Went there and got two cheeseburgers with sides - tomato and lettuce The burger was good BUT only came medium - The onion rings were sub par and were probably the frozen kind - nothing special. The bill came out to $ 38.51 - FOR TWO BURGERS !! Don't order the drinks - GET WATER - The sodas were $3.75 each !! Will not be coming back read more

Stopped by this place after some hunger-generating games of Laser Tag down the road. Lemme just say, OH MY LORD! Part 1- Jalepeno Cornbread was INCREDIBLE! It was so warm and the PERFECT compliment to a bitterly cold evening. Part 2 Wings: Vermont Maple Bacon was pretty solid although the sauce itself was relatively subtle and tame in flavor. Still quite delicious though. The Not for the Cowardly on the other hand....HOLY HELL. Lemme preface this with I LOVE hot and spicy things but I did not expect the level of pure heat that resonated off my first bite. 10/10 Part 3 Burgies- The Pineapple Jalepeno burger was a 10000/10 and was every bit of the perfect blend of sweet/savory/spicy. My GF LOVED her Nashville Spicy Chicken Sandwich too! I'd 100% come back again! read more

Yesterday we ate lunch at Cow Patties one of our favorite places to stop and have burgers. I decided I'd try their pulled pork sandwich, a mistake. The pork was cut incorrectly it was long stands of dry, flavorless meat. The barbecue sauce was good but scant. The coleslaw only tasted of being refrigerated a long time. My spouse had the Caesar salad with chicken, another mistake. The chicken was cut into long dried out strands. I think the sous chef needs a few lessons in cutting. The lettuce was seriously wilted. The croutons were tiny cubes of dry white bread in the bottom of the bowl. The Caesar dressing was served in a little paper cut. Will we go back yes but we will stick to their burgers. read more

Amazing. Delicious burgers and such an incredibly nice lady!! Had a shake and the fries were amazing as well. Between the burgers just like mom used to make and the ambiance, I can't give this any less than 5 stars, wish I could do 6. read more

I ordered my food to go, so i didn't get the dine in experience. But food was great i ordered the Build Your Own Burger. ( My Pictures have descriptions) Food was great, fresh, well seasoned. I highly recommend people if your going to order fries. GET THE OLD BAY FRIES w/ BEER CHEESE on the SIDE!!!! Mmmm so good. read more

See all

First time coming, coming the food was great. Friendly service. We will be back for the burgers !

What an amazing new burger spot. Everything we ordered from their menu was delicious and cooked perfectly. We started with the fried pickles, and as someone who used to live down south, they nailed these. The seasoning was great and the dipping sauce was excellent. The border burger was incredible, and I loved all the fresh ingredients on it. The bacon and beer cheese build your own burger was equally good. Not pictured here are also mozzarella sticks that we ordered. They were thick and delicious with excellent marinara sauce. Also beware, the wing challenge is difficult, we didn't come out successful but the wings were good nonetheless. I'm already planning a trip back here. Definitely give cow patty's a try. Sure it's a little more money, but the quality is well worth it. read more

See all

Fantastic burger. I mean--really good! The fries were also great, the service was prompt and friendly and the place was really designed nicely. Fun and modern. Extra points for having your lgo branded on the burger bun. read more

Cow Patty's - Burgers Near Me - Wantage, New Jersey

We have had cow patty's a few times. We usually order to go so I can speak to the staff or restaurant itself but we have never had a problem with the food. Everything we've ever ordered has always been delicious. I'm extremely picky when it comes to burgers so this is saying a whole lot! read more

I've been ordering takeout since they opened.. I can't have gluten and they have gluten free options The burgers are really good. I recently had the grilled fish sandwich on gluten-free bread and it was one of the best I've ever had. My husbands is not gf and bit of a food snob and he loves their burgers as well. The staff is very nice. read more

My first time here was a good experience they have very good burgers ! Will go back to try another different one from the menu than the classic. read more

Delicious! Mushroom Swiss burger and a Build Your Own burger with blue cheese, bacon, avocados and jalapeños - both were done perfectly! Split a chocolate milk shake, fries and fried pickles! We are completely satisfied and full!!! read more

Cow Patty's - Chocolate Milk Shake!!! - Burgers Near Me - Wantage, New Jersey

Delicious food, delicious burgers, so many different delicious food options, delicious deserts, milkshakes, and so much more ! If you like good food as well as good service, then i highly recommend this place !!! read more

Good and tasty burgers friendly staff. Definitely go there again. I always grab take out so can't tell you about dinning . read more

Workers are very nice and attentive. The inside is clean and nicely decorated. Nice deck to dine outside. The food is great!

