Awesome little hoagie store. Top quality meats and cheese. Sandwich was delicious. I would highly recommend this place. Bring cash though. They do not take card. They do have an atm inside but you know how that goes. That's an extra charge to take cash out. read more

Came here for weekend lunch and enjoyed our experience! Pros: - Friendly and attentive staff who all followed COVID protocol- wore masks correctly, reminded us to stay 6 feet apart from other customers, cleaned tables before and after meals, and made sure the space was at limited capacity. - Delicious hoagies all made with fresh bread and flavorful ingredients - loved the Roasted Italian Pork (my fave), Mushroom Cheesesteak, and Italian Market Hoagie (my sister-in-law wish it had hot peppers) Note: - To eat at Keystone Hoagies you dine at Dottie Audrey's Bakery Kitchen next door. read more

See all

Keystone Hoagies servers tasty sandwiches with the freshest ingredient and great flavors. At the time of this review, they offer both take-out and dine-in. If you are dining in they leave an ample amount of room in between tables and all the servers are wearing masks. The service is super friendly and they checked up on us the perfect amount of times. My favorite sandwiches here are the Italian Pork as well as the Mushroom cheesesteak. The bread they use is really fresh and takes the sandwich to the next level. I'll definitely be back to try out their other hoagies. read more

See all

Delicious deli sandwiches with a unique vibe!! Love this gem on our trip to Vermont. Crowded today but worth the wait.

Have had lunch here several times following church service which is next door. Good menu selection. Everything is very reasonable priced for the metropolitan tristate area Sandwiches are made a fresh baked bread and have ample fillings and toppings. Their fries are excellent whether plain or with gravy or cheese Friendly, attentive service. Can't go wrong! Well worth the trip. read more

A great new spot on my drive home from NYC. We always order the cheesesteaks with the signature cheese sauce. So delicious! This time we ordered The Italian Pork sandwich...meat was juicy. Great flavor combinations. Bread is definitely homemade and takes the sandwiches to another level. Friendly staff! read more

See all

AMAZING!!!!!!! We need more places like this in Orange County great service down to earth. And if you want a plate just ask. Not something to complain about Lol Delish thank you read more

Being a Philly area native, it was a pleasant surprise to go hiking in Harriman and find this Pennsylvania-style sandwich shop nearby. Great rolls are a must for a great sandwich, and damn does this place have some great rolls! They appear to either be baked in house or by a bakery nearby (perhaps next door?). I couldn't help but to be gluttonous and get 'The Polish Hammer', along with gravy fries. The sandwich was essentially a standard kielbasa and sauerkraut sandwich, but with pierogies on it. The fries were homemade, very good. The staff was friendly. The whole experience was very pleasant. This place is a gem, especially for the area its in, and can compete with some of the best sandwich shops I've been to in the NYC, Philly, and Pittsburgh areas. read more

Keystone Hoagies - American Near Me - Tuxedo Park, New York

See all

Thought this was going to just be a sandwich shop but was delightfully surprised that is was MUUch more. Excellent menu. I could have had all of it! Salmon bowl was cooked perfectly read more

Was a jem of a stop was so surprised how great the food and service were. Great outdoor seating as well. read more

Keystone Hoagies - American Near Me - Tuxedo Park, New York

This place is beyond phenomenal amazing food amazing people very friendly I love this place and would recommend it to anyone to come here absolutely great great FOOD!!! read more

Wow. The size of the cheesesteak was literally like 2 regular size heroes. Easily the best cheesesteak. Fresh and flavorful ingredients. I shouldn't be surprised its so good. They share a kitchen with dotties bakery and they are great. Cant wait to try the rest of the menu. I grew up in Brooklyn so i know a thing or two about good sandwiches. A must try for lunch. read more

Went with my family today for lunch. We were greeted by the very friendly girl working the counter. She helped us with our drink choices and recommended the raspberry hisbiscus tea which was a wonderful start to our amazing lunch. My father and I got the mushroom cheesesteaks with provolone, my sister got the the cab roast beef and my mother got the three little pigs. The sandwiches were huge and were so fresh and tasty. All four of us brought home half of our meals home because just half the sandwich was super filling. On another note the French fries......were so tasty!! I got the fries with cheese and gravy and I was amazed the brown gravy was so flavorful and the cheese sauce is homemade and amazing. They are also fresh cut and u can taste the freshness with every bite!! read more

This place is sick. Being from southeastern Pennsylvania, I'm a bit of a traditionalist when it comes to my cheesesteaks. To be honest, I didn't even look at the menu and ordered a cheesesteak wit Wiz, onions and mushrooms. While we waited, I actually overheard that the cheese sauce was their own melted blend of American, gruyere, and cheddar, and that the bread is baked daily next door at Dottie Audrey's. When I asked for ketchup, I was greeted with a full sauce cup - "better for dipping." That's what's up! It was delicious! The bread is an especially important element of a cheesesteak, and this roll was fantastic. I've never had anything that nailed the idea of a cheesesteak with a gourmet execution and this is exactly that. The only downside is that I hate Pepsi (but got a killer iced mocha at Dottie Audrey's!). Maybe they could check out Boylan's (NYC) or Drink More Good (Beacon, NY) for some cool local offerings! We will be back to try more from the menu very soon! read more

