Hands down best pizza joint in Palmer. Quality food and quality service! Tried the Greek Hawaiian, this is probably our new favorite! Will be back soon read more

I just have to say I order from this place quite often and absolutely love it. Im never disappointed and everyone is so rad when I go in to pick up my pizza. Plus the delivery fella today was chill and patient so I could put the pup away. Thank you so much! read more

We love the pizza from this place! It's expensive, but worth it. We recommend the Greek pizza. We've only used pickup or delivery and it's been ready when they said it would be. They have a great menu and we will definitely dig into it sometime. read more

Love the pizza here. Excellence customer service. Just one little thing I wish they could've done better is to maybe season the crust with something. But overall I loved it. read more

Ordered lunch delivery for a work session and it was delivered on time and hot. Gyro and appetizer was good. Pizzas were also good with lots of toppings. (although the crust was bit chewy). The service was great and would definitely recommend them for work lunches based on the variety of items on the menu, timeliness, and quality. read more

Decided to give them a try as we were heading back to Eagle River from Hatcher Pass, and needed something for dinner. Customer service on the phone and when picking up was good. They have a fairly extensive menu with a good selection of specialty pies as well as the ability to build your own. Outside of pizza they also some appetizers and things like gyros & spanakopita. This is a strictly carry out or delivery establishment. There is no room to dine inside. We ordered the 18 inch Sicilian pizza. I like that their biggest size is 18 inches. Not many pizza places do pies that big around here. The pizza itself was meh. The ingredients on the Sicilian pizza includes basil and oregano so I was expecting fresh basil on my pizza, which was not the case. The pizza sauce was not that good--it had a very sour taste like they didn't do anything to cut the acidity. The dough was very thick and pretty undercooked in my opinion. It did have a good amount of toppings which we appreciated. But, without good sauce and crust as the base there's not much you can do to save the pizza. For the price you are better off going to Great Alaskan pizza company or one of the other chain pizza places. read more

Pizza Athena - The Sicilian to go - Pizza Near Me - Palmer, Alaska

See all

Man, we try to buy local and avoid chain restaurants. Unfortunately, once again this has kicked us in the butt. The breadsticks seem to be some type of loaf, cut into sticks. So bread flats with sesame seeds on top? Very strange combination, and quite salty. Our pizza was under cooked, almost white on the bottom side. There were no toppings on the outside 3-4 inches of the pie, so we got the medium toppings on a large I guess. The sauce has some bitter aftertaste, almost acidic. Generally, you cut the acid with heat, or a bit of sugar. Too much, and you get that sweet chain sauce. The sandwich another person at our house ordered, seemed to be good. They didn't complain. Overall, the 2 hour wait, the cost, and the quality, I wouldn't order again. What a bummer! read more

Food, good service, and clean environment ! My orders are always on time! And, the boyz are very polite!

Oh I wish I would have known about this place last summer when my grandkids where here ! One granddaughter is named Athena.. the point is You food is wonderful the best Pizza and oh I love the Fettuccine Alfredo with chicken . Salads are yummy . Oh I like everything I have eaten on your menu! We will continue to eat you delicious food ! Thank oh and the grandkids are coming back this summer ! read more

Visiting our daughters who live in Palmer and they highly recommended Pizza Athena and tonight we ordered an Athena Supreme pie and a Gluten Free/dairy free pie, using their handy "slice" app, had it delivered, and it was absolutely delicious. Fresh toppings. Well seasoned sauce. Attractive crust. And savory cheese. Well worth the 3,043 mile trip and 45 minute delivery time (faster than promised!). Do they deliver to Ohio? read more

It was a nice pizza, but not my style. It was doughy and they kind of skimped on the pepperoni. The sauce was just so so.

Sunday, 5 :30 pm. They delivered food in 40 minutes. The Gyro tasted rancid, and potato salad was bland. The pizza was lacking. So I called the Manager at Pizza Athena, saying that I appreciate the potato Salad was made locally instead of Costco Potato Salad, however it is very. bland. The manager said he'd give me a "Free Order Next Time". I said "No, I am hungry Now". I ate the underwhelming pizza, in the mean time. So lunch today was "Rancid Gyro with No Flavor Potato Salad. Pizza Athena is open 7 days per week. I want the manager, to taste from his kitchen "Gyro with potato Salad side", Lamb should not be rancid in nature. Add mustard or salt to the potato salad. read more

Great service even better pizza! Always are quick well priced go to for pizza. Pizza are an amazing size for the price.

