We love this place! My daughter who lives in TN loves a good burger and has a vegetarian finance. Everyone found something to eat here that we absolutely loved! Our vegetarian opted for the build your own burger. Veggie burger on a pretzel bun w/ pallet jack, chipotle mayo, fries, frizzled onions and avocado. He loved it! My daughter and I split an order of pierogies and the amazing bacon onion marmalade burger. They even cut it up for us from the kitchen and put it on separate plates (love the attention to detail and service) My mother daughter truly enjoyed her pineapple jalapeños burger and was in heaven. Not too much heat but just the right amount of kick. Hubby is trying to be more health conscious so he opted for the Brie & Apple turkey burger. He said it was very well seasoned and enjoyed it thoroughly. We all took a sip or two of the peanut butter shake and left happy! The service was great and we complimented the owner his beautiful flowers and decor. read more

See all

Cow Patty's is a fun little burger joint right off the main drag in Wantage. And I say right off because as you pull in and out of the parking "lot," you're doing so onto NJ-23. Be prepared! Inside, we were met with a kind staff and a delicious lunch. The boomin bloomin onion was a favorite for our crew, with the typical blooming onion sauce you know and love from the steak chains. What differentiated it was the thin slicing of the onions, which made it easier to just keep dipping a little bit more. The only letdown of the meal, which was a relative letdown given how solid the burgers and onion were, was the fries. They didn't have flavor, even though I got mine with Cajun seasoning and my wife got hers with a beer cheese dip. They need to punch up the salt fresh out of the fryer to really let the other seasonings shine. We actually overheard another table say the same thing after we finished our fries, so I don't think it was just a fluke order. That said, if you're nitpicking over the sides at the burger and shake place, I'd say you're going to the wrong places! This was a tasty meal and a stop I'd easily go back to if I was nearby. read more

See all

This place was great and completely empty when I went on a Thursday afternoon. Everything we ordered was delicious- including a burger and chicken sandwiches. Chicken sandwich was very fresh and tasty. We finished everything on our plates! The service was friendly and quick. Would return here if we were back in the area! read more

Cow Patty's - California Chicken Club - Burgers Near Me - Wantage, New Jersey

Everything was absolutely delicious - from the wings to the burger. My husband is a burger connoisseur of sorts, so when I say teh burger was good - the burger was good. Cow Patty's did not disappoint...thank you! read more

See all

This was an excellent experience. We will travel far and wide for a good burger, and stopped here based on the recommendations of our friends who are regulars here. This was an hour and ten minute car ride, and it was SO worth it. First, the staff were incredibly welcoming, kind, and friendly. They struck up conversation with us, were appreciative of our business, and introduced us to how things work here. The decor is modern-rustic, clean, and comfortable. We didn't feel like we were in New Jersey, in a good way. I opted for the Jersey burger and my wife opted for the "build your own." Both of these massive angus burgers were incredible. They were flavorful, had a natural and authentic taste, and were loaded with toppings. My wife LOVED her milk shake. Fries were crispy, fresh, had a great taste, and were not greasy. Alligator bites were INCREDIBLE. I would take the ride just for these. Prices were incredibly fair for the amount and quality of the food. We will 100% be returning, and OFTEN! read more

The inside and outside of this place were beautifully styled -- it actually reminded me of Texas and an old western show. The food was hittin'! I was craving a burger with gluten-free buns, and it really hit the spot. The service from Kathy and Kimberly was excellent too! When I'm back in the area, I'll definitely be visiting again. read more

See all

Great customer service. Food was amazing. They offer a lot of vegetarian options; all you have to do is ask. I ordered the Pineapple Jalapeño with black bean patty, and hands down one of the best burgers I ever had! read more

Cow Patty's - Pineapple Jalapeño Burger w/Black Bean patty - Burgers Near Me - Wantage, New Jersey

Beat and clean burger joint with multiple burger combos on the menu. Nice variety between sweet and spicy. They also have multiple protein options and bun types. Stopped by here as I was driving through for a quick bite. I tried the apple and brie burger with fig jam, on a classic beef patty. Fresh and cozy, nothing out of the ordinary read more

See all

Best help and best burgers. A fav. Always bring something home and love the shakes. And I love Patty's sauce with the fries. The Brisket burger is awesome. read more

