I'm a city boy moving to the middletown area and been scoping out some food places and had a hankering for some good BBQ and I stumbled across pitchfork barbecue & biscuits off the side of the road in pine island. We tried the basics the fried chicken biscuit one with hot honey and one with maple mustard. First off the biscuit is flaky, buttery, but with enough strength to hold that big juicy crunchy piece of fried chicken. The flavor on the chicken was great along with the sauces such a perfect combo the hot honey is the perfect balance of heat and sweet and the maple mustard that tangy sweet combo either one is a great choice, I personally prefer it with the pickles for that nice acidic bite through the rich buttery biscuit. The St. Louis ribs we ordered a half rack and that more than enough for two people a very healthy portion. The ribs itself had the perfect amount of smoke and the rub a nice subtle peppery rub with a vinegary tangy sauce on the side to put at your leisure made a perfect contrast of flavors for the incredibly tender rib that fell off the bone with each tender bite. The staff are friendly and the scenery is lovely for a nice lunch with friendly staff and even friendlier prices Pitchfork BBQ and biscuits is definitely a must go I can't wait to go back to try their brisket which is a weekend only deal. They also offer pre order on their website the day before because apparently they do sell out. Head on down to pitchfork no fork necessary this is definitely a hands on kind of place. read more

See all

The food was plentiful, I had a pound of the pulled pork, so I would have left overs. My problem not enough sauce, 3 little medicine cup sized sauces, all different! When I got home I was able to doctor it so I had enough sauce. The service was welcoming and warm.. My spouse had the chicken sandwich and enjoyed it a lot. The ambiance was food truck with nice umbrella tables to eat at. read more

Every single item on their menu is phenomenal! Can never say enough good things about the brothers or their food. Always back!!

Best bbq in the area, hands down. Friendly folks, decent portions. Highly recommend the potato salad and baked beans. The brisket is phenomenal. If they have the burger, get it. I can't speak more highly of this place and I'm glad it's back open. read more

One of these days I'll show some pictures of the food here. It's just so good that I eat it before I think about taking pictures. The two chefs that run this truck are some talented individuals putting out some unbelievable food. The biscuits are unlike any I've ever tasted, pure heaven. Everything here is scratch made and you can taste the difference. The pickled onions and home made pickles add a dimension to the ribs that just makes you happy. I can drink the sauces (as I have done) because they are perfectly balanced and flavorful. They're at their location from Thursday through Sunday each week and certainly gives me something to look forward to. read more

Great biscuits! Awesome service. Amazing view. Country eats at its finest. Caught between wanting to tell everyone how amazing this place is, or keep it as a gem to ourselves. read more

Pitchfork Barbecue - Thick cut country bacon, farm fresh eggs, cheese and homemade fluffy biscuit...good enough to write home about. - Food Trucks Near Me - Pine Island, New York

This was a serendipitous find. Found this gem on our way back from a hike at STAIRWAY TO HEAVEN. It was heaven for sure! Food was GREAT &. Service was PHENOMENAL. read more

Pitchfork Barbecue - Brisket sandwich w. a side of potato salad. ...it was the - Food Trucks Near Me - Pine Island, New York

These guys had epic breakfast sandwiches. We need them back next year. World class bbq

If there was an option 10 Stars I'd be at 11! Best biscuits I ever had in my life! I've been at some world renowned places in the south hat are known for their biscuits and Pitchfork takes the prize! We stopped for breakfast yesterday and I had the chicken biscuit added cheese and an egg with the hot honey... Wow! Amazing even the simple things are to die for....My daughter had a biscuit with honey butter and jam. The sausage gravy was incredible. Keep doing what you guys are doing! I'll be back today for more! read more

I'm not one to say, "oh my God" when I eat something but there is no way not to. It's seriously one of the best food trucks in the Hudson Valley and defined the best BBQ. read more