Ok. I'll try to make this as short as I can. I live in Anchorage and my 86 year old father in law lives in Palmer in a little tiny house that my sister in law and her husband built for him on their property. There are a few other little houses and one big house on the same property. So there's quite a bit going on with equipment and all the usual things out in the valley. Well all my father in law wanted was a pizza delivered to his "little" house that's hidden on this property. I tried for hours trying to find a place that would deliver a yummy hot fresh pizza to him and I was just about to give up when I called And Malina answered at this place and she was soo sweet and totally said no problem took my order and my cc and I ordered and paid from Anchorage and she took care of the rest. Now it was not an easy delivery because it's a hard little house to find but their delivery man was soo nice he stayed on the phone with me until he found it. My father in law was so happy and the pizza was fantastic they said. Thank you again for going the extra effort for us. We really appreciate you. read more

Pizza Athena - Meat lovers with pineapple. - Pizza Near Me - Palmer, Alaska

I was not impressed at all! I ordered a Greek salad and half the ingredients were missing! The pizza was not good either. The service, management seemed unprepared and unprofessional! The quality of the ingredients could be better. read more

Pizza Athena - Greek Salad - Pizza Near Me - Palmer, Alaska

The pizza was so good. Every thing came out perfect, and was delivered on time. The Meatball Grinder

4 of us stopped by going to the Matanuska Glacier at about 9:30pm at night & we were hungry. After getting gas at the Fred Meyer, we doubled back to the pizza place. We split an extra large pizza - 2 slices each. Generous tasty mozzarella & sausages. We couldn't finish it. Berp! read more

Pizza Athena - Just before going into the oven - Pizza Near Me - Palmer, Alaska

See all

Don't order the Greek salad. It cost $14.50 and consisted of some less than fresh lettuce, a sprinkling of feta cheese, a smattering of red onion and cucumber, and 4 olives. Lame. The pizza was pretty good however albeit over priced. read more

We have eaten from most the pizza places out here in the Valley, this was one we had never tried. It is AMAZING! Not only was it one of the best pizza's I have in a while, the delivery was fast and the young man was so polite!!! read more

I hate to do this, but orders over time have been too inconsistent. Our last being yesterday. The pizza dough was so tough, it was inedible. Total waste of $50. read more

Pizza Athena - Garlic chicken ranch, w/o ranch. Red sauce substitute. - Pizza Near Me - Palmer, Alaska

I just love their pizza. I recommend it. I recommend the Gyro pizza in particular, same with the Calzone.

I have been ordering food to be delivered for years from Pizza Athena. Their pizzas are outstanding! They aren't fast, because they spend time to cook delicious food and deliver it in order. I usually call 2 hours ahead to get my meal delivered to my door, piping hot and yummy. What a treat!! I'm grateful to have this available, especially during this awful pandemic, when I've given up going to indoor restaurants. read more

Very bad food quality Don't ever get the "monster nacho" Literally juanitas with with a few sprinkles of cheese, and a couple slices of olives. Terrible took 2 hours for my food to get here. And I live 1 mile away. read more

This place looks like a dive off the road when you drive up. Thought we would go in anyway and try it out. Unfortunately the place is delivery or pick up only. I left and went to two other places but it's 90 degrees here this weekend and no one had air conditioners. So it seems not many places do have in Alaska and why would they it never gets hot enough . So I decided to call in my order and go back and wait for the "pizza surprise" seeing as they have had good yelp reviews. But let me tell you the pizza was spot on, money, grub gold , whatever you call it it's great. A must try if you like really good pizza. Try the gladiator it's fantastic read more

A perfect hole in the wall pizza joint. Take out or delivery only but if you're impatient they'll deliver it to you while you wait in the cozy comfort of your car in the parking lot. I had the bacon chicken ranch and it was magnificent! The perfect balance between the ingredients with plenty of onion and garlic. The small was enough for two. I'm just sad there isn't one in my hometown. I'd be a regular for sure. Oh, and friendly service too! read more