Starting with the food, their pulled pork is AMAZING!!! Had it with the Mac n Cheese and didn't regret it for a second. The pulled pork sandwich was equally as good and the portion sizes were GREAT!!!! Easy 10/10 rating. The Shrimp Tempura was a solid 9/10, crispy and flavorful. Wings and loaded nachos absolutely took it home, we devoured them without a second thought shortly after that picture lol 10/10. Fries were again solid 10/10, crispy, good size and plenty of flavor. The place is BYOB and drink options could be little more abundant but that's no reason to remove a star. The service was great, friendly waitress and she definitely did her rounds incase anyone needed anything. Great conversationalist with the customers and was patient with us while we looked over our options. The ambiance is a small town vibe, comfortable and relaxed. Parking lot has plenty of space from what I could tell. Definitely plan to come back to try some of the other things on the menu but for now it won us as a nice local NEED TO SEE stop in the area. read more

See all

Best burger in Sussex County. Every time I come here, the meal is perfect, no matter what I order. My personal fav is the regular burger with tots. The wings are AMAZING. Amanda is super courteous, funny, so sweet, and attentive. This is a regular stop and it NEVER disappoints !! read more

We used to love this place and recommend it to many friends. We hadn't been here for about a year or so and decided to stop by today. The wings and mozzarella sticks were still as good as we remembered. The burger however was not. You used to be served these amazing looking "photo" worthy pics. What we received today was about the size and quality of a fast food place. Not sure what has happened but it was definitely not the food we remembered. The pic I'm including shows what the BBQ Bacon Cheddar burger used to look like compared to what I received today. The quality of meat was also definitely not what they used to serve in the past. Very disappointed and will not be returning read more

Cow Patty's - BBQ Bacon Cheddar Burger - Burgers Near Me - Wantage, New Jersey

This place is amazing! The server was so nice and charming and felt really easy to talk to. The food was delicious and the portions are very generous. The restaurant itself feel warm and welcome and I will be eating here whenever able! read more

Came out to Cow Patty's's about three months ago, forgot to write a review. Food: I ended up getting a pineapple japaleno burger because the wonderful waitress recommended it. The words that I used to explain to her: refreshing. It's a unique spicy, yet slightly sweet taste that feels like it would be a solid summer burger. Fries were awesome too. Aesthetic: I hit this place up, because it looks like a diner, and I'm all for the vibe. Very well-kept and very nice tables and chairs. Service: there was only one woman that helped me the entire time, but she was on the ball. On top of everything. read more

See all

Second time I've been here. Awesome again. We had the beer pretzel that was huge and amazing. I had the jersey burger cooked to perfection. My wife had a Mac and cheese bowl. All homemade and delicious. The service was fast and pleasant. We will definitely be back again!!!! read more

Just had dinner at Cow Patty's's and it was truly amazing The whole pork and cheese sandwich was great the whole day french fries are amazing and I had six wings, which really filled me up Cow Patty's's staff is friendly. The entire place is very clean and the food is excellent. read more

See all

This place is a local gem. The food is delicious, burgers, cheesesteaks, chicken sandwiches, tenders. All the American classics. Great sauces and fries. Cow Patty's is becoming a regular spot for us after moving to the area. The servers are wonderful - we usually get Kimberly who is just awesome. Gives a diner feel, nice and casual atmosphere. great for family, or a casual date night or hang out with friends! They've been adding to the menu as well. Love to see it! read more

Cow Patty's - Gyro Burger - delicious! I believe this is a special. Served on delicious toasted pita bread. - Burgers Near Me - Wantage, New Jersey

See all

Of the rip the service is AAA. The server was so personable and warm. Milkshakes are amazing and a must -don't cheat yourself. Buffalo BBQ Mac n cheese bowl was . A must eat place and we already plan to come back. read more