Got the Pizza Steak and was very impressed with it. They have their homemade bread which makes the sandwich. I cannot wait to try some of their other stuff and if you like breakfast try their breakfast next door at Dottie Audrey's!! read more

Good food. Trying to copy Philly style hoagie and cheesesteaks, just not quite there. Friendly high schoolers running it but all professional. More drinks choices are needed. Why no root beer, a Philly staple? read more

My husband got Phili cheese steak and I got cod. Phili cheese steak was wrapped in wax paper and foil. No plate, the paper and wax melted on the bread and meat had to peel pieces off the food. My cod and fries where so salty and over seasoned with old bay. Definitely won't eat there again. read more

We love this place for the fries, the steak sandwich, perogies, and the "bug juice". The attached Dottie Audrey bakery is also full of tasty treats. read more

Really great high end cheesesteak. I'm picky about cheesesteaks and these hit the spot. Cheese fries are also amazing. Amazed that they make their own "cheese wiz" read more

We have enjoyed the sister restaurant quite a bit but for the first time we ordered from Keystone. The sandwiches were huge. No crazy fan fare, just a great sandwich wrapped in foil. We each ordered something different and we all ate ever bit of the food. Delicious and filling! read more

Still great. Friendly and prompt service. Veggie Duffy grinder was excellent. Big enough for two.

We really enjoyed this restaurant! The sandwiches had some delicious and unique flavors. The staff and owner are exceedingly friendly, knowledgeable, and patient. Make sure to stop by read more

Delicious! I had read other reviews and thought we had to try it. I was not disappointed. The cheesesteak was amazing. I chose the house cheese. What a nice mix. The order of fries was large enough to share. So happy we stopped. We'll be back. read more

Better cheesesteak than in Philadelphia. The bun and beef were excellent. One sandwich is enough for 2 people, or you will probably have leftovers. So glad to see small businesses with great food and staff in Tuxedo in a plaza that was empty for a long time. read more

Really good sandwiches for the area. They have a really good choice selection, and the best part is the bread. It's baked in the cafe next door (same owners) daily. If you love sandwiches like me then you know the bread is what makes it, and this place is on point. I got the Three Little Piggies, and I suggest getting it with a side of their homemade ranch.....you won't be disappointed. read more

I love Dottie Audrey's next door, and finally tried Keystone recently. My only gripes-I wish they had a better selection of beverages for adults and more comfortable chairs. Hubs and I went about 2 weeks ago and we had to sit outside since I'm pregnant and found the high stool/chairs inside incredibly uncomfortable and there was no way I could sit on them. The chairs outside were ok, but I had to settle on a picnic table. The food itself was pretty good-the hand cut fries are a must. We got ours covered in gravy and cheese, and I could have made a meal out of the fries alone, they were so good. They were piping hot, salty, covered in gravy and melted cheese and absolutely delicious. The sandwich I got was fine- (CAB roast beef with roasted peppers and garlic spread), just not very exciting. The meat was ice cold (although very generous), and there wasn't much interesting about the sandwich itself, and I love roast beef. The roasted garlic spread was thick, and when I ate my other half of sandwich the next day, I squirted horseradish sauce on it, which I think cut through the richness of the meat much better than the garlic spread. I just felt like there needed to be some acidity or texture to the sandwich other than the soft meat and the soft peppers. My husband got the Italian roast pork, which was very good. The meat was flavorful, and his sandwich in general was much more interesting. The components were flavorful and went well together. Overall, we enjoyed it, and the portions are pretty good for the price, and the bread is freshly baked and delicious. I still love 'Dottie Audrey's a bit more, but if I'm in the mood for a sandwich, I'd definitely stop in here again. read more

I went there for the first time a few days ago. It was pretty on the inside. The staff was all very friendly. The food came out quickly and it was delicious. I definitely will be going back because there are several things on the menu I want to try. read more

Awesome sub shop with delicious and enormous sandwiches. Excellent addition to town, great place to stop for a post hike meal.

Wow. The size of the cheesesteak was literally like 2 regular size heroes. Easily the best cheesesteak. Fresh and flavorful ingredients. I shouldn't be surprised its so good. They share a kitchen with dotties bakery and they are great. Cant wait to try the rest of the menu. I grew up in Brooklyn so i know a thing or two about good sandwiches. A must try for lunch! read more

Unbelievable hoagies. The Three little piggies was to die for. Nice atmosphere and a charming little place. Definitely worth the stop.

Stopped on Sunday around 11:30, Dotties breakfast crowd still going strong, we ordered two heros to go, one cheese steak and one just steak and onions. When we got home, you would think we went to 2 different places. Cheese Steak was just as good as last time, the steak and onions was gristle and burnt onions. If were not 20 minutes away, I would have gone back read more

Excellent food. Wow. Great place for JW's visiting HQ. The price is a little high however they give you a large sandwich. Finally it's clean. read more

Dottie Audrey's is just what this town needs, a beautiful bakery with excellent attitude and service. Although Dottie Audrey's is great, I also like the cheese stakes and meat ball subs from the connected business Keystone hoagies. Since I know the owners from past experiences, they make the restaurant an even better place to be. read more

Great cheeseteaks, very friendly service, clean, good value for the quality, highly recommended!