I've been here three times, and unfortunately the consistency has been consistently poor. The staff lacks personality and often comes across as borderline rude. Combined with the location, the overall atmosphere has an uncomfortable, almost Deliverance-like vibe. The place itself is not very clean. Each time I've ordered wings, they've been sitting in a puddle of oil. The pizza is mediocre at best not terrible, but far from good. Having worked in several pizza places myself, it's clear they're using old dough that's been sitting out, which results in a below-average product. Considering the high prices, there's just no value here. We won't be returning. read more

This place is great! We came in with a group of 35 guys, and they accommodated all of us without any issues. The pizza was very good, the service was fast, and the staff was super friendly. If you need a quick pit stop for pizza, this is definitely the place to go. Highly recommend! read more

this is truly the best pizza I've ever had best pizza joint in Heber /Overgaard If you love garlic, they have the best pizza with garlic and garlic wings I recommend pitstop pizza it's worth the price. Their service is awesome and very friendly. They make you feel like family. read more

Pizza not very good- sauce has weird taste. Owner likes to attack other local pizza businesses on social media by making up things about their dough not being fresh or using canned Alfredo. Won't be back. read more

I am from Scottsdale, Arizona and this pizza is by far the best pizza I've had just picked up one today with my mother visiting my grandmother up here we all love it 10/10 read more

A good local pizza joint but it's more than that for a small town. Easy selection of ingredients and ordering is simple with staff shortages being what they are, stick around with another beer. The food was good, service was okay and the prices were fair. Clean tables, floors and plenty of free parking. Ordering ahead of time might be the correct way to speed things up a bit. read more

Very good pizza for a small town with good prices. Word is they have the best wings in town but we have yet to try them. Great people up front very friendly. Love the supreme pizza it's loaded! read more

Nice and friendly staff, nice decoration and have some games for kids. Good food, quick service. Private parking lot. read more

See all

Great take out experience here. Ordered two small green salads, a seven inch personal and a twelve inch medium pizza. Staff here were friendly and efficient. Our pizzas were ready in 20 minutes after placing the order at the counter. Toppings were plentiful and the crust was nice and crunchy. Hot pizza and cold salads in the mountains...nice job we will be back. read more

See all

Over priced. Had hoped they would deliver and got a bunch of excuses. I guess when there are no workers but everyone was standing around when i picked up 3 pizzas for $92 ...the workers want to make $22 to stand around read more

We're up here visiting my parents and we always get pizza here. First of all, the people that work there are incredibly nice. The pizza is always good. This time we just had the pepperoni pizza and a small Hawaiian pizza. Nothing was left over. It was gobbled up. This was the first time that I went to pick up the pizzas and they have a very cute eating area with a few arcade games and I think I saw a pool table in there. Next time I'm hitting up that Ms PAC Man game. We will be back again for sure. read more

Family owned! They're always so friendly, the food has always been delicious and the arcade makes it a lot easier to bring small humans out to eat. We come here every time we're in town. Worth stopping by! read more

I got the Hawaiian. It was overcooked and so greasy it was soggy and you couldn't hold it like pizza. Not sure what was happening in the kitchen that day but someone should have noticed what they put in the box. read more

Great quality pizza and fantastic service. Brought my family here on a busy Saturday night, pizza was prepared quickly and all special requests done right. We ordered a large pepperoni, medium pepperoni, sausage, and mushroom square cut, small cheese well done, small cheese regular, and pizza rolls. Went up to request ranch which the nice owner gave us 3 for free which was nice. Definitely the best pizza and service in town. We'll be back! read more

Pit Stop Pizza - Pizza - A group of people are dining indoors, eating pizza on paper plates, with a window showing parked cars outside. - Pizza Near Me - Overgaard, Arizona

This place was friendly, had a really cool arcade to keep us and the kids entertained, and the food was great!

Best pizza in Overgaard. Easy to call in and pick up. Easy instructions to follow. Sweet sauce. Good amount of cheese. Fast and helpful service. Will definitely order again! read more

See all

Local pizza place with yummy pizza and some fun games for the kids and adults, nice little spot to sit and hang out while kids play games. Pizza priced competitively read more

Best pizza I've had in the entire area north of Phoenix Highly recommend everyone try this place. You won't be disappointed. read more

We had two great pizzas last night, one vegetarian with lots of yummy sauce and veggies, and one with pepperoni and olives. My husband and I will definitely be back. Service was awesome, and the staff couldn't be nicer. Indoor and outdoor seating. So happy Heber/Overgaard has them in town! read more

Great food and service...friendly staff highly recommended. Fair prices and I was able to bring my water bottle in!!