Cow Patty's - Burgers Near Me - Wantage, New Jersey

We stopped here to grab a Sunday lunch - 2 adults & a 2 year old. There is ample parking in front and it's right off the side of Rt. 23. We were seated right away - it was 1:30pm and not really busy. The little one got a little cup of crayons and a sheet to keep him entertained which was nice. For drinks, we ordered lemonade and root beer, apple juice for the little one. For appetizers, we got the Bloomin Onion and Fried Pickles. The onion was greasy but ok and the pickles were great - crunchy on the outside, vinegary & juicy on the inside. For mains, I ordered the California Bacon Burger that came with a side of fries, small container of cole slaw and a pickle spear. Husband got the Rodeo Burger with fries topped with the house dry rub and son got the kid's cheeseburger sliders that came with fries. The kids meal is a deal because it's a main, drink & ice cream for 1 price. Service was good and overall vibe of the spot was nice too. Probably would come back here again to try some of their desserts (we couldnt fit more food even if we tried!). read more

See all

Love Cow Patty's! I've been here many times and I've never had an incorrect order or any kind of issue. The staff is nice and friendly and the food is SO GOOD!!! The burger's are amazing and juicy! The hot dogs are really good also!! I recently ordered the Grilled Chicken Sandwich and it didn't disappoint. If you're in the mood for a great burger or dog I promise Cow Patty's is a great place to go! read more

Cow Patty's - Fries - Burgers Near Me - Wantage, New Jersey

See all

This place is AMAZING!!!! Great food and staff- I heard it was pricey but didn't think so at all for what you get- the old feel diner look is awesome We will definitely be back!!!! read more

Stopped in for lunch... cute place, friendly servers, efficient service and super tasty burgers. The Buffalo wings were good and the tater tots were insanely good with cheese sauce, bacon, and fresh jalapeños. Yum. Stop in if you're hungry and looking for a good burger. Fries were perfect! read more

Cow Patty's - Jalapeño tater tots, insanely good - Burgers Near Me - Wantage, New Jersey

See all

Love there burgers!!! Especially the rodeo burger. Service was a little slow but management.

Came with friends upon their recommendation because they live nearby and have been several times. I got the Brie and Apple Turkey burger and it was superb! The kicker was the fig purée bringing sweetness in contrast to the creamy richness of brie and crispy, tart apples. Onion rings were also on point but I wasn't sold on the coleslaw which had something in it that turned me off. COVID protocols were followed and service was kind and attentive. I would love to return and go down the burger list. read more

Cow Patty's - Brie and Apple Turkey burger with coleslaw and onion rings. - Burgers Near Me - Wantage, New Jersey

Best burger I have ever had. The black current Berger is excellent. Perfect balance of sweet and savory!!!!

first time there today and was very impressed with the food, friendliness and cleanliness; highly recommend it

Food is all overcooked. Had a burger & fries. Simple, what can go wrong. They wont make a burger med rare. Blamed it on the NJ health department. Only one in NJ that had that regulation. Most likely frozen food that needs defrosting. Ordered chicken wings to go. Over cooked and dry. My friend had chicken tenders. Again dry. This may be an excuse for incompetent personnel in the kitchen. Thought i had a new place for burgers. WRONG. read more

The greatest food, The absolute best Serviss from the best and friendliest staff and an overall great atmosphere really hoping to go back again very very very soon read more

Cow Patty's - Burger and fries - Burgers Near Me - Wantage, New Jersey

See all

For the traveler is the outback Sussex town, Sussex county, this is a nice local stop. Very friendly service in a bar like setting for burgers. Local certified angus burgers either made your way or selections on the menu. The burger was ok. The burger tasted like it was pre-cook and just warmed up as I ordered it rare. It still came out medium. Perhaps if you ordered the burger well done, it might come out nicely charred on the outside. The fries were to die for. Very crispy, not salty, flavorful. Service was excellent. read more

Cow Patty's - a tray of fries and a burger - Burgers Near Me - Wantage, New Jersey

I had lunch at this burger joint today and I want to note that the food was very filling and excellent. I ordered the Italian burger: bun, lettuce, mozzarella and condiments. I also got homemade fries to go with the burger. Delicious food and very filling. I'm happy with the price, because the products are from a local farm and you can feel it. I advise everyone to visit this wonderful place. Thank you read more

Cow Patty's - real beef from a nearby farm - Burgers Near Me - Wantage, New Jersey