Great atmosphere. Super fast service. Our waitress was extremely sweet and helpful. She made me raspberry iced tea from scratch! Yummy!! And the food. Yes! Had the pulled pork sliders. Super delish. This was my first time here and will def come back. read more

Ordered here for the first time, the wait time was an hour and a half for pick up ? Not sure why, when we got there, it was empty. Nonetheless, the food was pretty good. We ordered the chicken sandwich and a burger (doesn't come with fries). Would def return to try the other menu items. read more

Definitely overrated and overpriced. Went for the first time last Sunday with the family. We placed our order and we waited. We're not the type of people to complain about the food when it takes a little longer than average, especially if we are having a good conversation amongst ourselves, after waiting for a while, we noticed that some time had passed. We didn't think anything of it, and we even joked around saying. " what did they go kill the cow" however after about an hour of waiting, we got antsy. When I asked the waitress about our food, she had no idea kind of seem like she forgot about it, which made no sense to me because the place is small and there's only two waitresses when we were in there so kind hard to believe that you didn't notice that we didn't get our food. Finally after we got our food things weren't even right. I had ordered a custom burger. The burger was on the wrong bun. It had the wrong cheese, I asked for fried egg and it came with an over cooked dry egg, oh yeah and it also didn't have any bacon. After expressing all these concerns to my waitress, all we were given was a 10% discount which was ridiculous especially when our bill was $80 for three burgers. 12 wings and 3 sodas. I can tell you five guys burgers is way better by a long shot. I feel like people just go here because there's really nothing else to eat in the area besides some mediocre fast food places, and some other diners. definitely will not be coming here again. oh well, you live and you learn. (The excuse for our order not being placed/loss was blamed on the computer system) which I get it but still there wasn't many people there. How can you not notice that one of your tables has not received their food... like come on. On top of that even if you didn't notice why didn't you come back to the table to ask how everything was? read more

Food is great but pricy for the area Wish they would lower the prices so we could go more often read more

The burgers were really good. Hubby and I enjoyed our meal. A couple of minor items that bothered us. One thing that we feel is important in a burger is the bun. A good bun should last the entire burger and not fall apart. Salt Gastropub has a really good bun for their burger. The two buns we had - both Brioche and Pretzel - fell apart before we were finished. We also had a perception problem with the toppings pricing. $.25ea for lettuce, tomato, onions etc. I really don't want to pay for these toppings. I'd rather the $7 burger start at $8 and include these items at no charge. I don't want to feel like I'm being nickel and dimed for standard items. Not that I want to keep comparing Cow Patty's to other burger restaurants but OMG burger in Long Valley charges $10.50 for their custom burgers - they include fries, the bun and if you want them - lettuce, tomato, onion & pickle chips. Given that, next time we are in the area, we would definitely come to Cow Patty's again! read more

Cow Patty's - a close up of a cow patty's patty's patty's patty's patty's patty - Burgers Near Me - Wantage, New Jersey

Tried this cozy little place for the first time and the food and service was great!! I would definitely come back as the food makes you want to try everything on the menu. I would have showed you the burger but I ate it already. read more

Cow Patty's - Thai chili wings - Burgers Near Me - Wantage, New Jersey

See all

My husband and I came here while staying at a nearby resort and the food was AMAZING! Great food, great customer service, great price. Highly recommend! read more

Great burgers & pair it with a fantastic milk shake. The wait staff is prompt & very friendly. Love the old fashioned look of the place.

I haven't had a burger this amazing in a long time! I was really impressed and our waitress, Kimberly, is absolutely amazing! I live in New York State and I'm only visiting but I plan on coming here again! Also had a chocolate milk shake, which was fantastic! read more

Cow Patty's - BBQ bacon cheeseburger - Burgers Near Me - Wantage, New Jersey

Overprice hamburgers. It's ok once and awhile but not a weekly trip. They are big and you can have your choice

Good freshly made quality burger. Delicious and Fast service, took it to go! Friendly staff.