Decided on bbq and pitchfork was on my list to visit. For an food truck it was busy. Had an decent line. Ordered fried chicken sandwich half rack and half chicken with potato salad, biscuit, and sweet tea. Ribs were good came off the bone nicely. The chicken was not thrilled about with the white bbq sauce. Big biscuit good. Not a sweet tea drinker but would buy again. Potato salad was ok. I'm more of a little sweeter potato salad. In all I'll go back to try the other menu items. Good after you go for walk on the stairway to heaven. Sweet tea and ribs sounds good. read more

See all

Got up early enough on a Saturday to get breakfast and, let me tell you - The egg, sausage biscuit is EPIC. Perfect, slightly gooey, bright orange-yolked egg, just the right amount of sausage and that biscuit...should be illegal it's so good. Such. Good. Food!! Note: They only serve breakfast weekends starting at 9AM read more

This is a hidden gem in Pine Island. It's located on the street next to where the old Jolly Onion used to be. It seems like the menu varies depending on the day, and you have to come early because the food sells out. I had the half chicken and it was excellent, along with a homemade biscuit and jam. There is a nice lawn in the front and a few shady trees, so you can bring a blanket and sit down and eat. If you are in the area, you have to stop by! read more

Pitchfork Barbecue - Grassy area out front - Food Trucks Near Me - Pine Island, New York

See all

Amazing food with amazing views. Wonderful customer service. Sets a new bar for food trucks! read more

Found our new go to spot for BBQ, yay!!! The fried chicken is amazing, ribs are perfectly seasoned, and the salads, so tasty. It's a must try, if you're in the area. read more

See all

Good Lord. Why didn't I try this place earlier. Where do I start? You pull up to a meadow in the most idyllic farm-like setting with picnic tables and a set up that screams rustic America. Country music on the Marshall speaker, huge smoker / barbecue thing on the back, and greetings from the people you're about to fall in love with. I ordered the Brisket sandwich with potato salad. The presentation alone tells you this place is special. Not rushed, although it was ready quickly, and not overdone with fru fru garnishes, although it looked like a meal ready for film. First bite I knew it was the best barbecue I've had since moving here 3 years ago. Juicy, quality meat with sauce on the side. I killed it in about 2 minutes. Potato rolls give it a sweetness before you even consider the flavor in the sauce. Potato salad was chunky with no overbearing additives. I always fear anything that should be served cold might not be great right before closing but I got there about 30 minutes to 4pm and the salad was cold, brisket hot, and roll fresh. Oh yeah, since I'm a savage I also got the chicken biscuit. I asked the young lady to pick the sauce and she picked hot honey. While I was waiting the gentleman offered me a couple of ribs to sample which should be illegal because handing me food is considered entrapment. It worked, I will be having the ribs next time. Back to the chicken, I almost cried. You can tell the biscuit is homemade and was bigger than I thought it would be. Chicken was quality and crispy. Washed it all down with two sweet Iced Teas which you must try. Bottom line, these are personable and friendly local business owners. Exactly what you want to support. The food choices are unique and well proportioned. Thank me when you go and odds are I'll be there so buy me a sweet tea! read more

I couldn't believe how extremely delicious and welcoming this place was. We had ribs, pulled pork sandwich with their exquisite little blueberry biscuits - amazing. They have mac and cheese too, which was made from scratch, from shell pasta. I LOVED ALL OF IT! They have a great open space for seating and if you have kids, they can run along or teens can lay down the grass (get some sun), or perhaps just sit under the umbrella area for some shade but all in all WOW, great place to spend time and eat, a perfect quaint spot!!! I am also SUPER HAPPY that they had a banana pudding:) one of my favorite puddings done (again) perfectly. My personal favorite were the ribs and that pulled pork sandwich, I want to eat it allover again. Hospitality was FRIENDLY and they were very welcoming. I'm definitely coming back sometime soon. I love this food truck cafe style open service with GREAT taste & happy to see friendly people around:) spread the word, WE HAVE A RIB & PULLED PORK winner here! (THEY HAVE NICE CHICKEN TOO, I saw it, next order will be those big WINGS) read more

Pitchfork Barbecue - Pulled Pork Sandwich - Food Trucks Near Me - Pine Island, New York

The best ribs I've ever had. They absolutely deserve all the praise and the humble surroundings just added to the whole experience. Already looking forward to the next trip back. read more

Some of the best BBQ I've ever had. Get there early because the line seems to be consistent until they sell out. Highly recommend.