Pizza Athena YOU ARE A JOKE!!! You quoted 53 dollars including delivery, you charged debit card over 70! Your pizza is a one star at best compared to Locals which is even far less $$$!!!! Actually your pizza is almost all dough with very little toppings which I will add you refuse to substitute toppings, you only take toppings off!! Sammy your manager refused to make anything right according to him even saying they miss communicated!!! You will see NO MORE Business from US!!! YOU ARE A JOKE!!! read more

The pizza was disappointing. The ingredients were far from fresh, and the price was outrageous. Would not recommend and will not be going back. read more

1st time ordering, got the gladiator. Fresh and hot, delivery was neither fast nor slow, just right, I asked the delivery guy if it's good pizza and he goes "oh it's the best n the valley"! Pizza was the best I had in a long time will definitely order again! read more

Best pizza in the valley!! The closest to east coast pizza that you can get. I will for sure try other menu items!!!

This is the best pizza in Palmer in my opinion. Because I'm from NY, I prefer the thin, crispier crust and that's what they make. Always get my order right, always deliver it in a timely manner. My particular favorite is their white garlic chicken pizza. YUM! read more

staff was very friendly and the pizza looked great. The dough was nice but sauce was OK and the cheese must have been cheap version since the pizza was very greasy. The salad and garlic bread was great - big portion. I am not a local, so next time I would try somewhere else. read more

Long delivery times, but I only assume its because they're ALWAYS busy. I wasnt a huge fan of their pizza crust, but the pizzas were okay. I loved the Gyro. The fettucini sauce seems to split, which is unfortunate because the grease completely kills the flavor. However, I did get a seafood fettucini that was GREAT. I LOVE their salads, the greek salad is huge and they give you more than enough dressing and toppings. Everything is fresh. Dont expect quick delivery, but its worth the wait if you get the chef on a good night. read more

This place was awesome. Great pizza. It was quite busy when I went, so had to wait in the parking lot for a bit. But, in the end, it was worth it. Also would've been good to know that they don't take $100 bills. read more

Pizza Athena was recommended by a Close friend said it was the Best Pizza in the Valley and She was right. Pizza was Amazing service was Awsome. Ended up stopping by twice before I went home. Rich Milwaukie Oregon read more

Get the two topping medium special. This is not the best pizza I have EVER had but it is tasty and they are consistent. Been picking pizza up here for like 5 ish years? It is the same good tasting pizza every time. Their prices are reasonable and they are always very nice when you come pick up. read more

Always get great pizza from here! We get the bbq chicken ranch and it's delicious! The place is a small Like coffee stand type joint. I usually order to go. Prices are reasonable also. read more

We got married and had a really long day and wanted something on the way back to our lodge. We got two pizzas and WOW! Even with our 45 minute drive the pizza was amazing! We live on the East coast and there are pizza places everywhere but this place made top of our list. Plus really nice family! Happy we tried it out! read more

So disappointed. Really wanted to like this local business, especially since it serves Greek food, but it was very expensive for the lack of amount of food. We spent over $60 plus tip plus $12 to deliver. We ordered antipasta salad, gyro salad, spanakopita, and a medium pepperoni olive pizza. My husband did like his antipasta salad okay. The gyro meat and tzatziki on the salad tasted pretty good, but it was anemic for the price of $14, mostly iceberg lettuce. It would help if it came with feta cheese. I added my own feta to make it taste better and have more substance to it and that helped. The spanakopita tasted good, but was tiny - 4 small triangle wedges for $11! It was a dollar or more per bite. For the price, one large piece of spanakopita made in a sheet pan with a good amount of filling, thereby less phyllo would be much better. The pizza was the only thing that absolutely tasted awful. It is the first time I have ever actually been repulsed by red sauce that I can remember. It did not have very much cheese, barely any olives, and the pepperoni was not great either. Not fresh at all, maybe we got unlucky on that day. In the end, we were still slightly hungry and at $85 that is frustrating. $72 w/tip if we'd eaten in - still a lot to not be full and we are average eaters. The food is overall okay, but for that price at a decent restaurant we would have been full. Not coming back unfortunately, mainly because we did not like the pizza and it was so expensive. I will say their Greek dishes are much better than their pizza. If they could fix their pizza there would be nothing better than pizza with Greek salad. read more

Every time I call to make a delivery I get the worst tone and attitude. I always have to hang up because it's not worth my time or energy to feel bad for ordering a pizza .... read more

The peoples on the phone aren't that great, but the pizza is awesome but they do forget things a lot