We have driven past Cow Patty's since it opened. Finally stopped in the other day and was so glad that we did. We were greeted with a friendly staff and seated immediately. Our server was right there with menus and to take our drink orders. Everything is locally sourced and as fresh as fresh as I have ever tasted. The burgers were juicy but not at all greasy. I decided to do the "Build Your Own" burger. Fresh patty with a fried egg and American cheese on a pretzel bun. The egg was cooked to perfection and just enough yolk to flavor the fresh beef. Served with a side of perfectly seasoned and fried potatoes and a pickle wedge. I enjoyed it like no other burger I have had. Throughout the whole meal, the bread and integrity of the burger stayed in tact until the last bite. The vanilla shake was flavorful and just thick enough to be able to drink through the large straw. We will definitely be back next time we are in the area. Definitely give them a try! read more

See all

Went there for first time after passing it many many times,I had Italian Burger,I was never asked HOW would I like it cooked. Burger was sub par and nothing exciting,marinara sauce tastes like it was feom a jar,cheese was partially not melted. My wife Gluten Free bun crumbled. Not many GF options,not even fries were GF,no otion were available for GF customers. Even waitress had NO recommendations.. Coe Slaw also tasted like it came from prepackaged container. The cashier never asked how our experience was,she was more worried about hand sanitizer burning her cut on her hand AFTER she was done making a shake. Both our food was NOT worth the cost at all. I sure do miss the DOUBLE S that was there before this place. read more

Cow Patty's - Italian burger. Notice cheese not totally melted. - Burgers Near Me - Wantage, New Jersey

Good delicious - they give so much. No need to order an appetizer. I cannot remember the servers name she's been in there every time I've come very helpful very nice very congenial. Service was just as good as the food You should try it out. read more

Outstanding spontaneous experience. Driving through and opened Yelp to find something local. Immaculately clean. Great, extensive menu. Attentive staff. Reasonable prices. A+ all the way. Well do read more

Cow Patty's - Dining area. - Burgers Near Me - Wantage, New Jersey

See all

New gourmet burger place in Wantage NJ. We loved the concept of locally sourced ingredients as well supporting local businesses. We were very disappointed with the food. For the price they charge it's not worth it. $4.75 for cheese fries, $5.75 for the onion rings. My plain cheeseburger was $13.75 because I got a pretzel bun. I found the burger and bun very dry. They even forgot our shakes, we had to go back for them, and they both were no better than flavored/sweetened milk. Sorry Cow Patty's we will not be back. Such a shame. For the price the servings really should reflect the cost. read more

Nice place, diner-like atmosphere with a plethora of hamburgers to choose from. Burgers are from local farms and are hade made to order. The wait staff are friendly and most of them make kick ass milk shakes. You can always tell a seasoned professional service technician by the milk shake that they make. I always have two... read more

The grass fed beef burger tastes amazing; this is what beef is supposed to taste like! My favorite burger in NJ! The place and staff are great too. read more

Cow Patty's - Delicious hamburgers and fries at Cow Patties! - Burgers Near Me - Wantage, New Jersey

I had an AWFUL experience here. My daughter is 12 years old, she wanted something from the kids menu as she normally does. Which it states (12 and under). Yes she looks older than she is, so what! The waitress we had assumed she was older! Do not assume. It is rude. When my daughter ordered she said "I can't give you everything because it's for 12 and under". Like hello?? Let's not promote assumptions please! This was just so disrespectful. She also just gave an attitude the whole time for no reason and my daughter had to ask for the ice cream that came with her meal because she didn't bring it out. Besides the service, it is freezing in there! And there was some disgusting smell at our table in the back With the drinks on the other hand, my daughter and I had ordered chocolate milk. It was literally white, there was like no chocolate in it. Then other people we were with had ordered sprite, they got straight water. So disappointed. Food didn't take too long to come out but there were some flaws. Small things such as we asked for no onions on a burger and they gave them anyways. Which then they charged us an extra dollar for said onions. Our mozzarella sticks weren't melted enough. But besides these small things, our food was delish! Did not tip! read more

Service was great from our waitress but horrible with the young girl up front at the register. She was very rude, unwelcoming, and not professional. She honestly seems racist and kept rolling her eyes. Food lacked flavor, but it was cool to have the option to customize your meal. read more

Very poor all around poor burger,worse service, and cold in building so ambiance was fridgid.