This place is all time. I've had barbecue all over America and this is just as good as any place I've ever been. The chicken wings are the best bbq wings you will ever eat hands down. Great for a quick bite that won't ever disappoint. I've gone on my day off every week for a month straight. read more

Wow. Just looking for a quick lunch and stopped here. The fried chicken on a biscuit (with hot honey) was outstanding. Super friendly and great service, with some nice shaded picnic tables. Definitely will be back with friends!! read more

Stellar! It's all I can say... I had the pulled pork and coleslaw sandwich. Simply stellar! Can't wait to run through the whole menu with you guys!! read more

I will drive up from the city just to eat here. The food is magical.

The best pulled pork sandwich I have ever had. Good golly, It's dangerous having this food truck down the road from us. (But we are so glad it's there! It's the bomb) the prices are really good for the fantastic quality you get. My husband and I love their bbq sauce too! read more

Outstanding breakfast sandwich- great combo of flaky biscuit, gooey egg and cheese, and crisp sausage. Can't wait to go back and try the bbq. Also very friendly proprietors! Give them a shot! read more

Pitchfork Barbecue and Biscuits has mouth-watering pulled pork, delicious ribs, unbelievable brisket, freshly made biscuits, and phenomenal banana pudding that will keep you coming back for more. The portions are big and everything is made to perfection. Lauren and John do a wonderful job with their food truck and deserve the highest recognition and praise for providing the best barbecue you'll ever have! You don't want to miss this! read more

Perfect bbq place for a post hike meal. Like a small oasis in a vast desert. The biscuit with honey is to die for. Staff are super sweet and polite. I live an hour away but would come back just for this place. read more

AMAZING! The food and service are both awesome! The buttermilk fried chicken biscuit sandwich is my favorite! However, everything they have is SO good!! The homemade biscuits with jam or their breakfast sandwiches on the biscuits are a perfect way to start the weekend. All of the food is perfectly cooked and accompanied by homemade sides/additions like pickles, slaw, pickled onions, etc. Make sure you don't wait too long to go, the food is known to sell out before the end of the day. (It's that tasty!) I can't say enough good things about Pitchfork BBQ! read more

The Mac and cheese! The chicken maple sandwich (I think that's what it's called) is my favorite. The wings are massive and deliciously sweet and savory. The prices are reasonable, the sides are super large, enough to share for two. I also love how super clean and organize the truck is. This place is consistent and never disappoints! read more

Awesome food & Awesome place to have a picnic. We brought our own chairs w/ a small table. Came from NJ to have a barbecue lunch. It was a nice ride up on a beautiful day. Planning on going back & bring others for another barbecue lunch. No worries on social distancing w/ordering & setting up on the grounds! Best in Barbecue!! read more

The chicken biscuit sandwich is ridiculous...not sure what the best part of it was the chicken or the biscuit - both could stand on their own read more

I love off the beaten path food trucks and restaurants and seek them out when I can! This place surpassed every expectation and then some. Incredible biscuits, pulled pork and sides including potato salad that was perfectly balanced, mac and cheese and cole slaw. They will be at Warwick Valley Winery through October and I can't wait to eat there again. Owners are incredibly friendly and awesome. Try the chicken on a biscuit too. They sold out of ribs today (we were there sort of late) so I'll try them next time! read more

The food at this truck is excellent. I've stopped by during visits to the nearby park with my toddler. Whether you're in the mood for barbecue or breakfast, you won't be disappointed by anything they serve! read more

The best ribs I've ever had. And the humble surroundings just add to the experience. Absolutely deserve all the praise and more. Looking forward to my next trip back. read more

Go there now!!!!!!!! Without a doubt the best wings, pork sandwich and ribs I've ever had! I'm still working my way through the menu. I can't wait to keep trying new things. I truly hope their business takes off. The food is great and you can tell the owners are genuinely good people. If I could give more than 5 stars, I would!!!!!! read more