutes down the road, and we had been looking forward to having your food for lunch. Instead, we ended up having to order elsewhere after waiting so long. At this point, we're unsure whether we want to continue supporting your business, which is disappointing given how much we've enjoyed your food in the past. We truly hope this feedback helps improve communication moving forward.

The best pizza around!! Friendly staff and bright, clean…read moresurroundings. Wonderful crispy crust and plentiful ingredients with a real Italian flair.

Fabulous! A wonderful friendly welcoming upon entering this casual small shop on a dark rainy night…read morein Sanford, Maine. 60 years and 3 generations later, this family is going strong. I ordered 2 cheese pizzas for my grandkids and a veggie to go for me. The crust is light a crispy, tomato sauce and topping just right. We'll be back!

Drove down from Portland to try Coletti's and we were NOT disappointed. Coletti's offers a…read moreNeapolitan style pizza - which is important to know. Very different from Greek, New York and New Haven style pizza. Deliciously different from what we usually get in Portland. We ordered online but ate in the restaurant. The service was very good, friendly and knowledgeable. We had the Margarita pie and the Sausage and Broccoli Rabe pie. My husband is a pizza snob and he LOVED the broccoli rabe pie. Both pizzas were cooked perfectly with generous amounts of cheese. The margarita pie had just the right amount of basil. But the star of the show for us was the sausage/broccoli pie! We had never had broccoli rabe on a pie before. The broccoli rabe was tender, well seasoned, and had a floral note to it, the crust was chewy with just the right amount of char and the sauce added just the right acidity. The only thing we felt was lacking (slightly) was the sausage. It was so mild that you almost couldn't taste it. It was cooked well and no gristle at all - just lacking that sausage flavor that you expect when you order sausage on your pizza. Regardless we would and WILL order it again. We will definitely be back and strongly recommend Coletti's if you are in the area. If Coletti's is looking to expand - please come to Portland!

The flavor of this highly talked-about pizza is bland. It's not sweet, thank goodness, although…read moresome folks like it, and it's not savory (garlic and tomato forward) this pie is neither, so like I said bland. Also, the shape is terrible - too thick and puffy on the outside and too thin and flimsy closer. It's impossible to pick up a slice. I was very excited due to the hype, but when it arrived we were disappointed.

Love the crust on the pizza whenever I go here and the best fries around, I would not say the best…read morepizza in Sanford but pretty close, small place but always kept clean. The service is always good.

Pizza has always been outstanding. Good choices on the menu, especially the cheeseburger pizza, a…read morefamily favorite. It would be nice to see it open up to indoor seating at some time, but they are killing it on take out.

Decided to finally check this place out after driving by this all the time. We were very impress…read morehow close and quick it was. The service was great! The food was delicious and has a generous serving, pizza was a little chewy but that's okay! We will order again!

Food freshly made and a great variety of pre-made salads, pizza slices, sandwiches and sides. Small…read moremarket items in store. Lots of outdoor seating with some picnic tables covered. Took less than 20 minutes to get freshly made food.

The place was hopping on a Friday night. This is one of the best pizza and sub shops we've been…read moretoo. They have an amazing selection of pizza in the "showcase" along with hot and cold subs and dinners too. Service was fast and friendly and the atmosphere was clean and inviting. The chicken parmigiana sub was tasty with the sauce just right, toasted italian sub perfect and hot & spicy chicken wings (though we wished that they weren't battered) they were still good. Their subs are 10" which was a lot of food for me, so I opted to eat just the chicken. (Note to self for the next trip). Highly recommend Seacoast Pizza and subs

They're still kicking it. Drove 24 miles R/T just to have their pizza and Italian. It's the best…read moreItalian I ever had and I can be an Italian sub snob. Ordered some desserts for us and friends who we know would love them. The limoncello marscopone cake is FANTASTIC! Of course, as usual, the zeppoles and cannolis are great! The staff are so incredibly friendly. Sorry for all the pics that do not have the entire amount of food. We kept forgetting to take pics before we took bites.

Love Otto's pizza. Recently had a miscommunication regarding delivery from Saco store and I…read moresubmitted a customer service email to let them know. Within 24 hours, the general manager reached me by phone to resolve. Very professional and very nice - it's one thing to make really good pizza but Otto's has world class customer service as well. Amazing group of people, great company, they care about here patrons.

Came in on a Monday right at 11 when they opened. Sat at the bar. Bartender was friendly and…read moreaccommodating. Wine was cold, but can't say that about the beer. Not warm! But not ice cold. We ordered a pepperoni, mushroom and olive pizza. Pepperoni was spicy and cheese pull was in full effect. Crust was thin and toppings out to the edge. Would go back again for sure.

Went in for dinner with my husband and daughter - let's start off with a couple highlights:…read more 1-waitress was friendly ! 2-drinks were good.hubs has MAINE BEER CO LUNCH & I had Punch drunk rum. Now on to the very super unfortunate things that happened tonight ... $138.00 Bill (which by the way I'm 100% ok with when it's good or even decent. I got dinner sized Cesar salad add shrimp (additional 8 dollars and I maybe had 3?) The salad was swimming in dressing to the point where my fork couldn't even stab the lettuce !! And almost slimy. Husband got the "Oh my pad Thai" this teeny tiny bowl of peanut butter slathered noodles left his tongue sticking to the roof of his mouth - literally tasted like a jar of natural peanut butter was opened and poured on. Daughter got chicken tender plate - mediocre at best lacked and only really lacked salt . So sad ... don't think what we ordered was hard to nail unfortunately we will never come back .

food is good, service kinda hit and miss, depends on the wait staff. Place needs better…read moremanagement. And don't clean tables with a rag you dtopped on the floor. nowhere but good things to come if they shape up the place. good beer and drink choices. some motorcycle tables can be loud and noisy.

Wow!!! Hubby and I…read morestopped here since we received a gift card and had been meaning to go. He made a reservation in advance We were seated promptly and greeted by a lovely server who took our orders. I had pizza and hubby got a pasta dish with meatballs. The pizza sauce was perfect! Not too sweet and the crust was perfection! The meatballs were obviously made with love and care Highly recommend and we will be back

Don't usually have a late night craving but I decided we needed a quick pie…read more Cartelli's made us a late night snack! Over all it was very good. The sauce was a little sweeter than I like but the crust was crispy and had a nice char. Gave the slight burned taste I love but not overpowering. The jalapeños were a little too chewy for some reason but overall this was a really great pizza! We've been inside before and the ambiance is okay but I prefer taking their pizzas home!