Absolutely the best burger I have had in YEARS! Kimberly was great and a pleasant and competent wait-person. Everything was great from the onion rings to the pickles! The burger taste like fresh burger SHOULD taste. Definitely must return! read more

Went for dinner last night but was disappointed. Limited menu which meant that the kitchen should be able to produce hot food in a timely fashion. Not the case. About an hour after ordering the burgers came out cold, the cheese wasn't even melted. Burger was tasty but would've been so much better if served hot and not well done. You aren't given a choice on how you'd like your burger cooked. Young man who seemed to be running the place could care less that customers were waiting so long for food. His excuse is they were slammed with take out - since when does a restaurant ignore in house customers for take out? Not a good business plan. Although we live locally we will not frequent this local establishment. We can buy the same locally sourced beef and make our own burgers - at least they'd be cooked to our preference and be served hot. read more

I ordered online Monday for a pickup at 5:30pm, and the order was right on time. My wife selected the 'build your own' burger, and she though it wasn't anything to write home about. As described in other reviews, the burgers are not cooked to order. This was a 'one size fits all' which was too well done for my wife's taste. The crab cake sandwich which I had was ho-hum. Lots of filler without any indication that there were any crab parts. Everything was fresh, and there were no complaints with the slaw. We live locally, and we will not be making this a regular or preferred location. If you are hungry and in the area, it's probably not a bad choice. Prices are on the steep side. read more

They do not keep to mask wearing I left feeling uncomfortable. I can not suggest this place and I drove a far distance to get here

Well, I'll be honest, I was intrigued with the name. The menu seemed really good and the burgers were described deliciously. They have a build your own burger option which both hubby and I elected to try. After ordering, I realized I was never given a meat doneness option. I flagged down the sever and was told all burgers are cooked medium well without an option for the customer to change this. Both my husband and I prefer rare burgers but I'd accept a medium burger for health reasons and possible health department protocol. That being said, these burgers were dry like shoe leather! The fries were delicious though. Not sure if we'd go back because of the dryness of the burger. Definitely would never order a burger there again. I think my burger was cooked to at minimum 170° as opposed to 155° The pickles were delicious but very small and the coke slaw portion cup was filled with about 2 tablespoons! I was expecting a side order portion. All being said, a bit over priced for portion size and their unwillingness to bend to customer preferences. The server revealed that I wasn't the first person this evening that took exception to the burger doneness. Proprietor, please listen to customer preferences as, after all, the customers allow you to stay in business in this challenging time. read more

So-so quality, long wait time for food, an owner with an attitude, and terrible value for your money. Way overpriced for Sussex County. I could see a place like this in Bergen County, but not here. Prediction: out of business by this time next year. read more

Wow! The best turkey burger I EVER had! Brie, fig spread, fresh apples & spinach on a delicious bun. SOOOOO GOOD! My husband enjoyed the pineapple jalapeño burger as well. Messy, but worth every penny. We also had their delicious onion rings. Dip them in some chipotle sauce! I tried reviewing on Tripadvisor, but they are not listed there yet. The decor is very nice. The bathrooms were clean. The owner did the fun artwork on the chalkboard wall. The staff is very down-to-earth and friendly. Easy parking. read more

Whoever name this restaurant was exactly right because the burger tasted like cow shit it's got to be simply one of the worst burgers I've ever had in my life. Don't waste your time or your money you're better off going to Burger King. read more

Not good. Order placed on line for pickup with curbside pickup request. called at specified time, told curbside service not available, short handed and it would be another half hour. I then see girl come out 3 times and guy come out once looking for cars for their curbside pickup. I was then called to come in to pick up order, but waited 5 more minutes because the DOUCHE was on the phone and didn't;'t want to respond to me calling him out on his LOUSY service. It seems because my name was not of a female, I wasn't entitled to curbside pick up. Food: Not good. Burgers requested mid rare... they were bland gray charrless way OVERCOOKED and DRY. Just don't bother. read more

Not worth the money. Doesn't take that good and priced pretty high. $4 for 4 thinly sliced fried pickles, $13 for a grilled chicken sandwich (Wendy's tastes better than that), bbq cheddar burger with no bbq sauce on it and filled with coleslaw, and $7 for the smallest amount of "Mac and cheese" (boxed Kraft tastes better). read more

Food was amazing!!! The burgers were phenomenal! The beef was legit good hamburger meat. Very friendly staff! My husband and I left happy and full. read more

Cow Patty's - Burger flight - Burgers Near Me - Wantage, New Jersey

The black bean veggie burger was SO good! Also recommend the corn bread! We were very impressed with this place. read more

Really good, quality ingredients. I used their curbside pickup. A basic build your own cost $19 with tax and a soda. Kind of pricey but it came with a truly good pickle and a good slaw. I totally enjoyed it. read more

Cow Patty's - Medium cooked and delicious. - Burgers Near Me - Wantage, New Jersey

See all

This place is great. Went in on a whim and I'm glad we did. The burgers are make from local beef and they had a lot of toppings to choose from. Don't skip on the Patty's Sauce, put it on your burger and dip your fries into it! Btw the fries are fantastic, thick cut and seasoned. The service was great, and everyone working there was super nice! Will definitely be going back. read more