We spent the New Year's Eve weekend in a cabin in Heber. Didn't want to cook on NYE, so we decided on pizza. Pit Stop was one of the options that popped up. I'm glad we decided to take our business to Pit Stop. Food was good, but the service was even better. Super friendly and courteous staff. If you're in Heber for a trip, and you're looking for Pizza, this is the spot. The restaurant itself is really cool too. The atmosphere is welcoming, and it highlights a lot of the cool things that Heber has to offer. read more

This place might not look like much but the pizza is always superb. I don't get to eat here much as I live in Maricopa. However, every time I'm in the Heber/Overgaard area I make a point to visit this business. The staff are always wonderful too and they recently expanded into the store next door so there is a bigger dine-in area. read more

Visiting the area to escape the Phoenix heat and wanted pizza for dinner. This was some of best pizza that we have had in a long time and would definitely visit again! Highly recommend..... read more

Good Food! We did the family special with 18" pizza 2 topping, wings, cheese bread and liter of soda. Also they do have personal 10" GF pizza available. read more

Darn! Lots to like, such as quick service, friendly employees, and plentiful toppings. But our pizza was swimming in grease. The very outer edge of the crust was nicely baked and crunchy, but the rest was super soggy. read more

First time stopping in. Wings were very good, pizza wasn't bad. The older lady handling the cash might have been having a bad day as she was pretty snarky to customers as they came in to pick up. Everything was good enough we would return again, but not good enough to check out other places nearby. read more

So...we support small businesses and are proud to do so! The new owners have got this pizza stuff down!! These peeps know what they're doing. Yummy!! read more

Pit Stop Pizza - Meat Lovers. Yum!!! - Pizza Near Me - Overgaard, Arizona

Pit Stop went out above and beyond to help us! We needed pizza to feed an entire football team! They literally made special accomodations and with box sizes to fit in my pizza warmers. You need to stop and visit this pizza place! They are family run, the pizza is delicious and they are just overall great people! Make sure you make a Pit Stop to try their pizza!!! read more

My wife and I stopped here recently on a small road trip to The Rim Country and we weren't disappointed. The establishment decor is a bit boring, but all the employees we dealt with were friendly and accommodating. The pizza was the best we've had since moving to Arizona over 7 years ago. The prices are a bit high compared to the chain pizza joints but it was worth the money. We'll definitely stop again if we're in the area. read more

The food was good. Ordered at counter and food was promptly delivered to table. Atmosphere is fun with lots of racing memorabilia. Overall it was a great place. read more

Thought I would try again since it had been 5 years and I heard there were new owners. Crust still thin and old, this is what happens after the dough sits a few days, it no longer rises. I won't give it another try. $22 is to much to spend on something you can't eat. read more

Delicious pizza for the whole family. The crust, sauce, and toppings....delicious. My kids pretty much kicked their plates clean.

Stopped here on my way to Phoenix and was impressed! Quality of the food, friendliness of the staff, location were all factors into 4 stars. I'm only giving a 4 star review though because the inside is so tiny and doesn't allow for much of anything let alone dining in - pre covid obviously. read more

Stopped in a couple times, my opinion on what I've tried. have tried the pizza 4/10, wings 2/10, meatball sub 2/10. nothing tasted fresh to me. Plus bathroom was never cleaned even when they just opened. read more

Super fast delivery and so personal. It's like we were friends. Pizza is a little spendy which I why I didn't give it 5 stars but I know everything is more expensive in the mountains. read more

This is our favorite pizza place to visit every time we're at the cabin! We will definitely be back next time we come. read more

Pit Stop Pizza - Best Dr.Pepper! - A person holds a 12 fl oz Dr. Pepper bottle outside a pizza restaurant with outdoor seating and American flags. - Pizza Near Me - Overgaard, Arizona

See all

Better than average pizza and wings. Good service. Pretty quick. Take out only at least during the pandemic.

The NEW Pit Stop Pizza opened just months ago and is providing 'outstanding delicious variety of food.' Jim & Pat should be highly commended and HIGHLY RECOMMEND. read more

Stopped in here while passing through. Great tasting pizza and wonderful owners. They are very personable.

After being completely pissed about the crappiest service from Gigi's and my kids begging for pizza, I gave in and went to Pit Stop. Food wise they have improved a lot and I'm glad for that since my kids seemed to enjoy it. Pit Stop is closed on Tuesday and Wednesday- no biggie! I did call ahead on Monday to check the hours since it's not uncommon for places in our rural community to close early. Their Facebook business page shows them open until 8pm so it's better to call and check beforehand. I called on Monday around 3pm to find out they were going to close at 6pm. I said I'd call back between 4 and 4:30pm to place a to go order for dinner. I called back and no one would answer so I just figured they were busy. Once I arrived one of the owners and the staff were outside. I was informed they decided to close even earlier because they weren't busy. I was disappointed since my number was on caller ID and they could have made a quick call to say they were closing shop early rather than me having to drive over and I also didn't take anything out to make for dinner. Needless to say, my kids ate a lot later than normal since defrosting meat takes awhile. So basically I'm glad to see the food is better than it used to be per my kids however, they need better communication with customers. Had they said on my call they were closing before 4pm, I would have been absolutely fine with that. The owners are friendly so that's a plus. Just better communication is needed. read more